Cardio that isn't ... cardio?

What about something like a hand pedal machine? I've never used one, but an old gym I went to years ago had one or two and they seemed to get the folks hearts pumping...

Swim, row or paddle, ski, ride a bike, hike.

Cycling won't stress your feet of you ride at a high cadence (because that means low force) and stiff soled shoes (which spread that small force evenly across the entire foot), for what it's worth. Don't do it if you're not comfortable with the idea, but if cycling is something you've ever loved you can probably do it without pain.

In addition to what everyone else has mentioned, I would definitely work with a physical therapist to rehab your various injuries if you haven't started doing so already. They should also be able to give you some good ideas for various cardio exercises and how not to further injure yourself..

AnnPT77 wrote: »

I have my doubts about rowing. Speaking as a rower, there's a lot of foot/ankle flexing involved, and if you go hard it takes leg strength and pressure: It's very much a leg-power exercise! I would think it might be worse than spin/cycling, even.

Can you get a physical therapy referral to someone who can help you with tailored exercise suggestions?

I don't know if it's worse but I suspect it isn't any better. I can predict two things. If the OP doesn't have clipless pedals, they would move their foot around in such a way that would favor some odd part of their lower body (odd in that it's not typically used for cycling in the way that the OP would be using it) and potentially cause injury if they did it long enough. In the case of using a rowing machine, the OP's form would likely seriously suffer because they would be favoring various muscles which, like the bike issue, would likely cause injury.

I suspect the bike thing would be a bit easier to work around with the foot ligament tear, but I can't imagine you'd be able to do so without using rather stiff shoes (which isn't a bad thing in general). Either way, I wouldn't want to do so without the initial aid of a physical therapist.

Circling back round around, I think the primary way cycling would be better is if you are able to do so without flexing your foot (which would likely possible with a rigid shoe and clipless pedals). Otherwise, neither seem like a great option.

you gotta be on your toes a lot in boxing. unless you're thinking 'boxercise' where you just stand there and do 50 straight punches or whatever.

pilates, yoga, weight training? Swimming definitely.

I'd go with swimming also. You can reduce your ankle movement, I watch a lot of people swim and some hardly move their legs. What does your doctor suggest?

MostlyWater wrote: »

Bike riding and hiking are definitely out. I can't stress my feet (left foot) that much.

Swimming, OK. Rower, sure.

The hand bike? Yes, please !!!!

Thanks all.

Why do you imagine that cycling would stress your feet?

Granted, I do distribute my body weight between butt and feet when I ride, but when I've got the right shoes, there's not much stress on my feet.

You could consider a recumbent, perhaps, if you try an upright bicycle and it just doesn't work.



Rowing stresses my feet more than cycling.

Check with a doctor or physical therapist first of course, but what about a bungee aerobics class? You are jumping but the bungee takes away a lot of the impact.

Swimming or aqua fitness classes. You might even find some free classes at your community center so you could try it out and see how it goes. Our community center also has senior fitness classes. I know that many who attend these classes in my area are not seniors but have physical constraints that they feel are more comfortably addressed in these classes.

I’d definitely talk to the physical therapist first and whatever you choose start slow. Pay attention to any warning signs your body might be giving you.