Vegan Weight Issues

mollyammer
mollyammer Posts: 6 Member
edited November 18 in Health and Weight Loss
Hi everyone! I'm having a hard time maintaining my plant-based diet. I've always been naturally 'skinny' with a high metabolism, I'm about 5 feet and (used to) typically fluctuate between 95 and 105 pounds. In September 2015 I went vegetarian and ended up losing a lot of weight and toning up easier, I was doing around 30 minutes of cardio and an hour of weight training 4 days a week. Come June 2016 I decided to go fully vegan and have been literally eating exactly the same minus the dairy and eggs, and I still do around 30-40 minutes of cardio and an hour to an hour and a half of weight training 4-5 days a week. I started rapidly putting on weight around December 2016, and am now at my highest weight of 113 lbs. This is unusual for me and I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong as I'm saying virtually the same as before and working out harder. I'm toning up a lot however holding a lot of weight in my stomach and lower back which has become very noticeable. I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong but I do exercise to target love handles/stomach fat but it's being very stubborn and I'm not sure what else to do. If any other vegans have any advice that would be great and I'd be happy to share my specific diet for most days.

Replies

  • Hoshiko
    Hoshiko Posts: 179 Member
    Do you log and measure your food? If you log it here then it would help people give you advice if you opened up your diary.

    I managed to gain all of my weight being vegan, and I'm now losing all of my weight being vegan. It has always been less about my specific food choices than about going over my maintenance calories. If you switched out the foods you're used to maybe you're eating a bit more overall than you think?

    Also, exercise helps but there's no such thing as targeting specific areas of fat loss. Unfortunately our bodies choose where we gain or lose fat.
  • mollyammer
    mollyammer Posts: 6 Member
    @Hoshiko I just opened up my diary! I didn't realize you could do that lol, I only have one day logged so far but that's typically what I eat on an everyday basis, sometimes more. I'm currently in college so eating on campus can be difficult at times. I know I can't really specifically target the one area that's bothering me, it just sucks I'm pretty satisfied with everything else overall. I feel like lately I've been trying to tone down on heavy carbs & portioning my food better but still am not seeing the results that I want. I've been vegan for less than a year so maybe I just haven't given it enough time
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    Before you begin trying to diagnose what is wrong, I'd commit to getting a few weeks of consistent logging in. That will make it much easier to figure out what is going on and how you can adjust your intake.

    I'm another vegan who gained all my weight as a vegan and then lost it as a vegan, so it can be done! Like @Hoshiko says, my food choices were much less important than how many calories I was eating. If you are eating exactly like you did before minus dairy and eggs, I'm wondering if your protein intake went down and you are eating larger portions of the rest of your foods because you are hungrier. This sometimes happens to newer vegans who don't replace animal proteins with vegan sources of protein. Your one day of logging is pretty low on protein and a chunk of that comes from nuts. It's very hard for smaller people to get sufficient protein from nuts and still stay at their calorie goal -- most of us just don't burn enough calories to be able to eat that many nuts. I found it helpful to think of nuts as a source of fat, not a source of protein (although they do have some protein).

    Eating at school can be hard -- some easy sources of vegan protein that don't require a kitchen include protein bars, protein shakes, and most vegan jerkys. If you have access to a fridge in your dorm room, maybe find some simple recipes for bean salads? You can make these with canned beans and then have them in a wrap or with vegetables.
  • AliceDark
    AliceDark Posts: 3,886 Member
    1. How are you measuring your food? (Food scale, measuring cups/spoons, eyeballing)?
    2. You have entries that include "1 serving" as the unit; where did those entries come from? Are they straight out of the database, or did you create them using the recipe builder? If they're from the database, they're all but guaranteed to be inaccurate for what you're actually eating, since you have no idea what someone else's peanut butter sandwich looks like. It's always better to enter the individual pieces of a meal as separate entries (so, enter your specific brand of bread and your actual amount of peanut butter) than it is to use someone else's entry.
  • Hoshiko
    Hoshiko Posts: 179 Member
    College eating can be so hard! If you're logging it might actually make it a bit easier to see what areas you can improve on. I don't know what your situation is but if you have a fridge or mini-fridge it can open up your possibilities quite a bit.

    Thanks for opening up your food log. Like @janejellyroll said, I would focus on logging for 2 weeks consistently and upping your protein as much as possible. After two weeks you can re-evaluate and see where you are. Sometimes just being conscious and informed about what you're eating leads to weight loss, but if it doesn't then we can give you more specific tips.

    Logging can seem like a pain but it seriously, really works. Since you don't have a lot to lose it's even more important, because those tiny choices add up quick. I also think that it's really great that you're catching this now. I didn't and ended up gaining 40 lbs during my college years, even while being super active. Don't be like me!
  • emilyumich
    emilyumich Posts: 1 Member
    I also gained weight 8 months after I went vegan - I wasn't keeping track of what I was eating and was not eating as clean as I could have been. I would recommend keeping track of what you eat and also keep being active!

    Check out 'naturally stefanie' at naturallystefanie.com she's one of my favorite vegan youtuber/bloggers to follow. She eats a high carb low fat vegan diet which is what I follow as well! I generally do 60% carbs, 20% protein and 20% fat, and eat on average 1900 calories. I try to eat whole foods and avoid processed foods and added sugars.
  • FatDadSlim
    FatDadSlim Posts: 497 Member
    Same happened to me... Hummus was my problem, we are no longer on speaking terms :#
  • mollyammer
    mollyammer Posts: 6 Member
    @AliceDark I typically try to eyeball my servings out, the peanut butter sandwich i manually put in through the recipe feature! Do you recommend starting to measure things out exactly?
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    mollyammer wrote: »
    @AliceDark I typically try to eyeball my servings out, the peanut butter sandwich i manually put in through the recipe feature! Do you recommend starting to measure things out exactly?

    Studies have shown that many humans are awful at eyeballing portion size. I know that I am. Measuring cups are more reliable than eyeballing, but can be pretty inaccurate. A food scale is the best way to measure solid food, especially calorie-dense foods like peanut butter. I don't think I am making an unreasonable assumption when I say that many people who are eyeballing peanut butter are eating much more than they think they are.
  • mollyammer
    mollyammer Posts: 6 Member
    Since my food log isn't very informative right now, I just wanna mention some things that i normally eat on an everyday basis. Although I am on campus, I do have a full kitchen and have a decent amount of options on campus too; I recently started buying brown rice pasta instead of whole wheat and I make that a couple times a week, I normally add an organic tomato sauce lightly and a fake meat for protein (not the best i know), i also make regular brown rice a lot and will add some type of bean or fake meat. My log from today shows the salad i had for lunch which is something i get a few times a week as well. The on campus supermarket has cliff protein bars, I may look into those. @FatDadSlim i also eat a lotttt of hummus, i'm wondering if this has contributed to my weight gain as well? Although i had hummus just as much last year when i weighed less so i really don't know lol
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    mollyammer wrote: »
    Since my food log isn't very informative right now, I just wanna mention some things that i normally eat on an everyday basis. Although I am on campus, I do have a full kitchen and have a decent amount of options on campus too; I recently started buying brown rice pasta instead of whole wheat and I make that a couple times a week, I normally add an organic tomato sauce lightly and a fake meat for protein (not the best i know), i also make regular brown rice a lot and will add some type of bean or fake meat. My log from today shows the salad i had for lunch which is something i get a few times a week as well. The on campus supermarket has cliff protein bars, I may look into those. @FatDadSlim i also eat a lotttt of hummus, i'm wondering if this has contributed to my weight gain as well? Although i had hummus just as much last year when i weighed less so i really don't know lol

    If you're eyeballing your portion sizes and you just started logging, I'm not sure how you can know that you're eating just as much hummus as you did last year.
  • mollyammer
    mollyammer Posts: 6 Member
    mollyammer wrote: »
    Since my food log isn't very informative right now, I just wanna mention some things that i normally eat on an everyday basis. Although I am on campus, I do have a full kitchen and have a decent amount of options on campus too; I recently started buying brown rice pasta instead of whole wheat and I make that a couple times a week, I normally add an organic tomato sauce lightly and a fake meat for protein (not the best i know), i also make regular brown rice a lot and will add some type of bean or fake meat. My log from today shows the salad i had for lunch which is something i get a few times a week as well. The on campus supermarket has cliff protein bars, I may look into those. @FatDadSlim i also eat a lotttt of hummus, i'm wondering if this has contributed to my weight gain as well? Although i had hummus just as much last year when i weighed less so i really don't know lol

    If you're eyeballing your portion sizes and you just started logging, I'm not sure how you can know that you're eating just as much hummus as you did last year.

    I just mean that I have it just as often, like I've always consistently been eating it but you're right I may be eating larger quantities of it now

  • RGv2
    RGv2 Posts: 5,789 Member
    mollyammer wrote: »
    Since my food log isn't very informative right now, I just wanna mention some things that i normally eat on an everyday basis. Although I am on campus, I do have a full kitchen and have a decent amount of options on campus too; I recently started buying brown rice pasta instead of whole wheat and I make that a couple times a week, I normally add an organic tomato sauce lightly and a fake meat for protein (not the best i know), i also make regular brown rice a lot and will add some type of bean or fake meat. My log from today shows the salad i had for lunch which is something i get a few times a week as well. The on campus supermarket has cliff protein bars, I may look into those. @FatDadSlim i also eat a lotttt of hummus, i'm wondering if this has contributed to my weight gain as well? Although i had hummus just as much last year when i weighed less so i really don't know lol

    If you're eyeballing your portion sizes and you just started logging, I'm not sure how you can know that you're eating just as much hummus as you did last year.

    ^^^ Agreed. Also if you're working out 60-90 min per day and only eating the 1,000 or so calories like day one in your diary, weight would be coming off, you wouldn't be gaining.
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    mollyammer wrote: »
    mollyammer wrote: »
    Since my food log isn't very informative right now, I just wanna mention some things that i normally eat on an everyday basis. Although I am on campus, I do have a full kitchen and have a decent amount of options on campus too; I recently started buying brown rice pasta instead of whole wheat and I make that a couple times a week, I normally add an organic tomato sauce lightly and a fake meat for protein (not the best i know), i also make regular brown rice a lot and will add some type of bean or fake meat. My log from today shows the salad i had for lunch which is something i get a few times a week as well. The on campus supermarket has cliff protein bars, I may look into those. @FatDadSlim i also eat a lotttt of hummus, i'm wondering if this has contributed to my weight gain as well? Although i had hummus just as much last year when i weighed less so i really don't know lol

    If you're eyeballing your portion sizes and you just started logging, I'm not sure how you can know that you're eating just as much hummus as you did last year.

    I just mean that I have it just as often, like I've always consistently been eating it but you're right I may be eating larger quantities of it now

    The quantity of the food you eat will determine your weight much more than how frequently you eat a food. You can have hummus with every meal and maintain your desired weight or you could have it once a week and completely blow out your calorie deficit for the week -- it's all going to come down to how much you're eating and the quantities of everything else you're eating.

    I think the best thing to do would be for you to log consistently for 2-3 weeks with an accurate form of measurement to determine how many calories you're taking in. Then you can adjust from there.

    There's no reason to avoid faux meat (there's nothing wrong with it) or eat brown rice pasta (unless that is what you prefer) or skip hummus or choose organic (again, unless that's what you personally want to do). You can lose weight with or without any of those foods.
  • mollyammer
    mollyammer Posts: 6 Member
    I'll do my best to consistently log for the next few weeks and give a better idea of my normal routine, I'm definitely pretty surprised at how low my calorie count was for yesterday I always felt like it was normally more but also that was just one day and my servings may not have been correct. If that is 100% correct though or atleast close then I'm still pretty confused because i do workout for 60-90 minutes monday-thursday and typically eat a similar days worth of food during those days, but that's why i'm coming here for help :) and i'm also going to try to limit the peanut butter and see if that makes any difference, as well as up the protein from other sources
  • AliceDark
    AliceDark Posts: 3,886 Member
    I'd strongly recommend at least measuring with cups/spoons, or getting a food scale if you can. (They're in the neighborhood of $15-$20 on Amazon, so it's not a huge expenditure, although I totally get being a student and not always having available funds for unnecessary things). At the very least, try to be more consistent in measuring calorie-dense things like peanut butter, hummus, avocado, etc.

    In the first few weeks of logging, you're basically doing data collection, and the more accurate you can be there, the better.
This discussion has been closed.