Losing the last 5 kilos

amyrebel15
amyrebel15 Posts: 8 Member
edited November 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
I'm 164cm and weigh about 61 kilos. I've been struggling to get to my goal weight of 56. I've been below my overall daily calorie goal 90% of the time for the past 4 weeks and been exercising at least 4 times a week for the past 3 weeks. I want to get to my goal weight within the next 3.5 weeks. Any advice? What should I do differently? :(

Replies

  • malibu927
    malibu927 Posts: 17,562 Member
    You're at a healthy weight already, so it's going to take a LOT longer than 3.5 weeks to get to your goal weight (and even that rate isn't recommended at all). Be patient and make sure you're logging everything as accurately as possible. Being below your goal 90% of the time probably isn't good enough if those 10% are enough to erase your deficit. You should be AT your goal every single day, or averaged out over the week.
  • Christine_72
    Christine_72 Posts: 16,049 Member
    My only advice is be prepared for it to take more like 3-5mths. You're already very light so it will be sloooow going, plus once you're so close to goal your logging and calorie compliance needs to be closer to 100%.
  • amyrebel15
    amyrebel15 Posts: 8 Member
    malibu927 wrote: »
    You're at a healthy weight already, so it's going to take a LOT longer than 3.5 weeks to get to your goal weight (and even that rate isn't recommended at all). Be patient and make sure you're logging everything as accurately as possible. Being below your goal 90% of the time probably isn't good enough if those 10% are enough to erase your deficit. You should be AT your goal every single day, or averaged out over the week.

    It's been 4 weeks already though. Even if I go above my calorie goal, I offset it by exercising... thus still maintaining my deficit. Not sure what more to do agh.
  • Christine_72
    Christine_72 Posts: 16,049 Member
    amyrebel15 wrote: »
    malibu927 wrote: »
    You're at a healthy weight already, so it's going to take a LOT longer than 3.5 weeks to get to your goal weight (and even that rate isn't recommended at all). Be patient and make sure you're logging everything as accurately as possible. Being below your goal 90% of the time probably isn't good enough if those 10% are enough to erase your deficit. You should be AT your goal every single day, or averaged out over the week.

    It's been 4 weeks already though. Even if I go above my calorie goal, I offset it by exercising... thus still maintaining my deficit. Not sure what more to do agh.

    Patience and tight logging will be your best friends moving forward.

  • malibu927
    malibu927 Posts: 17,562 Member
    amyrebel15 wrote: »
    malibu927 wrote: »
    You're at a healthy weight already, so it's going to take a LOT longer than 3.5 weeks to get to your goal weight (and even that rate isn't recommended at all). Be patient and make sure you're logging everything as accurately as possible. Being below your goal 90% of the time probably isn't good enough if those 10% are enough to erase your deficit. You should be AT your goal every single day, or averaged out over the week.

    It's been 4 weeks already though. Even if I go above my calorie goal, I offset it by exercising... thus still maintaining my deficit. Not sure what more to do agh.

    How many calories a day are you eating? How are you measuring them?
  • amyrebel15
    amyrebel15 Posts: 8 Member
    malibu927 wrote: »
    amyrebel15 wrote: »
    malibu927 wrote: »
    You're at a healthy weight already, so it's going to take a LOT longer than 3.5 weeks to get to your goal weight (and even that rate isn't recommended at all). Be patient and make sure you're logging everything as accurately as possible. Being below your goal 90% of the time probably isn't good enough if those 10% are enough to erase your deficit. You should be AT your goal every single day, or averaged out over the week.

    It's been 4 weeks already though. Even if I go above my calorie goal, I offset it by exercising... thus still maintaining my deficit. Not sure what more to do agh.

    How many calories a day are you eating? How are you measuring them?

    My goal is a 900 but I end up at 1000 where as the recommended intake is 1250.

    Measuring them by reading labels or googling and estimating (the same way I've done for the past year+).
  • amyrebel15
    amyrebel15 Posts: 8 Member
    amyrebel15 wrote: »
    malibu927 wrote: »
    You're at a healthy weight already, so it's going to take a LOT longer than 3.5 weeks to get to your goal weight (and even that rate isn't recommended at all). Be patient and make sure you're logging everything as accurately as possible. Being below your goal 90% of the time probably isn't good enough if those 10% are enough to erase your deficit. You should be AT your goal every single day, or averaged out over the week.

    It's been 4 weeks already though. Even if I go above my calorie goal, I offset it by exercising... thus still maintaining my deficit. Not sure what more to do agh.

    Patience and tight logging will be your best friends moving forward.

    Does offsetting the excess calorie intake by exercise to maintian my calorie deficit not help though?
  • malibu927
    malibu927 Posts: 17,562 Member
    amyrebel15 wrote: »
    malibu927 wrote: »
    amyrebel15 wrote: »
    malibu927 wrote: »
    You're at a healthy weight already, so it's going to take a LOT longer than 3.5 weeks to get to your goal weight (and even that rate isn't recommended at all). Be patient and make sure you're logging everything as accurately as possible. Being below your goal 90% of the time probably isn't good enough if those 10% are enough to erase your deficit. You should be AT your goal every single day, or averaged out over the week.

    It's been 4 weeks already though. Even if I go above my calorie goal, I offset it by exercising... thus still maintaining my deficit. Not sure what more to do agh.

    How many calories a day are you eating? How are you measuring them?

    My goal is a 900 but I end up at 1000 where as the recommended intake is 1250.

    Measuring them by reading labels or googling and estimating (the same way I've done for the past year+).

    First off, you should not be aiming for anything that low. Set your goal to a quarter of a kilogram per week since you have so little to lose.

    Second, invest in a food scale. Your estimations are way off, and weighing your food will help you see exactly how much a serving is. Also when you eat your exercise calories (which is what you are supposed to do), don't eat all of them...try 50% to start off with, as they can often be overestimated.
  • Christine_72
    Christine_72 Posts: 16,049 Member
    amyrebel15 wrote: »
    amyrebel15 wrote: »
    malibu927 wrote: »
    You're at a healthy weight already, so it's going to take a LOT longer than 3.5 weeks to get to your goal weight (and even that rate isn't recommended at all). Be patient and make sure you're logging everything as accurately as possible. Being below your goal 90% of the time probably isn't good enough if those 10% are enough to erase your deficit. You should be AT your goal every single day, or averaged out over the week.

    It's been 4 weeks already though. Even if I go above my calorie goal, I offset it by exercising... thus still maintaining my deficit. Not sure what more to do agh.

    Patience and tight logging will be your best friends moving forward.

    Does offsetting the excess calorie intake by exercise to maintian my calorie deficit not help though?

    Yes, exercise will help. But you're wanting to lose over 1.5kg per week, and at your weight this will be near impossible. Your body can only lose so much fat per day/week, you will end up losing more muscle than fat if you try and lose too fast.

    Ditch the label/google calorie counts and buy a food scale. Weigh every single thing you eat and use measuring cups for all liquids. Accuracy is very important at this stage of your weight loss. A few extra inaccurate calorie counts here and there will add up at the end of the week and slow you down even more.
  • barni71
    barni71 Posts: 30 Member
    I was just under 61 kilos around mid August and only reached 56.5 kilos about a week ago so it's taken me just over 3 months to lose 4.5 kilos. My average net calories per day was around 1400 at the beginning (which includes over indulging at the week end) and I only exercise a few times a week. Yes it has taken a long time to shed those last pounds but I haven't felt like I've missed out on anything and you do have to be more accurate with your logging as you get closer to your goal
  • PAV8888
    PAV8888 Posts: 14,336 Member
    With exercise in the mix and normal starting weight the goal should be physique not weight number oriented. Deficit should not exceed 20% of tdee. And that 20℅ would be with 100% exercise counted, not half. Trending weight app. Essentially recomp.
  • amyrebel15
    amyrebel15 Posts: 8 Member
    barni71 wrote: »
    I was just under 61 kilos around mid August and only reached 56.5 kilos about a week ago so it's taken me just over 3 months to lose 4.5 kilos. My average net calories per day was around 1400 at the beginning (which includes over indulging at the week end) and I only exercise a few times a week. Yes it has taken a long time to shed those last pounds but I haven't felt like I've missed out on anything and you do have to be more accurate with your logging as you get closer to your goal

    I have been eating well below 1400 calories in the past 4 weeks.. But not seeing any decent results. It's a weird fluctuation situation going on. I think I'll reduce my sugar intake more and continue with maintaining a decent deficit to see good results. Congrats on reaching your goal though! :)
  • amyrebel15
    amyrebel15 Posts: 8 Member
    PAV8888 wrote: »
    With exercise in the mix and normal starting weight the goal should be physique not weight number oriented. Deficit should not exceed 20% of tdee. And that 20℅ would be with 100% exercise counted, not half. Trending weight app. Essentially recomp.

    What happens even if deficit increases from that?
    My stats are such that my deficit has usually been more than 20% of the tdee, including exercise specially. Still not working....
  • Christine_72
    Christine_72 Posts: 16,049 Member
    @amyrebel15 are all the "homemade" entries in your diary your own recipes or ones you chose from the database? If they are random entries then i would start there by entering your own recipes into the recipe builder here, their recipes could be completely different to yours so the calorie count could be way off.
    Also, ditch the spoon/slices and cups and weigh everything on a food scale, save the cups for liquids only.
  • Psychgrrl
    Psychgrrl Posts: 3,177 Member
    I was scanning the topics on the message board and accidentally combined this one with the one above it and though it read "Losing the last 5 kids."

    Clicked in like WTF!?! And then, oh ...! :lol:
  • amyrebel15
    amyrebel15 Posts: 8 Member
    @amyrebel15 are all the "homemade" entries in your diary your own recipes or ones you chose from the database? If they are random entries then i would start there by entering your own recipes into the recipe builder here, their recipes could be completely different to yours so the calorie count could be way off.
    Also, ditch the spoon/slices and cups and weigh everything on a food scale, save the cups for liquids only.

    Thanks for the tip, will definitely look at doing this!
  • amyrebel15
    amyrebel15 Posts: 8 Member
    Psychgrrl wrote: »
    I was scanning the topics on the message board and accidentally combined this one with the one above it and though it read "Losing the last 5 kids."

    Clicked in like WTF!?! And then, oh ...! :lol:

    Hahaha that made me smile! Good one
  • PAV8888
    PAV8888 Posts: 14,336 Member
    amyrebel15 wrote: »
    PAV8888 wrote: »
    With exercise in the mix and normal starting weight the goal should be physique not weight number oriented. Deficit should not exceed 20% of tdee. And that 20℅ would be with 100% exercise counted, not half. Trending weight app. Essentially recomp.

    What happens even if deficit increases from that?
    My stats are such that my deficit has usually been more than 20% of the tdee, including exercise specially. Still not working....

    If your deficit really is that big you end up losing more lean mass than you should/could. And you end up potentially making your body more efficient thus reducing your actual TDEE below what it is "expected" to be and having to eat at a lower level in order to generate an actual deficit

    Of course we don't KNOW that your deficit really is that big.

    Your actual deficit also depends on the accuracy of your logging. Correctly weighed, correct entries, items not forgotten, all food, tastes, pan wipes, samples, and drinks including those on overage days and/or the middle of the night accounted for using verified usda or similar entries and potentially even correcting deliberately misleading manufacturer/food producer labels. And correctly estimated daily activity and exercise calories.

    In reality you will never know how accurate your logging is. But with some effort (keeping track, comparing trending weight results) you may manage to find a golden path between over-eating and under-eating.

    The point is that eating nothing and exercising lots at a normal weight is an exercise in frustration that will get you no-where other than yo-yoing a few hard fought lbs up and down for the foreseeable future.

    Changing your body by eating a little bit less, moving a little bit more, and throwing in some kick *kitten* exercise may well yield results. But it is also an exercise in patience.

    I am sure that there exist people who hit the weights hard and cut real hard and lost weight fast while retaining most muscle in the presence of eating sufficient protein and doing this for only short periods of time. It is not the way that MFP (or I for that matter) advocates and it neglects that you should be engaged in routines and eat in a way that you are willing to continue doing for the foreseeable future. You know... when you're done with your diet!
This discussion has been closed.