Please don't flame me but I have got to ask....

Options
randisaucier
randisaucier Posts: 178 Member
in Health and Weight Loss
This post is not directed any at one in particular however .........

Time and time again I read posts from people (both male and female), who state they eat between 800 to 900 calories a day. How can anyone really think this is the key to weight loss? Even if you do make goal on a severe caloric deprivation diet, do you really think you can maintain it for life? I mean.....really find someone who inspires you fitness wise or who you think has the ideal body (unless you desire skin and bone with no muscle tone or shape at all) and I can guarantee they will not tell you they got their body through starvation.
One of the most important tools to weight loss is education! Educate yourself about why we gained weight in the first place and educate yourself on how to get it off the safe and healthy way. (NO that won't always be the fastest, but it's truly not about who gets to the finish line first)

Ok stepping off my soap box now, as I just needed to get that rant out.
«1

Replies

  • marnieinMB
    marnieinMB Posts: 196 Member
    Options
    Agree!
  • Rae6503
    Rae6503 Posts: 6,294 Member
    Options
    I don't understand how people do it without eating their left arm. I have a HARD time with 1500 calories.
  • Texas501
    Texas501 Posts: 274
    Options
    Flame......oops, sorry.....
  • NightOwl1
    NightOwl1 Posts: 881 Member
    Options
    It's also not sustainable. Eventually people will break from eating that little calories and binge and eat a lot more, and gain back the weight they've lost.

    Slow and healthily always beats fast and unhealthily.
  • cheeksv
    cheeksv Posts: 521 Member
    Options
    I actually remember in high school thinking eating 300 calories a day would do the trick. It was more me being uninformed than anything else. At the time I had NO idea it was bad for me, and it worked for a little while but then well I realized how hungry I was haha. The people who do it with all the nutritional info in the world should really reconsider!
  • rhondajean43
    rhondajean43 Posts: 14
    Options
    No flame here.....Totally agree. I want a lifestyle change. I want to be strong and healthy. And most of all, I want to teach my teenage daughter how to eat healthy and get the proper NUTRIENTS for energy, and health. I wish someone told me years ago. With the proper education of nutrition and calories, I don't think I would have had the weight struggles I had. I want better for her.
  • Clairebryant36
    Clairebryant36 Posts: 21
    Options
    I agree and also ones that don't eat breakfast and wonder why they are not losing weight.You need to eat to lose weight, but eat all things in moderation. I would go crazy on 800 cals a day, I struggled with 1200 so changed to 1500 to lose less amount of weight each week but I am so much happier!
  • GroovyGrubworm
    GroovyGrubworm Posts: 14
    Options
    Agreed!!
  • jlcrose
    jlcrose Posts: 22
    Options
    I tend to agree with you, however..

    My diet consists of mostly veggies and other very low-cal foods (I'm pescetarian and gluten free, and recently cut out baked goods and other vicious goodies that were OK on a pescetarian diet but were high-cal). I eat three very filling meals a day and I do eat snacks. Sometimes my diary leaves me at about 900-1000 calories a day, and if I eat another bite, I'll burst. Some have suggested that I eat almonds or other "good fats" to make calories, but I disagree with eating just to eat. While my calories are low, sometimes my fat is a little higher and so are my carbs, so I also look at the big picture.

    Some people are eating 800-1000 calories a day just to lose weight super fast, but some people have other reasons.
  • VStar55
    VStar55 Posts: 75
    Options
    I have noticed the same thing. It's a short term solution and unsustainable. Hopefully they will find a healthy balance.
  • EyeCanSeeYou
    EyeCanSeeYou Posts: 23
    Options
    I'm actually one of those who can eat 900 calories a day, sometimes 1000 calories. (I'm suppose to be eat 1200)
    I'm a vegan and I become obsessive when I diet and exercise.
    Just trying to change the bad habit of over eating junk and not exercising.
    In the end I really want to have some fat on me.
    I want to be soft, not hard.
  • MayhemModels
    MayhemModels Posts: 367 Member
    Options
    I zigzag alot so somedays i might only take in 1000 cals a day but the next day i will take in 1500
  • beamishcas
    beamishcas Posts: 226 Member
    Options
    I totally agree. I see a friend only eating 500 calories a day. I just don't understand what she is thinking. I'm concerned. Sure, she is losing NOW but one can not live like that the rest of their life. It's just not healthy.
  • crasula
    crasula Posts: 53 Member
    Options
    It's also not sustainable. Eventually people will break from eating that little calories and binge and eat a lot more, and gain back the weight they've lost.

    Slow and healthily always beats fast and unhealthily.

    Here here agreed completely. A good balance is key and that includes lots of regular exercise too which is so often overlooked.

    I've lost over 30KG's in a little over a year and never had to drop to less that 1400 calories per day. Now i've got my balance in terms of food groups, minerals and metabolism sorted i can eat over 2000 calories per day with a 30 min run ever other day and i'll still lose weight.

    Balance is the key, if you're stressing about it too it'll just make it worse....small steps.
  • jersey0725
    jersey0725 Posts: 62 Member
    Options
    I totally agree! if anyone else uses Yahoo Answers, they have a diet & fitness section. I used to help answer questions there. But i can not stand it anymore. There are tons of people asking if they would lose weight if they are eating 200 calories a day, it kills to read questions like that!
  • Shells77
    Shells77 Posts: 22
    Options
    I don't understand it, either, especially when it really slows down your metabolism to the most sluggish pace possible.

    There are some days on the weekends where I find myself, after sleeping in, trying to play catch-up, calorie-wise, but to only eat so little would drive me crazy.

    Food and eating is so enjoyable; why deprive yourself of all the awesomeness it has to offer?
  • LorinaLynn
    LorinaLynn Posts: 13,247 Member
    Options
    There was a similar thread topic this morning - a woman complaining that she was given 1500 calories and would rather 1200 - that I had a nice long reply all typed up, but she got in a stink and deleted her account. :ohwell:

    Yes. It's all about it being sustainable. It's better to eat a LITTLE less than normal and be able to keep it up long term than starve yourself for a short term. I've mistakenly done a 700 calorie a day thing when I didn't know better. I had minimal weight loss, and very quickly lost my motivation. I thought there was something wrong with me, physically, that I couldn't lose the weight. I thought it was simply a matter of "eat less." And I knew I couldn't eat any less than I was doing without screwing up my health. So I figured, if I can eat what I want and maintain a healthy, but slightly larger than my ideal, weight, vs depriving myself to possibly lose another 10 pounds... deprivation was NOT worth it.

    So finding MPF was a lightbulb moment for me. Realizing that the only thing I was doing wrong before was not eating enough. Eating my exercise calories was major missing link for me. And as I got closer to my goal and upped my calories, I'm noticing smaller changes on the scale, but bigger changes in my body.

    I'm pretty sure we're all in agreement on one thing. We call it losing weight, but what we really want to do is lose the fat. To lose the fat, you have to feed the muscle.

    EAT! :flowerforyou:
  • EricInArlington
    EricInArlington Posts: 557 Member
    Options
    I know the reason why I gained it, I eat a lot of junk, never drank more then a few glasses of water a day and never exercised because I was to embarrassed to go to the gym
    plus looking back at photos of myself I was huge and at the time I would ask people " Im not that big am I?" guess what? they all lie to you to not make you feel bad.
  • MzBug
    MzBug Posts: 2,173 Member
    Options
    Even those that stick to the 1200 and when you look at their diary more than half the cals are from cookies, candy bars, "good for you" type snack bars (special K, kashi etc.) soda and a ton of fruit. No vegies, no protein source, no water. Then they wonder why they don't feel good and are not losing weight....

    Educate yourself before you do some serious damage!
  • Schwiggity
    Schwiggity Posts: 1,449 Member
    Options
    I'M ON THE FROZEN FOOD DIET! I HEARD THAT CALORIES ARE HEAT, SO IF THE FOOD IS FROZEN IT DOESN'T HAVE ANY CALORIES....RIGHT?!

Categories