What's better for you, being a vegetarian or eating white meat?
samwiseenvs
Posts: 5 Member
I have a question. I'm trying to figure out whether it's healthier to be a vegetarian or to eat meat, but mainly only white meat, like chicken.
I have been adding baked chicken breast to vegetables for dinner as a way to increase my protein intact but is it healthier to leave it out? Not talking calorie-wise, but over all nutrition. There are so many studies that suggest any meat is unhealthy, but just as many studies that say the opposite.
I don't plan to go 100% vegetarian, I still want bacon on occasion, and a good hamburger every once in a while, but in a day to day occurrence, what are everyone's thoughts? Thanks! Oh, and my goal is to be healthier, which I believe will help with my weight goal (which is to lose 100+ lbs).
I have been adding baked chicken breast to vegetables for dinner as a way to increase my protein intact but is it healthier to leave it out? Not talking calorie-wise, but over all nutrition. There are so many studies that suggest any meat is unhealthy, but just as many studies that say the opposite.
I don't plan to go 100% vegetarian, I still want bacon on occasion, and a good hamburger every once in a while, but in a day to day occurrence, what are everyone's thoughts? Thanks! Oh, and my goal is to be healthier, which I believe will help with my weight goal (which is to lose 100+ lbs).
0
Replies
-
As someone who has gone vegan and vegetarian not for ethical reasons but just to try it out to see how I liked it. I really noticed no difference between that and eating meat. Back to eating meat now. About the bacon thing I eat bacon just about every morning. Opting to choose lower fat options to fit bacon into my diet.
The way I look at it... if you aren't ethically bothered by the meat industry I really don't see too much of a reason to eat like that unless you enjoy it. If you think its something you can sustain for the rest of your life. As you said there are studies promoting both lifestyles. At the end of the day tho as long as you lose weight you'll get healthier no matter what diet you choose. Unless of course for medical reasons you can't eat certain things.10 -
Since you are talking about overall health nutrition-wise, the answer is to get proper nutrition. A person can do that eating meat or eating a vegetarian diet; a person can also miss the mark on nutrition on either diet.
I would eat whatever way works for you and allows you to stay on track. There's nothing wrong with incorporating more plant-based meals into your diet, but you need to make sure you are getting enough protein and fat, as well as hitting your micronutrients. I wouldn't let yourself get too bogged down in studies, especially if you enjoy the way you are eating and your doctor doesn't have any concerns about your health.13 -
Vegetarians sometimes don't get enough vitamin B12 and a few minerals. It may be necessary to take supplements. On the other hand, if you're eating more beans, fruits, vegetables, nuts, and seeds, you may be getting more be beneficial nutrients and fiber than if you were eating more meat. So there could be benefits either way.1
-
veg for sure0
-
I've been vegetarian/vegan for 10+ years for ethical and personal reasons. It has taken me a very long time to ensure that my diet includes enough of all the nutrients I need. I've found that the more foods I cut out (meat, then seafood, then dairy and eggs), the more challenging it is to get all my nutrients.
I don't believe that going vegetarian will have a massive positive impact on your overall health. However, there is absolutely nothing wrong with eating vegetarian most of the time and eating meat as a 'sometimes' food.
11 -
As much variety as possible, nothing you don't like, nothing you're allergic to, in line with your ethical views and religious beliefs, not contaminated or spoiled, balanced - time, money, taste and culture-wise - and not causing too much worry, is my definition of healthy eating.7
-
I only eat chicken breast and stuff like pork and beef mince. Not a fan of lamb， steak or seafood cause I'm fussy and just don't really like it lol. Don't think either/or is healthier just a preference to what you like I guess?1
-
Studies on this subject are all over the place. One of the larger long-term studies done on the subject found that the healthiest group of people ate meat only occasionally and when they did ate mostly fish. It's possible to be healthy on both meat and non-meat eating diets, but it can be tricky to get all your nutrients as a vegetarian or vegan if you don't know what you're doing.
Protein isn't really the problem - most people get more than enough.
If you're doing this for health reasons, you might consider adding fish as well as chicken.
3 -
Depends on your body and it's metabolism. I suffer from carb-coma/lethargy if I eat too much starchy foods, so vegetarianism is completely wrong for my body. I also want to eat and eat and eat if I try to eat only plant material, so I would pile on the weight very fast. The scales are going down when I increased my meat intake and decreased my carb intake.
So figure out what does your body best; it might also be good to consult with a qualified dietician/nutrionist.1 -
rheddmobile wrote: »Studies on this subject are all over the place. One of the larger long-term studies done on the subject found that the healthiest group of people ate meat only occasionally and when they did ate mostly fish. It's possible to be healthy on both meat and non-meat eating diets, but it can be tricky to get all your nutrients as a vegetarian or vegan if you don't know what you're doing.
Protein isn't really the problem - most people get more than enough.
If you're doing this for health reasons, you might consider adding fish as well as chicken.
This.
I've been doing some research on 'blue zones'. One of the things the groups all have in common is that they eat a mostly plant based diet, with meat 0-5 times a month. I'm especially interested in the only blue zone in the U.S.-the SDA group in Loma Linda California, and while the community is predominately a vegetarian one, there's a sub-set group that includes fish almost daily and they have even better longevity of life outcomes than the vegetarians, (which have significant longevity of life statistics as well).
I'm loosely modeling my woe after them right now-a mostly whole foods, plant based diet with fish 4-5 times a week. But, I still eat meat 1-2 times a week and I don't foresee myself ever eliminating meat completely. I also still drink alcohol and caffeine, which the SDA blue zone does not. I think what's more important than what you're cutting out is what you're adding to your diet. Because of what I've been reading about different woes (blue zones, Mediterranean etc), as well as the recent meta-study that came out from the Imperial College London about veg/fruit quantity, I'm really focusing on upping my veg/fruit intake, whole grains, beans etc. That's most likely more important in terms of healthy diet, than just cutting out meat.
eta: Op-here's a couple of links you may be interested in-
http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/04/11/398325030/eating-to-break-100-longevity-diet-tips-from-the-blue-zones
http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/newsandeventspggrp/imperialcollege/newssummary/news_22-2-2017-16-38-03 -
samwiseenvs wrote: »I have a question. I'm trying to figure out whether it's healthier to be a vegetarian or to eat meat, but mainly only white meat, like chicken.
I have been adding baked chicken breast to vegetables for dinner as a way to increase my protein intact but is it healthier to leave it out? Not talking calorie-wise, but over all nutrition. There are so many studies that suggest any meat is unhealthy, but just as many studies that say the opposite.
I don't plan to go 100% vegetarian, I still want bacon on occasion, and a good hamburger every once in a while, but in a day to day occurrence, what are everyone's thoughts? Thanks! Oh, and my goal is to be healthier, which I believe will help with my weight goal (which is to lose 100+ lbs).
Neither.
The choice to eat or not eat meat, dairy, gluten, etc etc etc does not make one healthier or less healthy based on that decision. (*except for those with true sensitivities or intolerances)3 -
crazyycatladyy1 wrote: »rheddmobile wrote: »Studies on this subject are all over the place. One of the larger long-term studies done on the subject found that the healthiest group of people ate meat only occasionally and when they did ate mostly fish. It's possible to be healthy on both meat and non-meat eating diets, but it can be tricky to get all your nutrients as a vegetarian or vegan if you don't know what you're doing.
Protein isn't really the problem - most people get more than enough.
If you're doing this for health reasons, you might consider adding fish as well as chicken.
This.
I've been doing some research on 'blue zones'. One of the things the groups all have in common is that they eat a mostly plant based diet, with meat 0-5 times a month. I'm especially interested in the only blue zone in the U.S.-the SDA group in Loma Linda California, and while the community is predominately a vegetarian one, there's a sub-set group that includes fish almost daily and they have even better longevity of life outcomes than the vegetarians, (which have significant longevity of life statistics as well).
I'm loosely modeling my woe after them right now-a mostly whole foods, plant based diet with fish 4-5 times a week. But, I still eat meat 1-2 times a week and I don't foresee myself ever eliminating meat completely. I also still drink alcohol and caffeine, which the SDA blue zone does not. I think what's more important than what you're cutting out is what you're adding to your diet. Because of what I've been reading about different woes (blue zones, Mediterranean etc), as well as the recent meta-study that came out from the Imperial College London about veg/fruit quantity, I'm really focusing on upping my veg/fruit intake, whole grains, beans etc. That's most likely more important in terms of healthy diet, than just cutting out meat.
eta: Op-here's a couple of links you may be interested in-
http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/04/11/398325030/eating-to-break-100-longevity-diet-tips-from-the-blue-zones
http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/newsandeventspggrp/imperialcollege/newssummary/news_22-2-2017-16-38-0
Thank you! I saw something about this, and how it was healthier but when I started researching it, I found so much conflicting information. Then again, everything about nutrition and health seems to be debated. Carbs? No carbs? Meat? No meat? The only thing I see that is consistent is added sugar is bad lol1 -
The decision to restrict certain food groups does not inherently have any health value in and of itself, as you can achieve a perfectly balanced diet either way. Many people who embark on vegan or vegetarian plans do so for social or SJW reasons as opposed to practical ones, but that does not mean you can't achieve a nutritious and balanced diet going this route (though it's probably wise to ensure proper protein intake).
Since your goal is to lose 100 pounds, more important for you right now is to focus upon maintaining a consistent calorie deficit. Calories are calories in the context of weight loss, as the following study points out: cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/
1 -
This is an either-or? Red meat is a superior source for iron. Why eliminate the possibility for the sake of some misguided ideas about health?
Reflecting on my diary, I'm a dairy-arean. Cheese, yogurt and Kefir wiggle in to my plans every day. There are at least two days a week where meat does not figure at all. Nevertheless I make a roast beef at least once every couple months that then makes it in to stews and sandwiches for days afterwards.
Our teeth say we are omnivores which in turn tells me that people are dietary opportunists. Make full use of the grocery shelves.2 -
I grew up on a meaty diet, and became an ovo-lacto vegetarian for ten years during which I worked heavy blue collar work. I did a good job of being a healthy vegetarian: getting all the nutrients, etc. Then I met a hunter, and elk blackstrap was the end of that nonsense!
I've gone back and forth a few times, but I really feel better when I eat animal protein. I could go without dairy, but eggs and flesh give me more energy when I add some to my mostly veg diet. Any flesh in moderation--light, dark, fin or fur. Doesn't take much to make a difference. So whatever makes you feel best.1 -
I definitely find it easier to make healthy choices as a vegan
I have learned to cook at home instead of relying on prepackaged stuff, and it is a lot easier to avoid fast food etc when you can't just pop in to a McDonalds and grab anything- if I want junk food, I have to plan a special trip to the vegetarian/vegan junk food chain where I live- I can't just go to the KFC that is on every block (not that I'd want to anyway)!
Eating only plants means my meals are a lot more nutrient dense, and are lower in cholesterol. You also don't have the same hygiene issues that come with the meat and animal product processing industry.
I went vegan for ethical and environmental reasons, and I highly suggest you look in to those reasons too! In my view, mental and social health is a part of overall wellbeing- and how can I be mentally healthy while knowingly being responsible for the deaths of hundreds of innocent animals? How can I be socially healthy while contributing more than is necessary to the downfall of the environment, which will affect people all over the world- or even consume in a way that directly affects the lives of people living with the consequences of animal agriculture?
There are many separate aspects of health, and IMHO not eating meat (or other animal products) improves my health at every level x
Hope you found my input useful in making your decision!
3 -
samwiseenvs wrote: »I don't plan to go 100% vegetarian, I still want bacon on occasion, and a good hamburger every once in a while, but in a day to day occurrence, what are everyone's thoughts? Thanks! Oh, and my goal is to be healthier, which I believe will help with my weight goal (which is to lose 100+ lbs).
I eat meat on a daily basis, usually some form of it with every meal. Red meat, white meat and/or seafood. I also eat lots of vegetables and different varieties of fruits, along with grains, nuts, etc. I've lost 67 pounds and my health has improved vastly, as have my energy levels, sleep, workout performance and overall well-being. I find it very easy to eat a healthy and balanced diet while incorporating meat into it - in fact, I would find it considerably more difficult to do so as a vegetarian/vegan, to the point that I have no desire to even attempt it. Certainly not saying it can't be done, just that I don't consider it worth the effort for me. I love meat and have no ethical/environmental/health concerns over incorporating it as a significant portion of my diet. "Everything in moderation" works very well for me.0 -
I think the key either way is balance. People can eat like crap whether they are vegetarian or meat-eaters.
I personally found it difficult to eat a balanced diet while going vegetarian. I couldn't get enough protein without blowing out my carb goal for the day. Now, I try to eat lean meats, but I sometimes go for a nice fatty cut of red meat or a burger. I also try to get plenty of fiber, fruits, and veggies.0 -
samwiseenvs wrote: »crazyycatladyy1 wrote: »rheddmobile wrote: »Studies on this subject are all over the place. One of the larger long-term studies done on the subject found that the healthiest group of people ate meat only occasionally and when they did ate mostly fish. It's possible to be healthy on both meat and non-meat eating diets, but it can be tricky to get all your nutrients as a vegetarian or vegan if you don't know what you're doing.
Protein isn't really the problem - most people get more than enough.
If you're doing this for health reasons, you might consider adding fish as well as chicken.
This.
I've been doing some research on 'blue zones'. One of the things the groups all have in common is that they eat a mostly plant based diet, with meat 0-5 times a month. I'm especially interested in the only blue zone in the U.S.-the SDA group in Loma Linda California, and while the community is predominately a vegetarian one, there's a sub-set group that includes fish almost daily and they have even better longevity of life outcomes than the vegetarians, (which have significant longevity of life statistics as well).
I'm loosely modeling my woe after them right now-a mostly whole foods, plant based diet with fish 4-5 times a week. But, I still eat meat 1-2 times a week and I don't foresee myself ever eliminating meat completely. I also still drink alcohol and caffeine, which the SDA blue zone does not. I think what's more important than what you're cutting out is what you're adding to your diet. Because of what I've been reading about different woes (blue zones, Mediterranean etc), as well as the recent meta-study that came out from the Imperial College London about veg/fruit quantity, I'm really focusing on upping my veg/fruit intake, whole grains, beans etc. That's most likely more important in terms of healthy diet, than just cutting out meat.
eta: Op-here's a couple of links you may be interested in-
http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/04/11/398325030/eating-to-break-100-longevity-diet-tips-from-the-blue-zones
http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/newsandeventspggrp/imperialcollege/newssummary/news_22-2-2017-16-38-0
Thank you! I saw something about this, and how it was healthier but when I started researching it, I found so much conflicting information. Then again, everything about nutrition and health seems to be debated. Carbs? No carbs? Meat? No meat? The only thing I see that is consistent is added sugar is bad lol
It's about prioritization of factors. Whether are not you eat meat is probably at the low end of that. The bigger factors are obesity, inactivity and genetics. Things such as PUFA/MUFA can improve blood lipids, but so can whole grains, oats and fibrious carbs. Added sugar and SFA don't improve blood lipids, but may not adversely affect health if you are consuming adequate fiber/healthy fats.
IMO, people fail to see the forest for the trees.3 -
I've been ovo-lacto vegetarian for 43 years. My advice? Unless you have a moral, ethical, cultural, religious, or taste-preference reason to become vegetarian or vegan, don't bother.
Vegetarianism is ever so slightly less convenient. You have to pay a tiny bit more attention in order to get the best nutrition. There are occasional social issues to navigate (like getting invited to dinner at your non-vegetarian new boss's house). None of the issues are insurmountable, but why bother with extra complexity if you don't have a good reason?
Either way of eating can be nutritious. The basic rules are the same for any way of eating: Get enough high-quality protein. Get enough fats, as much as possible from healthy sources (like olive oil, nuts, avocado, etc.). Eat a boatload of nice veggies & fruits (5 servings minimum daily, 10 or more is better). Don't eat anything that you personally find causes you any distress (allergy, intolerance, OMG-that-tastes-awful). That's about it.2 -
If you eat mostly plant based, mostly greens, you will find out that you will need to eat a lot. If you watch your nutrition that can be a good thing.
(Beware, a little talked about fact, vegetarian/vegans can eat just about every peace of junk food on the planet)
Good luck, fresh is best0 -
If you eat mostly plant based, mostly greens, you will find out that you will need to eat a lot. If you watch your nutrition that can be a good thing.
(Beware, a little talked about fact, vegetarian/vegans can eat just about every peace of junk food on the planet)
Good luck, fresh is best
Given that just about every thread on veganism here includes someone warning about vegan "junk food," I'm not sure I agree that it is a "little talked about fact."1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions