Those who maintain without exercising...
Options
Replies
-
For me, exercise is the key to maintaining. You can't eat at a low calorie amount forever. burn out.3
-
Sure you can.
If you have to.
A bad back (2 surgeries) & a 'dead' right leg prevents me from being active.
Walking (even with a cane or a walker) 100 feet makes my back ache for 10-15 minutes.
Zero exercise.
So, I maintain by budgeting calories.
Period.
About 1870 per day.
I've been at my goal weight, well +/- 3 pounds, since 2011.
Right now, I'm ONE under goal.10 -
Sure you can.
If you have to.
A bad back (2 surgeries) & a 'dead' right leg prevents me from being active.
Walking (even with a cane or a walker) 100 feet makes my back ache for 10-15 minutes.
Zero exercise.
So, I maintain by budgeting calories.
Period.
About 1870 per day.
I've been at my goal weight, well +/- 3 pounds, since 2011.
Right now, I'm ONE under goal.
I think a no-exercise maintenance budget of 1870 calories would make things better for many sedentary maintainers. For me, no exercise means about ~1400-1500 calories for maintenance, with 1500 meaning I actually managed to take a few thousand steps. 1870 is still a bit too much for even a lightly active level of 10k steps.0 -
Sure you can.
If you have to.
A bad back (2 surgeries) & a 'dead' right leg prevents me from being active.
Walking (even with a cane or a walker) 100 feet makes my back ache for 10-15 minutes.
Zero exercise.
So, I maintain by budgeting calories.
Period.
About 1870 per day.
I've been at my goal weight, well +/- 3 pounds, since 2011.
Right now, I'm ONE under goal.
Thanks for commenting! You're one of the few who this post was geared towards! So many others chimed in just to say people shouldn't maintain without exercise. But they completely missed the title?? This post wasn't about if you should or shouldn't maintain without exercising. It was asking people who do how it's been going for them.5 -
I have a bit of a two part answer. I exercise regularly and often eat 2500-3500 calories per day. This is my norm. That said, what about the times when life happens and I go several days or a week and can't exercise? If I continue my "normal" eating I gain weight. During those times (or if I need to trim a few pounds) I eat around 1700-1900 calories per day.
When I transition to the lower calorie diet it seems "hard" at first. I simply can't eat the same way... What I do is make some choices. I lighten my breakfast. I skip the chips with my sandwich at lunch. I eat lighter snacks. These changes still allow me a hearty supper which is important to me. After a few days, the lower calorie meals are the new "normal" and life is good again.5 -
I lost 30lbs since last May (5’4”- start 167, maintenance at about 137). I never added additional exercise, however my job is physical involving standing, moving, walking, and lifting things almost all day long (surgical technologist).
I’ve been maintaining since about November. I stopped logging MFP in March. I still weigh daily and eat about what I was when logging all the time. I’ve been maintaining just fine.
For my cals to lose weight I was eating about 1430 and maintenance says 1800ish. But just logged today out of curiosity and I ate well under that without trying. And I eat calorie dense foods.
So am I the healthiest?, no. But I’m healthier now then a year ago and more aware of what I eat and how much. Maybe someday I’ll finally join a gym.1 -
I've been maintaining for 6 years, I have a desk job but keep my NEAT up by being active outside of work and getting up from my desk often. I 'only' do 30 mins of legitimate exercise a day (biking/strength training/walking).
I'm 5ft 2 /range 125-130lbs and maintain on 1900 cals approx. (only loosely count cals now so that's an estimate).0 -
Exercise is important for health but in my personal experience, it isn't required for weight loss or maintaining weight. Diet is actually the most important aspect of the many facets of these. You may not have a body that you love (I have found that an atrophied body just feels and looks yuck to me when I stop moving for long periods of time) if you don't move it much, but the diet portion is really what matters most here. I don't do much movement -- I do yoga and meditation and walking primarily. But just moving my body in these ways feels good.
Jenn1 -
I've pretty much maintained since the new year, and most definitely the last month without exercise. I was exercising up until a month ago really, but i cut back on calories to make up for it and its worked fine, but im on about 1200cals a day. I do general walking and stuff as part of my routine but thats all.0
-
Exercise isn't necessary to lose, maintain, or gain.
Hopefully all in all one should be developing good habits where counting calories is something not needed on the daily.
I would highly recommend to do some form a resistance training for there is overwhelming evidence that it not only extends life but creates a better quality of life. When you get advanced age you'll thank yourself that you did. I also highly recommend some form of activity at the very least LIIT for the same reasons.
0 -
A friend of mine lost about 70 pounds when he was in high school. He's in his 40s now and he hasn't regained. He never exercises. Ever. He eats 2 meals a day. Snacks rarely. If he eats a heavy meal, he skips the next meal or makes it pretty light.
It's weird. But that's what he does.0 -
Exercise, for me, is essential to maintenance, but life comes around sometimes and stops it, i.e., when you are having surgery or when something unforeseen happens and you aren't able to exercise for a while. For me, I have always loved any form of exercise, even at my top weight, and also avoid things like escalators or elevators when I can walk instead. Parking far away from wherever I'm going is a favorite trick, as well. But exercise is about more than weight ... it's about health, all kinds of health, and I think it's a part of building a healthy lifestyle.
0 -
You’d have to workout for an hour every day to maintain at your original calorie intake and that’s if you don’t go over at all. You should try varying your calorie intake - look at your week instead of a day, so one day you might eat 1500 calories and The weekends eat more, etc. I dont know anyone who is at maintenance without exercise.0
-
I have maitained for over 5 years doing little excercise. I walk, on average, about 20 minutes per day and I do have a job where I am lightly moving.
The calorie restriction is not onerous - I maintain on net of 1710 with a few extra calories for the little bit of exercise I do.
Fairly easy to keep to average of slightly above 1710 per day.2
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.1K Introduce Yourself
- 43.6K Getting Started
- 259.9K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.7K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 403 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.8K Motivation and Support
- 7.9K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 998 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.4K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions