Butter or Margarine
Replies
-
I never understand why it's necessary to fear monger and demonize over what for most people is a condiment
I just read the label of the margarine I have in the fridge and there's nothing scary there. Including no transfat - that's been largely eliminated in recent years.
Unless you're buying butter from a local farm, butter and margarine are both a similar level of processed, not that that really matters for anything other than bragging rights.
And as a city girl, I think the act of milking a cow is pretty darn gross. My parents live next to a farm and being downwind from a bunch of cows can be pretty gross too.
I like butter for some uses and margarine for others. They have the same amount of calories and fat. It really doesn't matter which you use.8 -
The nice thing about the book titled "Eating Clean" is that when you lose power in the winter, burning it will provide enough heat to make a 'Smore. Do this outside to avoid indoor air pollution.
Can you pronounce the ingredients of Nutelex? Is it some kind of hazelnut derivative?
6 -
I know nothing about Nutelex. However, most margarines contain more water than butter and will affect how baked goods turn out. I would stick with butter for baking.3
-
I would think butter would be more “clean” than some sorta solidified oil concoction.5
-
Personally, butter, but I’d go by whichever you like.1
-
Butter. I'm not going to the trouble of making soda bread to befoul it with margarine.3
-
Thanks everyone. I'm definately going back to butter. I did start eating it because it was natural so I think I will stick with that and thanks to those who gave advice about that stupid book 😁2
-
delaclos99 wrote: »Butter. I'm not going to the trouble of making soda bread to befoul it with margarine.
How do you make Soda Bread, sounds yum.0 -
Good afternoon All. Question regarding butter or marg. I have used butter for years but due too a book I read "Eating Clean" it doesn't recommend butter. So I have switched to Nutelex for the moment. Have I done the right thing? Or is there another alternative? I dont eat much of it anyhow so should I just stick to butter?
no such thing technically
0 -
I would go ahead and eat butter if you like the taste. These substitutes are usually worse for your health.4
-
amusedmonkey wrote: »LiftHeavyThings27105 wrote: »Running_and_Coffee wrote: »Kerrygold butter is delicious.
Amen! +1 to that. I put that in my BulletProof Coffee! Love it!
So many votes for that. I was curious about it and bought it, but didn't feel it was special. It felt tasteless like the cheaper butters we have and it wasn't as smooth and creamy as what I'm used to. Maybe because I grew up eating Lurpak which has a unique flavor and feels like it has more butterfat.
See? PERFECT EXAMPLE of just how true the statement "We are all so very different" is.....I do not know what Lurpak is, but I am going to investigate (just because I am curious and like learning new things).0 -
LiftHeavyThings27105 wrote: »amusedmonkey wrote: »LiftHeavyThings27105 wrote: »Running_and_Coffee wrote: »Kerrygold butter is delicious.
Amen! +1 to that. I put that in my BulletProof Coffee! Love it!
So many votes for that. I was curious about it and bought it, but didn't feel it was special. It felt tasteless like the cheaper butters we have and it wasn't as smooth and creamy as what I'm used to. Maybe because I grew up eating Lurpak which has a unique flavor and feels like it has more butterfat.
See? PERFECT EXAMPLE of just how true the statement "We are all so very different" is.....I do not know what Lurpak is, but I am going to investigate (just because I am curious and like learning new things).
You might not like it because it's different, but that's what I grew up eating. It's made from cultured cream so the flavor is different and the texture is smoother, more velvety than greasy.
ETA: this is just a brand name, but what you should be looking for if you can't find it is "European style butter" or "cultured butter" to see what higher fat content and cultured cream do to the taste.
ETA2: We use cultured butter for eating, but for baking, we make sure it's also European style high fat.0 -
amusedmonkey wrote: »LiftHeavyThings27105 wrote: »amusedmonkey wrote: »LiftHeavyThings27105 wrote: »Running_and_Coffee wrote: »Kerrygold butter is delicious.
Amen! +1 to that. I put that in my BulletProof Coffee! Love it!
So many votes for that. I was curious about it and bought it, but didn't feel it was special. It felt tasteless like the cheaper butters we have and it wasn't as smooth and creamy as what I'm used to. Maybe because I grew up eating Lurpak which has a unique flavor and feels like it has more butterfat.
See? PERFECT EXAMPLE of just how true the statement "We are all so very different" is.....I do not know what Lurpak is, but I am going to investigate (just because I am curious and like learning new things).
You might not like it because it's different, but that's what I grew up eating. It's made from cultured cream so the flavor is different and the texture is smoother, more velvety than greasy.
ETA: this is just a brand name, but what you should be looking for if you can't find it is "European style butter" or "cultured butter" to see what higher fat content and cultured cream do to the taste.
I just might.....I lived in Germany for several years after I graduated from University. I ate a lot of "interesting" things...those things were all "gross" until I tried them. And, I do follow Keto (as mentioned).0 -
I prefer butter, but I'm actually cutting down on the amount I use anyway. It's way too calorie dense for me to have as much as I used to.
For some reason I tend to prefer margarine for baking. I couldn't tell you why, except that's what my mum did, and for years I thought that that was what marge was for.1 -
Real butter0
-
I’m not sure what Nutelux is. I’d say use whatever you want that works best with your plan.
I tend to like butter, and don’t use it much at all. I do like that it’s “all natural” and supposedly the body does better with things that are more “natural” in nature - but as my husband says, opium and marijuana is all natural too! LOL.
Use what works best for you.2 -
I use margarine.
Is cheaper, is more spreadable and tastes fine to me.
I don't use a lot - a standard size container lasts our household of 2 for couple of months and I am not trying to eat clean and I have no health issues so the nitty gritty of the ingredients list doesn't bother me.1 -
delaclos99 wrote: »Butter. I'm not going to the trouble of making soda bread to befoul it with margarine.
What is soda bread and how do I make it?0 -
delaclos99 wrote: »Butter. I'm not going to the trouble of making soda bread to befoul it with margarine.
What is soda bread and how do I make it?
It's just bread that uses baking soda instead of yeast (or something else) as a leavening agent0 -
You do you, whatever makes you happy.
I choose butter, that’s what makes me happy, it’s tasty, butter made from cows that eat grass is even more yummy. I usually pick up Kerrygold because it’s found everywhere and is more affordable. No the cows not 100 % grass fed, and the feed supplements have gmo’s - this is fine with me, I don’t believe gmo’s are evil.
Kerrygold makes me happy, it fits in my diet.
If Margarin makes you happy, do it.1 -
I also don’t use either; I prefer nuts!
I use the following to get:
Omega-9: extra virgin olive oil, avocado, or olives
Omega-6: nuts or nut butters
Omega-3: salmon & walnuts0 -
-
butter0
-
I use whatever fits the situation. If I'm baking, I use spreadable butter (is that similar to margerine?) because I'm too lazy to wait for butter to be soft enough to use.
If I'm having fresh crusty bread and butter, I will go out and spend £4 on Finest Sea Salt Butter. Because that ish is amazing.0 -
I switched to using coconut oil. Once it's hard you can spread it on toast/bagels and it's delicious.1
-
Grew up on margarine because it was cheaper. I'm so old that when I was a kid, the margarine came with a little packet of bright yellow food colouring that you mixed into it to make the margarine look more like butter instead of lard.
Once I actually tasted real butter, I never looked back.
2 -
I switched to using coconut oil. Once it's hard you can spread it on toast/bagels and it's delicious.
Interesting. The coconut oil I use has no coconut flavor or scent. and I use it to saute, as I would a canola oil.
To me, it would be like spreading Crisco on toast or a bagel. No thanks. I'll take the delicious flavor of butter every time.0 -
The only thing I use coconut oil for is to pop popcorn. Doesn't taste like coconut at all, but gives the popcorn a delicious almost nutty flavour.0
-
Butter, child...always butter.1
-
I switched to using coconut oil. Once it's hard you can spread it on toast/bagels and it's delicious.
I don't like it, personally. It's too oily and greasy for toast and only works in certain applications. I like to use butter when butter is best, oil where oil is best, and margarine where margarine is best.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions