Loose weight & Gain muscle at same time?

clags301
clags301 Posts: 69 Member
edited November 20 in Health and Weight Loss
I am 49 yo peri menopausal female with 10 pounds to lose - I'm well within healthy weight, but hormones causing thighs and stomach to be lumpy and gross with any extra weight. I know that I need to also gain muscle to help the situation and for long term fitness, but is it possible to lose fat and gain muscle at same time, since losing weight requires calorie deficit?

Replies

  • usmcmp
    usmcmp Posts: 21,219 Member
    It is for people who are new to lifting weights and for people who are very overweight. Rather than trying to lose weight and gain muscle you could maintain weight, lose fat, and gain muscle. It's called recomposition. Essentially you ensure you eat adequate protein while following a progressive lifting routine. It's not a fast process, but gaining muscle is slow for women in general.
  • TimothyFish
    TimothyFish Posts: 4,925 Member
    If you eat sufficient protein while keeping your calorie intake at what is now but you also add more strength building exercise then the end result will be increased muscle while losing fat, since the increase in exercise will create a slight calorie deficit.
  • clags301
    clags301 Posts: 69 Member
    rmgnow wrote: »
    To lose fat and gain muscle, at the same time, at your age, you'd probably have to do steroids.
    Just letting you know your options

    Seriously? I'm not talking about bodybuilding! So, youre saying I will just be bone and skin when I lose the fat? That doesn't make sense - I see plenty of 50+ women with muscle definition and toned bodies. What am I missing?

  • rmgnow
    rmgnow Posts: 375 Member
    clags301 wrote: »
    rmgnow wrote: »
    To lose fat and gain muscle, at the same time, at your age, you'd probably have to do steroids.
    Just letting you know your options

    Seriously? I'm not talking about bodybuilding! So, youre saying I will just be bone and skin when I lose the fat? That doesn't make sense - I see plenty of 50+ women with muscle definition and toned bodies. What am I missing?

    Ya. You would have to lose weight, then you would have to gain muscle.
    Very hard to do it at the same time.
    I'm not saying you can't have a toned body at all
  • RavenLibra
    RavenLibra Posts: 1,737 Member
    Eat healthy, strength train and do moderate cardio... and you will lose fat... retain your current muscle... you may not see the scale move... so take measurements... also get on the foam roller band wagon... that may help smooth out the appearance of your skin
  • RavenLibra
    RavenLibra Posts: 1,737 Member
    To see significant gains... 3-5 hours of cardio and an equal amount of lifting/ week
  • livingleanlivingclean
    livingleanlivingclean Posts: 11,751 Member
    clags301 wrote: »
    rmgnow wrote: »
    To lose fat and gain muscle, at the same time, at your age, you'd probably have to do steroids.
    Just letting you know your options

    Seriously? I'm not talking about bodybuilding! So, youre saying I will just be bone and skin when I lose the fat? That doesn't make sense - I see plenty of 50+ women with muscle definition and toned bodies. What am I missing?

    You already have muscle. If you didn't, you'd be a crumpled pile on the floor. Muscle definition comes from losing fat to uncover the muscle. You lose the fat by being on a deficit, and resistance training at the same time will help maintain the muscle you have. If you lose the fat and aren't happy with the amount of muscle you have, then you need to eat in a slight surplus, keep lifting and try to gain some - this is a long, slow process!
  • rmgnow
    rmgnow Posts: 375 Member
    clags301 wrote: »
    rmgnow wrote: »
    To lose fat and gain muscle, at the same time, at your age, you'd probably have to do steroids.
    Just letting you know your options

    Seriously? I'm not talking about bodybuilding! So, youre saying I will just be bone and skin when I lose the fat? That doesn't make sense - I see plenty of 50+ women with muscle definition and toned bodies. What am I missing?

    You already have muscle. If you didn't, you'd be a crumpled pile on the floor. Muscle definition comes from losing fat to uncover the muscle. You lose the fat by being on a deficit, and resistance training at the same time will help maintain the muscle you have. If you lose the fat and aren't happy with the amount of muscle you have, then you need to eat in a slight surplus, keep lifting and try to gain some - this is a long, slow process!
    Long slow process indeed.
    At the OPs age.
    I stand by my first post
  • nutmegoreo
    nutmegoreo Posts: 15,532 Member
    Sounds like recomp would be a good option for you. It will be a long process, but not impossible.
  • vismal
    vismal Posts: 2,463 Member
    I do not think recomp is the most efficient way for the OP to go. Far from it actually. Why not focus on fat loss and lose the 10 lbs that she states she still has to lose, then focus on a slow weight gain doing a resistance training program the entire time during both phases. Fat loss/muscle gain cycles are going to be MUCH more efficient then endless recomping. Even for those new to training I think cycling is going to net a total of more fat lost and muscle gained then recomping. It's true that OP has potential to gain a bit of muscle during the fat loss phase if she is new to weight training, that's basically just a bonus and isn't going to be hugely significant. IMO recomps make more sense once you've already done a few gain/loss cycles.
  • usmcmp
    usmcmp Posts: 21,219 Member
    vismal wrote: »
    I do not think recomp is the most efficient way for the OP to go. Far from it actually. Why not focus on fat loss and lose the 10 lbs that she states she still has to lose, then focus on a slow weight gain doing a resistance training program the entire time during both phases. Fat loss/muscle gain cycles are going to be MUCH more efficient then endless recomping. Even for those new to training I think cycling is going to net a total of more fat lost and muscle gained then recomping. It's true that OP has potential to gain a bit of muscle during the fat loss phase if she is new to weight training, that's basically just a bonus and isn't going to be hugely significant. IMO recomps make more sense once you've already done a few gain/loss cycles.

    IMO recomp works better for newer people since they are further from their natural genetic potential. They're more likely to gain lean mass without a surplus. Once the years of training start adding up you gain less lean mass. The OP also has a slight age and gender disadvantage.
This discussion has been closed.