Homemade ranch

rachelredd
rachelredd Posts: 5 Member
edited September 2016 in Food and Nutrition
Does anyone know why homemade ranch dressing is listed as only 26 calories when it's made with buttermilk and mayo? That can't be can it? The bottled stuff is 140 cals for only 2 TBS.

Replies

  • BarbieAS
    BarbieAS Posts: 1,414 Member
    I assume that you're talking about a database entry?

    Most of the entries in the database are generated by MFP users. This means that while you can usually find an entry that works for what you're looking for, they are also often prone to errors. You should always double-check the nutritional info of any food you log to be sure it's accurate.

    Additionally, you should ALWAYS avoid database entries that say something like "homemade." This would imply that someone made it at home, right? But how do you know what they made it with? Perhaps you make your homemade ranch dressing with buttermilk and mayo, but maybe they make theirs with skim milk and fat-free greek yogurt so that it is only 26 calories for a tablespoon. Or maybe it's just a totally made up and inaccurate entry.

    Either way, you'll get a lot more accuracy (and success) if you stick with database entries for brand names, generic single-ingredient items, and restaurant foods that can all be verified against other sources of nutritional info, and to use the recipe builder when you're making something at home (if you don't want to log the components separately in your diary) so that you're sure to log a food the way you made it.

    Of course there are always times when you'll have to make your very best guess because you don't have nutritional info available, but make those the exception and not the rule. And, if you know darn well that the calorie count you find in the database is totally unreasonable (aka, you made your ranch dressing with buttermilk and mayo, you know there's no way your version is 26 calories), find a different entry. I mean, you can lie in your diary all you want, but the scale will always tell you the truth.
  • TeaBea
    TeaBea Posts: 14,517 Member
    Not sure if these are the ingredients used............but it's possible

    hidden valley ranch - mix, 1 tsp 10 Cal
    Kraft Mayo - Fat Free Mayo, 1 TBSP 10 Cal
    Evans' Farmhouse - Skim Cultured Buttermilk, 0.5 oz 6 cal = 26 total
  • Ready2Rock206
    Ready2Rock206 Posts: 9,487 Member
    If you're making the ranch dressing use the recipe builder - don't use random entries from the database where you have no idea what the other person is using.
  • rachelredd
    rachelredd Posts: 5 Member
    Thank you everyone!
  • fishshark
    fishshark Posts: 1,886 Member
    i make homemade ranch but i use buttermilk powder and greek yogurt :)