I am here! What now?
TheHappyLoser
Posts: 95 Member
The last time I attempted to lose weight was in 2016. It didn't work. I gave up.
My husband told me he would quit drinking if I lose 100 pounds. It bothered me. Now I am glad he said it. He doesn't know it but he will have to give up drinking eventually. I need to lose 150 pounds to be under 200. Overwhelming, a bit.
What know? Depriving me of food doesn't work. But overeating doesn't work either. I am like an addict. I have food on my mind all the time.
I know I would like to detox, get all the fast-food and sugar out of my system. I always wanted to do it like all the people around me. Why? I don't know it sounds healthy and I need to get healthy.
Do I log after eating or plan ahead?
Should I try different diets or just eat less?
Can I ignore Keto and low carb and enjoy carbs in moderation.
Palm-size portion meat, double size vegetables. Old school?
Small meals 5 x a day or 3 meals?
Liquid meals?
Is diet coke still ok?
Is low fat still in? My arteries could use a break.
I always wanted to try the Mediterranean diet.
Do I need a kitchen scale?
I have eight friends.
I am not alone.
I want this for me.
My husband told me he would quit drinking if I lose 100 pounds. It bothered me. Now I am glad he said it. He doesn't know it but he will have to give up drinking eventually. I need to lose 150 pounds to be under 200. Overwhelming, a bit.
What know? Depriving me of food doesn't work. But overeating doesn't work either. I am like an addict. I have food on my mind all the time.
I know I would like to detox, get all the fast-food and sugar out of my system. I always wanted to do it like all the people around me. Why? I don't know it sounds healthy and I need to get healthy.
Do I log after eating or plan ahead?
Should I try different diets or just eat less?
Can I ignore Keto and low carb and enjoy carbs in moderation.
Palm-size portion meat, double size vegetables. Old school?
Small meals 5 x a day or 3 meals?
Liquid meals?
Is diet coke still ok?
Is low fat still in? My arteries could use a break.
I always wanted to try the Mediterranean diet.
Do I need a kitchen scale?
I have eight friends.
I am not alone.I want this for me.
12
Replies
-
Do I log after eating or plan ahead? Either way works, I do both.
Should I try different diets or just eat less? Just eat less
Can I ignore Keto and low carb and enjoy carbs in moderation. Eat the way you plan to eat for the rest of your life.
Palm-size portion meat, double size vegetables. Old school? Get a food scale and weigh in grams.
Small meals 5 x a day or 3 meals? This does not matter.
Liquid meals? Not sustainable and you learn nothing on how to eat regular food.
Is diet coke still ok? Coke Zero Sugar is better, IMO.
Is low fat still in? My arteries could use a break. Fat is important. Try to keep saturated fat to a minimum.
I always wanted to try the Mediterranean diet. I really good idea.
Do I need a kitchen scale? YES8 -
What works for you is going to be trial and error to find what suits your personality and what you can do without getting frustrated or burned out, but here's my tips:
-Yes, you need a food scale. You have no idea how much you're really eating until you're measuring out portions. You might get good enough at eyeballing after a while that you don't have to weigh every single thing, but if your weight loss slows down, that's your #1 diagnostic tool.
-I am a fan of the Mediterranean diet, especially for "beginners." Nothing is really excluded, you wrap your head around what foods give you big doses of the nutrients you need, macros are pretty balanced, and satiety tends to be high. There's a ton of free online meal plans at various calorie levels for the Mediterranean diet. It includes carbs in moderation, which I get the impression you would like to enjoy. It has moderate fat, but leans toward foods high in MUFAs and Omega-3s. If you need a framework to start with, this is great, and you can branch out as time goes on. That said, at your weight you may be battling insulin resistance, and keto may be more effective for you, at least in the short term. If you do the Med diet (or DASH, or straight-up portion control with calorie counting) and don't get anywhere with it, try keto. But whatever you do, don't give up. Something will eventually work.
-I drink 2 12-oz cans of diet soda every day and have no negative effects. I do not think diet soda is the devil. If it helps you avoid consuming full-sugar soda, enjoy it. If you're one of those people who get headaches from it or who get bad sugar cravings from it, don't drink it.
-Liquid meals fill me up for about 5 minutes and then I'm starving again, so that's a no from me. YMMV.
-Meal planning and logging is very individual, but I prefer to meal plan once a week. For me, this is more than a grocery list - it includes picking out recipes, deciding what days to eat what meals, and pre-logging the whole week into MFP. My personal meal split is 250/600/600 with room for snacks like nuts and raw veggies, or maybe a treat like ice cream or wine. Having days planned in advance is somewhat inflexible, but my life isn't that exciting, especially with the pandemic going on.
-Not one of your questions, but it really helps my mental state to focus on losing small chunks of weight at a time. Instead of thinking about 150 lbs, think about losing 15, 10, or even 5 lbs. Then worry about the next 5 lbs.
Good luck to you!14 -
5
-
chocolate_owl wrote: »
Or just drink normal coke, and account for it in your daily calories budget.
Really, two things:
a) it doesn't matter how you eat and when, all matters is the amount of calories. A scientist proofed the point by eating only Twinkies, but in a calorie deficit. And he lost weight. Sure, it's not really healthy and lacks nutrients, but for weight loss all that counts is eating less. That's pretty cool, eh?
b) but that means you need to count your calories as good as possible. Nobody would be overweight if we could estimate the calories of the food we eat. We just can't. Thus a food scale is key here
Oh, lets add c) You say you always think of food. Why? When particularly? What would make you stop thinking of food? Are you bored? Try to find something you like and that distracts you. Don't say: but it's winter now, or I'm not good enough to do xyz. Just start something that sounds interesting, get winter clothes from a thrift shop if needed, doesn't matter. Just avoid boredom or whatever is causing you to think of food.
Oh, and d) Tell your husband to shove it! Either he's in or not. If he wants you to lose weight first then that's rather unkind. Maybe do it together: lose weight and stop drinking.6 -
I know I would like to detox, get all the fast-food and sugar out of my system.
unless you are a drug addict, you do not need to detox. that is what our kidneys do.
Do I log after eating or plan ahead?
everyone does it a bit different. I log ahead, but then will adjust the numbers based on what i actually ate (quantity or item)
Should I try different diets or just eat less?
all diets are a way of reducing calories. I eat whatever I want, if i can fit in in my calories. including 6 oreos last night.
Can I ignore Keto and low carb and enjoy carbs in moderation.
you can take my carbs from my cold dead hands. Half my macros are carbs.
Palm-size portion meat, double size vegetables. Old school?
it works but a food scale works better
Small meals 5 x a day or 3 meals?
whatever you want
Liquid meals?
I like to EAT my food
Is diet coke still ok?
I've lost 130 pounds and live off diet coke
Is low fat still in? My arteries could use a break.
its just another way of reducing calories
I always wanted to try the Mediterranean diet.
go for it if you want to
Do I need a kitchen scale?
absolutely
and your husband sounds like a jerk. He may have meant well, but was not kind about it. My husband quit drinking, but that was because he realized (on his own) that he could drink or continue being married to me. He has never EVER commented on my weight or criticized me for it.
12 -
callsitlikeiseeit wrote: »
and your husband sounds like a jerk. He may have meant well, but was not kind about it. My husband quit drinking, but that was because he realized (on his own) that he could drink or continue being married to me. He has never EVER commented on my weight or criticized me for it.
He never brought up my weight, until I started nagging about his drinking. I suppose I had it coming. One day I might thank him. Looks like it was what I needed.
It was great reading your advice. It gives me lots to work with. Thanks.4 -
chocolate_owl wrote: »
Or just drink normal coke, and account for it in your daily calories budget.
Really, two things:
a) it doesn't matter how you eat and when, all matters is the amount of calories. A scientist proofed the point by eating only Twinkies, but in a calorie deficit. And he lost weight. Sure, it's not really healthy and lacks nutrients, but for weight loss all that counts is eating less. That's pretty cool, eh?
b) but that means you need to count your calories as good as possible. Nobody would be overweight if we could estimate the calories of the food we eat. We just can't. Thus a food scale is key here
Oh, lets add c) You say you always think of food. Why? When particularly? What would make you stop thinking of food? Are you bored? Try to find something you like and that distracts you. Don't say: but it's winter now, or I'm not good enough to do xyz. Just start something that sounds interesting, get winter clothes from a thrift shop if needed, doesn't matter. Just avoid boredom or whatever is causing you to think of food.
Oh, and d) Tell your husband to shove it! Either he's in or not. If he wants you to lose weight first then that's rather unkind. Maybe do it together: lose weight and stop drinking.
I can't eat one or two Twinkies, I eat them all. I feel that sugar is an addiction for me.
I think about food because it's what I do. Food and eating is major in my life. Childhood issues I need to resolve. I am thinking about going to therapy. It can't hurt.
Thank you for your reply.3 -
Good Luck to you TheHappyLoser, I know you can do it! Little by little, it will come off! For me, I had to switch from Cokes to flavored sparkling waters, and I don't get those cravings for sodas any more. If I do want something sweet at then end of a dinner, I just break off a piece of dark chocolate and it seems to satisfy that need. You are definitely not alone; we are your cheering section!2
-
Congratulations on trying once again! Your MFP name is fantastic!
Best wishes for success this time. Regardless if your husband will actually follow through on his promise, you are always the captain of your own ship and have to pilot it as best you can.
Our bodies evolved over millions of years to allow us to eat more than we need and store those calories with us-- it's a definitive human superpower, in fact. Some of us now live in a situation where food is cheap and easy to obtain, and our prior superpower can now be detrimental to our health! It's easy to forget what an incredible blessing it is to have such control over what we eat. It really has only been true very recently in human history and it is only true in certain parts of the world. It must be turned to your advantage for you to be successful in taking charge of your health.
So, all you need to do is overcome your built-in natural superpower that has allowed your ancestors to survive in much more difficult circumstance. Easy, right? Well, that depends strongly on your physiology, which varies considerably from person to person. If you've tried many times and failed, then it is probably pretty hard for you.
So I ask: who can you ask for help (aside us)? Do you have any resources you can bring to bear on the problem? One interesting thing about the quarantine is that professionals are now available remotely, including doctors, dieticians, trainers, life coaches, and psychologists. If you want to make a change that is this monumental, I hope you will reach out as you are able to such people and get answers to your questions that work for you.
Best of luck!5 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »I can't eat one or two Twinkies, I eat them all. I feel that sugar is an addiction for me.
I saw this quote the other day and really saw truth to it "A mistake that happens more than once is a decision"
IMO things like food/sugar addiction gets tossed around as a concept because there's comfort in finding a cause beyond a lack of our own accountability.
I know I would like to detox, get all the fast-food and sugar out of my system.
- Like some others mentioned, you don't need a detox or a cleanse. If you want to choose to no longer eat fast food or limit sugar, great, but it's not a prerequisite to lose weight.
Do I log after eating or plan ahead?
- I'm a big fan of pre-logging but batch cooking/meal prepping isn't my preference. I pretty much eat the same thing everyday for breakfast and lunch so I can pre-log that very easily. My wife and I will at least have a conversation about what to do for dinner a day in advance. I log the most of my day right before bed the night prior or first thing in the morning.
Should I try different diets or just eat less?
- Despite many claims to the contrary, any named diet causes weight loss by triggering a calorie deficit. If a specific diet or way of eating helps you get to a calorie deficit, go for it. Again, it's not necessary to follow any particular diet to lose weight. I had really good success early on by just logging what I was eating and seeing where the calories and macros fell. It was really easy to see where the low-effort opportunities were to reduce empty calories or make portion adjustments.
Can I ignore Keto and low carb and enjoy carbs in moderation.
- Yes. I've yet to see a decent study that shows anything magic about keto and fat loss. People like the big initial weight losses to make it seem like they've found something special while the majority of that initial scale movement is water weight loss. (it's a 3:1 ratio of g water to g carbohydrate so when you limit carbs your body hangs on to much less water).
Palm-size portion meat, double size vegetables. Old school?
- Get a food scale. They're like $10 and people are awful at estimating.
Small meals 5 x a day or 3 meals?
-Doesn't matter. If we're really getting into the weeds there are some fringe performance and MPS advantages with meal timing for elite athletes and physique competitors but nothing really applicable for the average dieter.
Liquid meals?
- There are pros and cons. There's some evidence of brain chemistry and the act of chewing and swallowing that relates to satiety. Unless it's a casein protein shake (which is designed to be slow release/digesting) most protein sources in liquid form are pretty quick to digest and thus, also not great for satiety. That said, as someone with strength and physique aspirations, getting enough protein without liquid protein supplementation is a tall order. Though, I have not found this to be a significant impediment in my ability to manage my weight.
Is diet coke still ok?
-Yes
Is low fat still in? My arteries could use a break.
- See above regarding specific diets. Additionally, unless you have a diagnosed medical issue, bodily function do not need breaks or resets or detoxes. It's recommended that you get 20%-35% of your daily calories from fat. Yes, not all fats are the same, but eating too much fat, independent of calorie content, isn't what makes people fat.
I always wanted to try the Mediterranean diet.
- See above regarding specific diets. I'll also note that the genesis of promoting the Mediterranean diet was an evaluation of the occurrence of coronary heart disease in those countries vs. northern Europe and North America. A correlation was discovered but I've never seen anything studied with respect to weight and/or calories. I would speculate that following the Mediterranean diet but following American tendencies for portions would not end favorably for weight loss or heart health.
Do I need a kitchen scale?
- It's highly recommended. Even those who are diligent using volumetric measures find better accuracy and success using a food scale. Again, they're like $10 and you'll not make a better investment to support your weight loss goal.
I want this for me.
- Good. Right now you're motivated and have all the best intentions to succeed. Use this positive energy to foster discipline and healthy habits that will make it easier for you to stay the course and keep working towards your goals when that motivation starts to fade or when you have a hard day. Losing 100 lbs is a big goal and will take quite a bit of time but it's completely doable if you have the right mindset. It's far less about finding the perfect diet and/or the perfect plan and more about being consistent and having the perseverance to keep going when things haven't been perfect or you haven't necessarily seen the scale move as much as you were hoping/expecting.2 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »I can't eat one or two Twinkies, I eat them all. I feel that sugar is an addiction for me.
I saw this quote the other day and really saw truth to it "A mistake that happens more than once is a decision"
IMO things like food/sugar addiction gets tossed around as a concept because there's comfort in finding a cause beyond a lack of our own accountability.
I assume you never smoked? People know it's unhealthy and continue to smoke. They try to quit. Fail, try again.
Harsh judgment on your end.
Any addiction (alcohol/sugar/drugs/cigarette/gambling and many more) is not just a lack of own accountability or a decision it's much more complicated. Sugar does something to my brain and body I can't explain.
I didn't read what you wrote after that. Self-defense on my end! That was a decision!1 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »TheHappyLoser wrote: »I can't eat one or two Twinkies, I eat them all. I feel that sugar is an addiction for me.
I saw this quote the other day and really saw truth to it "A mistake that happens more than once is a decision"
IMO things like food/sugar addiction gets tossed around as a concept because there's comfort in finding a cause beyond a lack of our own accountability.
I assume you never smoked? People know it's unhealthy and continue to smoke. They try to quit. Fail, try again.
Harsh judgment on your end.
Any addiction (alcohol/sugar/drugs/cigarette/gambling and many more) is not just a lack of own accountability or a decision it's much more complicated. Sugar does something to my brain and body I can't explain.
I didn't read what you wrote after that. Self-defense on my end! That was a decision!
And yet people are still able to quit smoking. Yes, food and sugar specifically, trigger a similar dopamine response as nicotine and other drugs but that's not to say that it's impossible to break that addiction. I'll fully admit it's a harsh judgement but I stand by it being a pertinent one.
You're correct, I have never smoked. I've also never been 100+ lbs overweight either and yet you seemed fully prepared to at least read what advice I had to offer until I wrote something with which you disagreed.5 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »I can't eat one or two Twinkies, I eat them all. I feel that sugar is an addiction for me.
I think about food because it's what I do. Food and eating is major in my life. Childhood issues I need to resolve. I am thinking about going to therapy. It can't hurt.
Thank you for your reply.
Lots of good comments here...
It was mentioned that you don't detox from sugar / carbs... But that's depends on how any individual defines the word. I personally believe sugar to some of us, me included does induce what feels very similar to a detox off drugs. (I've detoxed off drugs, rehab the whole nine yards.).
And I know all to well what it's like to stop by a grocery store, and buy a box of "Ah Carmels" squares then sit in my car and eat the entire box by myself, while I casually look around and make sure no one is watching me.
Sugar does affect dopamine levels in the brain, and there have been many studies on this. Here's just a quick clip..
"Sugar can also disrupt dopamine levels as the brain becomes used to high levels of sugar. In fact, both the gene expression and availability of dopamine receptors can be altered in certain areas of the brain from consuming too much sugar over a long period of time."
The above if true, then would suggest when your not full of sugar you could find yourself feeling run down, or generally depressed. That makes sense, cause the first thing I always wanted to do after work, was stuff my face. Some how I felt better afterwards. And the roller coaster of insulin response can be crushing.
Based on your comments, I would suggest Keto or variation of might be just what you need. I couldn't not stop myself from getting crap in my system for many months straight. After about day 5 or so of keto, all those urges disappeared. I haven't stopped anywhere in 7 weeks. I have no cravings for sugar. (The detox is over).
Personally I'm a Keto guy.. And I still get to eat almost all the same great foods I always love... Minus some obvious items. But I eat Strip loin or Prime Rib steak once a week, Porkchops, roasted chicken with the skin on.. Bacon and eggs and (low carb toast)... Life it actually good, and I eat well.
Best of luck to you. You can really do it, it's just a matter of time and putting in the effort.
2 -
Do I log after eating or plan ahead?
I find it easier to stick to my budget if I plan ahead. I prepare breakfast and lunch for the week on the weekends, so I already know what those are going to be, and I plan out dinners such that I only need to cook 2-3 nights a week and it's easy to log leftovers the next day.
Should I try different diets or just eat less?
The only way to lose weight is to stay in a calorie deficit. All those different diets ultimately work by creating that calorie deficit. The great thing about MFP and calorie counting in general is that there are no forbidden foods. No matter what diet plan you're following, if it's a name brand or not, if calories in is more than calories out, you will gain. If calories in is less than calories out, you will lose. It's simple physics, end of. You can lose weight eating nothing but Big Macs and you can gain weight eating nothing but boiled chicken and broccoli.
Can I ignore Keto and low carb and enjoy carbs in moderation.
Unless your personal licensed medical doctor has told you specifically to avoid carbs, you can eat carbs and lose weight. Not some guy in a lab coat on TV or Youtube, not some article you dug out of some wretched corner of the internet. Your personal doctor, advising you personally as their patient. Anyone else is blowing smoke and should be ignored.
Palm-size portion meat, double size vegetables. Old school?
Nah, that's still a pretty good quick-and-dirty way to estimate portion sizes if you aren't able to weigh your food for whatever reason. Watch out for condiments (butter, dipping sauce, salad dressing, etc) though.
Small meals 5 x a day or 3 meals?
Up to you.
Liquid meals?
Also up to you, but most people don't find liquids nearly as satiating as solid food, so they end up eating the meal they were trying to replace anyway.
Is diet coke still ok?
If you've got a multiple-cans-a-day habit, maybe try to replace at least some of that with plain water. I'm not up to date on the latest science around artificial sweeteners but I also don't like diet sodas anyway so I just don't drink them. There's about ten million brands of flavored seltzer out now, if you miss the bubbles or your tap water tastes bad.
Is low fat still in? My arteries could use a break.
Again, consult your specific licensed medical professional regarding your dietary fat intake, but dietary fat does not become body fat unless you eat more than your body burns in a day (and we're back to CICO). You do need some fat in your diet in order to properly digest some vitamins, so don't avoid it completely. I'd be wary of "low-fat" versions of food that naturally contain some amount of fat, though; usually they replace the fat with sugar to make it palatable, which is a problem for obvious reasons.
I always wanted to try the Mediterranean diet.
What's stopping you?
Do I need a kitchen scale?
Yes. I won't hedge here and say iF yOu WaNt, absolutely go buy a food scale right now. I got my Escali on Amazon for thirty bucks. It comes in pink (or whatever your favorite color is). Weigh and log every gram of everything that passes your lips. The goal is to maintain that deficit of calories in being less than calories out. There's not a good way to directly measure calories out - even heart rate monitors and similar fitness wearables are using algorithms to estimate your calorie burn - but you can damn well measure calories in, by weighing your food in grams. (And make sure you're picking accurate entries from the MFP database to log that food.)1 -
Poobah1972 wrote: »TheHappyLoser wrote: »
It was mentioned that you don't detox from sugar / carbs... But that's depends on how any individual defines the word. I personally believe sugar to some of us, me included does induce what feels very similar to a detox off drugs. (I've detoxed off drugs, rehab the whole nine yards.).
Congratulation on overcoming a terrible addiction. Thank you for your reply.
Sugar treats, cakes, pies, cookies, all of it. Old reward system. Good grades in school = Icecream. Mowed the yard = chocolate. Birthday = more candy.
It gives me a high and energy. Not for long though.
No sugar yesterday or today. My brain is yelling: Sweets, sweets.
I hope you will accept my friend request.0 -
goal06082021 wrote: »Do I log after eating or plan ahead?
I always wanted to try the Mediterranean diet.
What's stopping you?
Question of the week. Too complicated? Not enough food? Too different?
All excuses. It's a go. I will try the Mediterranean diet. Thanks.0 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »Congratulation on overcoming a terrible addiction. Thank you for your reply.
Sugar treats, cakes, pies, cookies, all of it. Old reward system. Good grades in school = Icecream. Mowed the yard = chocolate. Birthday = more candy.
It gives me a high and energy. Not for long though.
No sugar yesterday or today. My brain is yelling: Sweets, sweets.
I hope you will accept my friend request.
Thank you... But for me, it's sort of like being an alcoholic, at least thus far my life has taught me that refined sugars is a very slippery slope for me. So I'm very happy to have broke fee of the hold sugar had on me.
Years ago, when I successfully lost 200 plus pounds, I didn't cheat, not even with a single square of chocolate, or a single hard candy for close to 3 years. Then one family get together, my former girlfriend and I decided to have 1 piece of pie at thanks giving. That was the beginning of my decent into madness (well aside from moving out of town and away from the gym). lol
I understand that the above seems sort of dramatic etc... And obviously I should be able at some point in my life be able to stray slightly without falling off the wagon, but at the same time, that has been my experience. To combat this, my fiancé and I have found some deserts we can enjoy during family get together while other people eat cake etc. Like a Microwaved "melty" Quest chocolate chip cookie with a nice big Tablespoon of Halo Ice cream. Or a Slice of "choose your flavor" low carb pudding pie made with low carb crust topped with whipped cream. There is also good low carb chocolate cake, and or lava cake options you can make in minutes in a jar etc. This all goes a long way in preventing cravings for things over the long run... Heck there is even something called Lily's Salted Almond Chocolate bars, (they double size bars) and they taste divine and only have ~3 carbs and ~180 calories. To not have to much of a good thing, I only have the chocolate on Fridays. The moral of the story is I don't feel deprived of the sweet and tasty things in life.
Ultimately though, Getting closer to goal and manipulating my diet and learning to successfully maintain my weight may be the most difficult part of this journey. Vigilance and continued determination will likely be key.
Friend request Accepted!
If you ever do choose to go low carb or keto, I'd be happy to assist you in any which way I can.
PS,,, You didn't log your supper last night? What's up with that?0 -
Poobah1972 wrote: »TheHappyLoser wrote: »
PS,,, You didn't log your supper last night? What's up with that?
I did, but late. Half of my favorite Subway sandwich. Still under my calories. High Five!
I got a kitchen scale. Makes my portions so much smaller.2 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »I did, but late. Half of my favorite Subway sandwich. Still under my calories. High Five!
I got a kitchen scale. Makes my portions so much smaller.
Ah good job! You're actually my first bud here, and I never checked someone else's food journal before... So I thought I'd let you know someone was watching. lol
And seriously.... Good Job on getting a scale, a huge part of staring right is becoming intimately aware of food portions and macro content. There is quite a bit to learn, if your haven't done that sort of thing before.
You get a gold star!
0 -
Some good advice above. Chiming in to add -- just start. Start - N O W. Start with small changes and go from there. If you stumble during the day, or with one choice, don't wait for tomorrow, get back on track today, the next meal or choice you have to make.
Wishing you success!2 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »goal06082021 wrote: »Do I log after eating or plan ahead?
I always wanted to try the Mediterranean diet.
What's stopping you?
Question of the week. Too complicated? Not enough food? Too different?
All excuses. It's a go. I will try the Mediterranean diet. Thanks.
For me, a quick path to failure would be to try to completely overhaul my diet right from the get-go. When I started on MFP many years ago with 100 lbs to lose, I resented having to limit my calories. I set up my profile with a reasonable goal to lose 1 lb/week and just worked on my logging and hitting that goal. Once I was in the habit and realized it wasn't going to ruin my life, then I slowly began to make changes to help me improve my diet and that, because they helped with satiety, helped me reach my calorie goal. I was even able to increase my goal to 1.5 lbs/week for a while, until I had lost enough weight that that required too big of a cut in calories for me.
FYI, I think the Mediterranean diet is a great goal to aspire to. I eat too many sweets and not nearly enough whole foods. But I can still control my weight with those flaws. I have teenagers, a husband with a calorie goal in the thousands who eats whatever he likes, and I struggle with depression, and the idea of overhauling everyone's diet is too much for me to consider. I do my best with what works in the circumstances I have.
6 -
Poobah1972 wrote: »TheHappyLoser wrote: »I did, but late. Half of my favorite Subway sandwich. Still under my calories. High Five!
I got a kitchen scale. Makes my portions so much smaller.
Ah good job! You're actually my first bud here, and I never checked someone else's food journal before... So I thought I'd let you know someone was watching. lol
And seriously.... Good Job on getting a scale, a huge part of staring right is becoming intimately aware of food portions and macro content. There is quite a bit to learn, if your haven't done that sort of thing before.
You get a gold star!
Someone watching my food journal 👀 Great. I love it. [Accountability]
Macro content? I think that's the advanced class. I am a beginner. I have no idea what you are talking about. I will read up on Macro. Super I sound like a moron.
1 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »Do I log after eating or plan ahead?
When first starting out, I think deciding what you plan to eat that day and loosely logging it to see how the cals look is a good plan. You can adjust if the cals are higher than anticipated. But I also think it's fine to log after cooking or eating and then if a day is too high, you can look over it and see what you might want to change up. Think of this as a learning experience.
After I did it for a while, I found I could pretty much tell roughly the cals certain meals would have, so I'd log after eating (or cooking) and in the rare occasion I was low on cals adjust future meals that day accordingly. When I specifically make leftovers and divide something into portions or cook ahead for lunches, I do still log those in advance, however.Should I try different diets or just eat less?
I'd start by just eating less (fewer cals, not necessarily less food). You can pay attention to how you feel -- energetic or not, hungry or not, etc., and adjust by looking at what you ate and how you might be able to improve.
I think focusing on eating a nutritious diet is, of course, good, but when you are first starting out calories might be the best thing to focus on. IMO, most people inherently adjust their diets to be more satiating and nutritious as they cut cals and pay attention to how they feel. Making gradual improvements over time is often the easiest and most sustainable approach, and you don't have to give up anything you love.Can I ignore Keto and low carb and enjoy carbs in moderation.
Yes!Palm-size portion meat, double size vegetables. Old school?
Yeah, but not a terrible starting point. I choose meat amounts by the amount of cals and protein, so don't limit it to palm size, but when I started I'd go with 3 oz or 100 g (not the same measure, just the two I'd use), and then adjusted over time (larger portions of lean meat often) to fit my goals. Double size veg if you are good with that is a good idea. I like to fill my plate with veg as both nutritious and filling for those of us who enjoy volume.Small meals 5 x a day or 3 meals?
100% matter of personal preference. Think about your own feelings and reactions. Do you tend to overeat if you feel hungry when you eat a meal? Are there ways you could control this other than not getting hungry (i.e., limit what you make or eat only what you portion out and put the leftovers away immediately)? Do you enjoy snacking and like snacks that contribute a decent amount of the nutrients you would want in your day? Or does snacking seem less appealing to you? Would snacking make you satisfied with less at meals? Do you mind having more times you have to think about or obtain/prepare food in a day?
Some people love snacking or feel more satisfied when they do. Others (like me) find smaller meals plus snacks makes them less satisfied and they prefer saving their cals for bigger meals and not having to think about food other than 2-3 times per day. People just differ on these and neither is inherently better for weight loss.Liquid meals?
If you are attracted by the idea, experiment. Many find them not as filling as eating the same cals, and if using shakes some aren't very balanced. I actually do enjoy smoothies, but mine are huge, and I think satisfying to me because they take time to consume, not just one glass. I also make sure to include protein, healthy fat, and vegetables.Is diet coke still ok?
Absolutely. I lost 90 lbs without giving it up, and it was helpful if I felt snacky sometimes just having a diet soda (or coffee or tea) would be all I really wanted.Is low fat still in? My arteries could use a break.
It's not in, but you will find what macro balance works for you by experimenting and looking to see your macros and food choices on days you find easier vs harder. I would say that I personally think limiting sat fat some (fat from meat and dairy, mostly) and focusing on adding in healthy fats (from fatty fish, avocado, nuts and seeds, and olives or olive oil) can be healthy. Fats (esp the healthy fats) are important for overall health. MFP's default (30%) is generally not considered high or low fat, and I think it's a reasonable starting place, to keep it simple. But don't worry too much about macros (other than for some protein can help if you are hungry).I always wanted to try the Mediterranean diet.
It's a great way to eat, but worth noting it's broadly similar to any other common healthy eating pattern, and especially those in other blue zones: focus on cooking from whole ingredients, eat lots of veg and fruit and also include foods like nuts and seeds, beans and lentils, whole grains and tubers. Olive oil/avocado oil might be good substitutes for butter in many dishes, limit meat other than fish and include seafood in the diet.Do I need a kitchen scale?
No, you probably don't need one unless you find you are not getting the results you expect. I love mine, however, as I prefer to use it when cooking than cups (except for liquids), and like trying to guess what things weigh and seeing how close I am. It's also just easier for me to log exact numbers than trying to guess whether something was a small whatever or a medium one or eyeballing or trying to shove broccoli in a cup. But lots of people do fine without them, and when I first started I would have told you I'd never be someone weighing my food. ;-)I have eight friends. I am not alone.
I want this for me.
You can do it!1 -
chocolate_owl wrote: »
This is so deeply wrong. Coke Zero is awful, Diet Coke is the best.
(OP, we are only sparring over taste.)4 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »Poobah1972 wrote: »TheHappyLoser wrote: »I did, but late. Half of my favorite Subway sandwich. Still under my calories. High Five!
I got a kitchen scale. Makes my portions so much smaller.
Ah good job! You're actually my first bud here, and I never checked someone else's food journal before... So I thought I'd let you know someone was watching. lol
And seriously.... Good Job on getting a scale, a huge part of staring right is becoming intimately aware of food portions and macro content. There is quite a bit to learn, if your haven't done that sort of thing before.
You get a gold star!
Someone watching my food journal 👀 Great. I love it. [Accountability]
Macro content? I think that's the advanced class. I am a beginner. I have no idea what you are talking about. I will read up on Macro. Super I sound like a moron.
You're new! It takes time to learn all this, and even more time to really understand and apply it.
The basics:
-Calories are king. Eat less than you burn and you'll lose weight.
-Logging accurately and honestly is very important to make sure you're eating less than you burn.
-Macros are carbs, protein, and fat. You do want a minimum amount of protein and fat to support healthy body functions, and many people who eat higher levels of protein and fat say they're less hungry, which helps them adhere to their calorie goals. Calories are still the most important part of the equation, though. If you eat more carbs and less protein than you "should" but still meet your calorie goal, you will lose weight.
You can send me a message if you want help setting your macro targets, but as you said, that's the advanced class, and I don't think it's super important for you to focus on that right now. Spend a few weeks settling in with calories. Once you feel like you're in the groove and you can do this for the long haul, you can start tweaking those macros.
Here's a few stickied posts that might be helpful to read through, if you want to get your head around all the stuff we're talking about:
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1080242/a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants/p1
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/819055/setting-your-calorie-and-macro-targets/p1
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1296011/calorie-counting-101/p1
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1235566/so-youre-new-here/p11 -
chocolate_owl wrote: »
This is so deeply wrong. Coke Zero is awful, Diet Coke is the best.
(OP, we are only sparring over taste.)
You're usually so right about everything, Lemur. I'm sad to see you be so wrong about this
We might have to take this to the Debate section.5 -
I don’t know if this helps but I did a DNA test specifically for a health panel and it showed I had genes that might not respond well to fat intake from the perspective of how my body stores it, but also showed sugar might not be as big of a concern with regards to the way my body stored it. It was interesting to read.
That being said, I’ve undergone a body composition analysis and have used the data to direct my macro percentages to target fat loss instead of mere weight loss. The numbers do help. The process also let me know that my cholesterol levels could potentially greatly improve on a low fat diet so I would personally not do KETO. It’s going to be such a unique decision for everyone since all of our DNA is unique and how we should approach overall health. (My macro numbers allow for high protein, decent amount of carbs and lower fat).
I would be cautious about a cleanse or any extreme measures and just focus on a few small changes each week with a reduced calorie intake and some moderate movement
If you can afford it, I recommend getting numbers and data that can help you formulate a plan that works best for you. Also, Mediterranean is usually a great option!👍🏻❤️(And so good)
Best of luck and I hope both you and your husband find some freedom from unhealthy habits that unfortunately, so many of us struggle with. 😊0 -
If you have access to therapy I think it would be worth a try!
Over the summer and early fall I had lost 32 pounds and between the holidays, vacation, winter and my own poor decisions I’ve gained almost half of that back since Nov 1st. Larger portions, more snacking and pounding cookies and desserts like no one’s business was more of an issue than my lack of exercise, but that also contributed.
So I decided to give up desserts/sweets for Lent as a sacrifice and for my own health. The first 10 days were pretty brutal and I craved something sweet after every meal but I have stayed strong and now the cravings are way more manageable. The first week also increased my calorie intake because I was snacking on savory snacks as a substitute, but that is also getting better.
Normally when I am losing weight I leave calories in my day for a sweet snack but until Easter it is off limits for me. Every person has to figure out what works for themselves. Sometimes cutting out food groups leads to binging but sometimes small amounts aren’t enough and it leads to a slippery slope. You figure out what works for you!1 -
My suggestions would be find what's manageable for you now and don't try it all at once. I too struggled with sugar and alcohol but by making food swaps and slowly reducing my intake, I've now found that I can keep the cravings at bay. Personally in the early days I found substitutions were key for me - so sweetner rather than sugar, diet coke rather than full fat coke, dark chocolate rather than a whole bar of milk chocolate. Nothing off limits, but also gradually removing the 'binge' products from the house and trying my best not to replace them. I've learnt that I really can't have a jar of peanut butter or a packet of biscuts in the house, otherwise I eat the lot (but that said I've not totally banned them, I just have to be accountable for them). Oh and log log log - for my first week i logged everything and just didn't even think about the calorie total - it was just to give me a view on just how much I was eating (a real eye opener). Slow and steady, small baby steps - you got this
3 -
TheHappyLoser wrote: »TheHappyLoser wrote: »I can't eat one or two Twinkies, I eat them all. I feel that sugar is an addiction for me.
I saw this quote the other day and really saw truth to it "A mistake that happens more than once is a decision"
IMO things like food/sugar addiction gets tossed around as a concept because there's comfort in finding a cause beyond a lack of our own accountability.
I assume you never smoked? People know it's unhealthy and continue to smoke. They try to quit. Fail, try again.
Harsh judgment on your end.
Any addiction (alcohol/sugar/drugs/cigarette/gambling and many more) is not just a lack of own accountability or a decision it's much more complicated. Sugar does something to my brain and body I can't explain.
I didn't read what you wrote after that. Self-defense on my end! That was a decision!
I actually pressed the like button on his comment. And yeh, I was once a two pack a day smoker 😉1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions