Intermittent Fasting Studies 2019 - Science Behind Fasting
pierinifitness
Posts: 2,226 Member
Just posted some new content about three intermittent fasting studies at the Intermittent Fasting group for those who stumble across this post and may be interested. I'm not directly posting it here because most MFP members are not interested.
Here's the link: https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10731877/intermittent-fasting-studies-2019-science-behind-fasting#latest
Here's the link: https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10731877/intermittent-fasting-studies-2019-science-behind-fasting#latest
17
Replies
-
I'm all about true IF. Combined with keto or a low carb/sugars diet it is amazing. I do 20/4 but this may be a little tough for some.12
-
I have a “science experiment” in progress on day 4 doing OMAD 22/2 and within 60 minutes of eating. Agree with what you said.2
-
Thanks for sharing.1
-
I fast when I sleep.10
-
I typically do 16/83
-
It is my understanding (and someone correct me if I'm wrong), that it takes 12 hours to enter the fasted state after your last meal. Fed, post absorptive and then fasted. So depending on when you last ate, you probably are not fasting while you are sleeping...1
-
It is my understanding (and someone correct me if I'm wrong), that it takes 12 hours to enter the fasted state after your last meal. Fed, post absorptive and then fasted. So depending on when you last ate, you probably are not fasting while you are sleeping...
It really depends on the researcher. A decade ago, fasting in literature would almost exclusively refer to things like alternate day fasting, while things like IF would be called time-restricted feeding. I think literature still tends to favor calling it time-restricted for patterns like IF.
Depending on what is being examined, I'd imagine there is a range of times that people's systems change and showing a more fasted profile.0 -
Have been doing for real for 2 months. Results have been amazing. I have been able to create true deficits while giving myself to fit in some not so good for you foods all without feeling hungry all the time.3
-
That’s great @jakea1963, as a disciplined IF practitioner with consistency under my belt, your results come as no surprise to me. Keep marching forward!5
-
pierinifitness wrote: »I have a “science experiment” in progress on day 4 doing OMAD 22/2 and within 60 minutes of eating. Agree with what you said.
What is OMAD?0 -
OMAD is an acronym for one meal a day, generally understood to mean a small feeding window in which an extended meal takes place.0
-
pierinifitness wrote: »OMAD is an acronym for one meal a day, generally understood to mean a small feeding window in which an extended meal takes place.
Gotcha...1 -
I’m fairly new to IF. It’s been about two weeks. So far I’m really enjoying it. I don’t find I’m hungry or maybe my mind is just refocused because I’m so determined to fast. I was going for 16:8 but I actually do 18:6. My morning routine of getting kids ready and to school then straight to the gym (I get so jacked when I go before I’ve eaten), then home and I eat by 12:15 and stop after 6. I’m not even craving snacks at night so far so it’s amazing. Very easy to create a deficit when you don’t snack in the evenings. Just a *kitten* tone of water. The only downfall is I end up waking at night to pee. Lol. I’ve also cut out coffee. I absolutely love French vanilla creamer and one day I measured how much I add to make it creamy and so yummy and I was disgusted at the amount of calories it was (150!!). So I said forget it and just don’t do it anymore. Well actually I did have a cup yesterday but only because my calories were so low. So now it’s a treat rather than 4 or 5 a day using up my daily allowance of calories.4
-
@KrystalGayle08, thanks for sharing,it’s something all active IF practitioners can relate to. By the way, we have an Intermittent Fasting group here at MFP. It’s loaded with great content and new stuff is being added daily. One member, @Diatonic12, regularly adds amazing content rich in perspective.
We’d love to have you stop by and say hello, maybe share and enjoy the pearls of wisdom and support we offer. Wishing you the best.2 -
@pierinifitness I just watched the video regarding the studies on IF and it makes so much sense. I’m so excited to be on this journey and I’m going to join the group thank you.0
-
KrystalGayle08 wrote: »@pierinifitness I just watched the video regarding the studies on IF and it makes so much sense. I’m so excited to be on this journey and I’m going to join the group thank you.
Your welcome and will see you there. I'll be privately cheering for you.0 -
So from the video, he talks about cals the same on the first study... does that mean the same deficit? what was the weight loss vs. in each group not just BF% loss? That will tell you the size of the deficits. Maybe the group that lost more bf% had higher cal needs, so eating the same amount as the other group would cause them to lose more weight and fat... should be based on deficit, not just cals in.
Tthe second study does make sense about naturally eating fewer cals following IF, since you only eat in a shortened window.0 -
One study I read in detail, not just a news article excerpt, is this one that obviously is IF positive. Now granted, for each positive study one can show a negative or neutral one; it's the nature of research.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5064803/1 -
I apparently do 16/8 because I have breakfast at my desk just before 9 and dinner right when I get home 18:00 latest.1
-
16/8 here as well. 12pm - 8pm...1
-
So from the video, he talks about cals the same on the first study... does that mean the same deficit? what was the weight loss vs. in each group not just BF% loss? That will tell you the size of the deficits. Maybe the group that lost more bf% had higher cal needs, so eating the same amount as the other group would cause them to lose more weight and fat... should be based on deficit, not just cals in.
Tthe second study does make sense about naturally eating fewer cals following IF, since you only eat in a shortened window.
The first study was not held constant and even more so, it was based on recall. The ND group was consuming 200 cal more than the IF group. That roughly equates to over 11,200 calories extra.
The second study was pretty interesting. What really caught my eye was:
"However, as we have seen with these participants, fasting diets are difficult to follow and may not always be compatible with family and social life. We therefore need to make sure they are flexible and conducive to real life, as the potential benefits of such diets are clear to see.
ETA: it really caught my attention because that is what I ran into. It didnt work well with my personal life, and I was always starving following IF.6 -
@psuLemon, one man's tool to success is another man's tool to torture; we're all different and need to pick our fitness, health and wellness tools smartly.3
-
Good advice! And to realize that one way of eating that leads to good results is not inherently more reflective of discipline or what not than another that also leads to good results, of course.4
-
Thank you for sharing!! I am learning and practicing IF. Any resources are appreciated!0
-
@bkelley32148, our Intermittent Fasting group here at MFP is IF resource rich. Stop by and say hello, look around and maybe share. We'd love to have you join us - here's how to get there:
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/49-intermittent-fasting
Hope to see you soon. Wishing you the best.3
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions