Garmin connect
deadhead1018
Posts: 2 Member
Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.
0
Replies
-
Today I have 5,709 steps amounting to 269 active calories. That's perhaps slightly high but within reason considering hills and stairs.0
-
My garmin ap says I have 457 active calories but mfp only says 80
-
Has anyone else found a solution for this? I'm at 10000 steps and only 19 calories burned0
-
My Garmin Forerunner 225 is OK at calculating Activity calories for a run (tracked by pressing go on the watch.)
But I've found it to be absolute rubbish at giving any calories for just steps walked.
I do 20,000 steps most days, and barely get 400 calories extra even when that includes running.deadhead1018 wrote: »Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.bluefire301175 wrote: »Has anyone else found a solution for this? I'm at 10000 steps and only 19 calories burned
Are you both talking about the calories burned according to Garmin, or what's been sent/added to MFP?
I'm currently experimenting with having my MFP activity level set to "very active", which is the highest setting meant for over 12500 steps a day. MFP gives me 500 extra calories. But no matter how much running or steps I do, the negative calorie adjustments take nearly all my exercise calories back.
Two weeks ago, I did a 50 km walk (64,000 steps) and I only earned an extra 1000 calories in MFP on top of the 500 I get every day for being "very active" and doing 12,500 steps!
0 -
My Garmin Forerunner 225 is OK at calculating Activity calories for a run (tracked by pressing go on the watch.)
But I've found it to be absolute rubbish at giving any calories for just steps walked.
I do 20,000 steps most days, and barely get 400 calories extra even when that includes running.deadhead1018 wrote: »Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.bluefire301175 wrote: »Has anyone else found a solution for this? I'm at 10000 steps and only 19 calories burned
Are you both talking about the calories burned according to Garmin, or what's been sent/added to MFP?
I'm currently experimenting with having my MFP activity level set to "very active", which is the highest setting meant for over 12500 steps a day. MFP gives me 500 extra calories. But no matter how much running or steps I do, the negative calorie adjustments take nearly all my exercise calories back.
Two weeks ago, I did a 50 km walk (64,000 steps) and I only earned an extra 1000 calories in MFP on top of the 500 I get every day for being "very active" and doing 12,500 steps!
That calorie burn actually sounds about right. A 160 lb person (and you look like you probably weigh quite a bit less), would burn ~1500 calories for a 50km walk (Net Calories Burned Walking = 0.30 * Weigh in pounds * Distance Walked in Miles).0 -
I confess that I don't track the actual interactions between Garmin and MFP, just the end result of losing weight with a calorie deficit, which shows that using Garmin as my activity tracker to feed my data to MFP appears to be working for me appropriately and I'm happy with the ongoing results so far.
I have MFP set to "Sedentary: Spend most of the day sitting (e.g. bank teller, desk job)" along with "Enable Negative Adjustments" activated, and am letting Garmin do the heavy lifting for steps and activities (currently doing three sessions a week of Jeff Galloway's Run-Walk-Run training).
I would expect that having MFP set to higher "diet/fitness profile" settings above "Sedentary" would impact the calorie adjustments and discrepancy between the two sites, Garmin and MFP. As to "why it's different all the time", I don't have any suggestions.
Looking forward to learning more about the interactions between the two.
2 -
Mine seems spot on. What watch do you have and what activity level are you set to in MFP?1
-
The_Enginerd wrote: »My Garmin Forerunner 225 is OK at calculating Activity calories for a run (tracked by pressing go on the watch.)
But I've found it to be absolute rubbish at giving any calories for just steps walked.
I do 20,000 steps most days, and barely get 400 calories extra even when that includes running.deadhead1018 wrote: »Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.bluefire301175 wrote: »Has anyone else found a solution for this? I'm at 10000 steps and only 19 calories burned
Are you both talking about the calories burned according to Garmin, or what's been sent/added to MFP?
I'm currently experimenting with having my MFP activity level set to "very active", which is the highest setting meant for over 12500 steps a day. MFP gives me 500 extra calories. But no matter how much running or steps I do, the negative calorie adjustments take nearly all my exercise calories back.
Two weeks ago, I did a 50 km walk (64,000 steps) and I only earned an extra 1000 calories in MFP on top of the 500 I get every day for being "very active" and doing 12,500 steps!
That calorie burn actually sounds about right. A 160 lb person (and you look like you probably weigh quite a bit less), would burn ~1500 calories for a 50km walk (Net Calories Burned Walking = 0.30 * Weigh in pounds * Distance Walked in Miles).
@The_Enginerd Thanks. Do you have that formula in metric? Also, do you have one for running? (I Googled, but it brings up calculators instead.)
0 -
My Garmin Forerunner 225 is OK at calculating Activity calories for a run (tracked by pressing go on the watch.)
But I've found it to be absolute rubbish at giving any calories for just steps walked.
I do 20,000 steps most days, and barely get 400 calories extra even when that includes running.deadhead1018 wrote: »Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.bluefire301175 wrote: »Has anyone else found a solution for this? I'm at 10000 steps and only 19 calories burned
Are you both talking about the calories burned according to Garmin, or what's been sent/added to MFP?
I'm currently experimenting with having my MFP activity level set to "very active", which is the highest setting meant for over 12500 steps a day. MFP gives me 500 extra calories. But no matter how much running or steps I do, the negative calorie adjustments take nearly all my exercise calories back.
Two weeks ago, I did a 50 km walk (64,000 steps) and I only earned an extra 1000 calories in MFP on top of the 500 I get every day for being "very active" and doing 12,500 steps!
I'm talking about the interaction between garmin and mfp. When syncing i had over 10000 steps and 300 or so calories burned in garmin but when it syncs over to mfp it only comes out to 8 calories.0 -
bluefire301175 wrote: »My Garmin Forerunner 225 is OK at calculating Activity calories for a run (tracked by pressing go on the watch.)
But I've found it to be absolute rubbish at giving any calories for just steps walked.
I do 20,000 steps most days, and barely get 400 calories extra even when that includes running.deadhead1018 wrote: »Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.bluefire301175 wrote: »Has anyone else found a solution for this? I'm at 10000 steps and only 19 calories burned
Are you both talking about the calories burned according to Garmin, or what's been sent/added to MFP?
I'm currently experimenting with having my MFP activity level set to "very active", which is the highest setting meant for over 12500 steps a day. MFP gives me 500 extra calories. But no matter how much running or steps I do, the negative calorie adjustments take nearly all my exercise calories back.
Two weeks ago, I did a 50 km walk (64,000 steps) and I only earned an extra 1000 calories in MFP on top of the 500 I get every day for being "very active" and doing 12,500 steps!
I'm talking about the interaction between garmin and mfp. When syncing i had over 10000 steps and 300 or so calories burned in garmin but when it syncs over to mfp it only comes out to 8 calories.
What have you got your MFP Activity Level set to?2 -
The_Enginerd wrote: »My Garmin Forerunner 225 is OK at calculating Activity calories for a run (tracked by pressing go on the watch.)
But I've found it to be absolute rubbish at giving any calories for just steps walked.
I do 20,000 steps most days, and barely get 400 calories extra even when that includes running.deadhead1018 wrote: »Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.bluefire301175 wrote: »Has anyone else found a solution for this? I'm at 10000 steps and only 19 calories burned
Are you both talking about the calories burned according to Garmin, or what's been sent/added to MFP?
I'm currently experimenting with having my MFP activity level set to "very active", which is the highest setting meant for over 12500 steps a day. MFP gives me 500 extra calories. But no matter how much running or steps I do, the negative calorie adjustments take nearly all my exercise calories back.
Two weeks ago, I did a 50 km walk (64,000 steps) and I only earned an extra 1000 calories in MFP on top of the 500 I get every day for being "very active" and doing 12,500 steps!
That calorie burn actually sounds about right. A 160 lb person (and you look like you probably weigh quite a bit less), would burn ~1500 calories for a 50km walk (Net Calories Burned Walking = 0.30 * Weigh in pounds * Distance Walked in Miles).
@The_Enginerd Thanks. Do you have that formula in metric? Also, do you have one for running? (I Googled, but it brings up calculators instead.)
Multiplier for running is 0.60 -
As others have said. if you have MFP set to active or very active, you won't get credit for steps below 10K or 12.5K. In other words, it's working exactly as designed.2
-
deadhead1018 wrote: »Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.
Are you also logging in a run or walking exercise? If so, Garmin will discount your steps that occurred at the time of that exercise to avoid double counting.0 -
I have a Vivofit 2 and it's very accurate, i actually think that it underestimates my calories burned sometimes especially when i walk 20,000 steps. But it does a good job showing the difference of calories burned based on the intensity/quality of my physical activity. I have my activity class Garmin Connect set to zero and I did not sync the app to MFP. I prefer to keep the information separate and do the deficit math in my head. MFP activity is set to lightly active.1
-
The_Enginerd wrote: »My Garmin Forerunner 225 is OK at calculating Activity calories for a run (tracked by pressing go on the watch.)
But I've found it to be absolute rubbish at giving any calories for just steps walked.
I do 20,000 steps most days, and barely get 400 calories extra even when that includes running.deadhead1018 wrote: »Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.bluefire301175 wrote: »Has anyone else found a solution for this? I'm at 10000 steps and only 19 calories burned
Are you both talking about the calories burned according to Garmin, or what's been sent/added to MFP?
I'm currently experimenting with having my MFP activity level set to "very active", which is the highest setting meant for over 12500 steps a day. MFP gives me 500 extra calories. But no matter how much running or steps I do, the negative calorie adjustments take nearly all my exercise calories back.
Two weeks ago, I did a 50 km walk (64,000 steps) and I only earned an extra 1000 calories in MFP on top of the 500 I get every day for being "very active" and doing 12,500 steps!
That calorie burn actually sounds about right. A 160 lb person (and you look like you probably weigh quite a bit less), would burn ~1500 calories for a 50km walk (Net Calories Burned Walking = 0.30 * Weigh in pounds * Distance Walked in Miles).
@The_Enginerd Thanks. Do you have that formula in metric? Also, do you have one for running? (I Googled, but it brings up calculators instead.)
I use weight(lbs) * km * .39 for running. But I think in pounds and kilometers.
I guess it would be weight (kg) * km * .86
For me, this gives ~ 470 cals for a 5 k run. Garming gave me 507 for my last one.0 -
The_Enginerd wrote: »My Garmin Forerunner 225 is OK at calculating Activity calories for a run (tracked by pressing go on the watch.)
But I've found it to be absolute rubbish at giving any calories for just steps walked.
I do 20,000 steps most days, and barely get 400 calories extra even when that includes running.deadhead1018 wrote: »Hey does anyone have the garmin connect? And if so do you have issues with your steps calculating to calories burned. I have 13000 steps and only have 8 calories burned today. Some days the same amount of steps equals about 300 calories. I don't get why it's different all the time and I'm sure that 13000 steps is way more than 8 calories.bluefire301175 wrote: »Has anyone else found a solution for this? I'm at 10000 steps and only 19 calories burned
Are you both talking about the calories burned according to Garmin, or what's been sent/added to MFP?
I'm currently experimenting with having my MFP activity level set to "very active", which is the highest setting meant for over 12500 steps a day. MFP gives me 500 extra calories. But no matter how much running or steps I do, the negative calorie adjustments take nearly all my exercise calories back.
Two weeks ago, I did a 50 km walk (64,000 steps) and I only earned an extra 1000 calories in MFP on top of the 500 I get every day for being "very active" and doing 12,500 steps!
That calorie burn actually sounds about right. A 160 lb person (and you look like you probably weigh quite a bit less), would burn ~1500 calories for a 50km walk (Net Calories Burned Walking = 0.30 * Weigh in pounds * Distance Walked in Miles).
@The_Enginerd Thanks. Do you have that formula in metric? Also, do you have one for running? (I Googled, but it brings up calculators instead.)
The multiplier for running is 0.63. This gives the NET calories burned, which is what you would be interested in for logging exercise calories.
http://www.runnersworld.com/weight-loss/how-many-calories-are-you-really-burning
In metric, it should be Net Cal = 0.87 * Weigh in kg * Distance in km if I did the conversions right...0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions