Transition to Maintenance
justkeeprunning91
Posts: 96 Member
Hello maintainers! By way of background, I'm 5'4.5" and currently 140 lbs. My goal maintenance range is 130-135. As I get closer to 135, I'm trying to develop a sensible plan for maintenance. Right now I'm at a 500 calorie deficit. I'm planning on keeping that going until 135, then decreasing my defective by 100 calories every couple weeks (adding to my intake) until I find my maintenance number. At that point I should be settled somewhere in my goal range. My question for you all is: is there any advice you wish you had gotten before making the transition from losing to maintenance, or anything I should expect that you didn't during the transition? Does my transition plan seem sensible? Thank you in advance!
2
Replies
-
Keep a goal range, not try to settle at some point. Your weight will fluctuate from day to day for the rest of your life. Daily weigh-ins and a 6 pound range is how I deal with it. Be mentally prepared to do practically the same as you have been doing while losing, but not get the satisfaction from seeing the dropping numbers. This is the new normal. But if you've enjoyed weightloss, maintenance will be wonderful. Welcome on board!
Heh, I forgot, yes - your plan looks good13 -
Your plan looks good to me. And congrats on getting so close to maintenance! I've been maintaining now for about 3 mos and - to my surprise - find it relatively effortless. I was really, really fretting about it!! As it turns out, I'm basically continuing to live the same way I did while I was losing: Eating healthy, tracking cico, and getting regular exercise. I eat at the level of deficit calories most days, but once or twice a week I relax and eat a burger and fries or mac & cheese, etc. Or a piece of decadent chocolate cake. In other words, those yummies I only rarely ate while reducing. I will probably continue to track my calories for the rest of my life - seems to make all the diff for me. But I'm pretty much on automatic about that, so it's easy. Life is good!8
-
Yes your plan sounds really good.
If you are goal-oriented then a replacement for the reward of seeing the number on your bathroom scales going down is sensible. For some people just seeing their weight in their chosen range is enough of a reward of course, every day is a victory with the right mindset.
The only thing that was a slight surprise to me was that my maintenance calories ended up higher than either the numbers or rate of loss predicted. Good news!2 -
A 500 caloric deficit daily will result in 3500 caloric deficit weekly. That will - all things being equal - lead to one pound of weight loss for that week. Everyone is different, but that is the general guideline.
Are you weighing yourself everyday, at the same time, on the same scale and then taking a weekly average?
Do you know what your Basal Metabolic Rate is?
Here is the formula (for a woman; there is a different one for a man):
BMR = 655 + (4.35 x weight in pounds) + (4.7 x height in inches) – (4.7 x age in years)
To give you a starting point, if you take your BMR and multiply it by an "Activity Multiplier" then you can find your "Active Metabolic Rate". This will give you a starting point as to what your "maintenance" caloric intake should be. Again, these are formulas so they are a starting point. Everyone will be a little bit different.
The "Activity Multiplier" looks like this:
*Sedentary (little or no exercise) – your AMR = BMR x 1.2
*Lightly active (light exercise/work 1-3 days per week) – your AMR = BMR x 1.375
*Moderately active (moderate exercise/work 3-5 days per week) – your AMR = BMR x 1.55
*Very active (hard exercise/work 6-7 days a week) – your AMR = BMR x 1.725
*Ultra active (very hard exercise/work 6-7 days a week) – your AMR = BMR x 1.9
So, to find out what your maintenance calories are, you take (BMR + AMR)/2. Again, this is a starting point. It will likely be close, but you will need to play with this. So, your "take some time and figure out my maintenance calories" is EXACTLY the proper thought process.
Small changes, over time, are indeed on order. Congrats on the great work!5 -
Yiur current deficit is too steep. With only 5-10 lbs to lose it is most healthy to Target 250 cals or .5 lb per week. This helps you retaining muscle & have a healthy nutritional calorie range. Transition to maintenance then will consist of adding a snack each day or an extra treat meal each week. Good job with the loss!0
-
Yiur current deficit is too steep. With only 5-10 lbs to lose it is most healthy to Target 250 cals or .5 lb per week. This helps you retaining muscle & have a healthy nutritional calorie range. Transition to maintenance then will consist of adding a snack each day or an extra treat meal each week. Good job with the loss!
I was thinking the same thing. I have been at half a pound for the last ten and still have 5 to go. It is tempting to speed it up but I don't want to lose any more muscle than I already have. Of course in my case I am older and only get 1290 calories a day so I can't go any lower anyway.
2 -
Thank you all for the advice! I decided today to decrease my deficit to 250. I'm training for my second half marathon in November, and it's probably going to be more pleasant on a smaller deficit. I guess it still hadn't hit me that I'm to the point now where I'm losing vanity weight now and it really won't make too much of a difference in the long run if it takes me 15 weeks instead of 7 to lose 7 more pounds.13
-
WELL DONE!0
-
justkeeprunning91 wrote: »Thank you all for the advice! I decided today to decrease my deficit to 250. I'm training for my second half marathon in November, and it's probably going to be more pleasant on a smaller deficit. I guess it still hadn't hit me that I'm to the point now where I'm losing vanity weight now and it really won't make too much of a difference in the long run if it takes me 15 weeks instead of 7 to lose 7 more pounds.
I was about to support your steepish deficit until I read this. Fuel your body for the demand you are placing on it
4 -
It's oddly hard to go back to eating maintenance amounts after an extended period of eating at a deficit without going overboard. Don't force a ton of foods you wouldn't normally eat on yourself or cram yourself overfull of foods you don't want just to get the calories in.
Think of the transition as 'dieting in reverse'. Keep eating the way you've been eating and just gradually eat more of it to avoid a shock to the system or the recrafting of bad eating habits.
Keep 100 calorie snacks, fruit, and/or other 'single serving' items around. They a great way to slowly add calories to your day in a controlled manner without having to resort to drinking straight oil or eating butter or anything goofy like that. And since they're relatively small, it won't feel like much of a change just to pop one every once in a while.
Enjoy the freedom and remember to keep monitoring your weight for long-term trends (studies say that people who regularly weigh themselves after losing have a much higher chance of keeping the weight off than otherwise).
The best part amount maintenance is that the hard work is done. All you need to do it to stay alert/aware enough to nip issues in the bud. Eating at a deficit for one or two days to make up a bad night at a restaurant is nothing compared to eating at a deficit for months in order to make up for years of indulgence.
Good luck!5 -
I am in a similar situation, just a few pounds (hopefully 2 weeks) away from starting to maintain. A little gun shy as I had success with MFP, left and stopped tracking, eventually gaining back 15 of the 40 lbs I lost. Now I am on the cusp of a total loss of 50. This time I will continue to log.
I am extremely active, including weight training with a trainer and I want to continue this level of activity. I am nervous about the future. Enjoying the suggestions in this thread so far and looking forward to more.
Would be open to becoming friends with fellow maintainers.
My main concern is eating back the activity calories. Somedays it's well over 600 for a workout. I can't imagine eating that many extra calories, especially since I want them to be "healthy" calories and not junk.1 -
Very helpful post as I'm on the cusp of transitioning to maintaining. I hit my initial goal weight (154 lbs- am 5'8") a few days ago but have decided to set my goal range about 5-10 pounds lower so want to gradually settle into a maintenance plan. I'm worried about putting it all back on again so think I will need to continue to track long term. Finding it hard to take the plunge and reduce my deficit as it has been rewarding to see the lbs come off as a steady rate.0
-
Cheers for the post same position I'm 5'5" at 135 aiming for maintenance range of 125-130 so in for the tips
I was linked to a interesting maintenance vid from Martin Macdonald, he has a slightly different view that you should diet as aggressively as you can that is sustainable for you (emphasis on sustainable) to hit maintenance levels as quickly as possible. His basic argument is that if you had two dieters, one losing slowly for 20 weeks one losing twice as fast and hitting maintenance 10 weeks early, you would see better results for the latter in body composition after the 20 weeks, even though they may have lost more lean mass than the slower dieter initially.
Please watch before you hit the woo button everyone I know it sounds woo or bro-science but he makes a great study based case and think its a great watch for debate regarding losing and maintaining for those of us at that stage or those interested in questioning the usual transition to maintenance.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhLIsFFsPAA&t=1319s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wx4npV4IV3s
What's peoples thoughts?1 -
My maintenance calories ended up higher than I thought they would based on calculators and my own weight loss results. I think when I upped calories, inadvertent movement increased...fidgeting and whatnot...my workouts were also better and I think I was getting more out of them in regards to effort than I was when dieting.
It took me awhile to hit my maintenance number and just kept losing even though my calories were going up.2 -
cwolfman13 wrote: »My maintenance calories ended up higher than I thought they would based on calculators and my own weight loss results. I think when I upped calories, inadvertent movement increased...fidgeting and whatnot...my workouts were also better and I think I was getting more out of them in regards to effort than I was when dieting.
It took me awhile to hit my maintenance number and just kept losing even though my calories were going up.
that's what I found...my maintenance calories have been slowly creeping up0 -
Following along as I am in the same boat. 3.5 lbs away from my goal weight, then onto recomp!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions