Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    What's the highest number of poptarts you've eaten over 24 hours?

    2

    Replies

    • Posts: 6,644 Member
      Not a fan.
    • Posts: 280 Member
      I am shocked at the lack of love for chocolate fudge!! Clearly the best flavor. I've probably had.... 4 in a day. When I studied abroad in the Netherlands (I'm from the US), I spent WAY too much money on a box of poptarts at an international food store. And a box of Reese's Puffs. Worth it.
    • Posts: 821 Member
      Pretty sure I binged on a whole box a couple times back in the day... 25 years or so ago. So, I guess the answer would be 6.
    • Posts: 9,409 Member
      2.

      have had them occasionally - i only like the fruit filled ones, we buy a box occasionally.

      Never eaten more than 2 in a day.
    • Posts: 19,809 Member
      About half of one tart - revolting.
    • Posts: 1,445 Member
      Just two in a day. I like the Brown Sugar and S'mores.
    • Posts: 480 Member
      Yes I'm from Australia and I love going to the international treat shop for naughty things from overseas. Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Butterfingers and the UK Cadbury's Milk Chocolate...especially the buttons. Recently PopTarts too, don't have them that often because of the calories and the price that is charged here.
    • Posts: 89 Member
      edited May 2017
      2 I think, though if someone were to tell me they remember me eating more I wouldn't be too surprised, I'm here for a reason...

      My favourite flavour was Choco Mallow back in the day, can't get them anymore, I heard a rumour that they burned someone so they withdrew the flavour, sad times!

      I'm also in the UK, so flavours are limited, on the rare occasions I eat them I would go for something chocolatey, like s'mores, though the brown sugar cinnamon ones sound pretty good!
    • Posts: 2,847 Member
      However many are in the box. S'mores, Frosted Cherry and Hot Fudge Sundae are the best flavors.
    • Posts: 480 Member
      Just enjoyed two brown sugar cinnamon ones and they were so good. 'Gilmore Girls' a tv show which I have binge watched several times mentioned poptarts in probably every single episode, I think this is partly why i eat them. Rory and Lorelai loved them
    • Posts: 17,562 Member
      edited May 2017
      4, only if I ate breakfast the second day earlier than the first day.

      My all-time favorite isn't made anymore (Frosted Chocolate Vanilla Cream). But I usually go for S'mores or Cherry. Sometimes Brown Sugar/Cinnamon. I usually have them if I have a day where I go into work later than 6.
    • Posts: 1,283 Member
      edited May 2017
      Probably 3 packets, which is 6 pastries total. My favorite in order are 1) cherry 2) blueberry 3) strawberry . I only like the fruit kind. Anything chocolaty makes me gag. Can you tell I've been obsessed with Pop-Tarts my whole life?

      Also, they have to be iced. I almost broke up with a guy once because he wanted me to buy plain Poptarts. Okay, so I'm kidding. (not kidding)
    • Posts: 480 Member
      midlomel1971 wrote: »
      Probably 3 packets, which is 6 pastries total. My favorite in order are 1) cherry 2) blueberry 3) strawberry . I only like the fruit kind. Anything chocolaty makes me gag. Can you tell I've been obsessed with Pop-Tarts my whole life?

      Also, they have to be iced. I almost broke up with a guy once because he wanted me to buy plain Poptarts. Okay, so I'm kidding. (not kidding)

      I've never tried them without icing, that's the best part! The strawberry ones are like a hot jam sandwich when toasted, I love them. Also they make me think of the movie 27 Dresses
    • Posts: 802 Member
      I don't think they're even available here in Sweden. I've seen them at home in the UK but not really my kind of thing.

    • Posts: 5 Member
      however many are in a box, so one box
    • Posts: 7,722 Member
      I haven't had Pop Tarts since I was a kid and can't eat them now.

      I'm too old to remember how many I ate in a day. I remember having a thing for the Brown Sugar ones, though.

      2 maybe?
    • Posts: 364 Member
      I don't think I've eaten more than two, and my faves are frosted cherry and smores, depending on what I'm in the mood for
    • Posts: 3,375 Member
      4 of the brown sugar cinnamon (unfrosted), but that was at least 25 years ago.
    • Posts: 51 Member
      can't remember the last time I had a pop tart but I never eat more than the two that comes in the package. If I'm going to binge it is on some kind of chocolate. :) I've been know to have 10 mini milkyways in one day. Not often but I'm a stress eater.
    • Posts: 4,838 Member
      2, but it's been a long time since I've had a Pop Tart brand one. I'm vegetarian, frosted Pop Tarts aren't, and I'm not interested in an unfrosted Pop Tart.
    • Posts: 789 Member
      The big box of 12 or 20 I think is how much I ate in a 24 hour period once. I used to get the unfrosted strawberry ones as a kid, then the frosted strawberry. That's the only ones I enjoy.
    • Posts: 325 Member
      edited May 2017
      Four, I would guess?

      That said, I find Pop Tarts disgusting, especially any of the frosted ones. I've only bought them a handful of times in my life, always with the optimistic hope that "THIS flavor must be good, surely . . . There must be a reason people like these . . ." Yeah, no, they're terrible. If you want pastry that is devoid of flavor and has an unpleasant consistency, this is the treat for you. The "least bad" was unfrosted cherry (or maybe strawberry--it was definitely red).
    • Posts: 10,330 Member
      Zero would be the highest number. I have never ever had a poptart.
    • Posts: 41,865 Member
      I had one once at a friend's house when I was a kid...not a fan...in general I'm not a fan of commercial baked goods and whatnot. I'm probably the only person on the planet who finds Oreos revolting.
    • Posts: 2,343 Member
      2, but technically less than that since I pick off the dry crusts lol Favourite flavour is classic strawberry or cookies n cream
    • Posts: 1,120 Member
      Poptarts are little decietful devils since a serving (200 cal) is just one. When I was younger I assumed that was for two. Finally in high school I was bored and reading the box and found out the sad truth lol
    • Posts: 823 Member
      edited May 2017
      2 just two weeks ago. I finally found the limited edition mocha flavored and they were quite tasty. However, has anybody noticed that they are smaller now than when we were kids? I was annoyed (as I was when I realized that Thin Mint sleeves had been shorted, but the price stayed the same) and I'm not sure if I'll buy them again.

      ETA: That's a lie. I'm definitely going to buy them again.
    • Posts: 1,119 Member
      4-5 back when I was an obese child. I haven't had any desire to eat one in years.
    • Posts: 178 Member
      I think I ate an entire box in one day once :-O Brown sugar cinnamon is my fave/has been since I was a kid.
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories