Impossible to hit Protein without going over Fat
jenlameo
Posts: 5 Member
I know this is all difficult, but I find it impossible to hit my protein goals without going over fat. If I stay under my fat I usually don’t have enough fiber . I’ve been barely reaching my caloric requirement while troubleshooting all of this. I’m female , 5’5 125 lbs. Any suggestions?
0
Replies
-
If your goal is weight loss or gain, calories are most important, regardless of macros. Get that right first.
Your weight is already pretty low, what are your goals?
Macro goals are a rough guide, it's no big deal if you're a little over or under
Lean protein sources include canned tuna, lentils, tofu, low fat dairy, egg whites, protein powder, and white meat chicken.
For more fiber, try beans & lentils, whole grains like oats, berries, and other veggies and fruits.10 -
A couple questions - what is your fat goal? protein? & total calories ? OK 3 questions2
-
There are plenty of low fat protein sources.
Fat comes from fat, fibre comes from carbohydrates. If you're eating less fat, you can eat more carbohydrates and potentially more fibre.
If you're not eating enough calories, eat more food.
Are you using accurate database entries with all the nutritional information included?6 -
I just don't worry about it. I kind of view as a hierarchy.
1. Calories
2. Protein
3. Fats
4. Carbs
If I'm over on fats, I reduce carbs. As long as my calories and protein are in line and I'm getting enough fats, the rest I don't fuss with.
My question would be why you can't eat lower fat protein sources? Lean meat, protein powders, fish and shrimp, legumes, low fat or fat free Greek yogurt? All decent sources of protein with low fat content.13 -
I have this trouble too. One thing that helps is protein bars from Costco. They have almost a days worth of fiber plus 21-22g protein for under 200 calories a piece.2
-
I think of this starting with the calorie goal. Say you are shooting to eat 1100 kcals per day. At 125lbs, your minimum protein intake should be ~56g to 112 g per day. I don't like going too high on the protein when on a deficit because it just forces your body to metabolize it for fuel, which is inefficient and can affect performance. You can just go by how you feel.
Say you pick 60 g per day of protein. That will be 320 kcals, which is about 29%. The rest will come from carbs and fats. In my opinion, you can go heavy on the fats, such that up to 50% of your total calories come from fats, meaning that only 21% come from carbs. This is a good strategy if you don't do big cardio workouts.
You can get zero or low calorie fiber supplements, if you need them. I have found that just eating a serving of oatmeal plus an apple every day is enough for me.
If you do cardio (jogging, etc.), I think you should replace a high fraction of calories burned with carbs. This gives your body a good source of fuel for such workouts. It helps to keep a regular schedule, so you can eat more or less the same every day. It also helps to have a banana or something right before a hard cardio workout.7 -
Not all fats are bad in fact its important to function well and for body health
Probably u r eating red meat and eggs
Try chicken breats and light tuna those are good alternatives
Try peanut butter, nuts, avocado for healthy fats3 -
Greek yogurt, whey protein powder, liquid eggwhites. All low in fat & high in protein. I used to love bars, but too high in fat and processed.6
-
Jthanmyfitnesspal wrote: »I think of this starting with the calorie goal. Say you are shooting to eat 1100 kcals per day. At 125lbs, your minimum protein intake should be ~56g to 112 g per day. I don't like going too high on the protein when on a deficit because it just forces your body to metabolize it for fuel, which is inefficient and can affect performance. You can just go by how you feel.
Say you pick 60 g per day of protein. That will be 320 kcals, which is about 29%. The rest will come from carbs and fats. In my opinion, you can go heavy on the fats, such that up to 50% of your total calories come from fats, meaning that only 21% come from carbs. This is a good strategy if you don't do big cardio workouts.
You can get zero or low calorie fiber supplements, if you need them. I have found that just eating a serving of oatmeal plus an apple every day is enough for me.
If you do cardio (jogging, etc.), I think you should replace a high fraction of calories burned with carbs. This gives your body a good source of fuel for such workouts. It helps to keep a regular schedule, so you can eat more or less the same every day. It also helps to have a banana or something right before a hard cardio workout.
Your math is off. 60g of protein is 240 calories not 320. 80 grams would be 320.2 -
Thank you everyone! i just NOW saw these replies, ( new to the Community section of this app). I have been able to find some low fat protein options. I think a lot of trial and error is a huge part of it. Sometimes I go way over my fiber. Usually getting my fiber in is no problem. I thought lean turkey breast was a good idea until my sodium skyrocketed. I try for low sodium tuna, etc. I think what I’m finding most difficult now is to reach my calories once my macros are hit. I’m left with almost 800 calories sometimes . This is hard!! haha2
-
Thank you everyone! i just NOW saw these replies, ( new to the Community section of this app). I have been able to find some low fat protein options. I think a lot of trial and error is a huge part of it. Sometimes I go way over my fiber. Usually getting my fiber in is no problem. I thought lean turkey breast was a good idea until my sodium skyrocketed. I try for low sodium tuna, etc. I think what I’m finding most difficult now is to reach my calories once my macros are hit. I’m left with almost 800 calories sometimes . This is hard!! haha
You should be able to find low sodium turkey breast. Also, consider supplementing with whey. It is low carb and low fat. I add banana and sometimes peanut butter because sometimes i want more fats and I definitely want more carbs.1 -
What do you consider your macros? I know some people say "hit my macros" when referring to just protein or protein and fat.I think what I’m finding most difficult now is to reach my calories once my macros are hit. I’m left with almost 800 calories sometimes . This is hard!! haha
If you hit all of the macros (carbs, protein, and fat), your calories should be very close (within 100 or so calories) to your goal. If they are 800 calories off then you need to double-check the accuracy of the database entries you are using.4 -
protein powder or slimfast advanced nutrition (20 g protein) in almond milk.0
-
Beans! Quinoa! Lentils, split peas, tofu, tempeh, plant-based protein powders, edamame... Don’t add butter, oil, or cheese to anything. I’m vegan, and need to hit 140+ grams of protein per day, but my fat intake is around 20% of my calories. I never go over. And you’ll get tons of fiber that way. I usually get 50+ grams of fiber a day.0
-
I know this is all difficult, but I find it impossible to hit my protein goals without going over fat. If I stay under my fat I usually don’t have enough fiber . I’ve been barely reaching my caloric requirement while troubleshooting all of this. I’m female , 5’5 125 lbs. Any suggestions?
Not impossible. Might be impossible with the food choices you are making. I hit 160-200g of protein a day on a regular basis and stay under or around my usual fat goal without any real effort. Just choose leaner meats or higher quality foods. Learn to try new things, like ground turkey, or more chicken in your diet. I also drink a protein isolate shake with my breakfast every morning that gives me a huge boost in protein.2 -
I honestly don't worry about fat. I aim to get 100 grams of protein every day, the rest of the macros fall where ever they fall.5
-
Just choose sources of protein w/minimal fat content in it.
Chicken/turkey breast, pork loin and beef jerky are some natural food high protein/low fat choices.
However, whenever I'm low on protein, I just drink a bottle of a protein drink which contains 42g of protein with no fat and few carbs and/or eat a protein bar that has 20g protein and very little fat and few carbs.
Works to help me maintain my 1g/P/#BW/day goal.1 -
I have the opposite situation... I hit my fats less than half the time.
Here's from a weightlifting day (two days ago) when I intend to eat a few extra calories.
Here's from yesterday, a non-weightlifting day.
Maybe you just need to eat leaner meats. I'm all about boneless skinless chicken breast or tilapia... always grilled. I also use whey protein.
As far as the fiber goes, you can always supplement if you're not getting enough.2 -
Thanks everyone! A lot of helpful strategies!0
-
On hot summer days, I love eating enlightened or halo top ice cream.
Today it is 92 out and my apartment has no AC, so I will be chowing down on the cold brew coffee "ice cream" which is 240 calories, 6g of fat, 24g of of protein, 20 grams of fiber
I also make yogurt bowls for lunch with fage nonfat greek yogurt with pumpkin seeds and pumpkin spread, which is about 283 calories, with 5g of fat, 44g of protein, sovery low in fat, which is why I happily eat tablespoons of almond butter and/or peanut butter otherwise I would never come close to the recommended amount.1 -
Jthanmyfitnesspal wrote: »I think of this starting with the calorie goal. Say you are shooting to eat 1100 kcals per day. At 125lbs, your minimum protein intake should be ~56g to 112 g per day. I don't like going too high on the protein when on a deficit because it just forces your body to metabolize it for fuel, which is inefficient and can affect performance. You can just go by how you feel.
Say you pick 60 g per day of protein. That will be 320 kcals, which is about 29%. The rest will come from carbs and fats. In my opinion, you can go heavy on the fats, such that up to 50% of your total calories come from fats, meaning that only 21% come from carbs. This is a good strategy if you don't do big cardio workouts.
You can get zero or low calorie fiber supplements, if you need them. I have found that just eating a serving of oatmeal plus an apple every day is enough for me.
If you do cardio (jogging, etc.), I think you should replace a high fraction of calories burned with carbs. This gives your body a good source of fuel for such workouts. It helps to keep a regular schedule, so you can eat more or less the same every day. It also helps to have a banana or something right before a hard cardio workout.
Your math is off. 60g of protein is 240 calories not 320. 80 grams would be 320.
Also I hope you're not shooting for 1100 calories a day only.1 -
Thank you everyone! i just NOW saw these replies, ( new to the Community section of this app). I have been able to find some low fat protein options. I think a lot of trial and error is a huge part of it. Sometimes I go way over my fiber. Usually getting my fiber in is no problem. I thought lean turkey breast was a good idea until my sodium skyrocketed. I try for low sodium tuna, etc. I think what I’m finding most difficult now is to reach my calories once my macros are hit. I’m left with almost 800 calories sometimes . This is hard!! haha
If you hit all your macros, all your calories would be accounted for. So this is likely an issue of using incorrect database entries. Many (and I mean MANY) of them are incorrect and don't add up right.
1 g of protein is 4 calories.
1 g of carbs is 4 calories.
1 g of fat is 9 calories.
If your entries in your diary are correct, then all macros and calories will be accounted for if you perfectly hit your macros.1 -
Go to foods include many mentioned by other posters:
Tuna, lean chicken/turkey, lean ground beef/steak, fat free greek yogurt (some carbs aren't going to kill you), protein powder (rarely used nowadays)
Key is making them palatable with spices, seasonings, low kcal condiments (dijon mustard, salsa, artificial sweeteners (greek yogurt, also not going to kill you...). Hell I even use relatively low kcal marinara sauce (measure & do not overdo it).
Eating dry lean meat on a consistent basis is challenging to say the least (compliance can be problematic). Other issue is high protein foods generally cost more1 -
I know this is all difficult, but I find it impossible to hit my protein goals without going over fat. If I stay under my fat I usually don’t have enough fiber . I’ve been barely reaching my caloric requirement while troubleshooting all of this. I’m female , 5’5 125 lbs. Any suggestions?
Im shooting for 200g+ of protein at a deficient of 2100 calories and its quite easy staying under 50g of fat ? I would like to know what your calorie intakes are and macros could easily adjust it for you0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions