Am I eating too MUCH?
graysmom2005
Posts: 1,882 Member
So I upped my calories to try and keep up with my crazy workout schedule (fitness instructor), but after weeks and weeks it's still not going anywhere. Friday night we had take-out for the first time in weeks...so ignore that. LOL! But other than that am I just eating too much now, instead of too little? I just can't keep going on much longer without ANY and I mean ANY progress. With the amount of physical activity I do, there should be SOME progress...even if it's slow! I'd take it! But no progress, and sometimes the scale going up is just making me want to cry. How can I be teaching 11 classes a week, logging everything, and STILL not seeing progress. My diary is open. Thanks friends.
0
Replies
-
It's enough to drive you crazy right!?! My scale budged a little in the very beginning but now it just seems stuck Almost 30 days in and I am getting very disappointed. Are you checking your inches? You may just be losing inches and not the "pounds"... and I am sure with all the work you do, you HAVE to be gaining muscle?0
-
Just my opinion - I don't eat back my workout calories. I'm 5'4" and weigh 164 (lost 40 pounds to date) and my calorie goal right now is 1200. No matter how much I work out, I try to keep it between 1200 and 1500. If I ate back all my workout calories, I wouldn't lose an ounce. I know... I was there.0
-
hey, i recently upped my calories as well and also thought i was eating too much, but i learned i was actually UNDER eating.
i'm also experiencing no results (in fact, i may have gained a couple pounds). so hopefully in two weeks, the scale will be lower now that i'm eating more (but still not as many as i burn). i was eating almost 1500-2000 below on some days0 -
How is your fat? You could be going way over and staying under your calories? And I'm assuming you use a HRM? You look amazing btw!!!
If I were you, I would try dropping my cal average by 200ish and seeing if a change occurred. It one didn't, I would try adding some to see if a change occurred..0 -
My only thought is this... if you've changed your goal to reflect your busy lifestyle, maybe you shouldn't count your exercise calories? That's the only thing I can think of. I'm no expert, but my lifestyle is set to "lightly active" because I work at an office but am on my feet much of the day. Therefore when I work out, I count those calories and eat most if not all back. If you have your lifestyle set to "highly active" already, it's accounting for the fact that you are burning some heavy calories already... so eating more of those exercise calories is giving you too many. This is just my theory, but maybe either reset to a lower activity level or just don't log those exercise calories. Good luck... you look amazing, by the way!!!0
-
It's enough to drive you crazy right!?! My scale budged a little in the very beginning but now it just seems stuck Almost 30 days in and I am getting very disappointed. Are you checking your inches? You may just be losing inches and not the "pounds"... and I am sure with all the work you do, you HAVE to be gaining muscle?
As a spinner her gains wouldn't be huge in the muscle department. If she were actively trying to gain muscle she probably wouldn't have herself in any kind of deficit.0 -
My only thought is this... if you've changed your goal to reflect your busy lifestyle, maybe you shouldn't count your exercise calories? That's the only thing I can think of. I'm no expert, but my lifestyle is set to "lightly active" because I work at an office but am on my feet much of the day. Therefore when I work out, I count those calories and eat most if not all back. If you have your lifestyle set to "highly active" already, it's accounting for the fact that you are burning some heavy calories already... so eating more of those exercise calories is giving you too many. This is just my theory, but maybe either reset to a lower activity level or just don't log those exercise calories. Good luck... you look amazing, by the way!!!
When you change the activity level, it only adds or subtracts 100 calories (for mine at least) Which doesn't compensate for her extreme burning.0 -
Well, from my perspective - you look AMAZING!!!
But of course - you need the progress you're striving for. I'm not anywhere near where you are right now, so I don't think I can give real advice. However - if I were you - I'd try to cut out the sugar & boost the veggies. Eat lots & lots of veggies for your carb replacements - whole foods, IMO, are so much better for us.
I give myself little treats here & there (I'm not the kind of person who can cut out *any* type of food & stick to a plan), since that makes me feel like I'm not even sacrificing anything. But since you've hit a plateau, maybe cutting out sugar (or cutting it down, at least), might help.
Also - are you taking your measurements? Because it's obvious that you're building some muscle there, lol!!
I'm sure others who've been there will have better thoughts - but whatever you do - DON'T give up. You are doing great!!0 -
I always eat at least 1200 calories and if I have a minimal burn day I try to be withing 200 calories.0
-
I don't see where you've logged any water consumption. Make sure you're drinking at least 8 8-oz. glasses of water every day or you could be holding on to water weight. Also, I don't lose unless I keep my calorie consumption to right around 1200 calories NET. How are you measuring calories burned? If you're estimating or using MFPs estimates you could be overestimating. I use a heart rate monitor and subtract 1 calorie per minute from the total my HRM says and I log that number as calories burned. I know seeing no results can be frustrating -- we've all been there, but stay the course. You WILL lose that weight eventually.0
-
Your food diary looks pretty good to me. The only thing I would suggest is lowering your sugar intake (try staying under 40 grams of added sugar, not fruit), and upping your fiber and protein intake.
Good luck!0 -
awesome fit body!!
dont know about the losing weight stuff, sometimes thats just trial and error.0 -
I am not as active as you but I was pretty active plus workouts on top of it. Everyone kept telling me to eat more so I did and I zig zagged. After two months no change. I was so discouraged! So after seeing it countless times on here I changed my goal to lose half a pound and now only do two workouts a week. I don't weigh myself often but I put on a pair of jean shorts yesterday and after a week they are loose!
I have also read repeatedly how some people had to set their MFP goal to maintanience to lose any pounds. It may not be possible for you to workout less but I would try. I know how it sounds, its been pounded in our heads to lose weight we have to starve ourselves and then kill it at the gym.
I just wish I had listened to this earlier. Youmight have to tweak a little. Eat 100-200 over or maybe even less. I agree losing weight when theres not a lot left to lose is not as easy as "burn more than you consume".
Edit to say I did a 7 day zig zag but I've also read some people had better luck with a 3 day plan. Eat low for two days then have a really high day. Although with your amount of exercise you would really have to plan out your day to get all those calories in!0 -
you should measure ur self instead ur waist arms legs etc because if ur working out and not losing then u might be losing inches and gaining muscle!0
-
I've found the best way to lose weight is zig zagging your calories. I eat 1200 most days (I'm allowed 1650) but then I will treat myself twice a week with bad food that I don't count. Yet I lose weight. The weeks that I don't treat myself I don't lose weight. It's a delicate balance, because humans aren't supposed to eat the SAME thing every single day.0
-
I would have to agree with those above who said you need to eat more.... our bodies are amazing at adapting... but keep in mind it takes over 2 weeks to see changes after making tweaks, etc.0
-
sorry no advice but daaaaaaamn i want your guns.
enough to make me do some several many tons of push ups. Bye.0 -
I'm not sure of how many calories you get a day, but I am very active(workout about 2 hours a day) and I get around 2000 calories a day. This is total calories consumed, not taking exercise into account. I am still losing around 1-1.5lbs a week, so maybe you need to get more calories.0
-
Just experiment until you can break the plateau. Try cutting fat, try cutting carbs. Try adding 200 calories, try dropping 200 calories. Try the "zig-zag" thing. Weight loss is a science but it isn't an "exact" science.0
-
I would suggest seeing a nutritionist to get you off on the right foot. In my opinion (and experience), you might not be eating ENOUGH! I know it sounds crazy, but over exercising can put your body into a stagnant state as it may feel under distress because of all the activity. Plus, YOU LOOK AWESOME! Is it possible you have reached your "optimum" body state?0
-
I looked through your diary. Here's what I saw:
Decent quantity.
Horrible quality.
Remember that it's not just HOW MUCH you put into your body, but also WHAT you put in it. 200 calories of M&M's does not equate 200 calories of fruit, or a sweet potato, or something nutritious.
Rather than fretting over calories, focus on nixing all of that junk food. Do you really need a hot fudge sundae one day followed by a sonic milkshake followed by a candy bar followed by M&M's? No! None of that will help you reach your goals.
Just to be sure: I have the same problem. I eat junk food, but I'm working on switching to whole foods (whole fruit instead of fruit-flavored gummies, whole veggies instead of veggie chips, whole potatoes instead of french fries, whole chicken instead of chicken patties, etc.) Making this switch will increase your energy naturally and fill you with more self-satisfaction than 500 calories-worth of processed syrup and fat.
Good luck.0 -
Horrible quality? Really? I'm not an eat clean person, but I wouldn't call my quality horrible. We went to Philly last weekend and we splurged on some food/chocolates etc, but mostly I'm eating lean meats, fruits, salad, veggies with a sugar free Jello or protein bar in there etc. I dunno. I just don't agree with that one..I appreciate your thoughts though. I also agree that yeah, quality is important, but I lost 40 pounds before eating lean cuisines, Fiber One bars, and sugar free jello before I started to try and eat more whole food. So I ate sodium and sugar and dropped basically all the weight I lost until present day. Now that I'm eating all this whole food the scale isn't budging...so when it comes to weight loss and not health I'm not sure I'm totally on board with thinking that keeps you from losing. But what do I know. Seriously.0
-
Hi! I think you look great, and I agree with what most of the other posts on here that you are probably gaining muscle, and that is why are you aren't losing the weight, but you are still getting rid of the fat. The only thing I would recommend is make sure you are drinking lots of water, and not skipping any meals. Good Luck!0
-
I too am a fitness instructor teaching 10 give or take some each week classes a week. So, I know what you mean, as far as striking a balance. First, I assume you are drinking your water. That is not a problem for me. second, how are you calculating your calories burned? are they from a HR monitor or just numbers you have calculated or from MFP calcuation. I think MFP is high in calculations, and if you do exercise on a maching again these are formulas not exact the error can be up to 25 % in either direction. I
In looking at your diary, you sugars are HIGH! I would adjust your sugar intake. I *try* to make my sugar intake be my carbs--fruits. I do treat myself once and a while...Rhubarb crisp, frozen yogurt, lo cal/no sugar ice cream bars or fudge bars, 16 choclate chips.
The thing that made the biggest difference in my change, was I switched the goals in MFP for carbs 40%, fat 30%, protien 30%. It is killer for me to no go over in carbs! Maybe try that also.
I do eat back some of my calories, but not all that MFP gives me. And if you are struggling, maybe invest the money into a Dietian appointment. you can print off you diary and take it with you.0 -
Maybe you are losing inches instead of weight. I lose weight slowly but inches come off pretty quick.0
-
First of all...me...skipping meals? Bwahahahahaha!!! That's a good one. ;-D Secondly..yep..lots of water. MUCH MORE than I was drinking before. I'm using a Polar HRM so my calories are pretty good. Finding that balance is proving to be the impossible task for me!0
-
Have you had your body fat checked?
You look great, I dream of looking like that.
Is there a reason you want to lose more?
Maybe if your body fat is measured it may be quite low and therefore would be difficult to lose any more weight.0 -
Thanks. The pic is only of my arms. I need to take a body shot. My lower half still could be leaner/smaller...heck it SHOULD be with all the gosh darn working out. *sigh* At 5ft6 150+ is on the high end...I know some is muscle...but I think 130s-140s would be ideal overall. My fat % always changes. Usually between 22-25%. Not super low or athletic. My inches went down a bit first but have stayed there for 3 weeks or so.0
-
First, can I just say WOW! Killer arms! Way to go!
I took a look at your food diary, I think your carbs are way high, several days your carbs are more than twice your protein intake. Maybe it's time to tweak your macros. I've been very successful following "The Zone" way of eating. It takes into account your lean muscle mass and body fat percentages, and the protein, fat, carb ratios allow for optimum fat burning and energy while sustaining lean muscle mass. Rather than calories to support your current BMR, the goal should be calories to support your "optimal/goal" BMR. I am not purchasing any of the zone foods, just eating regular foods and staying within the advised 40/30/30 ratio of carbs, protein and fat. I've been steadily losing just 2 lbs a week, but have really noticed results the most with the tape measure and body fat %. Check out zonediet.com for more info. Might be the change you need to beat this plateau. Good luck!0 -
First, can I just say WOW! Killer arms! Way to go!
I took a look at your food diary, I think your carbs are way high, several days your carbs are more than twice your protein intake. Maybe it's time to tweak your macros. I've been very successful following "The Zone" way of eating. It takes into account your lean muscle mass and body fat percentages, and the protein, fat, carb ratios allow for optimum fat burning and energy while sustaining lean muscle mass. Rather than calories to support your current BMR, the goal should be calories to support your "optimal/goal" BMR. I am not purchasing any of the zone foods, just eating regular foods and staying within the advised 40/30/30 ratio of carbs, protein and fat. I've been steadily losing just 2 lbs a week, but have really noticed results the most with the tape measure and body fat %. Check out zonediet.com for more info. Might be the change you need to beat this plateau. Good luck!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions