What 'Program' to choose??

mheagan
mheagan Posts: 8 Member
edited November 21 in Health and Weight Loss
I am struggling. What way of eating to choose / follow? I tend to jump from one plan to another when not seeing results in a week. There is SO MANY options out there :(

I am almost 40
I have PCOS / Hormone Issues
Insulin Resistance

The one thing that has worked for me is Keto.. I feel great doing it, but it's really hard for me as I don't like meat. I really enjoy an apple once in awhile. I could go vegetarian but beans (major source of protein) are super high in carbs!!

Carb cycling? I don't know. Experiences?

Replies

  • kommodevaran
    kommodevaran Posts: 17,890 Member
    Why don't you just eat what you like, but less (provided you want to lose weight)? Oh, and lose the impatience right away. This is going to take a long time (the rest of your life).
  • besdais
    besdais Posts: 76 Member
    I agree with the other responses you got. I have "dieted" for 40 years, and finally took off (and kept off) 50 pounds. I asked myself, what can I do to get healthy that I can do for the rest of my life? It all comes down to calories in, calories out. I still fix the same food my family and I like, but I have tweaked our favorite recipes to make them healthier and less caloric. I also eat less. I no longer prepare the really fatty things, and I allow myself to eat out and eat what I want, just make sure it works in my daily calories. This is something we will have to do the rest of our lives, there is no "ending point." My mantra? Eat smarter, Eat healthier, Eat less, Move more. It's not rocket science.
  • beaglady
    beaglady Posts: 1,362 Member
    The eat the foods you enjoy at a calorie deficit program works best. Making things overly complicated, restrictive and stressful doesn't work for you based on what you've provided above. Also you need some patience - I doubt you put on the weight in a week, you're not going to lose it in a week.

    Exactly this. Not restricting foods due to some made up 'diet' is why I've been successful this time, and feel confidant that I'll be able to continue losing slowly til I hit my goal. In the past, I've tried multiple variations of Atkins and low carb, always failed and gained the weight back because I couldn't permanently give up foods I enjoy.

    I used to think that counting calories was overly complicated, but it's not difficult, and I like being able to fit in enjoyable foods and adult beverages while staying at a deficit. No 'program'. Just deciding before I eat or drink something whether or not it helps meet my nutritional goals and if I can fit it in with my allowed calories.
  • sdolan91
    sdolan91 Posts: 250 Member
    Like everyone else said. I would try a calorie deficit for more than a week - try 2 months. See what happens. Maybe then start messing with other stuff, like carb intake?
  • MegaMooseEsq
    MegaMooseEsq Posts: 3,118 Member
    The best diet is the one you can stick with. That means figuring out what foods you like to eat, what foods fill you up, how often you need to eat to stay full, and how many calories you need to stay under to lose weight. Diet programs will give you shortcuts to get to a calorie deficit, but do nothing to help you figure out a sustainable way to eat less, which you will need to do to maintain weight loss. Only you can figure that out, and you need to be patient. Good luck!
  • PaulaWallaDingDong
    PaulaWallaDingDong Posts: 4,643 Member
    edited September 2017
    I agree. Break the cycle now. You can try specific diets if you want. They all have the potential to work for (virtually) all people. But it's best to log calories regardless so you can see how the numbers work out. If you aren't successful, you can turn to the numbers rather than the diet itself. Really, though, you can eat however and whatever you like, within the calories (and obviously you want good nutrition).
  • rickiimarieee
    rickiimarieee Posts: 2,212 Member
    I have tried the different types of dieting and I never stuck to it mainly because it wasn't what I wanted or liked. I've had great weight loss eating whatever I like just eating less of it! Switching out unhealthy things in my recipes for things that are healthier. Like French fries I switch out for green peppers. I still make French fries for the family but I have enough willpower not to devour the unhealthy things.
  • rickiimarieee
    rickiimarieee Posts: 2,212 Member
    Remember, WEIGH WEIGH WEIGH your food! You can easily overeat!
  • GemstoneofHeart
    GemstoneofHeart Posts: 865 Member
    I eat exactly the same things I ate before and have lost 45 pounds. Literally the only change is I recently started drinking diet root beer (I used to not drink soda at all) because I can drink one instead of my usual sweet treat like a candy bar and cut more calories there. I do still get a candy bar and eat other things I like almost daily, just less than I did when I gained 90 pounds.

    I eat the same things as my husband and son but I tend to share my meal with my son (he's 2) so I eat about 70% of the meal and he eats the rest plus maybe a few bites from dad. 2 meals feeds all three of us, we like what we eat, I eat in a deficit, and we save money because I'm not eating a full portion.

    Don't overthink it! All you have to do is start slowly reducing the things you already know and love. Skip the low-carb, keto, etc for now and work on identifying the types of foods that keep you full the longest. Eat those as a priority and fill in the rest of your calories with foods you enjoy and are well-balanced. Hope this helps
  • Machka9
    Machka9 Posts: 25,641 Member
    How about just simply eating fewer calories than you burn?
  • mheagan
    mheagan Posts: 8 Member
    Machka9 wrote: »
    How about just simply eating fewer calories than you burn?

    Before kids..... Absolutely possible. Right now, I am doing my best but being the primary caregiver and dealing with some injurys is holding back my exercise portion. According to my fitbit burn (not 100% accurate I understand) and my tracking I AM!!
  • mheagan
    mheagan Posts: 8 Member
    The eat the foods you enjoy at a calorie deficit program works best. Making things overly complicated, restrictive and stressful doesn't work for you based on what you've provided above. Also you need some patience - I doubt you put on the weight in a week, you're not going to lose it in a week.

    Oh, I know it's not coming off in a week.... I mean ANY progress... Even .2 lbs would be encouraging.
  • estherdragonbat
    estherdragonbat Posts: 5,283 Member
    You can lose weight without exercise. It's a little more challenging (I like the extra calories and I find it helps a lot with mood, which in my case means I'm usually feeling more positive overall, which makes me feel motivated to keep going during the inevitable setbacks), but it's definitely doable.

    Your body is burning calories every day, just by existing.
  • Ready2Rock206
    Ready2Rock206 Posts: 9,487 Member
    edited September 2017
    mheagan wrote: »
    Machka9 wrote: »
    How about just simply eating fewer calories than you burn?

    Before kids..... Absolutely possible. Right now, I am doing my best but being the primary caregiver and dealing with some injurys is holding back my exercise portion. According to my fitbit burn (not 100% accurate I understand) and my tracking I AM!!

    You burn calories just being alive - you don't need extra exercise. Your fitbit should be showing that. You've gotten good advice here - doesn't sound like you are ready to hear it yet - but any quick fix you try is unlikely to be successful.
  • mheagan
    mheagan Posts: 8 Member
    I appreciate the kick in the pants! I think it may help for me to come visit the boards regularly as some sort of accountability, I've been trying to swing it on my own and that isn't helping. I have such little contact with adults these days I can't really 'lean' on anyone in my own life.
  • mheagan
    mheagan Posts: 8 Member
    You can lose weight without exercise. It's a little more challenging (I like the extra calories and I find it helps a lot with mood, which in my case means I'm usually feeling more positive overall, which makes me feel motivated to keep going during the inevitable setbacks), but it's definitely doable.

    Your body is burning calories every day, just by existing.

    Yes! and maybe that's part of my slump. When I exercise I feel better about EVERYTHING and make better choices. I've been a bit on the blue side because of not being able to move like I want.
  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    Never had any kind of eating plan. I just eat a balanced and varied diet consisting of a lot of whole foods and good nutrition and sometimes some not so good nutrition...
  • bribucks
    bribucks Posts: 431 Member
    Eat at a calorie deficit, log accurately, and stay consistent.

    Since you have health problems, there's no sense limited yourself with fad diets. Just because it works for one person, doesn't mean it will work for you, and there is no reason you need to make it more difficult by forcing yourself.

    All you need is a calorie deficit.
  • 2Luverly
    2Luverly Posts: 143 Member
    I'm 44 (*sigh* - but feel stronger and look better everyday!) and have PCOS too. I find that keeping carbs on the "lower" end "better" for me. Anywhere between 50-100 grams.. sometimes even over 100 grams per day. (Menstrual cycle has become regular over the last 9 months! Wowzers!) I started out doing Keto but didn't feel I could commit to it for the rest of my life. I wasn't going to continue to make separate meals for my family nor did I believe I should keep my family away from things they enjoyed to eat. I stopped "Keto" at about the 5 month mark and introduced some carbs back in. (Like, some beans!!) In my opinion... Eat various foods that you enjoy but make sure you weigh everything and eat at your caloric deficit to lose weight. Stick to it. It takes time and a commitment to yourself. YOU CAN do it. Exercise if and when you can to give yourself extra calories that you can partially eat back and provide your body with the healthy benefits of working out/exercising. You certainly don't HAVE TO exercise to lose weight so long as you eat at a deficit but there are a lot of excellent reasons to incorporate exercise into your life. Best of luck.
  • estherdragonbat
    estherdragonbat Posts: 5,283 Member
    mheagan wrote: »
    I appreciate the kick in the pants! I think it may help for me to come visit the boards regularly as some sort of accountability, I've been trying to swing it on my own and that isn't helping. I have such little contact with adults these days I can't really 'lean' on anyone in my own life.

    These boards are a godsend. People in my life are supportive, but obviously, I don't want to be 'that annoying person' who talks about her fantastic weight-loss experience and all the stuff she's doing. I told a couple of friends initially, mostly because they invite me for meals often and I thought that a simple, "Please don't be offended if I'm not taking seconds this time out. I'm trying to cut back," would help. Now, I don't say anything unless people notice and then, unless they want advice, I just smile and thank them.

    Ultimately, you are your own best cheerleader. But that doesn't mean you don't get a thrill when someone else gives you a thumbs-up.
  • Tacklewasher
    Tacklewasher Posts: 7,122 Member
    Read through the stickies in this forum. They helped me a lot at the start. Find the sexy-pants one, it's good.
This discussion has been closed.