High protein?
tabbiyoung13
Posts: 3 Member
How do I get in my protein without affing a lot of cholesterol and sodium. Seems like peanut butter, seafood, and chicken is high in sodium and cholesterol. I went over in my cholesterol yesterday for having just 2 eggs with breakfast 😶
0
Replies
-
Do you have a reason to worry about cholesterol or sodium?
Egg whites, protein powder, cheese, beans...all good sources.8 -
tabbiyoung13 wrote: »How do I get in my protein without affing a lot of cholesterol and sodium. Seems like peanut butter, seafood, and chicken is high in sodium and cholesterol. I went over in my cholesterol yesterday for having just 2 eggs with breakfast 😶
Peanut butter isn't a protein source, its a fat source that has some protein in it.
do you have a medical reason to watch your sodium or cholesterol?7 -
tabbiyoung13 wrote: »How do I get in my protein without affing a lot of cholesterol and sodium. Seems like peanut butter, seafood, and chicken is high in sodium and cholesterol. I went over in my cholesterol yesterday for having just 2 eggs with breakfast 😶
I don't think of seafood and chicken as being high in cholesterol or sodium? To avoid sodium, cook from scratch. To avoid cholesterol, you can lean toward plant proteins like beans and lentils.
But unless you have a medical condition, most people don't have to worry too much about cholesterol, and they are even starting to back off on sodium as well.7 -
tabbiyoung13 wrote: »How do I get in my protein without affing a lot of cholesterol and sodium. Seems like peanut butter, seafood, and chicken is high in sodium and cholesterol. I went over in my cholesterol yesterday for having just 2 eggs with breakfast 😶
I buy a paleo pancake mix and add a half cup of whey protein to the mix before I cook them. Each pancake only has about 14 grams of protein in 140 calories (I make pretty big pancakes lol), but I don’t think that’s bad considering sometimes I would just about tear my house down for a pancake.
Fage 0% yogurt has over 20g protein per one cup serving if I remember right. I normally mash a ripe banana in it or add a tablespoon of my favorite strawberry jam.
Cottage cheese (low fat or fat free) is another option I use for added protein.
Obviously, various meats are an option. You’ll need to cook fresh though if you want to avoid excess sodium! If you look at canned meats, the sodium content is crazy. I’m not sure about their cholesterol levels, because I don’t worry about cholesterol.
I also use my snacks as protein fillers. I really love dried cheese snacks (not for you if you want low sodium though). I only get about 10g of protein per serving with those, but I really enjoy them so I consider the protein a bonus. You may be able to find sources of protein like that, small bits in things you enjoy. They can add up. Most days I am able to reach my personal goal of 100g of protein without much effort.1 -
My peanut butter says 0 cholesterol, which is what I expected from a plant based food. Nuts and beans would also be protein sources that also include the fibers that help your body control cholesterol levels.4
-
OP, it's also possible you are choosing bad entries in the database. Most are user entered, so maybe you are picking entries that someone created as more like a recipe, so the numbers include other ingredients not mentioned in the title.0
-
Chicken is not high in sodium. Unless it is coming out of a can. If you are concerned about the cholesterol in eggs, there are some very good egg replacement products. Or use one whole egg to every two or three egg whites.1
-
I think the entries you're looking at are bad...seafood and chicken are neither high in cholesterol or sodium unless you're eating it out of a can or it's processed like lunch meat or smoked salmon or something.3
-
No I add EVERYTHING manualy and make sure it all matches the nutr. Facts on the package. So when I want shrimp and crab on a salad, this thing flags me and tells me I'm WAYYYY over my cholesterol and sodium. I realized it's imitation crab after I bought it lol
I don't have a medical problem but I hold water weight pretty bad and soon trying to stay away from a lot of sodium0 -
Like for lunch I wanted shrimp, crab, spinach, and an avocado... With just that it put me over on a lot0
-
tabbiyoung13 wrote: »No I add EVERYTHING manualy and make sure it all matches the nutr. Facts on the package. So when I want shrimp and crab on a salad, this thing flags me and tells me I'm WAYYYY over my cholesterol and sodium. I realized it's imitation crab after I bought it lol
I don't have a medical problem but I hold water weight pretty bad and soon trying to stay away from a lot of sodium
Imitation crab has sodium added to it for flavor. Shrimp and crab themselves don't have a lot of sodium.
If you're buying meats that have sodium added (as is the case with many processed or pre-cooked or -prepped meats), then your intake of sodium is going to be higher. This is something you can control by choosing different products, ones that don't have sodium added.6 -
The thread linked below is an excellent one, for questions like yours. It links to a spreadsheet that lists many, many foods by protein efficiency: Most protein for fewest calories (so relatively less fat, including cholesterol). Find foods you enjoy that are high on the list, check to make sure they're low sodium, and eat more of those, less of something else that isn't as helpful in meeting your goals.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10247171/carbs-and-fats-are-cheap-heres-a-guide-to-getting-your-proteins-worth-fiber-also
How much water (or equivalent fluids) are you consuming? Sodium/hydration balance (taken in context of other micronutrients, for some) is related to water retention. I'm not suggesting you should drink crazy-big amounts of water (which is wrong in the opposite direction), but suggesting you check to see that you're getting enough, to the point where your urine is a pale straw color or lighter, for example.
Please don't try to game your body to eliminate water retention. Water weight fluctuations (up/down a few pounds) are part of how a healthy body functions. If you feel your water retention is excessive, or it keeps building up to the point of swelling, see your doctor. Otherwise, recognize that water weight is not fat gain, that its fluctuations are literally a sign of good health and proper body function, and don't stress about it.4 -
-
tabbiyoung13 wrote: »How do I get in my protein without affing a lot of cholesterol and sodium. Seems like peanut butter, seafood, and chicken is high in sodium and cholesterol. I went over in my cholesterol yesterday for having just 2 eggs with breakfast 😶
I don't think of seafood and chicken as being high in cholesterol or sodium? To avoid sodium, cook from scratch. To avoid cholesterol, you can lean toward plant proteins like beans and lentils.
But unless you have a medical condition, most people don't have to worry too much about cholesterol, and they are even starting to back off on sodium as well.
I guess shrimp is high in cholesterol, but I don't either, and agreed that most people don't have to worry about dietary cholesterol or sodium from whole foods like plain meats. I guess some are injected with saline, that would add sodium.3 -
What are you considering "high" in sodium? If the bulk of your diet is from minimally processed foods, your sodium level should be able to stay within the normal range fairly easily.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
This content has been removed.
-
Food pyramid isn't a thing anymore. Also, that's not how diabetes happens, and pretty sure among the gov't recs is that people be more active.7
-
Cholesterol thing has been debunked. Good rule of thumb? Do the opposite of what the government preaches regarding nutrition.
Current US guidelines include the advice to eat "a variety of vegetables" and "a variety of protein foods."
You think people should do the opposite?
This type of comment reveals that you don't actually know what current US dietary guidelines are.8 -
The food pyramid is wrong for your average person who doesn't workout. Hello type 2 diabetes
There's nothing wrong with the food pyramid or My Plate...nowhere do gov't recommendations say to eat a bunch of *kitten* and make sure you pile your plate with it. It emphasizes eating a variety of fruits and vegetables and lean proteins and whole grains like oats, etc. If people actually followed it, they would be fine.10 -
This content has been removed.
-
This content has been removed.
-
The country did not actually do low fat.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
tabbiyoung13 wrote: »How do I get in my protein without affing a lot of cholesterol and sodium. Seems like peanut butter, seafood, and chicken is high in sodium and cholesterol. I went over in my cholesterol yesterday for having just 2 eggs with breakfast 😶
There is absolutely no cholesterol in peanut butter, unless you've found some brand that adds lard. You can buy peanut butter that is just ground peanuts, no added salt. Of course, the real problem is that peanut butter is more of a fat source than a protein source.
Chicken breast and other lean meats are not particularly high in cholesterol, and if you buy raw cuts from the market, you can control how much salt gets added (there's not much sodium in the raw poultry or meat). Just don't buy brined. Fish is another option.2 -
-
The country did not actually do low fat.
https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2014/03/28/295332576/why-we-got-fatter-during-the-fat-free-food-boom
The point is, while people were saying "low fat this and that" and buying Snackwell cookies, they were still eating plenty of fast food, restaurant food, margarine, desserts etc. While all the talk was low fat, people weren't actually eating a low fat diet. They were eating a high fat/high sugar diet but making themselves feel like they were healthier by buying some "low fat" substitutes. People got fatter because they were eating too much.
I'm certainly not saying the low fat craze was a good idea, just that most people didn't actually eat a low fat diet.
None of which has anything to do with the OP, maybe you can start a thread in the Debate forum if you wantto continue discussing this to avoid derailing OP's thread.
OP, it doesn't sound like you need to worry about sodium and cholesterol, but if you want to, just check your labels. It sounds like you're getting chicken and fish that has sodium added to it. It might be as simple as grabbing a different brand.6 -
SOME people thrive off lower protein jus' sayin'
I'm on 15% according to an Ayurvedic system and I'm actually losing weight compared to when I was on 25%
Please don't hurt me :96 -
Chaos_Angel wrote: »SOME people thrive off lower protein jus' sayin'
I'm on 15% according to an Ayurvedic system and I'm actually losing weight compared to when I was on 25%
Please don't hurt me :9
Protein doesn't affect your rate of weight loss. It affects satiety and muscle retention. More important than your percentage is how many grams you're getting. If you are getting less than 0.6-0.8g per lb of goal body weight and especially if you aren't focusing on strength training, you risk losing far more muscle than you would want as you lose weight.
My comment not meant to hurt you just caution you and anyone else who might be reading. Everyone has to find that personal balance where they are comfortable and doing the best they can.5
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions