Warrior Fast
Seabassx2
Posts: 33 Member
4
Replies
-
"The Warrior Diet is based on the eating patterns of ancient warriors, who consumed little during the day and then feasted at night."
I'd be skeptical about anyone who made sweeping claims like this about how a certain class of people ate across broad portions of the world over a wide span of time.27 -
Some random dude made this up. Even he admits it’s not based on science. If you’re having fun, go ahead, but otherwise there are probably more effective ways to get results.12
-
rheddmobile wrote: »Some random dude made this up. Even he admits it’s not based on science. If you’re having fun, go ahead, but otherwise there are probably more effective ways to get results.
Given that last time I looked at it it smelled like an aggressive VLCD, you have to qualify the "effective" you're using and call it "long term effective". Because in the short term VLCD.... well... that's how you get millions of lbs lost for a day or two, rinse, lather, repeat.
To the benefit of the above link, the discussion was about an aggressive (20:4) IF protocol with no VLCD spotted during my skim read.
Some people do find IF methods of eating beneficial in controlling calories. Skipping breakfast or lunch are things I commonly do myself, even though they wouldn't be named IF.
Given the anecdotal evidence from people who try IF protocols on MFP, I would suggest a willingness to be flexible with timing in favor of sustainability while keeping in mind that it is total calories that matter for weight loss.4 -
It is really just a 20:4 fast..
I'm using an app called ZOOM to track my fasting. ZOOM is basically just a fancy timer..... LOL..... not sure how long I will use it.
I started this fasting thing 4 days ago....
Fasting is a way to reduce calories, but is also a mental challenge.
My goal is to lose weight.
3 -
ZERO no ZOOM for the fasting app.0
-
It is really just a 20:4 fast..
I'm using an app called ZOOM to track my fasting. ZOOM is basically just a fancy timer..... LOL..... not sure how long I will use it.
I started this fasting thing 4 days ago....
Fasting is a way to reduce calories, but is also a mental challenge.
My goal is to lose weight.
My take: my life provides enough mental challenges. I don't need my weight management technique to be an extra one.
(Others may have different preferences, obviously).11 -
I gave you a hug because you're just making your way down the chute. The warrior diet is imaginary nonsense. There. I said it. I could tell you how I know but we simply haven't got the time.
There's a good reason we call it a weight loss battle because humans will rise to the occasion and fight. Tell any of us we can't do something and we are going to prove you wrong. When the battle is over we often get bored in times of too much peace. That's just human nature.
All of us fighting for our health are indeed, warriors. Battle-tested and road weary, we keep going and going. Find your balance. Maintain your focus. You'll probably get bored with the warrior diet. Just trade that in for tracking your data points.
7 -
It is really just a 20:4 fast..
I'm using an app called ZOOM to track my fasting. ZOOM is basically just a fancy timer..... LOL..... not sure how long I will use it.
I started this fasting thing 4 days ago....
Fasting is a way to reduce calories, but is also a mental challenge.
My goal is to lose weight.
Why not just call it 20:4 IF then???
Which is a style of eating that suits some people -although I am not one of them.
Also have enough mental challenges in life without adding another random useless one.
8 -
Maybe not a useless challenge; I did the warrior diet and some longer (48 hour) fasts back when I was doing a lot of wilderness hiking/search and rescue. I wanted to know if I could function without food in an emergency.
Might be a useful skill for when the zombies come 😉2 -
I did the 20:4 (warrior) fast 5 days last week. Ate 1 meal a day around 4:00. Definitely consumer fewer calories. Lost a few lbs. Felt good. Definitely will be doing additional fasting and tracking with the ZERO app. I also logged 10k steps every day. Will increase my walking pace a little.5
-
I read the book when it first came out, only because someone had read it and told me, heh look, this guy wrote a book about how you eat.
I was a faster by choice most of my life. His book was about fasting, so I enjoyed it.
Is fasting magical for weigh loss? Not in my opinion. Does it have health benefits? Yes, in my opinion.
So much research has been done about the health benefits of fasting. Many, many have been done by our US government.
Why don’t they share these research results with the general public? There’s no money in it. Pure and simple.
The one thing I have kept from reading the Warrior Diet by Ori Hofmekler, and still incorporate in my daily life is the breaking of your fast.
Start with raw fruit or veges or fresh juicing.
Then cooked vegetables. Then your protein.
Then your carbs last. I’ve never felt healthier than when I incorporate this style of eating.4 -
frankiesgirlie wrote: »I read the book when it first came out, only because someone had read it and told me, heh look, this guy wrote a book about how you eat.
I was a faster by choice most of my life. His book was about fasting, so I enjoyed it.
Is fasting magical for weigh loss? Not in my opinion. Does it have health benefits? Yes, in my opinion.
So much research has been done about the health benefits of fasting. Many, many have been done by our US government.
Why don’t they share these research results with the general public? There’s no money in it. Pure and simple.
The one thing I have kept from reading the Warrior Diet by Ori Hofmekler, and still incorporate in my daily life is the breaking of your fast.
Start with raw fruit or veges or fresh juicing.
Then cooked vegetables. Then your protein.
Then your carbs last. I’ve never felt healthier than when I incorporate this style of eating.
If these studies are being deliberately hidden from the public, how did you find out about them?7 -
janejellyroll wrote: »frankiesgirlie wrote: »I read the book when it first came out, only because someone had read it and told me, heh look, this guy wrote a book about how you eat.
I was a faster by choice most of my life. His book was about fasting, so I enjoyed it.
Is fasting magical for weigh loss? Not in my opinion. Does it have health benefits? Yes, in my opinion.
So much research has been done about the health benefits of fasting. Many, many have been done by our US government.
Why don’t they share these research results with the general public? There’s no money in it. Pure and simple.
The one thing I have kept from reading the Warrior Diet by Ori Hofmekler, and still incorporate in my daily life is the breaking of your fast.
Start with raw fruit or veges or fresh juicing.
Then cooked vegetables. Then your protein.
Then your carbs last. I’ve never felt healthier than when I incorporate this style of eating.
If these studies are being deliberately hidden from the public, how did you find out about them?
Obviously this person has magical powers and can’t reveal their secrets. 😜5 -
There are thousands of different ideas that if you did them you would lose SOME weight in the beginning. What makes an idea good, or at least good enough, is whether or not it is sustainable. It is impossible to know for sure what will be and what won't be sustainable for several months if you drastically change the way you eat. You can hope you can stick with it but only time will tell.
I am not telling you this to rain on your parade but I strongly suggest you don't get so invested in this plan that you do not adapt or change if time proves this is not your answer. People lose weight eating 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and maybe more meals a day too.
This is one path. Not the only path.
Good luck.3
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions