Do you plan or wing it?
lauragreenbaum
Posts: 1,017 Member
This has probably been asked before, so please don't yell at me if so. :-) Do you plan your meals out each day or do you just wing it and add up the calories as you go? If you do plan, are you able to stick with your daily menu or do you sometimes go off it or change it?
Asking because I find I can stick to my calorie goals much better if I plan my meals for the day. It's easier now with the Covid lockdown because I'm home much more- I used to travel 30% of the time which made meal planning difficult.
Asking because I find I can stick to my calorie goals much better if I plan my meals for the day. It's easier now with the Covid lockdown because I'm home much more- I used to travel 30% of the time which made meal planning difficult.
1
Replies
-
Mixture. Which I know might not be helpful!
I plan meals most of the time but don't plan the calories in as such until the morning. Then I know how much leeway I have for snacks and other things.1 -
I plan seven meals. Usually stick to the menu, but lunch is unplanned, depends on leftovers (often make extra portions for this) and what needs eating in the fridge0
-
My meals are planned just simply for shopping purposes: I know which ingredients will be used for the hot meals. But I don't know the calorie count beforehand, so I'll take an appropriate portion (or a good guess, if I haven't entered the recipe yet) and then my evening snack will be adapted to fit the remaining calories.
Bread meals are not planned, I just calculate as I go and choose from the toppings available that day. I stop at a certain amount of calories (more or less).
Breakfast is fairly routine.
Snacks are variable depending on what I feel like and how many calories I have left. But I always have a varied stock to choose from.0 -
I meal prep so I have some Grab-N-Go meals on hand, Mix-N-Match, throw 'em in the oven and kick the door shut. I don't really fly by the seat of my pants because that got me nowhere good.1
-
I pre-log the day before so I can see right away if something I'm planning is way too many calories or will take me outside of my macro comfort zone. I do allow myself to make some changes the day of, but it's usually pretty limited.3
-
Both. Usually breakfast is, "What sounds good?" After breakfast I'll log dinner and my afternoon tea. That will usually leave me 500, "discretionary," calories which I'll use either as midday snack, dessert or after dinner snack or both but I don't pre-log those.1
-
Plan. Adjust on the fly when necessary/convenient/appealing.1
-
I plan a week ahead of time and then adjust amounts as I go. But I don't get too concerned if something happens and I have to change things up.
I find I stay on track better planning ahead and it really helps keep me organized through the week and for grocery shopping. My husband can't cook and it really helps me to do the prep work for the next day breakfasts and lunches in the evening so I'm not scrambling early in the morning or as soon as I get home from work.
I'm a little more lax on weekends - I have dinners planned but kind of wing it for earlier in the day.0 -
I am somewhere in the middle.
I have certain things I keep on hand and typically will have for weekday breakfasts, snacks, lunch. Dinner varies a bit more but I Try to have an idea of what is for dinner either the day before, or by midday. I prelog and then make changes as I go. Sometimes that is just updating weights of foods, and sometimes snacks and meals change completely.
My weekends are a little less predictable.
Prelogging gives me an idea of what calories I have to work with.0 -
I occasionally planned when I was losing and this was especially true when I had a batch of cooked stuff.
I definitely test entered items in my diary before eating while I was losing so that's another situation that I would call "fully" planned. Occasionally I still do this (test enter)
I usually have a collection of shelf stable, canned, frozen or fridge items that I know the approximate caloric count of cobbling them together in a "meal".
Some of them (canned soups, or shelf stable pouches of heat and serve Indian food, or frozen entrees) I deliberately pick in a variety of calorie counts to have the option to choose at prep time. Same applies to canned fish (tuna for low cal, salmon for high cal) that can quickly go on a slaw and tomato and onion and what have you salad
Frozen veggies in boxed mashed, onion & coleslaw or frozen veggies in hot and sour rice noodle soup, or my staple 650g 0% fruit yogurt mixed with cereal and a refrigerated jello pudding are examples of such meals during the past 2-3 days. Threw some frozen shrimp in the soup the other day for extra protein. High end cuisine it ain't, I leave that for special occasion!
So in that sense there does exist a vague plan of having things around that can make reasonably filling meals in the 500 to sub 1000 cal range and snacks in the 150-350 range.
Which also brings up that both during weight loss and now I am consuming in the 2500+ range, which does make it easier to get away with the occasional sub optimal choice.
While all this is definitely more planned than at any other time in my life, currently, as I am sitting here writing this, the only thing I **know** I will be eating today is the coffee in my hand! I haven't even decided if I am going to have breakfast or wait for lunch!
But I do log! Everything. By weight whenever I can!
🤷♂️1 -
My freezer, frig and pantry are always full w/food that I want to cook/eat but I generally don't do much meal planning, except to defrost any meat/seafood that I think I'll want 2 eat in the next day or so. Otherwise, I just cook whatever tickles my fancy when I get hungry and it's time to eat.1
-
I log after I eat, but I do tend to make the same dinners weekly (and eat leftovers for lunch) so I know it all will fit into my daily/weekly calorie goal.0
-
Not really. Breakfast is usually the same thing every morning. Normally I figure out what I want for my dinner around mid morning and log an estimate of how much I will consume in MFP then I make adjustments if needed during the meal. That way I know how many calories I have for lunch and snacks.0
-
Definitely in the "wing it" camp. That said, by preference I tend to have consistent breakfast/lunch choices, and most of the variety is at dinner. (This has always been true for me, regardless of weight. I'm a night owl. I don't cope well with choices in the first half of the day, and tend to stick to easy, comforting routines ).
As with many other things about weight management, I think understanding one's own preferences, limitations, strengths, and personality is really important. Tailoring strategy to oneself is a success strategy, IMO.2 -
My freezer, frig and pantry are always full w/food that I want to cook/eat but I generally don't do much meal planning, except to defrost any meat/seafood that I think I'll want 2 eat in the next day or so. Otherwise, I just cook whatever tickles my fancy when I get hungry and it's time to eat.
This is me as well.0 -
I've kind of settled into a food routine so I have a pretty good idea what my day will look like most of the time. Breakfast is usually the same thing probably 5 days a week, I have 1 or 2 others that I will sub in and out as I like. Lunch is pretty much one or two options (I brown bag it to work) so I am pretty much within a certain "range" by the end of the day. Snacks are the same, I rotate through a few favorites. dinner is the wild card because my wife cooks that so I'm never quite sure what I'm having until I walk in to door. At best I can try to control the portion size if it's something way out of my league. If its a lighter choice I can always grab a snack to up my calories before bed, too.
So in short, I'm pretty much planned out for the most part, but I always have to adjust a bit on the fly at the end of the day (unless I'm off and I'm cooking/barbecuing).
Side note: At work today and folks decided to get sushi so I jumped in. Had a tuna/avocado roll that was unplanned. Figured about 250-280 calories. I adjusted my day "on the fly"!0 -
lauragreenbaum wrote: »This has probably been asked before, so please don't yell at me if so. :-) Do you plan your meals out each day or do you just wing it and add up the calories as you go? If you do plan, are you able to stick with your daily menu or do you sometimes go off it or change it?
Asking because I find I can stick to my calorie goals much better if I plan my meals for the day. It's easier now with the Covid lockdown because I'm home much more- I used to travel 30% of the time which made meal planning difficult.
I plan as much as possible because when I wing it my diet is atrocious (see today's diary for example). I'm also only cooking for one, so planning ahead helps me reduce food waste to practically nothing.1 -
I have the same breakfast and lunch options daily during the week but dinner is 100% on the fly. Usually when I get home is when we decide on what to eat. I never know what I am going to be in the mood for or feel like cooking. I make sure I have plenty of calories for the end of the day meal and if I need extra then I go for a walk to earn some extra.0
-
I wing it, I’ve always found that if I plan ahead I’m 100% not going to want to eat what I’ve planned when the time comes.
I don’t eat breakfast, never have. Lunch is varied around a few vague templates - depending on what I have to use up. Usually between 150 - 250 cals.
Sometimes I’ll grab some fruit before starting to cook dinner for the family. I’m vegetarian so it suits me to cater separately. Generally, I’ll go the fruit route if their meal involves cheese as the fruit helps me to resist nibbling! If it’s a more meat based dish I’m not tempted! 😂
Then a couple of hours after I’ve cleared up I’ll start to cook for myself. This means I’m eating around 8:30pm which leaves no room for feeling ‘snacky’ before bed.
How much effort I put into my dinner varies but it generally comes in anywhere between 350 - 450 cals. Add a glass of red wine and I’m done for the day.0 -
Semi planned. It's on the fly, but breakfast and lunch especially are a rotation of 4 or 5 options which are roughly the same macros.0
-
I'm a wing it girl. I usually have oatmeal for breakfast but after that I have a few things on hand and whatever I feel like for lunch or dinner I'll make. For example, the last two night I had eggs. My plan was to make ham sandwiches but on the way home eggs sounded better..
Every time I pre log a meal I always change it on the fly. Every. single. time.0 -
I usually pre-log the entire day the night before. But I'm one of those weird, odd creatures that likes to eat a lot of the same things day after day. I'll go through waves where I rotate a handful of things and then remove or add something to that rotation as i get tired of something. But eventually that item works itself right back into the rotation at some point though, and the cycle continues. Lol.0
-
I have a two-week rotating meal plan, my breakfast, lunch and dinner are fixed and I can swap and change the snacks between days depending on how I feel.
I find having a fixed meal plan really helps me stick to it because I know what meal is coming and I know what I have to eat, less likely I will go off the rails
I am also starting to get confident with eating out on occasions, I can identify foods that will be in line with my goals and make educated decisions on what I am eating.0 -
I mostly plan because I’m only eating one meal a day and I have a family to cook for. So I buy groceries and plan out dinners. But there are also a couple nights a week, usually weekends, when we just wing it and pick up something from a restaurant.0
-
I plan, I know what I'm eating tomorrow but I leave 200-300 calories open to whims.0
-
BarbaraHelen2013 wrote: »I wing it, I’ve always found that if I plan ahead I’m 100% not going to want to eat what I’ve planned when the time comes.
I don’t eat breakfast, never have. Lunch is varied around a few vague templates - depending on what I have to use up. Usually between 150 - 250 cals.
Sometimes I’ll grab some fruit before starting to cook dinner for the family. I’m vegetarian so it suits me to cater separately. Generally, I’ll go the fruit route if their meal involves cheese as the fruit helps me to resist nibbling! If it’s a more meat based dish I’m not tempted! 😂
Then a couple of hours after I’ve cleared up I’ll start to cook for myself. This means I’m eating around 8:30pm which leaves no room for feeling ‘snacky’ before bed.
How much effort I put into my dinner varies but it generally comes in anywhere between 350 - 450 cals. Add a glass of red wine and I’m done for the day.
Based on this post you're not eating enough food!😲2 -
I don’t plan the calories per se but evening meals are planned out for the week during shopping as we have a family to cater for.
I tend to have the same breakfast each day - either toast with butter or I’ll have a pack of breakfast bars/biscuits to hand. Lunch’s are on the fly and I just pack a few things until it hits between 5-600 cals depending on what the evening meal plan is (pretty good at estimating the likely calorie total of meals now 😂)0 -
I usually plan out what I'm going have the next day at least the night before. Then when the next day actually comes, sometimes I change my mind and something else sounds better. In those cases I change my diary before I eat so I can make sure it still fits into my calorie day/doesn't have a big impact on what else I can eat that day.0
-
I eat relatively the same thing every day so it’s easy. Sometimes I substitute if I feel like it or I bank calories for a special meal but otherwise it’s pretty same ol’ same ol’0
-
I’m a wing it sort of girl which works in favour for me mentally but not as good physically. What I’ve started to do is meal prep some meat kebabs and fish cakes in the freezer and some home made frozen veg packets all weighed and portioned out. I still prefer fresh foods so it’s only good when I’ve run out of fresh food. I make yummy simple meals like stirfry veg and fish, oats, roast veg, pasta, quinoa, eggs etc so it’s easier to track the calories of the food. I’ve also bought some yoghurt pots which I can have with seeds and fruit for a quick snack/mini meal.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions