Swimming

AuburnDawg
AuburnDawg Posts: 1 Member
edited November 2024 in Fitness and Exercise
Just curious if anyone out there is swimming for weight loss and if so, what have you found is successful regarding workouts. I cannot do butterfly or breast stroke so backstroke and freestyle are my 2 strokes.

Replies

  • BrianSharpe
    BrianSharpe Posts: 9,248 Member
    Swimming is great exercise (I'm not a great swimmer and would rather run but as a triathlon wannabe I don't want to embarrass myself too badly next June) but as with every other activity the weight loss comes from maintaining a caloric deficit consistently over time.
  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    Swimming is great exercise (I'm not a great swimmer and would rather run but as a triathlon wannabe I don't want to embarrass myself too badly next June) but as with every other activity the weight loss comes from maintaining a caloric deficit consistently over time.

    Yup...
  • lorrpb
    lorrpb Posts: 11,463 Member
    Swimmimg is great for fitness. Backstroke & front crawl are great strokes. Many people like water aerobics too. It is common to feel very hungry after swimming, so plan an extra snacks into your calories for the day.

    Swimming by itself does not create weight loss. You must eat fewer calories than you burn. Set up your mfp stats, at sedenatry, to lose 1 lb per week, weigh all food, and log it. Eat back half your exercise calories in addition to the goal mfp gives you, because that number does not account for exercise. Weight loss happens in the kitchen, fitness happens at thE pool. Good luck!
  • __TMac__
    __TMac__ Posts: 1,669 Member
    I'm doing other cardio, but I'd like to fit swimming back in soon. My dad and I race across the lake every summer (a 30-year tradition). I beat him for the first time last year so I'll be darned if I'm going to lose THIS year! :)
  • beerfoamy
    beerfoamy Posts: 1,520 Member
    I swim Mon-Fri, as mentioned above, not noticed a massive weight loss from it alone, but it sure helps boost my calorie burn.
    I tend to do (in a 25m pool):
    20/40 front crawl warm up
    30 with my hand fin thingys to up the resistance
    5 normal front crawl
    5 breaststroke
    5 front crawl
    5 breaststroke (these sets of 5 I use as a 'rest if I am doing more than 2km)
    10 front crawl (sometimes with float to take my legs out and focus on arms)

    I get more out of breathe with breaststroke now than with front crawl, so am planning on upping my laps in that - backstroke needs to really be done in a clear lane for me, as I still haven't mastered 'straight' swimming, but I feel that the next day even from doing 10. :)

    love swimming :D
  • kenyonhaff
    kenyonhaff Posts: 1,377 Member
    You can certainly get a great workout just doing front and back stroke. Learning different strokes would help you work different muscle groups. Also, breast stroke is good to know if you are in outdoor swimming long-distance conditions...it's easier to keep one's bearings.

    Butterfly is a great workout, but is the most useless form of swimming. Only useful in swim competitions.
  • jjpptt2
    jjpptt2 Posts: 5,650 Member
    Swimming is great exercise (I'm not a great swimmer and would rather run but as a triathlon wannabe I don't want to embarrass myself too badly next June) but as with every other activity the weight loss comes from maintaining a caloric deficit consistently over time.

    Agreed. It's a great exercise and can have numerous benefits... but swimming to lose weight is like swimming against the current if your diet/intake isn't in check.
  • rosebarnalice
    rosebarnalice Posts: 3,488 Member
    Love it! Swear by it! Swimming is the only exercise that I LIKE, and that I CAN and WILL do consistently, so it's my exercise of choice.

    Any stroke will get the work done, depending on your rate of speed and your heart rate. A friend of mine is a TERRIBLE swimmer-- he breast strokes, goes slow, his stroke is horrible and he looks like a drowning pelican, but all that ineffiency means that he gets and maintains an elevated heart rate around 130 for a solid 40 minutes. He's a skinny little thing, so at his body weight, we've estimated that his 40 minutes of thrashing is about a 450 calorie burn--and that's a good workout!

    I on the other hand am a beautiful swimmer (if I must say so myself. . .) with powerful kick and a lovely smoothe glide. I usually swim freestyle, because breast stroke just doesn't get my heart rate up. But I can crank out the laps freestyle at a heart rate of 130 for 70 minutes two to four times a week. That's a calorie burn for me of ~ 500 - 550 calories--and that's a good workout, too!
  • jessicagreen1828
    jessicagreen1828 Posts: 133 Member
    I picked my gym because it was the only one near me with an indoor pool! I love to swim and did swimteam when I was younger. I don't miss getting in the (outdoor) pool at 8am when it was 65 degrees out (64 degrees or colder meant practice was cancelled), but I miss the motivation that came from being on a team. Swimming is so calming to me. I try to get in 10-20 laps (50's) and some days will push for 32, which I think is a mile. Just depends on how much time I have.
  • beerfoamy
    beerfoamy Posts: 1,520 Member
    I on the other hand am a beautiful swimmer (if I must say so myself. . .) with powerful kick and a lovely smoothe glide. I usually swim freestyle, because breast stroke just doesn't get my heart rate up. But I can crank out the laps freestyle at a heart rate of 130 for 70 minutes two to four times a week. That's a calorie burn for me of ~ 500 - 550 calories--and that's a good workout, too!

    I got told by a guy today after swimming 2.5km in 50mins that 'he hadn't seen me out of breath'.

    Did make me think, 'yay, I have stamina' but also, maybe I should be working on getting my heart rate up a bit more on shorter swims a couple of times a week. Unless of course it is up, and I just don't notice? maybe need an HRM......

    Completely justified this morn though as I am doing a 5km tomorrow and wanted to ease into it a bit, I find boredom can sometimes set in around the 120th lap! lol



  • deannalfisher
    deannalfisher Posts: 5,600 Member
    if you want to get your heartrate up while swimming - do some intervals/sets

    so a standard swim for me will be 200 w/u; 4x50 drill; main set of something like 20X25 on 30 (sprint the 25yds, and then start the next interval at the 30sec mark - you could adjust the time); then 200 cool down

    i'll happily post other swim workouts - i do everything from 1000-4500yd swims
  • HG210
    HG210 Posts: 103 Member
    I can't swim but wan to learn. You are moving every part of your body even you head so it has to be the best exercise ever.
  • sarabushby
    sarabushby Posts: 784 Member
    Often beginners can mistake breathlessness from swimming with having a high HR. It's quite feasible for someone to appear out of breath whilst swimming, believe therefore that they are 'working hard' but in fact not have an especially high HR, they just have poor breathing technique.
  • Jules_farmgirl
    Jules_farmgirl Posts: 225 Member
    I love using this as a form of exercise. An idea to add in if you want more options.. use a flutter board!! They are great! I use one to work either my legs (holding it out in front of me to cause resistance and not use my upper body at all) and to work my arms and shoulders (Put it between my knees so I can't kick)
  • goodkoalie
    goodkoalie Posts: 84 Member
    This is my absolute favorite cardio exercise. Of course, I may be biased as I have been swimming competitively for my 7 years.

    Swimming can be an amazing workout if you are able to get your heart rate up. Butterfly is the best stroke to achieve this, but be very careful, as you can injure yourself easily with improper form.
  • kaizaku
    kaizaku Posts: 1,039 Member
    I use to go swimming every week and will be restarting soon. Use to do laps for hour without rest. Well, sometimes 20 seconds. To catch my breath. But didn't use it for fat loss. But it's good to tone up and burn calories.

    Practice makes perfect.
  • dwisehart
    dwisehart Posts: 36 Member
    AuburnDawg wrote: »
    Just curious if anyone out there is swimming for weight loss and if so, what have you found is successful regarding workouts. I cannot do butterfly or breast stroke so backstroke and freestyle are my 2 strokes.

    I really enjoy swim workouts and I find it helpful to swim with a class twice a week. The class days are my aerobic workout days because we push ourselves further, harder and with shorter intervals when we working out together, cheering each other on.

    The other days of the week I swim by myself, working on my technique with the goal of keeping it interesting while keeping my heart rate above 80% of maximum while swimming and allowing it to come down to 70% of maximum during the rest between lengths.

    A good coach can be invaluable at pointing you in the right direction on what is most important for you to work on. We are always doing seven or seventeen things wrong while swimming, but the question is, which one should you be working on next. A coach gives direction to your days swimming alone.

    Probably your workouts will be based on what you do in class, with lots of modifications so you spend time working on your technique while swimming slowly, but with enough resistance to keep your heart rate up. A typical workout is a warmup with steadily increasing effort, followed by a main set with intervals to work on aerobic capacity or ladders to work on increasing speed. The distances will vary based on your swimming ability, but here is a simple ladder workout I might do:

    Warm-up:
    100 smooth
    50 kick
    50 drill
    50 pick up the pace
    50 easy
    (repeat four 50's)
    Main set:
    75 fast
    25 kick
    2x50 recover
    50 fast
    50 kick
    2x50 recover
    25 fast
    75 kick
    2x50 recover
    100 fast
    rest
    (repeat main set three times)
This discussion has been closed.