I'm so upset!!!!
zfitgal
Posts: 518 Member
I had surgery on my foot 12 weeks ago (i was at my goal weight)...I went back to the gym 1 week later only doing upper body. I never went on the scale because I had a cast and there really was no point. My diet was perfect, i lowered my calories to 1700 because i knew i wasnt going to be moving much. 6 weeks ago I was able to start doing all my activities again. So I started my cardio, still eating 1700 calories. 2 weeks ago I raised them to 1800 thinking I could. I've been feeling thick and puffy lately. I went on the scale today and I am 6 pounds up post surgery. I am so upset!! I have been working so hard daily.
I was eating 1650-1700 daily to get to my goal weight. I now feel I have to start all over!!! I kind of want to indulge tonight and start tomorrow. I wish I went on the scale earlier, i would have caught this earlier appose to increasing calories.
This is so weird because I even started walking more in the past few weeks (This is on top of my 6 day a week training).
I understand how i could have gained this weight, but I dontbunderstand how I didn't lose it inbthe past 6 weeks that I have been up and moving.
I'm going to cry. #help
I was eating 1650-1700 daily to get to my goal weight. I now feel I have to start all over!!! I kind of want to indulge tonight and start tomorrow. I wish I went on the scale earlier, i would have caught this earlier appose to increasing calories.
This is so weird because I even started walking more in the past few weeks (This is on top of my 6 day a week training).
I understand how i could have gained this weight, but I dontbunderstand how I didn't lose it inbthe past 6 weeks that I have been up and moving.
I'm going to cry. #help
6
Replies
-
-
Over what time period did you gain six pounds? Was this over 12 weeks since your surgery, or over two weeks since increasing your calories from 1700 to 1800?
Feeling puffy sounds very much like water retention, which is expected when increasing your activity level, as you have done recently. It does not sound like you gained six pounds of fat.8 -
Over what time period did you gain six pounds? Was this over 12 weeks since your surgery, or over two weeks since increasing your calories from 1700 to 1800?
Feeling puffy sounds very much like water retention, which is expected when increasing your activity level, as you have done recently. It does not sound like you gained six pounds of fat.
today was the first time that I went on the scale in the past 12 weeks. I just feel so thick. I felt so tight and lean before surgery and I want to get back to that point again.
i increased to 1800 because that's where I was prior to surgery. I wasn't exactly where I physically was before the increase. Maybe I should have waited and went on the scale before raising my calories.
for the past 6 weeks I stayed within my calories and tracked everything.. what do u suggest I do.3 -
surgery takes a lot out of you so try not to stress too much! it will go back down again! As said above, probably a lot of water retention (the puffy feels is usually water-related) as you heal. Give it some time it will start coming down again. HUGS4
-
I feel you. I was hit by a car while running and was completely out of commission for a year. Its extremely frustrating. Keep to your diet, let yourself heal and don’t worry about any extra pounds. Once you are 100% healthy they will come off.13
-
I would recommend not panicking, and resisting the urge to say F it and binge. Six pounds seems like a lot, but many things cause your weight to fluctuate, and fat gain/loss is only one of those things.
Without knowing your stats, I still believe you didn't gain six pounds of fat. A pound of fat is 3500 calories. That means it would take 21000 calories above your maintenance calorie goal in order to gain six pounds of fat, or about 250 extra calories per day over 12 weeks. So, unless your maintenance calorie goal is 1450 (that is, 1700-250), you did not gain six pounds of fat. For comparison, I am under 5 feet tall and I maintain at 113-115 lb. on 1400 plus exercise. So unless your stats are similar to mine, your maintenance calorie goal is more than 1450.
Increasing your calories from 1700 to 1800 for two weeks would also not get you six pounds of fat. We can do the math on this too, but I think you can see from the calculation above that it wouldn't work out. Mathematically, this is just not likely to be all fat.
That's not to say that you definitely didn't gain any fat at all. It's possible that a small amount of the gain is fat, but not all (and probably not even most).
The symptoms you describe also perfectly match symptoms of water retention. Water retention is normal for a few weeks after increasing your exercise level. That matches the situation you describe, since you're now beginning to exercise again.5 -
I think you should just stick with 1700-1800 calories , work on getting back to your normal level of activity and weigh yourself regularly. Don't judge your progress based on one weigh in. Don't be devastated or give up.
You are likely retaining water and that is most of the 6 lbs. 6 lbs is not a lot. It will come off again.1 -
How is your foot now? Any remaining swelling? And are you still taking any medications that could be affecting water retention?
Even when I had a fairly minor surgery to remove screws etc from my ankle, I had swelling for a good few months (slowly reducing over that time). So I'd say it's likely still some water weight and just try to stick to your goal calories and be patient.0 -
Is it possible that you could be at a point in your cycle that could be contributing to water retention?3
-
How is your foot now? Any remaining swelling? And are you still taking any medications that could be affecting water retention?
Even when I had a fairly minor surgery to remove screws etc from my ankle, I had swelling for a good few months (slowly reducing over that time). So I'd say it's likely still some water weight and just try to stick to your goal calories and be patient.
I didnt take any medications after my surgery. it is still slightly swollen. but it's been 3 months and I'm doing all the activity I was doing prior to my surgery.
0 -
How much had you lost to get to goal? If it was more than 6 lbs, then you hardly need to start over. That kind of a gain (especially after surgery) is part of what maintenance is about. No starting over, just keeping going.4
-
mariececilia10 wrote: »Is it possible that you could be at a point in your cycle that could be contributing to water retention?
my cycle is expected in 9 days, I wish that were the case. It's funny I use a tape measure to measure my progress. My thighs usually measure 21.5 inches, today they were 22.5. ..that's 1 inch difference from last weel...I hate complaining but I'm doing everything right and.measuring everything by the gram (even my mustard ).
I'm training hard and heavy and intense, so I just don't really understand.4 -
mariececilia10 wrote: »Is it possible that you could be at a point in your cycle that could be contributing to water retention?
I'm training hard and heavy and intense, so I just don't really understand.
It's common to gain water weight after increasing exercise.
It's common to gain water weight after an injury -- especially one as severe as yours.
You have hit the perfect storm of water weight.
Step back. Put the tape measure and the scale away.
Re-evaluate in six weeks.14 -
I sometimes have a six pound water weight gain in ONE DAY due to water. When I hurt my leg I gained 5 lbs temporarily. Twelve weeks may seem like a long time, but you're just now starting to be properly healed.
At least for me, only weighing every few weeks would not work. It's too easy to lie to myself about how much activity I'm getting and what I need to be eating. I think probably part of your weight is water weight, but if not, lesson learned, you lost the weight before and you can lose it again. And track more often, you can't stop watching your weight just because you hit goal!4 -
For the sake of all the baby felines in the whole dang world.
1" of FAT GAIN -- CANNOT-- HAPPEN -- OVERNIGHT.
BY DEFINITION the frigging inch is mostly from non fat gain causes... i.e. water weight!!!15 -
rheddmobile wrote: »I sometimes have a six pound water weight gain in ONE DAY due to water. When I hurt my leg I gained 5 lbs temporarily. Twelve weeks may seem like a long time, but you're just now starting to be properly healed.
At least for me, only weighing every few weeks would not work. It's too easy to lie to myself about how much activity I'm getting and what I need to be eating. I think probably part of your weight is water weight, but if not, lesson learned, you lost the weight before and you can lose it again. And track more often, you can't stop watching your weight just because you hit goal!
I never stopped tracking. I tracked everyday before surgery and everyday after.. I don't lie to myself. Why would I do that? this is all for me.
today was the first day I weighed myself since surgery.3 -
My guess is water and inflammation too.
I tweaked my kneeat playing basketball a few weeks ago, around the same time my autoimmune issues flared up minorly, and I gained six-seven pounds within a few days. It wasn't diet, just my body's reaction to an injury and an immune issue. I lost most of it within 2 weeks once my AI issues calmed down. I'm still up a bit, but my knee is still burning, so my guess is that it will go once I am more fully recovered.
I have had injuries and autoimmune flare-ups that affected my weight for months. It's annoying, but there was nothing I could do about inflammation.
My guess is that you still need some more time. If you are tracking, and taking into account less activity, you should be fine. Even if you did somehow gain a few pounds of fat, you know how to lose it.3 -
rheddmobile wrote: »I sometimes have a six pound water weight gain in ONE DAY due to water. When I hurt my leg I gained 5 lbs temporarily. Twelve weeks may seem like a long time, but you're just now starting to be properly healed.
At least for me, only weighing every few weeks would not work. It's too easy to lie to myself about how much activity I'm getting and what I need to be eating. I think probably part of your weight is water weight, but if not, lesson learned, you lost the weight before and you can lose it again. And track more often, you can't stop watching your weight just because you hit goal!
I never stopped tracking. I tracked everyday before surgery and everyday after.. I don't lie to myself. Why would I do that? this is all for me.
today was the first day I weighed myself since surgery.
By tracking, I don't mean logging, I mean TRACKING YOUR WEIGHT. If this is the first day you have weighed yourself in several months, you are not tracking your weight.
It's very easy, as you have learned, to make assumptions about how much food you need. Only the scale can tell you whether or not you are overeating in the long term. One person's 1800 calorie diet may be too many calories for another person with seemingly identical stats.5 -
LosingLaurensWay wrote: »I was hit by a car while running and was completely out of commission for a year.
I'm sorry to hear about the accident. I run and cycle both and I worry about getting hit. My thought is that I was hurting myself one fork-full at a time; if I get hit that's on someone else. I still worry about it.
1 -
garystrickland357 wrote: »LosingLaurensWay wrote: »I was hit by a car while running and was completely out of commission for a year.
I'm sorry to hear about the accident. I run and cycle both and I worry about getting hit. My thought is that I was hurting myself one fork-full at a time; if I get hit that's on someone else. I still worry about it.
Right? The hardest part of riding in traffic, in my opinion, is trusting that the drivers behind me will see me, give me room, and not be homicidal maniacs with a hate on for cyclists.
OP, I agree with posters above that weighing yourself weekly would be the best way to avoid getting shocked after a long time away from the scale. Sticking with 1700 - 1800 calories for a few weeks as suggested while getting back to routine will give you an idea of what you have to do going forward. I understand feeling sad - it's very hard to have to backtrack when life throws you a curve. You're in a position now to take back control, and you have a good record of success to fall back on as you get back into your routines.3 -
quiksylver296 wrote: »
Thanks, @Quiksylver296 for preaching my sermon.
Seriously, OP, you're doing all of the right things, just let your body get all the way better. It will know when it doesn't need to hold every extra ounce and stop doing it.3 -
I spent 8 months in bed , all my muscles got soft and my legs were so giggly ☹️. You have to understand that a healing body has to be given time to heal and stressing out won’t help 🌸I actually ate more protein during recovery which you’re supposed to do so your body heals.
I’ll bet as soon as you’re 100% and active again you’ll have a good loss ,but by saying you took no medication I hope you really gave your body the best situation to heal . Pain killers allow us and our bodies to relax and heal , I trust my drs so I take them .0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions