What sorcery is this?
bidingmytime
Posts: 129 Member
Anyone ever step on the scale in the morning, get your number, then go use the restroom, come back expecting to see a lower number, but you've actually gained weight?
This happens all of the time to me. I would assume that my scale is not accurate, however, when I don't use the restroom and re-weigh myself within a few minutes, the weight is consistent. It's only inconsistent, it seems, after having used the restroom.
This happens all of the time to me. I would assume that my scale is not accurate, however, when I don't use the restroom and re-weigh myself within a few minutes, the weight is consistent. It's only inconsistent, it seems, after having used the restroom.
2
Replies
-
I love it anytime anyone uses that gif.
And I only weigh myself once a day. Keeping it simple, one day at a time.6 -
bidingmytime wrote: »Anyone ever step on the scale in the morning, get your number, then go use the restroom, come back expecting to see a lower number, but you've actually gained weight?
This happens all of the time to me. I would assume that my scale is not accurate, however, when I don't use the restroom and re-weigh myself within a few minutes, the weight is consistent. It's only inconsistent, it seems, after having used the restroom.
My scale reads +3lbs the first time you step on it in the morning. Step off and wait for the display to dim, then it reads 3lbs lower every time. I discovered this doing the same experiment you speak of. I was shocked for a long time at a 3lb loss after a wee bit of wee.0 -
The gif is broken on my machine.
Anyway: Run-of-the mill digital scales have an accuracy of about +/- .25lb. They have a display resolution of .1lb which exceeds their accuracy. (Some scales don't report in .1lb increments, but many do.)
It would annoy some people if you stepped on and off and got a different value every time, although this would be entirely reasonable given the above specs. So, many scales remember the most recent value and pick it preferentially unless your weight has change by more than the accuracy spec. Now you will see exactly the same weight if you weigh yourself multiple times in a row, making you feel like your scale is accurate to within it's resolution of .1lb.
To test your scale, try weighing yourself with and without something that weighs more than a pound (like a big shampoo bottle). Does it return to the same value every time you put the bottle down? (Mine doesn't.)4 -
Yes.
0 -
Fluid fluctuations1
-
cmriverside wrote: »I love it anytime anyone uses that gif.
And I only weigh myself once a day. Keeping it simple, one day at a time.
Yes, great gif.George_of_the_Jungle wrote: »My scale reads +3lbs the first time you step on it in the morning. Step off and wait for the display to dim, then it reads 3lbs lower every time. I discovered this doing the same experiment you speak of. I was shocked for a long time at a 3lb loss after a wee bit of wee.
Yes, mine, too. However, my issue was that I'd weigh *more* after the initial weigh-in from going to the restroom. That's my conundrum.Jthanmyfitnesspal wrote: »The gif is broken on my machine.
Anyway: Run-of-the mill digital scales have an accuracy of about +/- .25lb. They have a display resolution of .1lb which exceeds their accuracy. (Some scales don't report in .1lb increments, but many do.)
It would annoy some people if you stepped on and off and got a different value every time, although this would be entirely reasonable given the above specs. So, many scales remember the most recent value and pick it preferentially unless your weight has change by more than the accuracy spec. Now you will see exactly the same weight if you weigh yourself multiple times in a row, making you feel like your scale is accurate to within it's resolution of .1lb.
To test your scale, try weighing yourself with and without something that weighs more than a pound (like a big shampoo bottle). Does it return to the same value every time you put the bottle down? (Mine doesn't.)
Wow, that's actually really insightful and helpful. Thank you for that. Makes a lot of sense now as to why this happens.corinasue1143 wrote: »Yes.
Glad I'm not the only one!
angelexperiment wrote: »Fluid fluctuations
Yes, just strange that I'd release liquid, then suddenly have *more* in me when I'd weigh in the second time.1 -
Ok I have actually tested this many times and I'm glad I'm not alone! People think I'm crazy. Lol1
-
Jthanmyfitnesspal wrote: »The gif is broken on my machine.
Anyway: Run-of-the mill digital scales have an accuracy of about +/- .25lb. They have a display resolution of .1lb which exceeds their accuracy. (Some scales don't report in .1lb increments, but many do.)
It would annoy some people if you stepped on and off and got a different value every time, although this would be entirely reasonable given the above specs. So, many scales remember the most recent value and pick it preferentially unless your weight has change by more than the accuracy spec. Now you will see exactly the same weight if you weigh yourself multiple times in a row, making you feel like your scale is accurate to within it's resolution of .1lb.
To test your scale, try weighing yourself with and without something that weighs more than a pound (like a big shampoo bottle). Does it return to the same value every time you put the bottle down? (Mine doesn't.)
Taking that the scale could be off each time. Why would it always go up and not just be more random up or down?1 -
George_of_the_Jungle wrote: »My scale reads +3lbs the first time you step on it in the morning. Step off and wait for the display to dim, then it reads 3lbs lower every time. I discovered this doing the same experiment you speak of. I was shocked for a long time at a 3lb loss after a wee bit of wee.
Mine does exactly the same thing. I always just stick one foot on it first to get some random reading before reseting and actually stepping on it.
0 -
cmriverside wrote: »I love it anytime anyone uses that gif.
And I only weigh myself once a day. Keeping it simple, one day at a time.
I love the good Captain.0 -
Even after, we expel urine & feces via our body, there's still some that remains within us. My guess' that due to gravity moving what remains along thereafter, the motion within us' equivalent to moving the scale outta place.0
-
When you use the toilet, you weight definitely goes down. The only excuse for your scale showing it as higher is if it has changed, but it is still with the scale's margin of error (typ +/- .25lbs). Anyway, if you don't trust your scale, because it is doing weird things (such as you describe), buy a new one. I have this one, for example (cost<$20).
EatSmart Precision Digital Bathroom Scale with Extra Large Lighted Display, Free Body Tape Measure Included
by Amazon.com
Learn more: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001KXZ808/ref=cm_sw_em_r_mt_dp_U_W0RvEb80XK0FF
3 -
@bidingmytime totally OT, but your avatar is from the book about a little girl with anemia who becomes a ballerina, right? I don’t remember the name, but my parents gave it to me when I was a little kid with anemia.
I LOVED that book!1 -
Jthanmyfitnesspal wrote: »When you use the toilet, you weight definitely goes down. The only excuse for your scale showing it as higher is if it has changed, but it is still with the scale's margin of error (typ +/- .25lbs). Anyway, if you don't trust your scale, because it is doing weird things (such as you describe), buy a new one. I have this one, for example (cost<$20).
EatSmart Precision Digital Bathroom Scale with Extra Large Lighted Display, Free Body Tape Measure Included
by Amazon.com
Learn more: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001KXZ808/ref=cm_sw_em_r_mt_dp_U_W0RvEb80XK0FF
Thank you for the recommendation! Yeah, scales can be quite strange!springlering62 wrote: »@bidingmytime totally OT, but your avatar is from the book about a little girl with anemia who becomes a ballerina, right? I don’t remember the name, but my parents gave it to me when I was a little kid with anemia.
I LOVED that book!
Honestly, I do not know! I just found the picture online and liked it. I'll have to look up that book though!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions