One month of Intermittent Fasting complete
Replies
-
Hey everyone thanks for the nice comments. In no way am I tying to provide misinformation. Thanks for all the requests, I look forward to following success with the rests of you
Congratulations on your loss and thanks for sharing your information. Pay no attention to the nay sayers. I think they are just a bit jealous in the success and freedom we have found.
I followed IF and broke a plateau as I was eating 1200cal/day, very closely weighing and logging every bite that went into my mouth. I switched to IF 5:2 (eat 5 days, fast 2). On the fast days I ate only 500 calories. I drank black coffee and water, some unsweetened tea. I restricted my eating to my dinner meal. On non fast days I ate up to 2000 calories. SOOOOO - that totals 11,000 calories/week which averages 1,571 calories/day. I ran 3-4 days per week totaling about 15-20 miles. No strength training. I broke my plateau and within 2 months had lost 20 lbs - from 155 to 125. When eating 1200 cal/day that totaled 8,400 calories/week. I didn't change the types of food I ate. Both ways I ate clean mostly, but occasionally ate takeout and processed - just kept it to a minimum. If you want me to explain the science of it, I cannot. I do know a MD who subscribes to this method who explained it to me and it made sense so I tried it . It worked for me.15 -
Hey everyone thanks for the nice comments. In no way am I tying to provide misinformation. Thanks for all the requests, I look forward to following success with the rests of you
Congratulations on your loss and thanks for sharing your information. Pay no attention to the nay sayers. I think they are just a bit jealous in the success and freedom we have found.
I followed IF and broke a plateau as I was eating 1200cal/day, very closely weighing and logging every bite that went into my mouth. I switched to IF 5:2 (eat 5 days, fast 2). On the fast days I ate only 500 calories. I drank black coffee and water, some unsweetened tea. I restricted my eating to my dinner meal. On non fast days I ate up to 2000 calories. SOOOOO - that totals 11,000 calories/week which averages 1,571 calories/day. I ran 3-4 days per week totaling about 15-20 miles. No strength training. I broke my plateau and within 2 months had lost 20 lbs - from 155 to 125. When eating 1200 cal/day that totaled 8,400 calories/week. I didn't change the types of food I ate. Both ways I ate clean mostly, but occasionally ate takeout and processed - just kept it to a minimum. If you want me to explain the science of it, I cannot. I do know a MD who subscribes to this method who explained it to me and it made sense so I tried it . It worked for me.
Similarly it appears to be working for me. On about 1200 cal a day (8400 a week - never more than 9000 a week) & careful measuring and logging it took me about 4 months to lose 10 lb. I started 5:2 intermittent fasting, 2 days at 500 and 5 days around 1550 (still hitting 8400 to 9000 a week). Started Oct 4 and have dropped 6 pounds. Same calories but my body is responding VERY differently. And, I feel fantastic! No longer hangry and deprived all the time. And so free!
So, I personally do still count calories for now. But changing to 5:2 made my weight loss rate triple. No changes in CICO. I fully admit this is very early into 5:2 eating, but dang! (YAY).
So from my perspective- If there is no reason NOT to try IF (like health concerns, eating disorder history etc) then it is a good thing to try. Because it sure is good for SOME people.17 -
Hi I’m following the blood sugar diet and using the 16:8 method, I’ve lost 21lb in the last six weeks and a lot of inches! Finally found something that works and feel amazing to be honest! Well done fellow IF7
-
livingleanlivingclean wrote: »StephanieDL1 wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »I've been tracking my macros, I eat high protein, low carb unless it's a day I am lifting. Some days I'll be in a deficit because of work getting in the way of my eating schedule. I do my cardio in a fasted state, anything from hiking, hiit, and cycling.
Your macro breakdown is irrelevant for fat loss (although going lower carb would result in initial fluid loss, and lighter weight), just as whether you train fasted or not is irrelevant.
The number of days youve been in a deficit, and the size of the deficit, has clearly been significant enough for you to drop 14lbs in a month. If you're disputing this, perhaps present yourself to the closest university for studying.
I'm just sharing my results my friend, I'm a simple person. Their is no reason for me to lie in regards to what I'm doing. You have a nice night.
You are a simple person, who is claiming to function completely differently to the rest of the population - if people could lose weight without being in a deficit, how did we end up with so many over-fat people?
You sound like you're very upset my body building friend. I eat healthy, exercise regularly, and I'm very young. I think some of those factors can be incorporated.
The only thing I'm upset at is that your aren't publicising how to lose 14lbs a month without being in a calorie deficit. This is something the world needs to know - share it, and you'd make squillions of dollars.
I am doing intermittent fasting ... I said it at the begging of my post. No need for the unwanted sarcasm. If you don't like what I wrote, then simply go elsewhere to share your words of wisdom.
I also do IF. It's not magical. If you do IF but eat too many calories, you'll still maintain or gain depending on how much you're eating. You don't lose weight unless you're in a deficit - something you seem to be disputing.
Have a nice night my body building friend... I'm going to go starve myself, then eat, and then throw up...
Again, please share how you don't eat in a deficit and manage to lose weight. The world needs to be enlightened, seriously. (you don't want to be a squillionaire as well as helping millions of people?)
I would seriously love to eat more food without consequence!
Let it go. Leave him alone, seriously. He gave you an answer, why are you still badgering him? If he isn’t giving you the answer you want move on...
Because telling people you lost weight just by following IF without being in a calorie deficit is completely misinforming people. That's not how it works.
If the OP has actually achieved this, I honestly want to know how. I'm sure that many other people would too - I would love the opportunity to eat more food but achieve my weight loss goals at the same time.
Maybe his metabolism is going faster than he realizes and if he isn't aware of it he will think it's all because of the IF. Maybe the metabolism is burning more than his records account for. It doesn't seem very likely, but that's about the best I could come up with.1 -
I think so, no sugar, bread, pasta and potato, full fat fresh cooked food1
-
KirbySmith46 wrote: »
What the heck is “woo”? .
Right, "woo" definition, here ya go.
woo
n.(or adj), Look it up if you can't draw the meaning from context on your own.
Shirley believes that in a past life she was the Jolly Green Giant of Rainbowland. Shirley is very woo.
3 -
I've always wondered about the working out at the end of the fasting period... that's so awesome that you do it. I've always tried but find that 95% of the time I have no energy and am so excited to eat so skip the workout
I need to get over that hump. I really do think that is key, awesome job! 1 -
Here is a link to a recent study that was done at the University of Ottawa Heart Institute.
https://www.ottawaheart.ca/media-release/and-fasting-helps-fight-obesity
2 -
livingleanlivingclean wrote: »I've been tracking my macros, I eat high protein, low carb unless it's a day I am lifting. Some days I'll be in a deficit because of work getting in the way of my eating schedule. I do my cardio in a fasted state, anything from hiking, hiit, and cycling.
Your macro breakdown is irrelevant for fat loss (although going lower carb would result in initial fluid loss, and lighter weight), just as whether you train fasted or not is irrelevant.
The number of days youve been in a deficit, and the size of the deficit, has clearly been significant enough for you to drop 14lbs in a month. If you're disputing this, perhaps present yourself to the closest university for studying.
Working out fasted is relevant. You have to use fat to produce glucose and keytones while fasted and expending energy which is far more inefficient that producing glucose say from eating glucose or carbs. That makes no sense at all.
No it's not relevant. Someone like the OP will have c. 2000 cals of glycogen stored in his liver and muscles. No gluconeogenesis or ketosis required.
All the daily time restriction IF is doing is moving the periods of eating / losing around the day - it's not changing the total energy balance.
Fasted exercise is an irrelevance for weight loss apart from adherence and performance (which is very personal).
Well done OP, remarkable change in a short time.1 -
wendyandgilles wrote: »Here is a link to a recent study that was done at the University of Ottawa Heart Institute.
https://www.ottawaheart.ca/media-release/and-fasting-helps-fight-obesity
Thanks for the article I see this as a permanent lifestyle change on a personal level. 2 -
hughjazz74 wrote: »I've always wondered about the working out at the end of the fasting period... that's so awesome that you do it. I've always tried but find that 95% of the time I have no energy and am so excited to eat so skip the workout I need to get over that hump. I really do think that is key, awesome job!
I find that I have enough energy to hike, do hiit training but when it comes to lifting I perform at an optimal level post a nice tasty meal
Take it one step at a time, and listen to your body. Best of luck to you!1 -
Hello, I wondered what your height is? I am the same weight as your original and my ‘ideal’ bmi is 168lbs. It seems low to me but I’d like to have a go.1
-
Palmeralex wrote: »Hello, I wondered what your height is? I am the same weight as your original and my ‘ideal’ bmi is 168lbs. It seems low to me but I’d like to have a go.
My original weight was at 182 lbs, I weighed in this a.m at 166.4 lbs. I am 5 ft, 8 inches, not sure what my body fat percentage is to be honest.1 -
Great work! This is something that I really need to experiment with...have done some reading on it. Glad to see/hear when someone has proven success with something. Keep it pushin!!!!1
-
Thehardmakesitworthit wrote: »Great work! This is something that I really need to experiment with...have done some reading on it. Glad to see/hear when someone has proven success with something. Keep it pushin!!!!
Yes, I love it! It was an adjustment since I love my early morning breakfast, but I feel a lot better a month into it. You can do anything you set your mind to2 -
How do you determine how many days on and off ratio? I have lost 80 lbs just by cutting out fast food and eating right but since July I have been stuck here. I would like to get another 20 lbs off.1
-
How do you determine how many days on and off ratio? I have lost 80 lbs just by cutting out fast food and eating right but since July I have been stuck her. I would like to get another 20 lbs off.
If you have not lost weight since July, you are eating at maintenance calories and either need to tighten up your logging or reduce your calorie intake to get you into a calorie deficit.2 -
[/quote]
The only thing I'm upset at is that your aren't publicising how to lose 14lbs a month without being in a calorie deficit. This is something the world needs to know - share it, and you'd make squillions of dollars. [/quote]
How manyy 0's in a squilloin? It sonds like a pretty large number -
1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000.000,000? - Eastcoast Jim
2 -
How do you determine how many days on and off ratio? I have lost 80 lbs just by cutting out fast food and eating right but since July I have been stuck here. I would like to get another 20 lbs off.
I do it daily, for my personal schedule I eat from 11-7 pm with about 1900 cals, sometimes more/less depending if I worked out or I'm working.0 -
IF is really flexible. The MD who taught me about it said you can do however many days you want at fasting - he suggested I start with 2 days a week fasting. When I got to goal weight I moved down to 1 day a week fasting. When I gained a few pounds I moved up to 3 days a week fasting. I found that I had to assure I got in adequate calories on non fast days or I would really struggle on fasting days. in other words, on non fast days eat. Eat healthy but eat! Don't go nuts, but I made sure I always ate 1600-2000 calories on non fast days.How do you determine how many days on and off ratio? I have lost 80 lbs just by cutting out fast food and eating right but since July I have been stuck here. I would like to get another 20 lbs off.3 -
IF is really flexible. The MD who taught me about it said you can do however many days you want at fasting - he suggested I start with 2 days a week fasting. When I got to goal weight I moved down to 1 day a week fasting. When I gained a few pounds I moved up to 3 days a week fasting. I found that I had to assure I got in adequate calories on non fast days or I would really struggle on fasting days. in other words, on non fast days eat. Eat healthy but eat! Don't go nuts, but I made sure I always ate 1600-2000 calories on non fast days.How do you determine how many days on and off ratio? I have lost 80 lbs just by cutting out fast food and eating right but since July I have been stuck here. I would like to get another 20 lbs off.
Thank you! That is what I was wondering.1 -
livingleanlivingclean wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »I've been tracking my macros, I eat high protein, low carb unless it's a day I am lifting. Some days I'll be in a deficit because of work getting in the way of my eating schedule. I do my cardio in a fasted state, anything from hiking, hiit, and cycling.
Your macro breakdown is irrelevant for fat loss (although going lower carb would result in initial fluid loss, and lighter weight), just as whether you train fasted or not is irrelevant.
The number of days youve been in a deficit, and the size of the deficit, has clearly been significant enough for you to drop 14lbs in a month. If you're disputing this, perhaps present yourself to the closest university for studying.
I'm just sharing my results my friend, I'm a simple person. Their is no reason for me to lie in regards to what I'm doing. You have a nice night.
You are a simple person, who is claiming to function completely differently to the rest of the population - if people could lose weight without being in a deficit, how did we end up with so many over-fat people?
You sound like you're very upset my body building friend. I eat healthy, exercise regularly, and I'm very young. I think some of those factors can be incorporated.
The only thing I'm upset at is that your aren't publicising how to lose 14lbs a month without being in a calorie deficit. This is something the world needs to know - share it, and you'd make squillions of dollars.
I am doing intermittent fasting ... I said it at the begging of my post. No need for the unwanted sarcasm. If you don't like what I wrote, then simply go elsewhere to share your words of wisdom.
I also do IF. It's not magical. If you do IF but eat too many calories, you'll still maintain or gain depending on how much you're eating. You don't lose weight unless you're in a deficit - something you seem to be disputing.
Have a nice night my body building friend... I'm going to go starve myself, then eat, and then throw up...
Again, please share how you don't eat in a deficit and manage to lose weight. The world needs to be enlightened, seriously. (you don't want to be a squillionaire as well as helping millions of people?)
I would seriously love to eat more food without consequence!
Some things just cannot be explained,i have a 22yr old brother that i live with who eats the same meals as me plus tonnes of other crap,i have seen him eat 2 breakfasts then chips,candy,lunch,more chips and candy,dinner then half a large pizza and he drives everywhere and does not workout and he weighs 148 lbs and most of it is muscle.2 -
Dear Posters,
This is a friendly reminder to make sure your posts follow the MFP guidelines which prohibit attacking other members, name calling, and hijacking (taking off topic) others posters threads. If you need to refresh yourself on the guidelines they can be found here:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/welcome/guidelines
Furthermore, unless you are a forum moderator please do not try to moderate discussions. If you feel something is inappropriate please report it so the moderators can address the issue. Hijacking a thread to call out a post you do not like is still hijacking, and you will be warned for it. If you are unsure of how to report a post please find instruction here:
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10007789/flagged-content-reported-posts-warning-points#latest
Thanks for your cooperation,
4legs
MFP moderator5 -
Im an IFer too! I love it! Congrats on the progress! I have been slipping up the last two weeks and need to get back on it. I love working out fasted. I didn't lose weight because I was already at my goal, but I noticed with IF my body fat percentage went down.2
-
That's so awesome! I am almost at my goal weight but I hope I can drop more fat percentage as well. I feel like this is a lifestyle change for meellenmarielifts wrote: »Im an IFer too! I love it! Congrats on the progress! I have been slipping up the last two weeks and need to get back on it. I love working out fasted. I didn't lose weight because I was already at my goal, but I noticed with IF my body fat percentage went down. great job! Jump back in!
1 -
livingleanlivingclean wrote: »I've been tracking my macros, I eat high protein, low carb unless it's a day I am lifting. Some days I'll be in a deficit because of work getting in the way of my eating schedule. I do my cardio in a fasted state, anything from hiking, hiit, and cycling.
Your macro breakdown is irrelevant for fat loss (although going lower carb would result in initial fluid loss, and lighter weight), just as whether you train fasted or not is irrelevant.
The number of days youve been in a deficit, and the size of the deficit, has clearly been significant enough for you to drop 14lbs in a month. If you're disputing this, perhaps present yourself to the closest university for studying.
Working out fasted is relevant. You have to use fat to produce glucose and keytones while fasted and expending energy which is far more inefficient that producing glucose say from eating glucose or carbs. That makes no sense at all.
No it's not relevant. Someone like the OP will have c. 2000 cals of glycogen stored in his liver and muscles. No gluconeogenesis or ketosis required.
All the daily time restriction IF is doing is moving the periods of eating / losing around the day - it's not changing the total energy balance.
Fasted exercise is an irrelevance for weight loss apart from adherence and performance (which is very personal).
Well done OP, remarkable change in a short time.
It is relevant see:
https://melanieavalon.com/science-intermittent-fasting
glycogen in the muscles isn't shared with the rest of the body. The liver will perform gluconeogensis to keep up with glucose demands.
0 -
Why do you think the liver would be depleted of its glycogen stores on a 16:8 schedule?livingleanlivingclean wrote: »I've been tracking my macros, I eat high protein, low carb unless it's a day I am lifting. Some days I'll be in a deficit because of work getting in the way of my eating schedule. I do my cardio in a fasted state, anything from hiking, hiit, and cycling.
Your macro breakdown is irrelevant for fat loss (although going lower carb would result in initial fluid loss, and lighter weight), just as whether you train fasted or not is irrelevant.
The number of days youve been in a deficit, and the size of the deficit, has clearly been significant enough for you to drop 14lbs in a month. If you're disputing this, perhaps present yourself to the closest university for studying.
Working out fasted is relevant. You have to use fat to produce glucose and keytones while fasted and expending energy which is far more inefficient that producing glucose say from eating glucose or carbs. That makes no sense at all.
No it's not relevant. Someone like the OP will have c. 2000 cals of glycogen stored in his liver and muscles. No gluconeogenesis or ketosis required.
All the daily time restriction IF is doing is moving the periods of eating / losing around the day - it's not changing the total energy balance.
Fasted exercise is an irrelevance for weight loss apart from adherence and performance (which is very personal).
Well done OP, remarkable change in a short time.
It is relevant see:
https://melanieavalon.com/science-intermittent-fasting
glycogen in the muscles isn't shared with the rest of the body. The liver will perform gluconeogensis to keep up with glucose demands.
There is a huge difference in GNG in prolonged fasting and short term fasting.
0 -
Why do you think the liver would be depleted of its glycogen stores on a 16:8 schedule?livingleanlivingclean wrote: »I've been tracking my macros, I eat high protein, low carb unless it's a day I am lifting. Some days I'll be in a deficit because of work getting in the way of my eating schedule. I do my cardio in a fasted state, anything from hiking, hiit, and cycling.
Your macro breakdown is irrelevant for fat loss (although going lower carb would result in initial fluid loss, and lighter weight), just as whether you train fasted or not is irrelevant.
The number of days youve been in a deficit, and the size of the deficit, has clearly been significant enough for you to drop 14lbs in a month. If you're disputing this, perhaps present yourself to the closest university for studying.
Working out fasted is relevant. You have to use fat to produce glucose and keytones while fasted and expending energy which is far more inefficient that producing glucose say from eating glucose or carbs. That makes no sense at all.
No it's not relevant. Someone like the OP will have c. 2000 cals of glycogen stored in his liver and muscles. No gluconeogenesis or ketosis required.
All the daily time restriction IF is doing is moving the periods of eating / losing around the day - it's not changing the total energy balance.
Fasted exercise is an irrelevance for weight loss apart from adherence and performance (which is very personal).
Well done OP, remarkable change in a short time.
It is relevant see:
https://melanieavalon.com/science-intermittent-fasting
glycogen in the muscles isn't shared with the rest of the body. The liver will perform gluconeogensis to keep up with glucose demands.
There is a huge difference in GNG in prolonged fasting and short term fasting.
I guess I should have been more clear. I do a 20:4 IF schedule and the liver does has some depletion on that schedule, especially if you are eating at a deficit and are carrying over some deficit from the day before. The liver is going to start doing gluconeogensis with any deficit, the more the deficit, the more it is going to do.1 -
I lost 64 pounds by doing low carb the entire time and OMAD half the time...I didn't count calories either...Great job isay808 5
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions
Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!