Do longer work days require more calories?
ajctrain2027
Posts: 4 Member
I start my day at 4:30 and get home between 5:30-6:00. I have a hard time stretching 1200 calories over the day and arriving home famished. I have a protein drink on the way home, but evenings are a real challenge. I wonder if people with longer schedules need an extra 200-300? Or is that wishful thinking?
0
Replies
-
It depends more upon what kind of work you do than anything. If it's physically demanding, absolutely. If it's an office job that involves 90% sitting on your butt, probably not.
I found that for my really low-calorie, longer days, eating smaller amount every four hours tended to help. By the end of each four hour period, the hunger was really starting to set in hard, and for me, the hungrier I am, the less food it takes to shut my gut up.3 -
That's true. It's probably key to keep to that 4 hour limit and avoid being overly hungry. And it's 98% at my desk. Thank you0
-
I am the opposite...
Skipping breakfast most days helps me control hunger, it gives me more volume for lunch/dinner. My husband works early hours from home so I usually wake up when he does so often times I'm up 4am too. I eat on average 1250 calories.
I also started playing around with my macros and I found having a carb, protein, fat with every meal helps keep me satiated on lower calories.
So maybe try playing around with your macros and meal frequency to find your sweet spot.3 -
No. Your maintenance calories account for your daily activity. Is 1200 calories what MFP gave you?0
-
Yes. So I have to stick to it. Keeping the 4 hour rule in response 1 is helping. Paying attention to macros also makes sense.0
-
I work 12 hr shifts (desk job). 5 smaller meals throughout my day (every 3-4 hours) along with lots of water works well for me. I never feel hungry,1
-
ajctrain2027 wrote: »I start my day at 4:30 and get home between 5:30-6:00. I have a hard time stretching 1200 calories over the day and arriving home famished. I have a protein drink on the way home, but evenings are a real challenge. I wonder if people with longer schedules need an extra 200-300? Or is that wishful thinking?
Is your goal appropriate or overly restrictive and agressive? Are you a very active person or sedentary?
Do you get 8 hours or less of sleep each day? If you get much less than 8 hours consider getting more. When I am sleep deprived I always want to eat more. http://www.uchospitals.edu/news/2004/20041206-sleep.html
Most people are probably awake 14-16 hours a day so no you don't need more calories than someone else just because you have a long work day instead of being home during those hours.
Are you meeting your protein, fat, fiber goals? You said you were drinking a protein shake. I personally find chewing satisfies me more than drinking my calories.
Play around with when you eat most of your calories. I eat every 3-5 hours. That is when I get hungry but I don't split my calories evenly. Some people eat more frequently or less frequently. Find what helps you function best. Try eating lighter in the morning and save more calories for later in the day maybe.3 -
I, too, am a female desk-sitter in my late 50's and keep similar hours. MFP and other calculators give me @ 1500 to maintain my current weight of 131 for a sedentary lifestyle. You must be very small to maintain at 1200 per day. Exercise is your best friend! Eat at least some (half?) of the calories burned.0
-
ajctrain2027 wrote: »I start my day at 4:30 and get home between 5:30-6:00. I have a hard time stretching 1200 calories over the day and arriving home famished. I have a protein drink on the way home, but evenings are a real challenge. I wonder if people with longer schedules need an extra 200-300? Or is that wishful thinking?
I think that 1200 calories is too few for the vast majority of people. (You can ignore that statement if you're a very short sedentary older woman.) That's more likely the problem.
As others have noted, sitting at a desk for a few extra hours doesn't mean your body needs extra calories. Staying awake longer doesn't even usually mean your body needs extra calories - but it sure will try to convince you of the opposite. Which is why getting enough sleep is important for weight loss. Your day starts very early. Do you get enough sleep? Not getting enough sleep can make you hungry.2 -
Sleep is a big issue. So all of you have given me the things, that I need to work on. Thank you!0
-
The more you work, the more energy you need. This includes mental energy, as if you have a desk job, you don't need more calories. But if food is motivating, then that long of a work day you will crave more food to keep you going!0
-
I mean im not a fan of protein shakes in this situation i almost wonder if its not mental, You want something to chew and enjoy when you get home. But no you don't need more calories for long hours of sitting on your booty at work XD0
-
I have a desk job and have found if I don't get some cardio at lunch time I'm more prone to the munchies in the afternoon.
The sun is out today and I'm looking forward to a long walk around the pond in a state park near me at lunch.0 -
ajctrain2027 wrote: »I start my day at 4:30 and get home between 5:30-6:00. I have a hard time stretching 1200 calories over the day and arriving home famished. I have a protein drink on the way home, but evenings are a real challenge. I wonder if people with longer schedules need an extra 200-300? Or is that wishful thinking?
1200 is a DEFAULT minimum for women. It's not necessarily right for you. I'm 55 (5'5") and eat 1400 calories. I do lose slower, but staying consistent is the most important thing.
I will go for a walk at lunch time, or after work. Bad weather - I walk in a local home improvement store - or use a "walking" video (YouTube). Staying active is so important for your health.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions