Comments people have made about your weight?
KatieNicole95
Posts: 133 Member
Being an overweight person, I have gotten comments, mostly from older family members or older members of my previous employment about being overweight. Anyone like to share some rude comments they have gotten about being overweight OR underweight?
I got one from a member of my previous employment, "You would be such a pretty girl if you just lost some weight. I just don't understand it."
Or family member, " I don't think she would have those big boobs if she lost some weight."
At the time these hurt my feelings but now I can laugh about them realizing other's comments should be irrelevant. People can be savage sometimes I swear lol.
I got one from a member of my previous employment, "You would be such a pretty girl if you just lost some weight. I just don't understand it."
Or family member, " I don't think she would have those big boobs if she lost some weight."
At the time these hurt my feelings but now I can laugh about them realizing other's comments should be irrelevant. People can be savage sometimes I swear lol.
5
Replies
-
I have never had any comment--ever at my heaviest or lightest. I'm 69---I'm so glad I don't have to put up with the nonsense that seems to follow the youngins now days.2
-
My most hated comment is "should you really be eating that?" Like bish I know what i'm eating, now stay in your lane.16
-
Had this yesterday from a client, "have you stopped running, as you put a bit of weight on"
My answer, yes 3 kids, both work full time = routine out the window.
Back on it this week though3 -
yes I have had rude comments. Family can hurt us the most but for others if they aren't someone important in my life their opinion means very little. Why let someone have that power over you?1
-
I had a complete stranger at my gym comment on my weight. He’s an older guy and I think he thought he was complimenting me. At the time of his comment I had lost about 40 lbs (pregnancy weight) over the course of a year. He said “wow you look great. I mean really. Your thighs before were huge! How much do you have left to lose, maybe 10-15? Keep it up”
Like wow. Didn’t emotionally bother me cuz don’t know this man from Adam, but I was shocked that people find it appropriate to comment on others bodies. It didn’t feel like a compliment to me lol7 -
I'm very underweight because of gastroparesis and can barely eat. I get comments like eat a cheeseburger (I would love to be able to), I look like a biafran, i'm anorexic, just eat more, you look horrible, you are just attention seeking.13
-
So I'm 155lbs and 5'7. My BMI is the top end of the healthy scale...24.3. Despite this when I was in a queue to buy some breakfast last year the woman behind me tapped me and said 'I hope you don't mind me saying but you really should try caffeine tablets to help with the weight'. I was pretty stunned so a blunt 'thanks for that' came out of my mouth and I turned back around to hear her say 'fine. Be chunky. Can't help some people'...
Attempted not to take it to heart, since I was stood with my particularly tiny best friend and (not out of bitterness) said woman looked a bit questionable (extremely thin, makeup all over the place and drinking a frozen coke at breakfast time) and was just a crappy person... but wow.13 -
Also with ya on the boob comments... people wouldn't comment on the size of a person's thighs, so not sure why everyone feels welcome to comment on boobs...4
-
This content has been removed.
-
I never had anyone say stuff to my face when I was almost 300lbs. When I was 155Lb everyone said anything and everything. It actually came to the point I felt like I was verbally abused4
-
Just out of the blue? No, I don't think anyone has commented on my weight. When I've said "no" to some treats, especially when I was much closer to my ideal weight, then yes, I did have people comment on "why not" and when I said I was working on losing 5 pounds, go off on a tirade about how I didn't need to lose any weight.
I've learned to keep my weight goals or plans to myself unless it really comes up in conversation or if I think someone would be as supportive of me as I would be of them (several of my coworkers fall into this category) - but again, I seldom initiate the conversation.
For reference, I'm 5' 7", at my heaviest I was around 163 ish (never got on a scale at that weight), currently around 152, and my goal is somewhere around 128-140 depending on my muscle mass as I get into that range.
I got the most negative comments when I was around 132 and would turn down extra-rich desserts or extra servings of high-calorie foods.2 -
I personally have never had it about my weight, but I have a young lady in my life that is very tall and thin. I have held her in my arms crying after being told by complete strangers that she should eat more burgers. This was said as she was ordering burgers at McDonald's on two separate occasions. I don't understand how people can be so rude to another human being.5
-
I had a Korean neighbor who had a wonderful garden. My yard is completely shaded so I cant grow that many veggies. Every time she saw me she said "you too fat, eat some vegetables..." then would walk over to her garden get a lot of fresh veggies and hand them to me "here, eat these you too fat." Why thank you..I am and free fresh veggies WOOT WOOT! I always knew in veggie growing season if she saw me I was getting a lot of free veggies LOL12
-
I've posted this before but it's worth mentioning again. I had gotten some new glasses and asked if they noticed anything new. They said "I dunno, you don't have a big plate of food in your face?"
I mean...I get that comments like that should motivate but instead it just made me eat more. That's where the extra 100 lbs after the first 100lbs I had gained came from.8 -
Never from strangers but my mom has said some pretty hurtful stuff. She once asked me if I was trying to figure out how big I could blow up...I think she forgets she was very overweight for my entire childhood. Once she lost weight she thought she was better than everyone else 🙄11
-
A few people have. The worst was from (now ex) friends and family members I really don't talk to anymore. Somehow the act of bettering yourself can bring out the worst in other people.8
-
A “body positive” therapist told me I looked like a flat-chested little boy. A fat activist friend (who I know had BED because we binged together more than once) told me I was triggering and she couldn’t be my friend anymore. I was told CPS would be called on me because I was too thin (and they were). I had some women follow me in a mall (middle aged women) and talk about, “Ewww. What size do you think she is? She looks disgusting” when I was about 25 pounds lighter than I am now. I was extremely depressed from a bad medication interaction and was at the mall so I wouldn’t self-harm. You never know what a person is going through (I’m off meds and mentally fine now- but I was a mess that day.)
I have been obese and underweight, and I honestly was never treated as poorly when I was bigger as I was when I was smaller. Even now- I’m actually an acceptable weight for my bone structure (I have 5 inch wrists- my frame is extremely small despite being 5’9”- so if I eat healthy and exercise, I’m going to be smaller), people always tell me to eat carbs. Like... I do. Constantly.14 -
I got the "You would be such a pretty girl if you just lost some weight" but I didn't really take it negatively. I simply took it to mean that the person who said it thinks I'm pretty, but they're not into the obese look. Not everyone is. That's a fact and I don't feel it's a personal attack directed at me, more like an ignorant attempt at motivating me to lose weight. That's really all I can remember outside of the rare actual mean comment from strangers (mostly teenagers who are peacocking for their friends, makes me smile).
I don't think it's helpful to ruminate, but I may be biased because I have an unusually thick skin for actual insults, let alone foot-in-mouth syndrome. I don't really perceive certain comments like some people may so I'm often not even aware of them. I just think most people aren't really trying to hurt other people for no reason.8 -
This content has been removed.
-
It's a sad commentary on our society when people think it is okay to comment on someone else's physical being. It was bad when my mother was alive, because she would continually comment on my weight. Even when I was a teen, and my measurements were 36-24-34 and I wore a size 8, she used to refer to me as "zofty". She was obsessed about weight. My middle sister is obsessed about weight and she is very fit. Sometimes if she and my other sister and I have lunch (she lives in another state), she eat something and then say she feels she feels like a "fat cow". Now my youngest sister and I are overweight, so I wonder how she thinks that makes both of us feel?5
-
I've mostly gotten comments about how I must be lazy or else I wouldn't weigh this much. One that really gets me is "good thing your fiance like them on the bigger side." *eye roll*4
-
I have a lean short build and I get comments like" eat something" or you're " skin and bones" all the time. I honestly believe a majority feel it's OK to make these comments to people who are at the other end of the spectrum. I don't appreciate them at all. Not so much hurt, more pissed off.6
-
Non-family members:
Back when I was slim "you could afford to put on some weight" - this was the only time someone has commented that I was possibly too slim, it was annoying at the time but I'm kind of flattered now.
After I gained a lot, and reached my heaviest "have you put on weight?" this did hurt at the time but I am glad she said it.
A woman I was seeing casually who saw my photo of me wearing a tight shirt "lumberjacck you have breasts!". She's Asian and many Asian cultures feel free to say such things.
Family members generally don't care but can say things that annoy me. They know me enough that I'll make a sarcastic reply so they'll generally not bother.3 -
I worked for homecare and a cliendlt if mine insisted I was quite pregnant. Nope. Not pregnant Just a food baby I guess.1
-
Ive lost 45 kilos. I personally find comments at this end of the scale to be more hurtful.
You look so beautiful...... now.
You are losing weight healthily ....right?
Are you sick? Youd tell me if you were sick right ??
Was it ........... surgery????
You train too much
You look too skinny
Give her a burger she can afford it
Just eat it skinny *kitten*
You know if you keep training the way you do you might need a hip replacement... WTF??!?
Nasty, comes in all shapes and sizes it seems. Try really hard to put peoples negativity in a box and in a bin where it belongs. I try everyday.
Much love and positivity your way beautiful xxx
7 -
Can't believe some of the things I'm reading here...wow. I'm so sorry for everyone who has had their feelings hurt by eejits who I can almost guarantee were far from body perfect themselves....
Before I lost weight I never really had any comments. Now I get them all the time & for the most part, they are lovely, pure & come from an adorable place.
One that "got" me though was a casual work acquaintance who said she was happy that I was "still me & hadn't become stuck up like some who lose a lot of weight". Weird...but okie coke. She then went on to say she couldn't believe how much I was shrinking each time she saw me & added "you were really quite big you know"
Yep...I DO know! I've been at bare minimum overweight since childhood & obese my entire adult life. It just felt very paradoxical to say I'm the "same person" then go on to thinly insult the very same person to their face haha! There was no malice intended, just felt it was a bit thoughtless. Especially as she wasnt for piping up beforehand xD
Weirdest thing I've found though is some folk take your success as their failure? I never talk about my weight unprompted so it's bizarre when someone questions me on how much I've lost/what I eat/what exercise I do before telling me why they can't do the same XYZ.
Firstly, I've been unaware these folk were actively trying to lose weight & secondly, I'd be the last person to judge them even if I was! These conversations are my least favourite cos I feel like by just existing folk feel the need to justify themselves...saddens me
Even the "nice" (using that SO loosely)ones from strangers can be jarring though. A few weeks ago I was crouched down looking for something on the chemists bottom shelf & this random guy just stood there staring at me before saying "Well ...someone squats!" with this horrible smirk on his face. Frankly, the comment made me feel grubby & somehow ashamed?!
Met my husband outside & he could tell from my face something was wrong. These things can really sour your day, not sure what type of person thinks it's okay to say anything to folk they've never clapped eyes on before..
Next month I'm moving away long distance & it will be super weird to have folk take me at face value without knowing my history. Kinda looking forward to not talking about weightloss so often....
Keep smiling & definitely mute out the negative9 -
When I was teenager a few friends were hanging out at my house and a commercial came on the TV of someone dangling a Twinkie in front of a larger man on a treadmill to get him to run (don't remember what the commercial for) and my mom laughed and in front of all my friends said "that would be you chasing a Twinkie" . I cried real tears there rest of the evening after my friends left. I was so embarrassed.5
-
I could list incredibly cruel things from family, kids at school, strangers, etc. but I don't want to give those comments power anymore. I worked through the damage they caused and now I choose to be more positive and try to attract positivity. I am not great at it, but I try. It is making a difference in my life. (I used to think posts like this were hippy-dippy bullkitten, I was in a dark place and it has been a long journey 😂)
All of you here are brave and strong for making steps toward better health.4 -
""Don't get rid of the clothes that are to big on you now, your just going to gain the weight back."8
-
I'm 5'7" and ~160lbs. I've been told I'm "too skinny" and "toothpicky" more than a few times. Not too many comments when I was at my heaviest.3
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions