Which is the best diet for overall health and weight loss?
Replies
-
I have several autoimmune diseases, and they are all genetic. Not one of them came from having anything resembling a "leaky gut". I've never seen any credible science supporting evidence that there is such a thing.
A healthy gut biome can be had by eating resistant fiber and fermented foods.
If you want a healthful diet, eat vegetables, lean proteins, whole grains, fruits, legumes, tubers and healthy sources of fat. BTW, low fat dairy isn't any more processed than regular dairy. Eat it, it's just fine. I eat plenty of it myself. As a vegetarian, it's my primary source of protein.5 -
A diet that helps manage your weight and gets/keeps you healthy.1
-
I do follow the Slimming World eating plan, but not exclusively. I listen to my body. If I want junk, I eat junk until my body says ENOUGH. If i want a HUGE bowl of fruit, i eat fruit. This is what makes sense for me. When I want to be active, I am. When I don't want to be active, I try to make myself do SOME moving. I don't do extreme ANYTHING, because I just don't want to.1
-
The lab test tested lactulose levels in urine. it was called an intestinal permeability test. Before this, a nutrition biochemist named Van Beveren pricked my blood from my finger and looked at it under a microscope and saw food particles in my bloodstream. He said I had leaky gut. If I didn't have digestive holes, then how did the food get there?
L-glutamine and bone broth and collagen are known to repair the intestinal wall gut lining. In fact, after the program, i was free of leaky gut. Meaning the test came out normal.
The test was done by Genova Diagnostics.
I'm not saying everyone should believe in this. I'm just saying that functional medicine doctors usually describe leaky gut as a condition. The Institute of Functional Medicine would agree. It's perfectly fine for me if you disagree though.
Are you surprised that food acts as medicine in so many ways? It really does.
Genova Diagnostics is on Quackwatch.7 -
If your goal is something else other than weight loss then you may need a specific diet, but as far as weight loss goes there is no “best” diet. Any diet that helps you to maintain a calorie deficit will work, no matter what food that diet consists of.
And no, eating fat does not make you fat.0 -
The goverment healthy plate diet is good if you use sourdough bread or sprouted bread, and sprouted grains. The paleo diet is so high in good fats that it may not let you lose body fat. Is fat fat whether good or bad? I don't know. In terms of losing weight I mean. Low fat dairy and low fat diets may cause inflammation of the organs, causing acne and diseases. Because low fat products are all too processed. This is just my experience, what's yours?
Thinking aloud, I need to start the best diet that will eliminate all possible disease. i just went through the healing leaky gut elimination diet with dr. axe and i didn't finish it properly. Then i went to a nutritionist who has a healthy plate diet, low fat dairy, and lots of carbs. I can't figure out which one will help me mainly maintain healthy gut and still lose weight. I think it's the paleo diet.
1. Fat does not make you fat. Excess calories from any source make you fat.
2. Leaky gut is not a medical diagnosis. Increased intestinal permeability does present in certain autoimmune conditions. See a real doctor.
3. The Healthy Plate is a good place to start. Sourdough bread, sprouted bread, sprouted grains are not a necessity. Any whole grain source of carbohydrates will do, and many that do not need extra fiber do just fine with regular old white bread. If you are looking for the beneficial microbes found in fermented foods, they are not present after bread has been baked. Far better sources include yogurt, kimchi, sauerkraut, or pickles, if they have not been heat treated (canned).
4. Of the many blood samples I have looked at, none showed food particles. Food particles would have to be HUGE to be seen with a microscope. This is not a real thing.
5. As mentioned above, tests run by Genova Diagnostics are included in Quackwatch. "Most of the laboratories listed below cater to practitioners who engage in nonstandard practices. All of these labs perform one or more nonstandard tests. Most also perform various standard tests. When evaluating practitioners, we would regard routine use of any of these laboratories as an unfavorable sign."4 -
singingflutelady wrote: »Leaky gut is not a thing....
Whenever I hear/see "leaky gut" all I can picture is the hilarious reviews for Haribo Sugar Free gummy bears or Alli.5 -
There is only one diet that has been proven to reverse heart disease, and it happens to be low fat with no processed food, AND helps you maintain a healthy gut flora. You need to check into a whole foods, plant based diet, such as what is recommended by Dr. Dean Ornish or Dr. Caldwell Esselstyn.Because low fat products are all too processed. This is just my experience, what's yours?
I can't figure out which one will help me mainly maintain healthy gut and still lose weight.
11 -
there is no one size fits all answer.
Most important, it must be an eating plan that is sustainable. Wiggle room for treats now and then.
For my cholesterol and triglyceride numbers, low carb high fat is best. That dropped my triglycerides from over 300 down to 45.2 -
If guts were truly leaking, sepsis would get you within days. Bleeding ulcers, ditto. I know someone on the leaky gut protocol, self-diagnosed of course. They're using it mostly as a cover or mask for an eating disorder. Nothing has improved in over 4 years. Still leaking and squeaking as they walk down the street.3
-
there is no one size fits all answer.
Most important, it must be an eating plan that is sustainable. Wiggle room for treats now and then.
For my cholesterol and triglyceride numbers, low carb high fat is best. That dropped my triglycerides from over 300 down to 45.
And my triglycerides dropped from 402 to 73 just from weight loss (as far as I can tell). Certainly, I was and am eating reasonably balanced macros, neither low carb nor high fat.
As you observe, everyone is indeed different in the details.
3 -
there is no one size fits all answer.
Most important, it must be an eating plan that is sustainable. Wiggle room for treats now and then.
For my cholesterol and triglyceride numbers, low carb high fat is best. That dropped my triglycerides from over 300 down to 45.
And my triglycerides dropped from 402 to 73 just from weight loss (as far as I can tell). Certainly, I was and am eating reasonably balanced macros, neither low carb nor high fat.
As you observe, everyone is indeed different in the details.
Similar story here. Didn't change diet at all. Just reduced body fat and improved fitness.1 -
there is no one size fits all answer.
Most important, it must be an eating plan that is sustainable. Wiggle room for treats now and then.
For my cholesterol and triglyceride numbers, low carb high fat is best. That dropped my triglycerides from over 300 down to 45.
And my triglycerides dropped from 402 to 73 just from weight loss (as far as I can tell). Certainly, I was and am eating reasonably balanced macros, neither low carb nor high fat.
As you observe, everyone is indeed different in the details.
[/quo
Similar story here. Didn't change diet at all. Just reduced body fat and improved fitness.
I didn't even improve fitness!
(I've been pretty active for a long time, including have been so for quite a while when my tris & chol remained very high.)
I did probably increase my daily veggie/fruit servings from something around the recommended 5 most days, to a currently pretty ridiculous level (10-15 much of the time). Could make a difference, dunno. It's the only change I can really pin down, other than weight loss and related lower intake.1 -
I think that a Whole Foods Plant-Based “diet” is one of the most effective because it lends itself to more sustainable habits. Portion sizes are often larger and more filling due to the lower calorie foods and higher fiber intake. It’s also zero cholesterol. It has worked well for me thus far. It’s easier for WFBP to become a lifestyle more than a diet. Mindset and ability to sustain are everything!
(If WFBP is difficult at first- start with a vegetarian or with a regular plant-based diet and ease into it. Let your body adjust.)
As others have said, there is no one size fits all. Diets can be a lot of trial and error. Best of luck!5 -
I think that a Whole Foods Plant-Based “diet” is one of the most effective because it lends itself to more sustainable habits. Portion sizes are often larger and more filling due to the lower calorie foods and higher fiber intake. It’s also zero cholesterol. It has worked well for me thus far. It’s easier for WFBP to become a lifestyle more than a diet. Mindset and ability to sustain are everything!
(If WFBP is difficult at first- start with a vegetarian or with a regular plant-based diet and ease into it. Let your body adjust.)
As others have said, there is no one size fits all. Diets can be a lot of trial and error. Best of luck!
I'm currently transitioning to a mostly WFPB woe, and while I'm really enjoying it I have found that I still need to be careful of portion sizes-beans, whole grains, seeds and nuts (pistachios, I'm looking at you
), are pretty easy to eat a lot of, and the calories in these things add up quickly. Fruit is another thing I have to be mindful of because of how many calories some of them have.
I've found that my calorie intake is the same, or slightly higher, than the more SAD woe I was previously eating. I'm making corrections now, (measuring out portion sizes on my food scale, limiting myself to one serving of nuts a day etc), to get my calorie intake back down again.
4
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions