Losing inches not weight
bgonzalez_2016
Posts: 24 Member
Hi guys maybe you can help me out with this question. I started MFP about 4 weeks ago and my daily calorie intake was 1265 a day with being slightly active, Now that I'm active my calorie intake went up to 1450 a day, my question is since I went up in calories I haven't lost weight but did lose inches, will I lose any more weight or just lose inches? I still want to lose weight but not cut my calorie intake since I'm working out 5 days a week now. Any suggestions would greatly help
0
Replies
-
weight is just a number! If you're losing inches you are good. Also muscle weighs more than fat but makes you leaner and healthier. Don't worry, you're doing just fine7
-
bgonzalez_2016 wrote: »Hi guys maybe you can help me out with this question. I started MFP about 4 weeks ago and my daily calorie intake was 1265 a day with being slightly active, Now that I'm active my calorie intake went up to 1450 a day, my question is since I went up in calories I haven't lost weight but did lose inches, will I lose any more weight or just lose inches? I still want to lose weight but not cut my calorie intake since I'm working out 5 days a week now. Any suggestions would greatly help
Can you clarify what you mean by now that I am active? Did you recently start a work out routine and are logging the exercise so you get more calories? Or has your recently daily activity changed where you are walking around more? How long has it been since you saw movement on the scale?
If you have recently started a new work out it is common to retain water. It can be frustrating because the scale doesn't move for a couple of weeks.0 -
You're retaining water. Weight loss should continue soon.0
-
That activity letting on MFP has nothing to do with your amount of exercise - which it sounds like you increased it because of working out more now.
MFP, unlike almost every other site out there - figures an eating goal based on your selected daily activity level with NO exercise being expected.
You are expected to honestly log the workouts when done, then you eat more on those days you do more.
Less on days you do less.
Life lesson regarding weight control there.
Honest means by time - was the aerobics program really 60 min long - or 5 min warmup much easier, 5 min cooldown, and 5 min stretching - so actually 45 min aerobics program. Or spinning class, or whatever.
If you eventually hit 6 mph on the treadmill, but total distance for an hour was 5 miles - you don't log 6 mph jogging.
Some workouts that have no intensity listed on them (like spinning, aerobics, ect) probably take 75% of suggested calorie burn, but others that are specific (4mph walking, 6mph jogging, bicycling 15mph) are better.
This will likely end up with less calories for the week - for weight loss.
But more on the days you want it to recover from a good workout.
Dittos to water weight for right now.
Hard to find a valid weigh in day too probably to avoid known water weight fluctuations.
Morning after rest day eating normal sodium levels, not sore from last workout.3 -
have you considered weighing yourself everyday, on the same scale, at the same time and seeing what that trend is? Yes, I sound like a broken record with that. And, take into account that your menstrual cycle will affect that....1
-
Why did your calorie intake increase? You probably gained weight and lost inches due to being more active... did you do weight training? You will only see drop in weight if you keep being active but eat in a calorie deficit,i.e. Keep your calorie intake at 1265 or if necessary adjust it. You can't lose weight if you eat 1265, workout and burn 500cal and add calories just to be at 1265 (1265-500=765+685=1450) In order to lose you need to eat in a deficit!5
-
gportman08 wrote: »Why did your calorie intake increase? You probably gained weight and lost inches due to being more active... did you do weight training? You will only see drop in weight if you keep being active but eat in a calorie deficit,i.e. Keep your calorie intake at 1265 or if necessary adjust it. You can't lose weight if you eat 1265, workout and burn 500cal and add calories just to be at 1265 (1265-500=765+685=1450) In order to lose you need to eat in a deficit!
You may not understand how MFP works from your math.
Because you absolutely would lose fat weight with your formula, if the 1265 is the already deficit eating level that MFP would set you at.
Because that 1265 was created as a deficit already to an estimated daily burn that is higher, but a daily burn with NO exercise expected, planned, or accounted for.
So if you really did 500 cal worth of exercise, and ate 500 more, you'd still be at a deficit to daily burn.
If daily activity really did increase, then base activity eating level should increase.
And if workouts being done on top of that higher activity level - yes you could eat more on workout days and still have a deficit.
Many people get confused on MFP initially because every other site out there does NOT use their method - they include planned/hoped for exercise in their eating level goal with deficit.
And while MFP can be used that way - huge assumption that is what is being discussed without asking first or it being stated.6 -
At first MFP put me at 1265 cal because I was not working out. Once I started working out my calorie intake increased to 1450. I work out 5 days a week for about 1 hour . 30 minutes cardio and 30 to 45 minutes weight lifting1
-
bgonzalez_2016 wrote: »At first MFP put me at 1265 cal because I was not working out. Once I started working out my calorie intake increased to 1450. I work out 5 days a week for about 1 hour . 30 minutes cardio and 30 to 45 minutes weight lifting
It has been a few weeks. Is the scale still not moving? What is your weight and height? How are you measuring your food intake - are you weighing your food or using measuring cups?0 -
I think everybody's body responds different to exercise/diet. You mentioned you started about four weeks ago at 1265 which puts you in a big caloric deficit. The first 5-10 lbs are usually easy to come off. Now that you added weight training you may lose lbs much slower but your waist line will feel/see a big difference. Keep up the good work, it sounds like you're ok the right track. Just don't put yourself in such a deficit where you don't have energy to go about your day. Feel free to add me as a friend, would love to track your progress.2
-
Screw weight!! I'm heavier than most of my friends but carry a smaller waistline. think of body building like body-shaping. you want to sculpt your desired physique. the weight on the scale is just a byproduct.1
-
hi, i am also in the same boat. I lost inches all around the body but the scale is not budging. frustrating. I am doing 2 miles leslie sansone walk and JM 30 day shred. so 54 minutes daily. why scale is not moving? pls suggest.0
-
neerajanarayan1967 wrote: »hi, i am also in the same boat. I lost inches all around the body but the scale is not budging. frustrating. I am doing 2 miles leslie sansone walk and JM 30 day shred. so 54 minutes daily. why scale is not moving? pls suggest.
Probably should start your own thread - and include a whole lot more useful info for anyone to give an informative response.
You give no stats, no daily life activity level comment, 54 min daily of what exactly, both those workouts daily with no breaks, no eating level, no amount to lose, no weight loss selected comment, ect.
These are all needed pieces of info for useful comments, or else you'll just get a bunch of comments that no one would have a clue if they really applied to you, and you could spend years trying different ideas which really don't matter.
Include all those comments in another topic you start - but it sounds like not put under Gaining Weight and body building since you said wanting to lose weight.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions