Lifting but little physical results
cherriegh
Posts: 196 Member
I started working out 3months ago doing glute/leg focused training 3x weekly consistently with 1day intense cardio 30mins but my glutes are just still flabby and saggy and not perking up.
I'm 5'2 at 66kgs - My goal is to strengthen my saggy butt not really lose weight.
My weight has remained the same and clothes still fit the same even though I haven't measured.
I have been training very hard with progressive overload but change to physical appearance of my glutes is still minimum.
Is there something I'm doing wrong or is it early? Is there such as a waste of training?
I got training by PT at gym and exercises include: Hip thrusts, glute bridges, Leg press, Squats, Sumo Deadlift, Hip abduction, Hyper-extensions or Cable pull through as finishers
I'm so discouraged because I don't see changes Help please!
I'm 5'2 at 66kgs - My goal is to strengthen my saggy butt not really lose weight.
My weight has remained the same and clothes still fit the same even though I haven't measured.
I have been training very hard with progressive overload but change to physical appearance of my glutes is still minimum.
Is there something I'm doing wrong or is it early? Is there such as a waste of training?
I got training by PT at gym and exercises include: Hip thrusts, glute bridges, Leg press, Squats, Sumo Deadlift, Hip abduction, Hyper-extensions or Cable pull through as finishers
I'm so discouraged because I don't see changes Help please!
2
Replies
-
Did you take 'before' pictures?2
-
Are your weights increasing as you continue to train?
Weight training will strengthen muscle, but it won't spot reduce fat in the areas your are training. At 5'2 and 66kg, you are a BMI of 26.5, which is classified as overweight. You may find that the issues you are seeing there are because you still have excess fat in those areas. A moderate calorie deficit help lose some weight may help reduce the fat in those areas, making them appear less "flabby" and reveal the muscle you are burning underneath.8 -
I'm loading 2.5kgs weekly so I'm adding weights but my concern is when to expect physical changes. Even though I weigh more I don't want to be skinny and I'm comfortable with my size I wear size 10 and small/Medium tops and if i lose more I start showing bones on my shoulders and back
But maybe I should lose a bit of weight and see....thanksAre your weights increasing as you continue to train?
Weight training will strengthen muscle, but it won't spot reduce fat in the areas your are training. At 5'2 and 66kg, you are a BMI of 26.5, which is classified as overweight. You may find that the issues you are seeing there are because you still have excess fat in those areas. A moderate calorie deficit help lose some weight may help reduce the fat in those areas, making them appear less "flabby" and reveal the muscle you are burning underneath.
1 -
quiksylver296 wrote: »Did you take 'before' pictures?
Not really I'm monitoring how my clothes fit but I think I should take and check after a month0 -
quiksylver296 wrote: »Did you take 'before' pictures?
Not really I'm monitoring how my clothes fit but I think I should take and check after a month
Agreed!2 -
You probably do have some muscles - but like the previous poster said - they are hiding under a little bit of fat. Its amazing how much you have to lose to get any definition. I'm 5 foot and 20 kilos lighter than you, and I still have some fat (specifically around my hips/thighs) that hides any definition I might have there.3
-
I'd say we can't expect the results within 3 months, there might be changes but like Mike mentioned, it's still covered by fat. I'd say you will be able to see changes easily after 1 year, so you need to expect that it is gonna be a life long progress.5
-
It's great that you're on the right track. Are you actively trying to lose weight, if so what is your deficit and how are you logging? If you're focusing mainly on lifting, are you following a structured program with progressions built in? Can you lift more than you did 3 months ago? If so, you are making progress. If not, you need someone to review your program.
If you are not taking progress pictures or measurements, it will be very hard to see your progress. We DO NOT have accurate memories of what we used to look like and we DO NOT have accurate self-perceptions in the mirror. If you are basically doing recomp, i.e. no weight loss and mostly lifting, it is a slow (but effective) process and takes a while to see noticeable results in the mirror.2 -
I started working out 3months ago doing glute/leg focused training 3x weekly consistently with 1day intense cardio 30mins but my glutes are just still flabby and saggy and not perking up.
I'm 5'2 at 66kgs - My goal is to strengthen my saggy butt not really lose weight.
My weight has remained the same and clothes still fit the same even though I haven't measured.
I have been training very hard with progressive overload but change to physical appearance of my glutes is still minimum.
Is there something I'm doing wrong or is it early? Is there such as a waste of training?
I got training by PT at gym and exercises include: Hip thrusts, glute bridges, Leg press, Squats, Sumo Deadlift, Hip abduction, Hyper-extensions or Cable pull through as finishers
I'm so discouraged because I don't see changes Help please!
At this weight for your height you have a BMI in the overweight range. Which is not muscle since you just started training. If you are trying to do a recomp, so that you convert the excess weight into visible muscle, you probably need a really good program, and have several years of effort ahead of you to see really visible results. This does not mean you will not become stronger, it is totally doable to be strong and overweight, rather common actually.2 -
If you are recomping (by this I mean not losing weight but maintaining your weight to change your composition), it is more difficult and slow if you are at a higher weight and your bodyfat is higher. Results can take longer and progress is harder to track. Not impossible but 3 months is not a lot of time and it can take much longer than that.
You might want to set a deficit to 0.5lb per week, continue your progressive training and get adequate protein (0.8-1g per lb bodyweight/goalweight) and then re-evaluate when you get leaner.7 -
Don't give up. I didn't see any real results until I was 50-60 lbs down in weight. 90% of it is DIET..get that under control and have a calorie deficit and you will see results eventually.3
-
If your lifts in the isolation exercises are going up, you're almost certainly gaining muscle. Seeing change from gaining muscle takes a lot longer than changes from losing weight.2
-
Getting muscle definition and/or toning is difficult. If you're overweight it's really only possible if you have years of working out under your belt and are healthily overweight.
I'd suggest continuing the strength training and trying to drop a few pounds. You'll probably be surprised and happy with the result, however if you're not it shouldn't be difficult to pack on the pounds until you reach what you're looking for.4 -
I would agree with those who say to keep on working out, keep up the progressive overload, but perhaps consider losing some weight as well. I'm *technically* in a healthy weight range, but losing a few pounds while lifting has made noticeable differences that even others have commented on. Mind you, I was lifting regularly (mostly trying to recomp) most of last year, and didn't see very noticeable differences because my weight was still up.
I'm now about 7 pounds lighter, and back to lifting after an ~6-8 month break, and the differences are far more noticeable with weight loss+ lifting (at least visually - obviously you're not going to gain muscle mass - outside of newbie gains - while losing weight).
Ultimately, you can keep on lifting, build up the muscle and then lose some weight to reveal your beautiful new muscles, or keep the very slow recomp road (which is what it sounds like you're doing), or try shedding a few pounds and see if you like what ends up being uncovered - you might be surprised.3 -
Thank you so much everyone very insightful.... I will try drop the 7kgs or so plus continue lifting and see how I look afterwards 🙂4
-
HoneyBadger155 wrote: »I would agree with those who say to keep on working out, keep up the progressive overload, but perhaps consider losing some weight as well. I'm *technically* in a healthy weight range, but losing a few pounds while lifting has made noticeable differences that even others have commented on. Mind you, I was lifting regularly (mostly trying to recomp) most of last year, and didn't see very noticeable differences because my weight was still up.
I'm now about 7 pounds lighter, and back to lifting after an ~6-8 month break, and the differences are far more noticeable with weight loss+ lifting (at least visually - obviously you're not going to gain muscle mass - outside of newbie gains - while losing weight).
Ultimately, you can keep on lifting, build up the muscle and then lose some weight to reveal your beautiful new muscles, or keep the very slow recomp road (which is what it sounds like you're doing), or try shedding a few pounds and see if you like what ends up being uncovered - you might be surprised.
Yea I really wanted a recomp but my start weight is off even though my body is firmer, I see it's gonna be a long lonely road so I'll drop a few while continuing lifting and see 🙂1 -
If you keep increasing the weight and doing your reps with proper form, you'll achieve your goal eventually.1
-
As others have said recomp is slow. I am 5 ft 8 and around 140 pounds. I’ve been lifting consistently following a structured programme for just over 2 years. I’m only now seeing small changes to my body but I wouldn’t say I look in any way muscular. I still have fat on my thighs bum and stomach. 3 months is not a long time to build muscle. I agree with others that losing a few pounds in your case may reveal some of your gainzzzz.
Also I think you need to find a programme you enjoy doing and can stick to long term. You didn’t say which programme you were following. Strong curves is a popular one for booty.1 -
Recomping takes a long time to get results. I'm around the same height and weight as you and recomped for the first year of maintenance. Found it was great mentally but it was when I started doing bulk and cut that I really laid on the muscle (I was actually eating at a surplus to aid recovery from long runs in marathon training the laying on of muscle was just an added benefit)
It's also harder to see the muscle at the higher weight. I'm looking to slowly drop another 5kg or so to hopefully reveal more definition.
0 -
I am in a similar situation...where i am slim but have a higher body fat level then i would like. i have decided to slowly lose a couple of kilos while doing weight training (cos I love it) but slightly lighter loads. what body builders call cutting i think. i then intend to slowly build up my strength and muscles. have a look at body building.com. i think you need to consider a specific program to get the results you want. changing your body composition is quite a science involving diet, training loads, patients and time. not to say that working out with the weights isnt fun and satisfying no matter wat
0 -
Take photos. I took no before or after photos of weight loss, until I started with a PT twice a week in March. She takes photos every session and texts them to me but I generally don’t look. (Still feel awkward looking at myself.)
I was down in the dumps because I felt I hadn’t lost much since March. I started going through photos on my phone, hoping to clean out some space.
I finally looked at those photos she’s been sending and I. could. NOT. believe. the. difference.
Thank goodness she took and shared them. They put an end to the second guessing and brought joy back to the process.
Now I look at her and smile when she takes them, instead of cringing.3 -
Thanks I'll start the photo trick 🙂0
-
I started working out 3months ago doing glute/leg focused training 3x weekly consistently with 1day intense cardio 30mins but my glutes are just still flabby and saggy and not perking up.
I'm 5'2 at 66kgs - My goal is to strengthen my saggy butt not really lose weight.
My weight has remained the same and clothes still fit the same even though I haven't measured.
I have been training very hard with progressive overload but change to physical appearance of my glutes is still minimum.
Is there something I'm doing wrong or is it early? Is there such as a waste of training?
I got training by PT at gym and exercises include: Hip thrusts, glute bridges, Leg press, Squats, Sumo Deadlift, Hip abduction, Hyper-extensions or Cable pull through as finishers
I'm so discouraged because I don't see changes Help please!
Physical changes with weight lifting take time...3 months isn't very much time...it's a drop in the bucket.2 -
You’re doing way to much to try and tone a specific area. Fat loss doesn’t work that way and muscle growth isn’t going to happen like you think.
The body will lose weight where it wants. Your body fat percentage is most likely too high which causes you to not be able to see the changes.
I’m assuming you’re female which means you don’t produce test levels like a male. You’re not going to see a huge level of mass gain in 3 months, 6 months etc. it’s a marathon not a race.
Muscle building has a lot to do with genetics and diet. You’re most likely overtraining the body and not giving it time to rebuild the micro tears.
If you break a bone the body rebuilds it back stronger. It does the same thing when you are weight lifting. You’re creating micro tears in the muscle that need to be repaired. I wouldn’t do what you’re doing with legs more then 1-2 times a week. Start incorporating other muscle groups as well such as chest, shoulders, arms, back, etc.
Just keep up the work and be happy with you. Results will come in time but you can’t rush it. I didn’t start benching 495 , squatting 675 or deadlifting 765 when I started lifting years ago. It took time to get there and build the muscle I needed.
2 -
I have been lifting for about a year. Started SUPER lightweight (couldn’t even lift the empty barbell to start) and have been adding weight EXTREMELY slowly and conservatively to avoid injury (which I’ve had in the past). I am now seeing some very exciting results, especially on my arms and back. Not a lot of “mass” but muscle definition and fat loss. But it took a long time (6-9 months) before I started seeing much significant change.5
-
Hello all,
I'm not highjacking the thread but just a thought. I'm the same height as the original poster but much leaner. so 5'2 and 53 kg. I have the very same problem as her. A very saggy butt and it's flat on top. So lowering body fat didn't help the appearance (in my case).I constantly try to activate my glutes when I squat, and doing clams and glute bridges etc ( all bodyweight btw) but I'm unable to activate them successfully. No matter which exercise I perform I never feel anything in my glutes either during or after the workout. Could this be the original poster's ( and so mine) issue? Not being able to activate them effectively?0 -
Hello all,
I'm not highjacking the thread but just a thought. I'm the same height as the original poster but much leaner. so 5'2 and 53 kg. I have the very same problem as her. A very saggy butt and it's flat on top. So lowering body fat didn't help the appearance (in my case).I constantly try to activate my glutes when I squat, and doing clams and glute bridges etc ( all bodyweight btw) but I'm unable to activate them successfully. No matter which exercise I perform I never feel anything in my glutes either during or after the workout. Could this be the original poster's ( and so mine) issue? Not being able to activate them effectively?
Before lifting I start with glute activation exercises usually 7-10mins on threadmill followed by 2sets of clams, glute bridges, hyper-extensions, kickbacks, crabwalks (I choose 3 not all)
I still am not seeing the lift just where the butt starts(lower glute area) where it connects to hamstring its flabby, I do have volume at the top I'm ok with. I'm continuing with progressive lifting and lower calories to drop body fat and monitor every 3months......fingers crossed1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions