Am I in the clear?
ChickenKillerPuppy
Posts: 297 Member
Drank and ate too much last night. About 3,500 calories and I usually consume an average of 2100/day to maintain, but I tend to eat less than that during the week so I can eat more on the weekends (hence the average).
Had whiskey and a lot of chocolate last night. Got up and weighed myself this morning and I weigh exactly what I did yesterday morning. If I just eat my normal maintenance calories today as I planned (or a slight deficit), you think I’m in the clear for las night’s indulgence, or is it going to show up tomorrow or in a few days?
Obviously only time will tell but curious to see what people think!
Had whiskey and a lot of chocolate last night. Got up and weighed myself this morning and I weigh exactly what I did yesterday morning. If I just eat my normal maintenance calories today as I planned (or a slight deficit), you think I’m in the clear for las night’s indulgence, or is it going to show up tomorrow or in a few days?
Obviously only time will tell but curious to see what people think!
2
Replies
-
It may show up. You may be dehydrated a bit this morning. It's only an extra 1400 calories ( a little over 1/2 a pound) over your 2100 so isn't much in the grand scheme of things unless you do it repeatedly and often.5
-
Usually after drinking you can actually weigh less due to dehydration, but I think you're fine.
I practice something similar and last weekend I had cake, ice cream, an entire bottle of rum and still managed to come across with -1.0 lbs today (my login day).
And even if not, don't worry about it. Just avoid making it habitual.2 -
Well.
You'll know in a day or two.
I wouldn't think any more of it, life happens.4 -
Hard to tell, but for sure not worth worrying over.
I'm in year 4+ of maintenance. I calorie bank, and have some over-goal days. The latter are spaced out, so I've basically simulated what you say you did, in my body (sometimes with substantially more than 1400 extra calories above maintenance, BTW). I generally just to go back to my regular routine afterward (so 150 or so calories under where I think my maintenance is, as that's my bank-deposit routine deficit). If I'm less hungry that day, I'll eat accordingly, but I don't make any other attempt to "make up for it".
Usually, I see a big-ish scale bump the next day (which you didn't, but as others said, that could be dehydration). Usually, that next day, my resting heart rate is up a bit, by anything from a few to 10bpm. Subjectively, I may be a little likelier than normal to feel hot (like hot flashes). Other than that, I don't usually perceive any kind of energy jump the next day, but maybe there's something happening.
Even if I ate enough over goal to gain a pound or more of fat (which I have done quite a number of times), I can't think of a case where the total gain seems to be as much as the raw number of calories would suggest, if this is a rare event. This, even though "3500 calories = 1 pound" works out pretty close for me in slow gain/loss situations. (I wonder whether some of the calories are not extracted during digestive transit, when eating dramatically more than my body is accustomed to eating. 🤷♀️)
I've seen at least 2 other people here report pretty much what I said above, about their experience - less gain than expected from a big day. I've seen one person report the exact opposite, that they gain more than expected from a big over-maintenance day, after the water weight settles out.
So, bodies are weird. You're running your n=1 experiment. You can learn how your body responds, which will be useful info. I don't know whether you're a daily weigher, but if you're not, and the scale isn't too stressy for you, this might be an educational time to weigh daily for a week or two.
FWIW, I posted a "case study" of a long weekend of over-goal eating for me, with calorie estimates and weights for about a week: https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10603949/big-overfeed-ruins-everything-nope
If you feel like it, let us know how this works out, eh? 🙂3 -
It shows up later, at least for me. But, so what?
Do you expect to weight the same every day? To never eat more one or two days and a bit less on a couple of others?
Dampen the perturbation. Don't chase the ball. Aim for generally normal.
Don't overcorrect but also don't refuse easy pickings.... I wouldn't go out of my way to replace a meal I might have missed while sleeping off my indulgences, but I would view that differently as compared to deliberately trying to create a deficit to compensate.
beyond that... that's why you observe your weight trend change over time as opposed to your daily weight...5 -
Personally I see the increase (if any) about a week after. I see the effects of what I was eating about a week delayed. So if I have an indulgence I usually see it about a week later. It takes time for the body to convert extra energy to fat. You weren't much over so you may just naturally expend a bit more energy the next few days (extra walking here and there, etc) and may see nothing. That is what usually happens for me.1
-
Thanks everyone! I really was just curious - I’m not concerned at all. I have gone on vacations and totally indulged and have gotten back on track and all that - just was nice to see no change in the scale. But it’s all good - I weigh myself every day so yes, of course I know my weight changes every day. I guess we will see!3
-
I tend to find that it takes a couple of days for the weight to show up if I have a binge.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions