General Weight Loss, Low Carb, and/or Primal Paleo Tips
samb
Posts: 464 Member
Interested in going low carb &/or paleo/primal?
This is my experience. Everyone is different so don’t hold me to any of this as “fact” or that it is best for everyone. I have just done a lot of research, spoken with many many people who have had awesome results from this and altered my life and this is what seems to work for me and what my opinions are on it all. I truly wish I had known all of this my whole life, but you live and you learn and I wanted to spread the word in case it is something that changes your life as it has for me! If you are losing as is, then keep doing what you are doing! But if you are looking for a boost, it is worth a try. I was a vegetarian for about 4 years and at first I did lose weight and maintained it fairly well. But over time I was adding more and more carbs and didn’t realize it was a bad thing since I only really focused on calories. I started working out like crazy most days and was not losing really any fat or weight. I got beyond frustrated and did not understand what I was doing wrong. I finally became fed up from feeling bloated, lethargic, working extremely hard, and not seeing ANY results at all. After researching a lot and asking people what worked for them, etc, I decided to first go primal/paleo, then low carb. I already had a healthy diet, but it was high carb, low fat & pretty low protein. I started by cutting out grains completely, including corn, then began eating meat again (shockingly!!-truly felt this could change all of my frustrations though) and worked my net carbs down to 100g, then 75g, then 50g, now 35g which is where I will stay on my regular days until I get to my goal, which is only a few pounds away now. I eat mostly meat & veggies and some cheese (which is not in the paleo diet), with occasional fruit and potatoes. On my free days I eat literally whatever I want – though this is far different from when I started all of this! So here are some random tips/ideas/things that I do that you may want to consider:
This is what I do: 6 days on, 1 day off (Saturday): Usually only eat from 11am-7pm or so on the on days. About 1200 cals, >100g protein, and <35g net carbs. On my free day I consume about 2000 calories and about 150 net carbs, sometimes even more (though I don’t really gain much because my body is a fat burning machine still during that day!). When I crave something during my on days I usually tell myself I can handle waiting the couple days til the free day.
--6 days on, 1 day off --- or you could do it differently. Atkins doesn’t have days off. Research is varied so nothing is fact. I just worry that my body’s metabolism, etc will be changed if I am constantly low carb. But I also feel that maybe having more days on before the free day could help in the case of ketosis (see below). I also notice the day off helps to spike my weight loss significantly. I only gain about a pound and lose that within a day, but my weight goes significantly lower following that. Without the day off I seem to lose much much slower. One important thing is to make sure you don’t have more than 1 free day back to back. I have done this, and that is when significant weight gain can kick in – I have gained up to 5 lbs in just 2 days, but usually only 1 lb when its 1 day at a time).
--Net carbs are what is important, not total carbs really (which is carbs minus fiber basically).
---protein is very important not only for muscle recovery (I no longer get sore no matter how strenuous the workouts are!!) but also for fat burning and energy.
---lots of water is very important for fat loss among everything else for your body to function – please take my word for this, this is FACT and dehydration is nothing to mess around with. If you feel thirsty at all then you already are way too low on water.
---the big misconception: the idea is to find your maintenance level by starting low (to lose weight) and slowly work your way up – adding about 5g net carbs per week until you stop losing – then you know where to maintain --- so this is for life!
---work your way down to low carb, you don’t have to just jump right into it
---cutting grains while going low carb is the best bet (see http://www.marksdailyapple.com/why-grains-are-unhealthy/) – some disagree – but this has had a enormous impact on my life! I occasionally have them on my day off as I am now closer to my goals, but I still try to avoid them as much as possible as they make my body feel bloated and lethargic. I would much rather get the carbs from potatoes or a more natural source.
--paleo/primal is eating the way our long ago ancestors would have – meats, veggies, fruit, some nuts, etc – even if not followed strictly this helps significantly in the low carb diet as this and low carb help you to make better decisions by looking at what is in products & avoiding processed foods, etc.
--by eating paleo/primal & low carb, you likely do not even need to focus at all on calories. I notice it is hard to get in enough cals as I feel full, but not bloated, and I rarely ever go over, and when I do it does not seem to matter.
-ketosis – when your liver’s glycogen stores (from carbs) are depleted so your body resorts to burning fat stores as a source of energy: (Wikipedia: If the diet is changed from a highly glycemic diet to a diet that does not provide sufficient carbohydrate to replenish glycogen stores, the body goes through a set of stages to enter ketosis. During the initial stages of this process, blood glucose levels are maintained through gluconeogenesis, and the adult brain does not burn ketones; however, the brain makes immediate use of ketones for lipid synthesis in the brain. After about 48 hours of this process, the brain starts burning ketones in order to more directly use the energy from the fat stores that are being depended upon, and to reserve the glucose only for its absolute needs, thus avoiding the depletion of the body's protein store in the muscles.)
Some resources that helped me along the way:
The Atkins diet --- even though I did not follow this it helped to teach me the main ideas of low carb
PRIMAL LIFESTYLE:
** http://infographic.paleolithicdiet.com/
marksdailyapple.com
http://everydaypaleo.com/
http://paleodietlifestyle.com/
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/246360-low-carb-primal-grain-free-sources
http://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/
http://arthurdevany.com/
http://freetheanimal.com/
http://drbganimalpharm.blogspot.com/
http://www.archevore.com/panu-weblog/?currentPage=2
http://robbwolf.com/
http://paleohacks.com/#axzz1QndiZAoN
RECIPES:
http://paleopot.com/ & just search low carb recipes on google – there are tons of sites
This is my experience. Everyone is different so don’t hold me to any of this as “fact” or that it is best for everyone. I have just done a lot of research, spoken with many many people who have had awesome results from this and altered my life and this is what seems to work for me and what my opinions are on it all. I truly wish I had known all of this my whole life, but you live and you learn and I wanted to spread the word in case it is something that changes your life as it has for me! If you are losing as is, then keep doing what you are doing! But if you are looking for a boost, it is worth a try. I was a vegetarian for about 4 years and at first I did lose weight and maintained it fairly well. But over time I was adding more and more carbs and didn’t realize it was a bad thing since I only really focused on calories. I started working out like crazy most days and was not losing really any fat or weight. I got beyond frustrated and did not understand what I was doing wrong. I finally became fed up from feeling bloated, lethargic, working extremely hard, and not seeing ANY results at all. After researching a lot and asking people what worked for them, etc, I decided to first go primal/paleo, then low carb. I already had a healthy diet, but it was high carb, low fat & pretty low protein. I started by cutting out grains completely, including corn, then began eating meat again (shockingly!!-truly felt this could change all of my frustrations though) and worked my net carbs down to 100g, then 75g, then 50g, now 35g which is where I will stay on my regular days until I get to my goal, which is only a few pounds away now. I eat mostly meat & veggies and some cheese (which is not in the paleo diet), with occasional fruit and potatoes. On my free days I eat literally whatever I want – though this is far different from when I started all of this! So here are some random tips/ideas/things that I do that you may want to consider:
This is what I do: 6 days on, 1 day off (Saturday): Usually only eat from 11am-7pm or so on the on days. About 1200 cals, >100g protein, and <35g net carbs. On my free day I consume about 2000 calories and about 150 net carbs, sometimes even more (though I don’t really gain much because my body is a fat burning machine still during that day!). When I crave something during my on days I usually tell myself I can handle waiting the couple days til the free day.
--6 days on, 1 day off --- or you could do it differently. Atkins doesn’t have days off. Research is varied so nothing is fact. I just worry that my body’s metabolism, etc will be changed if I am constantly low carb. But I also feel that maybe having more days on before the free day could help in the case of ketosis (see below). I also notice the day off helps to spike my weight loss significantly. I only gain about a pound and lose that within a day, but my weight goes significantly lower following that. Without the day off I seem to lose much much slower. One important thing is to make sure you don’t have more than 1 free day back to back. I have done this, and that is when significant weight gain can kick in – I have gained up to 5 lbs in just 2 days, but usually only 1 lb when its 1 day at a time).
--Net carbs are what is important, not total carbs really (which is carbs minus fiber basically).
---protein is very important not only for muscle recovery (I no longer get sore no matter how strenuous the workouts are!!) but also for fat burning and energy.
---lots of water is very important for fat loss among everything else for your body to function – please take my word for this, this is FACT and dehydration is nothing to mess around with. If you feel thirsty at all then you already are way too low on water.
---the big misconception: the idea is to find your maintenance level by starting low (to lose weight) and slowly work your way up – adding about 5g net carbs per week until you stop losing – then you know where to maintain --- so this is for life!
---work your way down to low carb, you don’t have to just jump right into it
---cutting grains while going low carb is the best bet (see http://www.marksdailyapple.com/why-grains-are-unhealthy/) – some disagree – but this has had a enormous impact on my life! I occasionally have them on my day off as I am now closer to my goals, but I still try to avoid them as much as possible as they make my body feel bloated and lethargic. I would much rather get the carbs from potatoes or a more natural source.
--paleo/primal is eating the way our long ago ancestors would have – meats, veggies, fruit, some nuts, etc – even if not followed strictly this helps significantly in the low carb diet as this and low carb help you to make better decisions by looking at what is in products & avoiding processed foods, etc.
--by eating paleo/primal & low carb, you likely do not even need to focus at all on calories. I notice it is hard to get in enough cals as I feel full, but not bloated, and I rarely ever go over, and when I do it does not seem to matter.
-ketosis – when your liver’s glycogen stores (from carbs) are depleted so your body resorts to burning fat stores as a source of energy: (Wikipedia: If the diet is changed from a highly glycemic diet to a diet that does not provide sufficient carbohydrate to replenish glycogen stores, the body goes through a set of stages to enter ketosis. During the initial stages of this process, blood glucose levels are maintained through gluconeogenesis, and the adult brain does not burn ketones; however, the brain makes immediate use of ketones for lipid synthesis in the brain. After about 48 hours of this process, the brain starts burning ketones in order to more directly use the energy from the fat stores that are being depended upon, and to reserve the glucose only for its absolute needs, thus avoiding the depletion of the body's protein store in the muscles.)
Some resources that helped me along the way:
The Atkins diet --- even though I did not follow this it helped to teach me the main ideas of low carb
PRIMAL LIFESTYLE:
** http://infographic.paleolithicdiet.com/
marksdailyapple.com
http://everydaypaleo.com/
http://paleodietlifestyle.com/
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/246360-low-carb-primal-grain-free-sources
http://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/
http://arthurdevany.com/
http://freetheanimal.com/
http://drbganimalpharm.blogspot.com/
http://www.archevore.com/panu-weblog/?currentPage=2
http://robbwolf.com/
http://paleohacks.com/#axzz1QndiZAoN
RECIPES:
http://paleopot.com/ & just search low carb recipes on google – there are tons of sites
0
Replies
-
Thanks for sharing. Interesting info.0
-
bump for later thanks babe0
-
bump0
-
Bump0
-
:flowerforyou: Very interesting - thank you.
I am what I call a semi-vegetarian because I don't like the taste or texture of most meats. So what would you recommend for non card proteins without too much meat?
Sars0 -
bump0
-
*subscribing
I'm currently doing my own version (as in drinking one or two low-carb slim fast shakes everyday, which most people doing a stricter low-carb WOE wouldn't approve of, which is fine. It's working for me and it's sometimes difficult for me to eat solid foods first thing in the morning) of low-carb.. keeping it under 20 net carbs a day, but also around 1500 calories (give or take a few hundred.. I'm not too worried about my calorie intake, but have been trying a calorie cycling type deal). I'm also working on increasing my fat intake, by adding more nuts and the like to my daily diet.0 -
Careful.. lots of carb lovers here on the forum.
I do pretty much the same thing, but I do my carb ups every 2 weeks, and I save what little carbs I do take in per day an hour or so before my workouts.
I tried doing the low fat/low calorie thing for years while training (weights/muay thai). I had results but it was a lot of work, and I was always hungry. Now I don't need to workout near as hard as I did, I don't have to give up eating the foods I like, and I'm satisfied when I eat.0 -
bump...thank you0
-
Thanks for keeping me focused Sam!!!!0
-
Thanks for posting this info.0
-
Careful.. lots of carb lovers here on the forum.
I do pretty much the same thing, but I do my carb ups every 2 weeks, and I save what little carbs I do take in per day an hour or so before my workouts.
I tried doing the low fat/low calorie thing for years while training (weights/muay thai). I had results but it was a lot of work, and I was always hungry. Now I don't need to workout near as hard as I did, I don't have to give up eating the foods I like, and I'm satisfied when I eat.
That's awesome! And I completely agree! Haha I know everyone has their own opinions and what works for some doesn't always work for everyone. I am not bashing anyone or any ideas here (not even grains because I know some people are fine with them, but I apparently am not for some reason, though I never even knew it til I cut them out then realized the effect they had on me this whole time!). Like I said, its just my true experience. Just wanted to share because it took me my whole life to find out this is what worked for ME I hope to help others to at least find what works for them!0 -
I tried to dukan diet but this looks great and it would be nice to have 1 cheat day. I'll check it out for later.0
-
But carbs are so much fun!0
-
:flowerforyou: Very interesting - thank you.
I am what I call a semi-vegetarian because I don't like the taste or texture of most meats. So what would you recommend for non card proteins without too much meat?
Sars
Being a full vegetarian I found it is VERY difficult to have below 75g carbs with high protein, only because the majority of protein sources are equivalent with the amount of carbs. For example, nuts have the same carbs as protein. Same with many veggies, if not more carbs. Fruit has quite a bit of carbs. And yogurt has more carbs than protein. As a lacto-ovo vegetarian I added in a lot of eggs and cheese before I decided it was way too difficult to get to the level I wanted to be at without eating meat. I know some can do it, which is awesome, but it wasn't working for me. And meat really really reallllly grossed me out to be honest, it was a huge step to do this, but it was truly worth it. I still try to stay mostly vegetarian though, but as time has gone on I have been adding more and more meat to my diet. And I am actually happy about it! :O
*keep in mind going low carb should coincide with eating healthy - avoiding processed foods... there are a lot of manufacturers out there that say low carb on their products - yes this may help, but you should be trying to avoid processed foods if you are truly committed to weight loss
Here are all of my suggestions off the top of my head for low carb foods (vegetarian and non-vegetarian):
Zero or very little carbs:
eggs
poultry
fish
beef
pork (though most pork does have some carbs)
vegetables
oils
Low-Moderate Carbs:
nuts
peanut butter
La Tortilla Factory low carb whole wheat tortillas (I do use these for wraps and they don't have the effect bread/pasta has on me)
Moderate Carbs:
some fruits (mainly berries)
potatoes
legumes (beans, etc)
High Carbs:
grains
most highly processed foods/junk foods
some fruits (bananas, etc)
*atkins is a really good source to compare foods and to see where they stand as far as carbs go0 -
I tried to dukan diet but this looks great and it would be nice to have 1 cheat day. I'll check it out for later.
I have heard of people trying out the dukan diet, the only thing I don't like about it is that you are not allowed to even have veggies in the beginning. I suppose that means your carbs would be super low and cause rapid weight loss, but I like to go with a healthier more sustainable approach. I didn't cut anything besides grains totally out. And I try to consume lots of veggies along with the meat, and still allow the free day for other things. Veggies are good for your metabolism and provide you with fiber (so they are extremely low carb) unless you are adding stuff onto them. That is just my opinion though, and whatever works for you is great! I just am trying to be as healthy and practical as possible as well as losing weight. I don't like being overly strict as I have tried to do in the past because I find that it just does not work for me. I obsess over things I shouldn't be and let myself down too much. Doing this has been more rewarding than anything and I find it is pretty easy to follow. It may not always be perfect, there are days I reach 50g net (mainly when I consume potatoes), but if I am eating natural foods and do my best to stay as low as possible I feel that is really what counts. And going to 50 still does not cause me to gain weight at all, so I know my tolerance is above that. I just shoot for less than 35 for quicker fat loss. You can only do your best. And I truly believe if you are always doing your best then there is no reason for regret, etc.0 -
But carbs are so much fun!
hahaha thats what i thought too....but now i actually cringe at the thought of eating high carbs cuz of how it makes me feel....literally i feel like a blimp!! when i am eating low carb it doesnt matter how much food i eat as far as calories or volume, i always feel thin and my body doesnt feel swollen, and i also have the next day to look forward to seeing a weight loss! IMO the weight loss and appearance results as well as the energy, etc greatly outweighs eating the carbs! :P0 -
Saving. Been spending a lot of time reading up on the information at Marks Daily Apple and definitely coming to the conclusion going primal might be the best option for my health.0
-
I think Paleo style + Anabolic Diet could be interesting.0
-
bumpy0
-
Thanks for all those resources!
I tried to go Paleo 3 weeks ago and I did really well for 10 days then I went on vacation. Everything you said was 100% true! I stopped counting calories but I lost 2.5 lbs in the first week. I had WAY more energy than with carbs. It's a great way of life. I actually started at it today again! I've only had 2 egg muffins I made with tons of veggies, sausage, eggs; 2 peaches; a can of tuna and black coffee..that's it and I'm feeling good!0 -
Thanks for the post, it's always interesting and helpful to hear about other people's experiences. And thanks for posting the low carb websites!0
-
bumpity bump bump0
-
Bumpity bumpity bumpity all down the lane...0
-
Nice work, samb.
I've been Paleo/Primal since January. I do this along with intermittent fasting. For the most part I stayed in ketosis but have recently started carb cycling, <50g's on non-powerlifting days and around 100g's on heavy powerlifting days. All of these carbs come from either vegetables,a sweet potato or the rare piece of fruit/berries.
In doing this, I've dropped about 50 lbs (weigh in/bodyfat measurements on Saturday), 8 jean sizes and 16% bodyfat since late January. I'm at the lowest weight I've been since leaving for college football two-a-days 25 years ago.
Completely LOVE this way of eating in that I no longer have urges/cravings for sugars or sweets and believe me, I was like a shark tasting blood when I'd take the first bite of a piece of milk chocolate in the past.0 -
Hi Samb,
I'll add my low carb/Primal testimony I suffer from PCOS (I had an ovary removed in December 2008 due to a 15 pound cyst!!!!), Insulin Resistance, and with each child I carried (5 of them) I had Gestational Diabetes. The GD diet that I was put on meant I had to eat almost 200 g of carbohydrates a day, and take insulin injections. I tried to eat low fat to compensate for the calories and try to control my weight, but with each baby I was not losing the fat afterwards. Low calorie diets just left me starving and cranky all the time. I would have some weight loss...then nothing.
I joined MFP in May to start tracking my latest attempt at a 1200 calorie diet, and I saw a thread about Paleo and a link to the documentary Fat Head on Hulu. Watching that documentary changed my life, and I then decided to try to learn all I could about low carb eating, but without eating a bunch of bars and other "non-foods". I read the Paleo Diet by Robb Wolf and The Primal Blueprint by Mark Sisson. I started doing strict Paleo, and found that a low carb Primal-ish approach made more sense and worked better for ME. I also do Primal Essentials workouts twice a week, and walk, cycle, or sprint the other days of the week. I really started on my journey mid May of this year. Since then I have gone from 48% body fat to 33% - I have lost 50 pounds of FAT, and 35 pounds of scale weight. That means I have gained muscle, and other non-fat mass. I keep my carbs well under 50g per day, my fat around 100g per day, and about 100-140g of protein a day on average. I try to eat as clean as I can, but I am not perfect by any means and that's okay. I am never hungry even when I spontaneously fast or skip a meal. My skin is glowing, my mood is even, and I am experiencing regular non-painful TOM"s for the first time in my life. I still have about another 50 pounds of fat to lose to get to my body composition goal, but for the first time in my life, I honestly believe I will get there this time.
I actually get angry sometimes when I think about what I have been missing out on. I am losing weight like crazy without having to deprive myself of good tasting foods. I don't have to count calories either. I just count the carbs and make sure I get enough protein, and I don't care at all how much fat I eat, as long as I am not hungry. I live in a constant state of ketosis, and I burn body fat for fuel all of the time now. It feels great!! Thanks so much for sharing your story, I hope mine helps someone as well.0 -
Awesome info!0
-
...... I was like a shark tasting blood when I'd take the first bite of a piece of milk chocolate in the past.
^THIS is exactly why I want to work my way into Paleo. It finally hit me that sugar is the most addicting drug I've ever tried - And I've been addicted to it my entire life.0 -
Thanks for all of the info, I have PCOS and find that a low carb high protein diet works best for me too. I'm struggling to get back to it since going to Cuba, the sugar is killing me. I have to be tough for about a week until I get over it and I'll be fine, It's just getting there that's the issue! Reading this and the links will help me with ideas to cut down the carbs. Thanks again :bigsmile:0
-
Bumping for later and thank you for the info.
I've been trying to eat primal for the past 2 months now and I was actually surprised at how easily I've managed to stay away from bread, pasta, cookies:) etc which I used to LOVE and crave! The only thing that i need to overcome to be truly Primal is dairy (i love cottage cheese, quark and low fat greek yoghurt:( and fruit... However I've managed to stay under 90grams of carbs for the past few weeks:) and it feels great:)
Thank you for your post as it definitely helps:)0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions