Gained 4lbs? :(
metalbish
Posts: 20 Member
Been dieting for a month today, been weighing myself a few times per week but recording every Thursday morning.
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
0
Replies
-
It sounds just like water weight from a high salt meal.
Could it be your ovulation week as well? I shoot up a few lbs 8 days before my period.1 -
Relax. 1 lb is about 3500 calories you did not overeat by 4lbs. It is likely you consumed extra salt which is retaining water plus the extra weight of the food itself is still in your gi track. Relax eat sensible and you will poop and pee out the change in a day or two3
-
RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: »It sounds just like water weight from a high salt meal.
Could it be your ovulation week as well? I shoot up a few lbs 8 days before my period.
It could possibly be, will need to check my calendar when I get home from work. I'm wondering if it's water retention in my muscles? I weigh 17st currently and am doing c25k felt it in my knees on Tuesday..
Still don't think that could account for 4lbs.0 -
RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: »It sounds just like water weight from a high salt meal.
Could it be your ovulation week as well? I shoot up a few lbs 8 days before my period.
It could possibly be, will need to check my calendar when I get home from work. I'm wondering if it's water retention in my muscles? I weigh 17st currently and am doing c25k felt it in my knees on Tuesday..
Still don't think that could account for 4lbs.
It can account for a lot more than 4lbs. You can get a 4lb gain just due to the take away, add in muscle soreness and hormone fluctuations and 7-8lbs is not unusual.
Weight loss is not linear either. We can alter weight by a few lbs each day due to a whole host of reasons.5 -
Relax. 1 lb is about 3500 calories you did not overeat by 4lbs. It is likely you consumed extra salt which is retaining water plus the extra weight of the food itself is still in your go track. Relax eat sensible and you will poop and pee out the change in a day or two
My partner said the exact same thing this morning when I flailing and huffing at 5am hahaha! No, I most certainly did not. About 500cal tops. Thank you
0 -
Maybe recording your weigh ins into one of the trending apps (such as Libra) might help you see the long term trend and ignore or accept the totally normal fluctuations?1
-
Been dieting for a month today, been weighing myself a few times per week but recording every Thursday morning.
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
what was your cheat meal?0 -
Best thing is to weigh and record yourself twice a week, then as you fluctuate up and down, you will see the gradual trend of weight loss better.
Water weight can be caused by many things:-
- Too much salt leads to water retention
- Dehydration, not drinking enough leads to water retention
- Eating a high carb meal does as well, you need extra water for each gram of carbs eaten
- Hormones
The good news is it's only temporary, if you have a day or two of the above it will lead to weight increase.
But the good news is that it's not real weight and will soon be lost.
I weigh myself midweek as it's then that I'm more likely to have kept to my diet, it's then that the weight loss shows.
I also weigh myself at the start of the weekend, before I crumple. Lol1 -
-
TavistockToad wrote: »Been dieting for a month today, been weighing myself a few times per week but recording every Thursday morning.
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
what was your cheat meal?
Special fried rice w/ curry sauce and banana fritters..0 -
TavistockToad wrote: »Been dieting for a month today, been weighing myself a few times per week but recording every Thursday morning.
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
what was your cheat meal?
Special fried rice w/ curry sauce and banana fritters..
carbtastic! from a take away?0 -
TavistockToad wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »Been dieting for a month today, been weighing myself a few times per week but recording every Thursday morning.
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
what was your cheat meal?
Special fried rice w/ curry sauce and banana fritters..
carbtastic! from a take away?
Yus.. And it wasn't worth it, goodness me. Lesson learned!2 -
TavistockToad wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »Been dieting for a month today, been weighing myself a few times per week but recording every Thursday morning.
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
what was your cheat meal?
Special fried rice w/ curry sauce and banana fritters..
carbtastic! from a take away?
Yus.. And it wasn't worth it, goodness me. Lesson learned!
so also sodiumtastic... welcome to water weight fluctuations!
don't weigh after a cheat day unless you're doing it for a laugh!!!7 -
TavistockToad wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »Been dieting for a month today, been weighing myself a few times per week but recording every Thursday morning.
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
what was your cheat meal?
Special fried rice w/ curry sauce and banana fritters..
carbtastic! from a take away?
Yus.. And it wasn't worth it, goodness me. Lesson learned!
You might be surprised to hear someone ask this, but why wouldn't it be worth it? Gaining water weight for a couple of days after a meal is no big deal and there is nothing inherently wrong with that. Further, gaining water weight from muscle repair is a good thing. If you eat at a calorie deficit you burn fat. If you burn fat at 2 lbs per week, it could show up on the scale as -8 (loss of water weight would exaggerate your loss) or +5 (water weight gain could mask your loss).
Unless you have other health issues dealing with water retention, it's a part of life. And you should know that your weight has fluctuated up and down your whole life, whether you are trying to lose weight, stay the same, or gain. You're just paying closer attention now because you want the number to go down.
It won't be last time you wake up 4 lbs heavier than you might expect. It's been a month for you. You will need a couple of months before you can really see trend. Time and trend. They're your friends.
4 -
Silentpadna wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »Been dieting for a month today, been weighing myself a few times per week but recording every Thursday morning.
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
what was your cheat meal?
Special fried rice w/ curry sauce and banana fritters..
carbtastic! from a take away?
Yus.. And it wasn't worth it, goodness me. Lesson learned!
You might be surprised to hear someone ask this, but why wouldn't it be worth it? Gaining water weight for a couple of days after a meal is no big deal and there is nothing inherently wrong with that. Further, gaining water weight from muscle repair is a good thing. If you eat at a calorie deficit you burn fat. If you burn fat at 2 lbs per week, it could show up on the scale as -8 (loss of water weight would exaggerate your loss) or +5 (water weight gain could mask your loss).
Unless you have other health issues dealing with water retention, it's a part of life. And you should know that your weight has fluctuated up and down your whole life, whether you are trying to lose weight, stay the same, or gain. You're just paying closer attention now because you want the number to go down.
It won't be last time you wake up 4 lbs heavier than you might expect. It's been a month for you. You will need a couple of months before you can really see trend. Time and trend. They're your friends.
i presumed OP meant not worth it as in the meal wasn't very nice so not worth the calories.5 -
TavistockToad wrote: »Silentpadna wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »Been dieting for a month today, been weighing myself a few times per week but recording every Thursday morning.
Monday, I was down 3lbs from last week. Last night, had a cheat meal which I didn't really want to do before today but I figured it wouldn't really effect the scales.. Woke up 4lbs heavier than Monday. What gives?
Stuck to a high protein, fruit and veg diet all week. Drink about 2L of water per day. Worked out (cardio) 4x since last Thursday. I'm confused and disheartened..
what was your cheat meal?
Special fried rice w/ curry sauce and banana fritters..
carbtastic! from a take away?
Yus.. And it wasn't worth it, goodness me. Lesson learned!
You might be surprised to hear someone ask this, but why wouldn't it be worth it? Gaining water weight for a couple of days after a meal is no big deal and there is nothing inherently wrong with that. Further, gaining water weight from muscle repair is a good thing. If you eat at a calorie deficit you burn fat. If you burn fat at 2 lbs per week, it could show up on the scale as -8 (loss of water weight would exaggerate your loss) or +5 (water weight gain could mask your loss).
Unless you have other health issues dealing with water retention, it's a part of life. And you should know that your weight has fluctuated up and down your whole life, whether you are trying to lose weight, stay the same, or gain. You're just paying closer attention now because you want the number to go down.
It won't be last time you wake up 4 lbs heavier than you might expect. It's been a month for you. You will need a couple of months before you can really see trend. Time and trend. They're your friends.
i presumed OP meant not worth it as in the meal wasn't very nice so not worth the calories.
-ahh, could be. In which case my whole question on worth probably doesn't apply, does it...?0 -
I think there are many videos on YouTube that discuss just how much weight fluctuates. You eat a nice meal full of salt, you're going to notice it on the scale. It takes 3500 calories beyond your maintenance goal to actually gain a single pound of fat. It's water and should come off in the next couple of days.
Fight water retention with upping your water. Have an extra glass or two if you're really concerned about it.
I had several hefty meal weekends last month. Did my monthly progress post on Instagram and I was just over 10lbs down. In a month where I had fun socially.
(My loss is taking into consideration I'm still in the upper 200s so it may be a bit more aggressive than the suggested 2lb a week loss. Don't be discouraged if you are not losing upwards of 10lbs a month. 4 to 8 is freaking amazing.)1 -
On tuesday morning I was down lb from my friday weigh in (210lbs down to 209lb)
yesterday was my daughters birthday and we had a family bbq, although I didnt eat loads I did drink a fair bit and spent the night feeling like my mouth had dried up completely and what i did eat was high in salt......got on the scale this morning to see 214lbs, i was expecting it to be up but was shocked at by how much.
Needless to say im on the water today in the hope that atleast some of that weight is gonna flush out.
Iv also had a poo for the first time in 3 days due to constipation caused by my meds (sorry tmi lol) which im guessing is also gonna help with getting those numbers back down0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions