Calories of bread crust
Meihuii
Posts: 4 Member
I only eat the bread crust, so I took many slices of bread but ate just the crust, will this habit sabotage my weight loss plan?
0
Replies
-
Bread crust has the same calories as the rest of the bread. Weigh the portion you are going to eat and that will tell you how many calories you are eating. Maintaining a deficit is how you lose weight.
I'd be more concerned about the waste involved in tossing most of a loaf of bread and only eating the crust.14 -
I totally applaud everyone that eats breadcrust! Because it's delicious if it's proper crust.
However the crust has the same calories as the rest of the bread. Thus weight it and use the calories for this bread. Oh, and please don't throw out the bread. Poor bread
4 -
Thanks for the info! No worries the rest of the bread is eaten by fam since i cut out the crust!1
-
I'm glad others responded nicely. My first instinct was to tell you that you were doomed... 😊😂
Clearly you're not... But still... Kinda hard to resist a slight tease!3 -
take your crusts and weigh them. Look at what the weight is (in grams) for a slice of bread. Do the math and you'll have your answer...6
-
@Meihuii I'm curious, why only the crust. Why not throw a couple pieces of bread under the broiler or in the toaster and eat the whole slice and save other slices for the family, intact. It's kind of like taking a bite out of every chocolate in the box and giving it to the family for a present. You have to tear those crusts off with your fingers. There's no way I'm coming behind someone and eating only the crumbs that are left over. Give me the whole slice or give me nothing.4
-
Diatonic12 wrote: »@Meihuii I'm curious, why only the crust. Why not throw a couple pieces of bread under the broiler or in the toaster and eat the whole slice and save other slices for the family, intact. It's kind of like taking a bite out of every chocolate in the box and giving it to the family for a present. You have to tear those crusts off with your fingers. There's no way I'm coming behind someone and eating only the crumbs that are left over. Give me the whole slice or give me nothing.
Wait so you DONT want me to sample every chocolate in the box first??? 😜2 -
Funniest diet question of the year contender!9
-
@Dogmom1978
You know what I would do with that dough ball of bread? I would roll it up in a ball and let it bounce out the door. I would let it roll on down the mountain and then go find it and stomp on it.
Dogmom, it reminds me of someone who came over to our house for breakfast. Maw made center cut pork chops, grits, eggs, sourdough biscuits, the works. This person ate all of the centers out of the pork chops and threw the rest on the plate for us. That was the last time they were ever invited over for anything. It's respect to take your portion and leave the rest for the dear loved ones.
Diet sabotage would be the least of the worries here. I would refrain but the temptation would be great to bounce the dough ball off of someone's head a few times.
2 -
Speculatively, I'd guess that the crust has *slightly more* calories, gram for gram, than the middle part of the bread.
Why? Less airy, more dehydrated (browned) so less water in the weight.
Not enough to make a practical difference though: I'd still just weigh the portion eaten, and log it as that amount of bread. Plenty close enough. 😉11 -
Speculatively, I'd guess that the crust has *slightly more* calories, gram for gram, than the middle part of the bread.
Why? Less airy, more dehydrated (browned) so less water in the weight.
Not enough to make a practical difference though: I'd still just weigh the portion eaten, and log it as that amount of bread. Plenty close enough. 😉
I actually wonder if the crust might have less calories as a bit might get burned when baking the bread. At least at a proper bakery. But that aside, provided there are no seeds or nuts on the outside of the bread it should be pretty much the same. Oh, and fresh baked bread with a proper crust IS heaven. The end pieces are always mine!1 -
A proper bakery has bread with a crispy crust, not burned
I'm on the same page as AnnPT77, I'd say there's a bit less moisture, so a bit more calories for the same weight.
I log a few extra grams when I eat a bread crust, for that reason. Especially our homemade bread, which has a much thicker and crispier crust.4 -
Honestly though... 2 calories? 5 calories? 10 calories?
You're never going to get that precise with your logging. If you obsess that heavily with your logging, it's going to be unmanageable over the long term. If in doubt, pick the higher cals and move on.
I applaud you for your dedication but I think your focus may be a bit misdirected.5 -
KickassAmazon76 wrote: »Honestly though... 2 calories? 5 calories? 10 calories?
You're never going to get that precise with your logging. If you obsess that heavily with your logging, it's going to be unmanageable over the long term. If in doubt, pick the higher cals and move on.
I applaud you for your dedication but I think your focus may be a bit misdirected.
Is that directed at me? My focus is fine, logging some extra calories for crusts doesn't require extra effort and doesn't detract in any way from anything else I do for weight loss.2 -
(Hopefully) a useful tip: if you don't like bread crusts, grate them up and dry them, it's a really cheap way to get breadcrumbs.2
-
-
Except she only likes the crusts, lol!
Oh, my bad! I guess I read this entire thread completely backwards. I guess the breadcrumbs would still work on the innards haha3 -
Depends, what is your weight loss plan?1
-
KickassAmazon76 wrote: »Honestly though... 2 calories? 5 calories? 10 calories?
You're never going to get that precise with your logging. If you obsess that heavily with your logging, it's going to be unmanageable over the long term. If in doubt, pick the higher cals and move on.
I applaud you for your dedication but I think your focus may be a bit misdirected.
I have concerns with your dismissing contributions to one's tracking. The OP stated many slices of bread. How many is many? Vocabulary wise, many is not two. It is defined as "being one of a large but indefinite number". So if the OP is being accurate in their statement, I would state that eating a "large number" of bread crust should be tracked, while if it were the crust off one slice I would not worry. And I agree with other posters that the easiest solution is to track them by weight.
4 -
KickassAmazon76 wrote: »Honestly though... 2 calories? 5 calories? 10 calories?
You're never going to get that precise with your logging. If you obsess that heavily with your logging, it's going to be unmanageable over the long term. If in doubt, pick the higher cals and move on.
I applaud you for your dedication but I think your focus may be a bit misdirected.
I have concerns with your dismissing contributions to one's tracking. The OP stated many slices of bread. How many is many? Vocabulary wise, many is not two. It is defined as "being one of a large but indefinite number". So if the OP is being accurate in their statement, I would state that eating a "large number" of bread crust should be tracked, while if it were the crust off one slice I would not worry. And I agree with other posters that the easiest solution is to track them by weight.
I'm not dismissing tracking entirely. I was just saying that in all reality the difference in calories between say 100g of crust vs 100g of crustless bread vs 100g of bread with both... is likely quite negligible.
If they scan the bar code on the bag and log what they ate based on weight... They'll probably be more than fine.
Most of our calorie inaccuracies come from people who just eyeball portions and assume 1 serving is three times more than what it is.
But it's no big deal... It was just my opinion. My apologies if it was not clear enough and thank you for your comment.
7 -
KickassAmazon76 wrote: »KickassAmazon76 wrote: »Honestly though... 2 calories? 5 calories? 10 calories?
You're never going to get that precise with your logging. If you obsess that heavily with your logging, it's going to be unmanageable over the long term. If in doubt, pick the higher cals and move on.
I applaud you for your dedication but I think your focus may be a bit misdirected.
I have concerns with your dismissing contributions to one's tracking. The OP stated many slices of bread. How many is many? Vocabulary wise, many is not two. It is defined as "being one of a large but indefinite number". So if the OP is being accurate in their statement, I would state that eating a "large number" of bread crust should be tracked, while if it were the crust off one slice I would not worry. And I agree with other posters that the easiest solution is to track them by weight.
I'm not dismissing tracking entirely. I was just saying that in all reality the difference in calories between say 100g of crust vs 100g of crustless bread vs 100g of bread with both... is likely quite negligible.
If they scan the bar code on the bag and log what they ate based on weight... They'll probably be more than fine.
Most of our calorie inaccuracies come from people who just eyeball portions and assume 1 serving is three times more than what it is.
But it's no big deal... It was just my opinion. My apologies if it was not clear enough and thank you for your comment.
I thoroughly agree that the 100g of bread whether crusts or whole is very similar from a calorie point of view I think you and I each interpreted the Op's question differently. When I look back at it again, I have no clue which interpretation is correct.
4 -
Bread dooms me. When good bread flour, water, salt and yeast get together and do their thing for a few hours, the resulting product and its lovely chewy crust call to the butter in the fridge and get together to undo me. Fresh bread, still warm from the oven with butter melting into it? Heaven.12
-
HeidiCooksSupper wrote: »Bread dooms me. When good bread flour, water, salt and yeast get together and do their thing for a few hours, the resulting product and its lovely chewy crust call to the butter in the fridge and get together to undo me. Fresh bread, still warm from the oven with butter melting into it? Heaven.
I hear ya.2 -
-
HeidiCooksSupper wrote: »Bread dooms me. When good bread flour, water, salt and yeast get together and do their thing for a few hours, the resulting product and its lovely chewy crust call to the butter in the fridge and get together to undo me. Fresh bread, still warm from the oven with butter melting into it? Heaven.
I'm glad bread-making never became 'my thing' because I'd be in worse trouble than I am now.
I have a favorite bread, just a simple Italian off the shelf variety but even that, calls me to throw some in the toaster and slather with butter. Carbs. No matter what kind.
When I ran a daycare, kids were notorious for leaving their crusts on the plate. Into the blender it'd all go, to be crumbed up for the birds. Even my dh refuses to eat the heels of a loaf so if I don't eat them, to the birds they go.
When calories are important to me, I either avoid bread or buy the 45 cal. a slice kind.1 -
That's funny. I used to do that too. Tastes so good. But it's a sad waste. Some people would love to eat that slice of bread you are throwing away for their breakfast, lunch and dinner. 😢1
-
kristinetetteh wrote: »That's funny. I used to do that too. Tastes so good. But it's a sad waste. Some people would love to eat that slice of bread you are throwing away for their breakfast, lunch and dinner. 😢
Reread the OP. Others in the household are apparently willing to eat the crustless slices. Nothing is being thrown away
4 -
Any way you slice it the crust is more dehydrated and/or has fat brushed on it. This it is more likely to have more calories per gram on average than the more moist inside of the bread. Whether this matters or not... depends! For most, it probably doesn't.2
-
HeidiCooksSupper wrote: »Bread dooms me. When good bread flour, water, salt and yeast get together and do their thing for a few hours, the resulting product and its lovely chewy crust call to the butter in the fridge and get together to undo me. Fresh bread, still warm from the oven with butter melting into it? Heaven.
I'm glad bread-making never became 'my thing' because I'd be in worse trouble than I am now. I have a favorite bread, just a simple Italian off the shelf variety but even that, calls me to throw some in the toaster and slather with butter. Carbs. No matter what kind.
When I ran a daycare, kids were notorious for leaving their crusts on the plate. Into the blender it'd all go, to be crumbed up for the birds. Even my dh refuses to eat the heels of a loaf so if I don't eat them, to the birds they go.
When calories are important to me, I either avoid bread or buy the 45 cal. a slice kind.
I left a high end Bosch bread mixer behind when I moved because I was eating WAY too much fresh bread. With LOTS of butter. I could have it on the table in two hours after I started.
For my new favorite recipe I have to start the night before, which really discourages impulse eating.
I mostly have store bought bread though. My OH won't eat the heels either. I do when I'm eating his bread (I usually get another brand for myself) but if I don't get to them I give them to the birds as well.
I think it speaks poorly of cultures who teach their children it is ok to waste food like that.*
*Now, I'm sure there is someone out there who has a legit neuro-atypical reason for not eating crusts or heels - that's not what I'm referring to.0 -
lynn_glenmont wrote: »kristinetetteh wrote: »That's funny. I used to do that too. Tastes so good. But it's a sad waste. Some people would love to eat that slice of bread you are throwing away for their breakfast, lunch and dinner. 😢
Reread the OP. Others in the household are apparently willing to eat the crustless slices. Nothing is being thrown away
I think she was referring to the PP who sometimes gives heels to birds.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions