KETO & OMAD the best weight loss marriage!!
deborahbarnes904
Posts: 15 Member
I started January, 34 days ago, down almost 16 lbs. I lose on average 2 to 4 ounces a day. Of course some days no loss, others a gain. I have experienced two "whoosh" and each time lost over 1 lb. My loss is trending pleasantly down. Much different than my first attempt at LCHF.
Making mistakes with Keto can cause serious stalls and even hinder weight loss. I'll talk about Keto first. Learn from my blunders. If you're doing keto and not happy with your loss answer these questions. Am I drinking diet soda? Am I consuming artificial sweeteners? Am I consuming any "diet" food (example: Atkins products). Am I consuming more than 30% of protein daily? Have I used a keto calculator to determine my total daily energy expenditure? Am I consuming OVER 75% fat? Do I daily eat at a deficit? (Some keto folks don't believe in eating at a deficit. I learned to, i personally had to. You may be different. Discover your own truth about deficits by experimenting).
I used to consume upwards of 80% fat or more, (fat bombs) (you want to utilize your OWN body fat so you do not want to consume over 75% fat on average. I currently consume between 70 to 75%, most often is 70%. Protein is essential. I used to not calculate at all how much protein I consumed. Too much and it converts to glucose. You should keep protein between 15 to 30%. I average around 25 to 30%. (Once you know your daily energy expenditure say it's 1700. Then you use the keto calculator to determine how many fat, protein grams you should consume. Then log daily what you'll eat, and from there you will see as you log your food what percent you're at. I use fatsecret and cronometer.com.). You can google ketogenic diet for appropriate food to consume.
OMAD. What can I say about one meal a day? I would suggest intermittent fasting regularly and increase your time to learn how to manage hunger with distraction and water. Fasting takes much practice. The more often you do it the better you get at managing the little voice in your head that says" feed me!" I love OMAD.
I was surprised that my stomach volume shrunk by fasting everyday for 23 hours. At first I could hardly eat 1000 calories, then I was able to eat normal amounts then I found I was miserable because I felt so stuffed. It's taken some time but now I eat till I'm almost full. I consume between 1350 and 1850 calories. Averaging 1500.
When I started OMAD for some reason I didn't lose any weight. A week later I decided to go back to LCHF or Keto. I wanted to do them together. There was an immediate response. I started losing right away.
Not like many people, I believe in climbing the scale everyday. I'm learning patterns in my weight loss and gains. I simultaneously take body measurements of my neck, arm, waist, hips, and thighs. As well as photos. When the scale goes up I grab my measuring tape. So far each time I check I've LOST more inches from the last record made. So far I've lost 8.5 inches, five on my waist!
Finding a weight loss plan is very personal. What works for me may not work for you. Don't give up. Keep tweaking and trying. I gave up and regained 30 lbs.
This is the first time in my life when a weight loss strategy/lifestyle worked so well for me. I'm here if you have any questions!!
Deborah
Making mistakes with Keto can cause serious stalls and even hinder weight loss. I'll talk about Keto first. Learn from my blunders. If you're doing keto and not happy with your loss answer these questions. Am I drinking diet soda? Am I consuming artificial sweeteners? Am I consuming any "diet" food (example: Atkins products). Am I consuming more than 30% of protein daily? Have I used a keto calculator to determine my total daily energy expenditure? Am I consuming OVER 75% fat? Do I daily eat at a deficit? (Some keto folks don't believe in eating at a deficit. I learned to, i personally had to. You may be different. Discover your own truth about deficits by experimenting).
I used to consume upwards of 80% fat or more, (fat bombs) (you want to utilize your OWN body fat so you do not want to consume over 75% fat on average. I currently consume between 70 to 75%, most often is 70%. Protein is essential. I used to not calculate at all how much protein I consumed. Too much and it converts to glucose. You should keep protein between 15 to 30%. I average around 25 to 30%. (Once you know your daily energy expenditure say it's 1700. Then you use the keto calculator to determine how many fat, protein grams you should consume. Then log daily what you'll eat, and from there you will see as you log your food what percent you're at. I use fatsecret and cronometer.com.). You can google ketogenic diet for appropriate food to consume.
OMAD. What can I say about one meal a day? I would suggest intermittent fasting regularly and increase your time to learn how to manage hunger with distraction and water. Fasting takes much practice. The more often you do it the better you get at managing the little voice in your head that says" feed me!" I love OMAD.
I was surprised that my stomach volume shrunk by fasting everyday for 23 hours. At first I could hardly eat 1000 calories, then I was able to eat normal amounts then I found I was miserable because I felt so stuffed. It's taken some time but now I eat till I'm almost full. I consume between 1350 and 1850 calories. Averaging 1500.
When I started OMAD for some reason I didn't lose any weight. A week later I decided to go back to LCHF or Keto. I wanted to do them together. There was an immediate response. I started losing right away.
Not like many people, I believe in climbing the scale everyday. I'm learning patterns in my weight loss and gains. I simultaneously take body measurements of my neck, arm, waist, hips, and thighs. As well as photos. When the scale goes up I grab my measuring tape. So far each time I check I've LOST more inches from the last record made. So far I've lost 8.5 inches, five on my waist!
Finding a weight loss plan is very personal. What works for me may not work for you. Don't give up. Keep tweaking and trying. I gave up and regained 30 lbs.
This is the first time in my life when a weight loss strategy/lifestyle worked so well for me. I'm here if you have any questions!!
Deborah
14
Replies
-
what time do you eat your meal?0
-
Lizh9 because of my odd sleep schedule on average I eat at 9:30pm. But I'm not married to it if my schedule changes.0
-
I am also on the keto diet and have lost 9.2 pounds and 2.75 inches so far over the past 4 weeks. I love it because after getting over the keto flu in the first 3 days I no longer want starches, sweets, or breads. And the reduced appetite is so wonderful; I don't have to worry about going over on my daily calories which I also keep track of along with the carbs. My clothes are fitting better and I've already been able to open back up part of the "inaccessible" part of my closet. But I still have about 70 pounds to go before I reach my goal, which should be around 3rd quarter this year.1
-
Awesome tahliadcrock! I have about 85 to go. I had a touch of keto flu. I'm over a month now and I don't have any real hunger that demands attention. So getting in my 23 hours is surprising and easy. Congrats on your loss! It's Exciting! Love keto, love OMAD!0
-
-
Thanks a million for that comprehensive and selfless piece. I'll be saving that for reference as so many of my questions were answered. I started normal low carb on January 7th with an average of 6hrs cardio st the gym. I'd only lost 6lbs. Started keto last Sunday and down 4lbs. I'm really struggling with the fats that make me a bit queasy. I'm 207 and target is 250 by end of June. I'm also combining the 5:2 and 16:8 IF. All the best.0
-
Congrats!! I do not exercise though I want to to be more active. You can put healthy fats/oil on your salad. Or butter or oil in coffee. In the beginning I was nausaed when I consumed my meal which was high in fat, that goes away. Took over a week maybe longer. Work through that. If you are logging what you eat you'll find if your foods are Keto you don't need many tablespoons of butter or oil. lately ive been averaging 2 tablespoons a day. Though one day I goofed and needed in my coffee 2 tablespoons of both butter and coconut oil. It was yummy. That's happened only once. So log for entries. You may be surprised to reach your percent is not many spoons away.0
-
I have just started eating (officially) LCHF last week. Not only have I lost 2.2 lbs, but I feel better. I'm less bloated and have less digestive issues. I have been able to stop using crystal light in my water and I do not eat bread, pasta or sweets. My next goal is to eat more vegetables, so any recipes for low carb veggies would be great. I love reading what others have done to give me ideas of how I can keep improving.1
-
I lost about 10lbs in 4 weeks on Keto. Then I got a stomach flue and had one piece of bread. It pushed me off ketosis. Crap! Now I have to get back into it! Has anyone tried a FAT FAST to get back into ketosis? Any recommendations on food?1
-
kathykrupa297 wrote: »I lost about 10lbs in 4 weeks on Keto. Then I got a stomach flue and had one piece of bread. It pushed me off ketosis. Crap! Now I have to get back into it! Has anyone tried a FAT FAST to get back into ketosis? Any recommendations on food?
It takes about 3 days sometimes less to get back into ketosis. I on average lost 3.8 lbs doing a fat fast. You regain about 1 lb when you resume eating. Generally is used to break a stall. It's a five day high fat diet of up to 1000 calories though you can go as high 1200. It's four to five mini meals. The following are meals separated by a comma.
1 boiled egg w 1T mayo, 1 oz cream cheese w half ounce macadamia nuts, slice cheese w slice bacon, 2oz tuna w 1 T mayo, BPC w butter 1T or 1T coconut oil, oz cream cheese w bacon, egg w bacon.
4 -
physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.2 -
slbenner21 wrote: »I have just started eating (officially) LCHF last week. Not only have I lost 2.2 lbs, but I feel better. I'm less bloated and have less digestive issues. I have been able to stop using crystal light in my water and I do not eat bread, pasta or sweets. My next goal is to eat more vegetables, so any recipes for low carb veggies would be great. I love reading what others have done to give me ideas of how I can keep improving.
That's awesome. Be sure to check carbs on your veg. Avoid roots like potato, yams, oh and corn as starch is a carb. Good for you quitting Crystal lite. Artificial sweeteners really really impeded my weight loss. Good luck!0 -
I am a keto'er....Most of us are in this awesome group.....Feel free to join http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-lcd-group
I have lost 91 lbs with 30 more to go
Congrats on all your weight loss
3 -
deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.7 -
deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
I was drawn to your thread title when I saw it because it was catchy and I was happy for your success.
Until I saw this.
While neither keto nor OMAD are for me personally, I have nothing against either of them.
A calorie intake of 800? I have plenty against that. It's unsafe and not healthy. Please eat more and lose weight in a healthy manner. Above all, don't advise other people that this is a path to success.5 -
physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
A weight loss averaging 1lb every second day is an incredibly steep deficit. With keto a person will often drop a lot of water weight initially, but even with a larger initial drop, it's still a high rate. To be honest, this whole thread confuses/concerns me for a few different reasons.4 -
nutmegoreo wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
A weight loss averaging 1lb every second day is an incredibly steep deficit. With keto a person will often drop a lot of water weight initially, but even with a larger initial drop, it's still a high rate. To be honest, this whole thread confuses/concerns me for a few different reasons.
I was just about to compose a post about the rate of loss and was caught up on how to word the confounding nature of water weight losses on keto. You've voiced everything I'd like to have said nicely.3 -
physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
In 34 days this is my first 800 calorie day. It's no different than doing 5:2. My average intake is 1500 though it varies. This thread was created to support persons interested in OMAD and Keto. Kindly respect that.0 -
This thread is not about losing quickly.1
-
People are going to call you out when you start promoting 800 calorie days. You didn't state that it is a "fast" day, just that you are hitting 800, which is VLCD and not a good plan. Thanks for clarifying that it is a once a month thing and that you're eating more on average.1
-
nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
Eat low calories habitually is unhealthy. Doing 5:2 fasting is beneficial though I have not done low calories since I started in January. My weight loss stems from keto and OMAD.
Thanks for your input.2 -
Congrats on your sucecess so far! I agree that you may want to join the Low Carber Daily group. Many keto'ers there.
I've been keto fo quite a qhile and find that reduced meal number is quite complimentary to the diet too. Before keto I had reactive hypoglycemia so I ate every couple of hours or I had the cold sweats and shakes. Now, I generally eat breafast somewhere between 12 and 2pm and dinner around 6 or 7pm. I occassionally eat OMAD too. The only reason I don't do it more often is that I have IR so eating 1500+ calories in one sitting tends to raise my BG. There's a lot of freedon in not worrying about getting hungry. 0 -
16+ pounds in a month is entirely unrealistic and generally unhealthy by ALL standards. That's double the recommended healthy weight loss that's accepted by this community and most doctors.1
-
physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
Say what?0 -
physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
Say what?
Take a loose average of a woman's maintenance calories. Let us say 2,000 calories a day. 800 calories are 40% of that. That is almost half of your daily food requirement in 1 sitting.
And? If it's also your biggest meal of the day, that's perfectly reasonable. Not to mention, 800 calories of calorie dense food could make a reasonably small meal - say a decent sized burger. Hardly "stuffing your face".
And on your 2000 a day, that still leaves 1200 a day for breakfast, lunch and snacks. That's a pretty generous allowance.2 -
physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
Say what?
Take a loose average of a woman's maintenance calories. Let us say 2,000 calories a day. 800 calories are 40% of that. That is almost half of your daily food requirement in 1 sitting.
And?
My hunger patterns work that way.
I am not hungry early in the day and eat around 1000 calories, every day, within 2 hours at night. That's of a daily intake of anywhere from 1400-1800 calories.
I weigh 115 pounds on my way to 110, maintaining a loss down from 210 from over 2 years ago. Not a quick loss at all.
800 calories doesn't even begin to touch some restaurant meals and is hardly stuffing one's face.3 -
physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
Say what?
Take a loose average of a woman's maintenance calories. Let us say 2,000 calories a day. 800 calories are 40% of that. That is almost half of your daily food requirement in 1 sitting.
And? If it's also your biggest meal of the day, that's perfectly reasonable. Not to mention, 800 calories of calorie dense food could make a reasonably small meal - say a decent sized burger. Hardly "stuffing your face".
And on your 2000 a day, that still leaves 1200 a day for breakfast, lunch and snacks. That's a pretty generous allowance.
Everything you said just reinforces bad habits. Meals with a high-calorie density really do not help anyone. The only way to achieve meals with high calories density is junk food or high fat. Both will not offer much to satiety.
People should eat more often than 1 to 2 times a day. With larger meals, you're just training your body to consume more food per sitting. It's like weight training lifting little girl weights(eating more frequently with smaller meals) will not do much. If you start to add intensity(large meals) you adapt. What was previously difficult is now easy. Do you want to be able to consume a lot more food more easily? Obviously not.
I had 1000 calories tonight with 2 hours. Here's the menu:
Bean pasta with olive oil and broccoli
Peanut butter protein fluff topped with walnuts and some light Hershey's syrup
Not high fat, not junk food. Try again.1 -
physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
Say what?
Take a loose average of a woman's maintenance calories. Let us say 2,000 calories a day. 800 calories are 40% of that. That is almost half of your daily food requirement in 1 sitting.
And? If it's also your biggest meal of the day, that's perfectly reasonable. Not to mention, 800 calories of calorie dense food could make a reasonably small meal - say a decent sized burger. Hardly "stuffing your face".
And on your 2000 a day, that still leaves 1200 a day for breakfast, lunch and snacks. That's a pretty generous allowance.
Everything you said just reinforces bad habits. Meals with a high-calorie density really do not help anyone. The only way to achieve meals with high calories density is junk food or high fat. Both will not offer much to satiety.
People should eat more often than 1 to 2 times a day. With larger meals, you're just training your body to consume more food per sitting. It's like weight training lifting little girl weights(eating more frequently with smaller meals) will not do much. If you start to add intensity(large meals) you adapt. What was previously difficult is now easy. Do you want to be able to consume a lot more food more easily? Obviously not.
There's nothing wrong with eating one or two larger meals, if that is what helps someone feel satisfied and they are still able to meet their nutritional needs. Eating several small meals each day leaves me stabby and endangers those around me. I feel better eating three reasonable sized meals and usually a snack before bed. Losing just fine, and can pick up more than the pink weights. Some people find fat more filling than others, which is one of the reasons why keto works well for some people. Personally, the restrictions don't work for me. My concerns with the OPs choices have nothing to do with the 5:2, or the OMAD, or the Keto. I think that these things are fine, if they work for her. One of the struggles with diet is that people feel like they have to make drastic changes to how they eat or what they eat. The more dramatic the changes, the more likely they will fail, because it isn't something that they personally prefer. Dietary adherence is a much stronger predictor of success than the things you are suggesting.1 -
nutmegoreo wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
Say what?
Take a loose average of a woman's maintenance calories. Let us say 2,000 calories a day. 800 calories are 40% of that. That is almost half of your daily food requirement in 1 sitting.
And? If it's also your biggest meal of the day, that's perfectly reasonable. Not to mention, 800 calories of calorie dense food could make a reasonably small meal - say a decent sized burger. Hardly "stuffing your face".
And on your 2000 a day, that still leaves 1200 a day for breakfast, lunch and snacks. That's a pretty generous allowance.
Everything you said just reinforces bad habits. Meals with a high-calorie density really do not help anyone. The only way to achieve meals with high calories density is junk food or high fat. Both will not offer much to satiety.
People should eat more often than 1 to 2 times a day. With larger meals, you're just training your body to consume more food per sitting. It's like weight training lifting little girl weights(eating more frequently with smaller meals) will not do much. If you start to add intensity(large meals) you adapt. What was previously difficult is now easy. Do you want to be able to consume a lot more food more easily? Obviously not.
There's nothing wrong with eating one or two larger meals, if that is what helps someone feel satisfied and they are still able to meet their nutritional needs. Eating several small meals each day leaves me stabby and endangers those around me. I feel better eating three reasonable sized meals and usually a snack before bed. Losing just fine, and can pick up more than the pink weights. Some people find fat more filling than others, which is one of the reasons why keto works well for some people. Personally, the restrictions don't work for me. My concerns with the OPs choices have nothing to do with the 5:2, or the OMAD, or the Keto. I think that these things are fine, if they work for her. One of the struggles with diet is that people feel like they have to make drastic changes to how they eat or what they eat. The more dramatic the changes, the more likely they will fail, because it isn't something that they personally prefer. Dietary adherence is a much stronger predictor of success than the things you are suggesting.
All of this.
If it feels natural to eat once a day or to eat keto, this thread is cool.
If it's a struggle, then... eh.
Annnnnnd to the detractor who is saying that you HAVE to eat more often... no, if it doesn't feel natural to have little meals spread out, if adhering to that makes dieting more difficult, then no, that is not a good thing.
There's only one "should" with dieting, and that's creating a calorie deficit. That's it.
After that? It's all personal preference.2 -
physiquelore wrote: »
I am sorry, I do understand what you're saying. I do not think you understand what I am saying. Sure all those things work. The question is "For how long???" That's my point. Look at the thinner countries. Their portion sizes, their meal frequency.nutmegoreo wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »Alatariel75 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »deborahbarnes904 wrote: »physiquelore wrote: »If you're doing OMAD you're already stuffing your face once a day. This is not a healthy mindset and it does not strengthen long-term positive habits.
My max weight loss was roughly 200lbs. My experience with OMAD is I eventually got sick. I eventually gained back about 100lbs. I did keto on and off through the years. I started to do it again and I Lost about 50lbs putting me at a 150lbs weight loss. I stalled out a bit, took a diet break. Stress hit gained those 50lbs right back.
I'm sorry you didn't have success with OMAD. Not everyone does OMAD the same as you. I do not ever "stuff" my face. Today I'm consuming 800 calories, keto, OMAD. Each person has to find what works for them and their personality. OMAD wasn't for you. I know many who refuse to acknowledge Keto works for weight loss.
Each person should be encouraged to keep trying to find what works for them. YouTube is full of persons successful on OMAD alone without keto. One in particular losing over 100 lbs and are going strong.
Thanks for your input.
You are losing that weight from very low calorie intake. Not healthy and certainly not something to promote.
She did say she consumed 1,500 calories on average. For a woman, Consuming 800 calories in 1 meal is still stuffing your face. Obviously, consuming 1,500 calories is worse.
Say what?
Take a loose average of a woman's maintenance calories. Let us say 2,000 calories a day. 800 calories are 40% of that. That is almost half of your daily food requirement in 1 sitting.
And? If it's also your biggest meal of the day, that's perfectly reasonable. Not to mention, 800 calories of calorie dense food could make a reasonably small meal - say a decent sized burger. Hardly "stuffing your face".
And on your 2000 a day, that still leaves 1200 a day for breakfast, lunch and snacks. That's a pretty generous allowance.
Everything you said just reinforces bad habits. Meals with a high-calorie density really do not help anyone. The only way to achieve meals with high calories density is junk food or high fat. Both will not offer much to satiety.
People should eat more often than 1 to 2 times a day. With larger meals, you're just training your body to consume more food per sitting. It's like weight training lifting little girl weights(eating more frequently with smaller meals) will not do much. If you start to add intensity(large meals) you adapt. What was previously difficult is now easy. Do you want to be able to consume a lot more food more easily? Obviously not.
There's nothing wrong with eating one or two larger meals, if that is what helps someone feel satisfied and they are still able to meet their nutritional needs. Eating several small meals each day leaves me stabby and endangers those around me. I feel better eating three reasonable sized meals and usually a snack before bed. Losing just fine, and can pick up more than the pink weights. Some people find fat more filling than others, which is one of the reasons why keto works well for some people. Personally, the restrictions don't work for me. My concerns with the OPs choices have nothing to do with the 5:2, or the OMAD, or the Keto. I think that these things are fine, if they work for her. One of the struggles with diet is that people feel like they have to make drastic changes to how they eat or what they eat. The more dramatic the changes, the more likely they will fail, because it isn't something that they personally prefer. Dietary adherence is a much stronger predictor of success than the things you are suggesting.
I was a strong advocate for IF, I done it for over 4 years. I was one of the first to preach it on the forums. I got a ton of hate for it. Intermittent fasting is just over eating. You are just reinforcing it.
You are completely missing what I'm saying. IF works for some. I'm not reinforcing anything other that following what works for you as an individual. Personally, I don't follow IF, OMAD, 5:2, LCHF, or any other specific restrictions. The only foods I won't eat are the ones I don't like. I think that having stringent rules on what you can and can't eat sets people up for failure (generally speaking, for some it works).
For me, dietary restrictions have only lead to a darker place. I ate something bad, therefore I am bad, and a failure, so I may as well give up today and start again tomorrow. The next time, might as well start again next week. Removing all of those rules, allowed me a freedom to enjoy my food and still strive toward my goals. I eat when I want and usually what I want.2
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions