Breaking my very low calorie diet
Ririia
Posts: 10 Member
Hello, I started my very low calorie diet march this year, I used to eat between 600-900 calories a day and I've done that for the last 6 months and still am however I'm currently eating 900. I am acknowledging that this is a problem so I want to stop this unhealthy way. I went from a size 8 to a size 4, I'm 157.5 cm tall and 45.5 kg. So I've lost about 15 kg. I plan on increasing 100 calories a week, however I'm afraid my size would increase. How can I maintain my size while trying to increase my calorie intake?
Please, I wouldn't want anyone lecturing me about how bad my diet was. I understand that's why I want to break this 6 month habit and revert to a healthy lifestyle. Although I'm still cautious about my size going up. ):
Please, I wouldn't want anyone lecturing me about how bad my diet was. I understand that's why I want to break this 6 month habit and revert to a healthy lifestyle. Although I'm still cautious about my size going up. ):
2
Replies
-
To address your question: If your main concern is not gaining weight (as opposed to health/nutrition), I would probably do what you are thinking and increase calories by about 100/week until you determine your maintenance.
Most will probably tell you increase to 1200 immediately. I doubt you'll be able to escape the lectures.9 -
VLCD's are defined as 800 calories per day, or less. It can be an effective tool for certain people, in certain situations, and is usually monitored by a doctor. But even then, this is only recommended for a short time.
https://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/weight-management/very-low-calorie-diets
I suggest you visit a doctor to see what you should be doing.8 -
I would suggest also that you don't modify your diet for a weight swing of five pounds give or take. Five pounds can be water weight and are not a reflection of actual fat gained or lost. Use a weight trending app and adjust your diet just once a week based on your trend line.
Please do get your minimum protein a day in.6 -
You need to maintain your current weight. Put your stats into MFP, set for maintain, and see what it gives you for daily calories. Then eat that amount, with accurate food weighing. I agree with seeing a doctor and dietician to check for any deficiencies brought on by your past choices and get a food plan that is nutritionally sound. You will manage maintenance the same as anyone else: set a 5-lb range (100-105) and when you get to the top or bottom of that range, adjust your daily calories up or down by 100-200 cals. Your size will not go up by increasing your calories to maintenance. You will keep at your current size. Your size would go up only if you eat much higher than maintenance for many weeks.6
-
Well, but keep in mind this: You will gain water weight as you go into maintenance. Don't be surprised, and try not to feel like a failure. It sucks, but supposedly it's normal (according to my therapist and dietitian) as your body tries to find an equilibrium.
There's a lot of talk on these boards about how weight gain beyond a five pound range means that you're not logging right, or you're eating too much, or you're not burning what you think you are. But sometimes, the horrible awful reality is that bodies get really pissed off and start holding on to boatloads of water weight.4 -
No lectures Riria, just a gentle suggestion to visit your GP.
Your health physically and mentally needs to be addressed.
For each of us, this is not only a journey to weight loss, it's a journey to wellness.
Taking care of your health holistically is vital.
Your GP can give you sound medical advice, refer you to a dietitian who can help Reset your eating plan and Counsellor who can work with you and help you be the best and healthiest version of you.
Good luck10 -
To address your question: If your main concern is not gaining weight (as opposed to health/nutrition), I would probably do what you are thinking and increase calories by about 100/week until you determine your maintenance.
Most will probably tell you increase to 1200 immediately. I doubt you'll be able to escape the lectures.
I can't help but notice that you are simultaneously preemptively putting down the people who will "lecture" the OP to increase to 1200 immediately AND very carefully parsing your language to basically state that "if health and nutrition are less important to you than potentially gaining some weight" then I would increase by 100/week.
So congratulations on putting the OP's health at a lower priority level than potentially gaining weight when she is starting at an underweight BMI.
Furthermore, 1200 is not a balance point. For most people 1200 is a LOSING/DEFICIT position. Increasing one's eating to a caloric deficit position can hardly be called an aggressive move to halt weight loss for a person who is currently underweight.
As to the OP it is time you evaluate your own state of physical and mental health.
Eating at maintenance *should not* be such a BIG DEAL.
Gaining or losing 2-5lbs (1 to 2kg) should NOT be a "BIG DEAL", these kind of numbers fall within NATURAL VARIATION.
Just having more POOP in you from eating some extra food will increase your weight by a few grams.
Sodium, exercise, time of the month can all lead to 2+kg variations (actually 3+kg variations but I know that will sound excessive to you).
If you can't deal with this from a position of equanimity then you should seriously consider talking to someone who specialises in eating disorders.
A visit to a doctor and getting some lab tests re plasma electrolytes may not be a terrible idea. Especially if you've been eating sub 1000 Cal for a long period of time.15 -
See a doctor and/or dietician. It sounds very much like your eating is disordered and needs professional help.4
-
Hello, I started my very low calorie diet march this year, I used to eat between 600-900 calories a day and I've done that for the last 6 months and still am however I'm currently eating 900. I am acknowledging that this is a problem so I want to stop this unhealthy way. I went from a size 8 to a size 4, I'm 157.5 cm tall and 45.5 kg. So I've lost about 15 kg. I plan on increasing 100 calories a week, however I'm afraid my size would increase. How can I maintain my size while trying to increase my calorie intake?
Please, I wouldn't want anyone lecturing me about how bad my diet was. I understand that's why I want to break this 6 month habit and revert to a healthy lifestyle. Although I'm still cautious about my size going up. ):
What you need goes beyond what can be given here. As a community, most folks in here want others to be successful.
Your attempt to prevent lecture about how bad your diet was fortunately doesn't prevent the lectures about how bad your diet is. This looks more to me like a disguised plea for help we cannot give.
I'm no expert, but it sure looks like eating disorder style thinking to me. Your perspective on size and calories is not reality.
There are answers to your last question, but if you are truly worried about size at 900 calories per day, you need to increase your understanding of how this works. You need a bigger fix than recommendations on how to maintain size with a caloric intake increase.
See a professional please.10 -
I agree, you need to speak to someone - a doctor, ideally. My feeling is that you may gain a little bit initially as you body readjusts to eating a normal amount of food, but this pales in comparison to the fact that you must be suffering from malnutrition at the moment, as you simply can not get all the nutrients your body needs to thrive and survive at less than 1200 per day. Getting healthy physically and mentally should be your primary goal.3
-
Hi there, we are a similar size. From my calculations, your BMR is around 1150. This is how much "fuel" your body would need even if you literally laid in bed all day or were in a coma. Obviously you aren't in a coma, so you need more food than that to maintain your weight.
Even if you are sedentary, your TDEE (how many calories you burn in a normal day, excluding purposeful exercise) should be around 1382. If you have a job where you are on your feet (or are a student who walks around) it might be closer to 1584.
For minds' sake, I think your plan of 100cal per week is a good bet. I would recommend starting at that 1150 marker, since that is the amount your body literally "needs." And, good on you for recognizing that you needed to make a change and take control of your health. It can be hard, but it's worth it!
And to echo what others said, try not to stress about a few pounds (sorry, kgs?) one way or another. I can easily fluctuate 5 lbs from one day to the next, just based on sodium, mass of food, bowel movements, monthly cycle, etc. But that doesn't mean my actual size changed.
One thing that helps me is using a weight trend app - I use Happy Scale. It helps me not to stress over fluctuations because I can see that even if I'm up a lb from yesterday, my overall trend is consistent. This will be helpful for you in maintenance as well.
9 -
scarlett_k wrote: »See a doctor and/or dietician. It sounds very much like your eating is disordered and needs professional help.
+11 -
I ageee with the others about seeking professional help the lowest amount recommended for ladies is 1200 calories, and that's assuming you're not even working out, and completely sedentary.
Get help.1 -
This content has been removed.
-
People are being kinda silly... OP has already acknowledged their diet is poor. They know this. They are aware they are undereating.
If they seek help it should be just to check their body and make sure they're ok, and to recommend foods to balance nutrition.
Increasing 100 calories per week if you're at 900 is sound. You'd reach a good amount in a few weeks. Ignore the scale if it's a tool that pressures you because, yes, weight fluctuates. Pay attention more to how your clothes fit.7 -
People are being kinda silly... OP has already acknowledged their diet is poor. They know this. They are aware they are undereating.
If they seek help it should be just to check their body and make sure they're ok, and to recommend foods to balance nutrition.
Increasing 100 calories per week if you're at 900 is sound. You'd reach a good amount in a few weeks. Ignore the scale if it's a tool that pressures you because, yes, weight fluctuates. Pay attention more to how your clothes fit.
Look ma, I'm bleeding!
S'ok girlie. Put 1/10th of a bandaid on.
Next week put another 1/10.
In no time at all you will get to 100% bandaids and you will stop bleeding!10 -
People are being kinda silly... OP has already acknowledged their diet is poor. They know this. They are aware they are undereating.
Knowing and actively doing something about it to become healthy are two different things. Going "up" to 1200 calories and still eating at a deficit to maintain weight is not doing something about it.3 -
Here's the thing though... trying to jump from VLC to 1000...1100... even 1500 is an absurd expectation for someone who's experiencing anxiety about food, weight, calories, etc. And she's not going to die by adding in 100 as she's comfortable. To say it must be "all or nothing" only reinforces the anxiety and is more likely to lead to going back to a more restricted state.
To the OP:
I agree with what others said - get your protein and fat in, and go up in calories as you can. That's really more important than hitting some magical number. Kudos to you for reaching out.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions