Why am i now gaining??
YouBlowMyMind
Posts: 552 Member
Hey all
In 3 weeks I had lost 6.3kg/13lbs and that was just counting calories... Ever since I started moving more I keep putting on weight. It's very disappointing
In 3 weeks I had lost 6.3kg/13lbs and that was just counting calories... Ever since I started moving more I keep putting on weight. It's very disappointing
0
Replies
-
Could be water retention from the new exercise...2
-
You may not be eating enough. How many calories a day are you consuming? What type of exercise are you doing?0
-
I started using A magnetic rower last week. And the 30ds yesterday0
-
I'm eating my allocated calories of 1200 plus most of my exercise calories. I started using A magnetic rower for 10 mins a day last week and the 30ds yesterday1
-
New exercise will cause you to retain water. It will go away within a couple weeks.Sls2bhealthy wrote: »You may not be eating enough.
How would not eating enough cause someone to gain weight?11 -
New exercise will cause you to retain water. It will go away within a couple weeks.Sls2bhealthy wrote: »You may not be eating enough.
How would not eating enough cause someone to gain weight?
If you don't eat enough, you body will begin to store fat. It will not allow itself to starve. You need to have enough fuel to burn calories. Your car will not run without gas nor will your body run with out proper nutrition. You should aim for about a 500 calorie a day deficit for a steady loss. More exercise = more food. Proper food.
0 -
Sls2bhealthy wrote: »New exercise will cause you to retain water. It will go away within a couple weeks.Sls2bhealthy wrote: »You may not be eating enough.
How would not eating enough cause someone to gain weight?
If you don't eat enough, you body will begin to store fat. It will not allow itself to starve. You need to have enough fuel to burn calories. Your car will not run without gas nor will your body run with out proper nutrition. You should aim for about a 500 calorie a day deficit for a steady loss. More exercise = more food. Proper food.
Have you ever met anorexics? Or seen people in third world countries who don't have adequate food resources? Does it look like they're storing fat?16 -
Under eating is bad for you, but it does not cause your body to store fat it wouldn't have otherwise. Over long periods of under eating your metabolism might slow a bit to adapt, But if you are under eating, where is your body getting fat to store? By definition, under-eating means you are eating less than your body needs, so it will use all the energy you give it, and either burn some of your muscle as alternative fuel or neglect non-crucial processes while waiting for more fuel, like growing your hair or regenerating cell-damage.
OP if we are talking about a week or 2, it could be any combination of water weight caused by the new exercise or your time of the month. Also, weight loss isn't linear. Even if you do everything perfect every day, some weeks you won't lose as much or anything. Be patient and hang in there :drinker:6 -
Sls2bhealthy wrote: »You may not be eating enough.
Seriously now. I keep reading this comment in every similar thread. How can anyone ever think that eating too little can cause weight gain? How?! No matter what they might have read online, thinking should come first.
OP, I can assure you, this is not the reason you have gained. It is either water from your new routine, a random fluctuation, or fat from eating too much (as in above maintenance). My advice is to wait.
8 -
Thanx I think I just won't weigh daily anymore3
-
gebeziseva wrote: »Sls2bhealthy wrote: »You may not be eating enough.
Seriously now. I keep reading this comment in every similar thread. How can anyone ever think that eating too little can cause weight gain? How?! No matter what they might have read online, thinking should come first.
OP, I can assure you, this is not the reason you have gained. It is either water from your new routine, a random fluctuation, or fat from eating too much (as in above maintenance). My advice is to wait.
Just curious, are you trained in nutrition? You can believe what you want, but this is factual. Talk to any nutritionist, dietitian, or personal trainer with nutritional backing.
http://www.stack.com/a/undereating0 -
Sls2bhealthy wrote: »New exercise will cause you to retain water. It will go away within a couple weeks.Sls2bhealthy wrote: »You may not be eating enough.
How would not eating enough cause someone to gain weight?
If you don't eat enough, you body will begin to store fat. It will not allow itself to starve. You need to have enough fuel to burn calories. Your car will not run without gas nor will your body run with out proper nutrition. You should aim for about a 500 calorie a day deficit for a steady loss. More exercise = more food. Proper food.
Um... but people do starve. All the time.
OP - I'm going to posit that it is water retention from the new routine. Are you sore from the 30DS? Your muscles will retain water for repair, and that can add to your weight on the scale.5 -
Ooooh...grabbing some popcorn.3
-
-
I am extremely sore from the 30ds lol0
-
try doing a few weights0
-
-
Yeah I know when I'm sore, I always see a rise in the scale. 30DS kicked my butt the first time I tried it. DOMS for days.0
-
-
Thanx guys0
-
I'm in the same boat! We've gotta persevere
1 -
You said you're eating nearly all exercise calories as well. I wonder if you're going by the calories that MFP gives you for your exercise? If so, just know that it typically gives excess calories and it may be beneficial to try eating 25-50% of those exercise cals rather than all of them:)2
-
tiffanifair wrote: »You said you're eating nearly all exercise calories as well. I wonder if you're going by the calories that MFP gives you for your exercise? If so, just know that it typically gives excess calories and it may be beneficial to try eating 25-50% of those exercise cals rather than all of them:)
I was about to ask this!1 -
Not all but most. Will defs cut that down0
-
Sls2bhealthy wrote: »New exercise will cause you to retain water. It will go away within a couple weeks.Sls2bhealthy wrote: »You may not be eating enough.
How would not eating enough cause someone to gain weight?
If you don't eat enough, you body will begin to store fat. It will not allow itself to starve. You need to have enough fuel to burn calories. Your car will not run without gas nor will your body run with out proper nutrition. You should aim for about a 500 calorie a day deficit for a steady loss. More exercise = more food. Proper food.
I'll give you your car won't run without gas, in human equivalents it would mean you were feeling tired, sluggish. What is proper food? I probably shouldn't show you the can of reddiwhip in my fridge I bet...
OP, keep at it and you should see loss as long as you're sure you're being as accurate as you can be. A lot of us eat back about 50% exercise calories especially if MFP or a potentially inaccurate fitness band might be overestimating calories (MFP does). 0 -
Sls2bhealthy wrote: »gebeziseva wrote: »Sls2bhealthy wrote: »You may not be eating enough.
Seriously now. I keep reading this comment in every similar thread. How can anyone ever think that eating too little can cause weight gain? How?! No matter what they might have read online, thinking should come first.
OP, I can assure you, this is not the reason you have gained. It is either water from your new routine, a random fluctuation, or fat from eating too much (as in above maintenance). My advice is to wait.
Just curious, are you trained in nutrition? You can believe what you want, but this is factual. Talk to any nutritionist, dietitian, or personal trainer with nutritional backing.
http://www.stack.com/a/undereating
Are YOU trained in nutrition? I'd guess not, or you would know that it doesn't work like you think it does. If you'd like to read the actual science on it from a trainer who IS trained in nutrition and has written numerous books on the subject, here you go, have at it: http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/another-look-at-metabolic-damage.html/5
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions