sub 1 lb weight loss?

I'm not sure what you mean by "sub" weight loss. If I didn't log each pound, I would never log, b/c I am only aiming to lose 10-15 lbs total and am doing it slowly, less than a pound a week.

I'm not sure what you mean by "sub" weight loss. If I didn't log each pound, I would never log, b/c I am only aiming to lose 10-15 lbs total and am doing it slowly, less than a pound a week.

I think he means anything less than 1 pound, like .8 pound loss etc

My point is that this site is designed for a 1 or 2 lb weight lose. Each pound requires a 500 calorie pet day deficit. So what I am getting at is if you are loosing less than a lb then you aren't properly logging. Anyone who needs to lose weight can SAFELY lose 2 lbs per week.

Not sure what you mean by not properly logging? I am set up to lose .5 lb a week. So I log my food and exercise and lose about a half lb a week. Each person has different goals and mine is to tone and lose a few pounds, not overweight.

Actually the site allows for 0.5 lb increments (from maintenance to 2.0lb/ max loss), AND you can even customize your goals (I am currently set at 0.8lbs/week because I am so close to my goal and want to minimize muscle loss and maximize fat loss). It really depends on your goals how you want to use the site... I would definitely say it is NOT safe for everyone to lose 2lbs/week - especially if they are small frame to begin with or have a small amount (<10-15lbs) to lose

Exactly If I lost 2 lbs a week. I'd be starving and way skinny, which isn't what I'm going for.

If you go to My Home -> Goals -> Change Goals -> Guided - at the bottom there is a "What is your goal?" section that should give a drop-down list including 6-7 things (0.5-2.0 loss, maintenance, or even gain).

For weighing yourself, whatever works for you is best - but MFP DOES allow decimals in weight, so I tend to include them (though the fluctuation in weight/scale means rounding up or down shouldn't make much of a difference).

Also, you are 100% correct in that your weight varies significantly throughout the day. That is why I said in my first post that consistency is key (time of day, location of scale, etc.). I personally agree with you that first thing in the morning (post-am bathroom break) works for me

Ok....I get it. This wasn't directed at you small girls that barely have anything left to lose...but more those that have over 100lbs to lose and are logging .5 lb losses which to me.....when you are over 200lbs means you need to change your habits, goals or logging. I personally do 2 lbs a week and am not horribly strict.....I log it all but routinely go a bit over. I also add muscle so for me a scale is virtually useless. I hate to see people rely on a scale when they are doing strength training.

I do quite a bit of strength training and really enjoy it. I don't get too hung up on the number on the scale, just try to get toned. and drop a couple of those "I just turned 40" pounds.

I will remember the part about weighing in the morning. Thanks!