Diet and fitness FADS you’ve tried before...
Options
RunsWithBees
Posts: 1,508 Member
When attempting to lose weight and get fit I’m sure a lot of us have tried many of the fads that are out there, most of them will eventually fail us because they are simply not sustainable. What fads have you tried before and how did it turn out?
0
Replies
-
Years ago before understanding CICO and counting calories I tried water fasting. I did it for 3 days straight (ugh!) and felt just awful afterwards. To break the fast I ate some pineapple and it gave me a very strange mouth/throat feel, like puckered but almost painful. I am not allergic to pineapple but it kinda felt like my body was rejecting it anyways?! It took awhile to feel back to normal about eating, needless to say I will never put myself through that willingly again! I also remember at some point buying “metabolism booster” herbal pills of some type or other and a “cleansing tea”... they were absolute rubbish of course!3
-
My mom enrolled herself along with me and my sister in Weight Watchers once, probably circa 2002, so that was when they just had the one "points" system for everyone. I hated the public weigh-ins and group meetings, which is funny because now I participate in multiple groups on here where I do the same things. Maybe it's because I'm choosing to do that on my own terms, and also there are other people in these groups who look like me? I was the youngest person in the WW meetings by easily 25 years (the next-youngest being my mom), so I guess I felt like I couldn't relate. Anyway, we stopped going to the meetings after they gave us a points calculator widget that has since been lost to the ages.6
-
I'm old enough to have tried the grapefruit diet8
-
Along with Weight Watchers, did the cabbage soup diet back in the 90's and Atkins in the 2000's. When I was a teen, my mum went to a bariatric doc who gave her (pronounced "us") a 500 calorie diet that included plain ground beef patties, green beans and Melba toast.
BTW- I think I still have my well-worn paperback copy of Barbara Kraus' Calories and Carbohydrates that I carried with me everywhere as I stuck to an 800 calorie diet through college.6 -
I've also tried Couch to 5K a few times - it seemed pretty popular in the early-mid 20-teens when I was doing it, so I'm comfortable calling it a fad. And when I finished the program (the one time I got past week 4 and kept at it), I did one of those gimmicky "color run" 5k races where you get pelted with colored cornstarch the whole time. It was a fun thing to do once, and I took the most colorful and satisfying shower of my life afterward.2
-
I started with Dr. Stillman, which was all protein: eggs, meat and cottage cheese, nothing else. I got so I couldn't look at eggs or chicken breasts. Then I did all fruit and vegetables. That didn't last long. I tried very low calorie diets (900 cal. IIRC). Generally I would only last 3 or 4 days. I did a little fasting. That lasted even less time. I lost a lot of weight on Atkins, as I could sustain that longer, but had to have cheat days in order to continue, and once I lost the weight I always regained it because I wasn't willing to give up sugar and bread forever.
I have the Kraus book as well.2 -
The first diet I tried I found in a workout book of my mom's. It was very restrictive on fat - I think maybe 15g of fat per day? I think that's how I picked up my Diet Coke habit, to combat the crazy fatigue and brain fog. I was probably also really low calorie to dangerous levels (calorie counting was trashed by the author.)
I've also tried variations of low carb, South Beach, and intermittent fasting. To the extent that any of these helped, I think it was honestly just keeping track instead of doing whatever.1 -
goal06082021 wrote: »I've also tried Couch to 5K a few times - it seemed pretty popular in the early-mid 20-teens when I was doing it, so I'm comfortable calling it a fad. And when I finished the program (the one time I got past week 4 and kept at it), I did one of those gimmicky "color run" 5k races where you get pelted with colored cornstarch the whole time. It was a fun thing to do once, and I took the most colorful and satisfying shower of my life afterward.
That sounds like fun!2 -
rosebarnalice wrote: »I'm old enough to have tried the grapefruit diet
That diet cycles around again every few years, I usually see it advertised on magazines1 -
Juicing! Haha. But I did discover fresh juices are very good (along with actual food!)0
-
Slimfast
Keto
Atkins
Whole 30
Does Zumba count? Seems like it was at its height of popularity back when I did it.
Edited to add: wouldn't waste my time on any of the diets again, they just aren't sustainable for me. But would do Zumba again given the opportunity!1 -
My first diet was the "crash diet" suggested in this book I got from the library at age 14: The Woman Dr.'s Diet for Teenage Girls. It was recommended to do it for only 2 weeks, but after 2 weeks I felt I could keep going. Lost a lot of weight, but became obsessive and eventually my calorie target was 500. This set me up for years and years of restrict/lose some/binge cycles. I also went to WW a few times (although I think now that's a reasonable "lifestyle change"), LA Weight Loss Center, a "medically supervised" weight loss clinic (where they basically gave me some prescription pills, had me fill out a food diary and meet with them once a week), and a number of OTC pills and supplements. I also read the "Buff Brides" book before I got married. Using that, I was able to dial in my workouts and lose some weight to get into a healthy BMI range without changing my diet too much. I've also done "The Body Reset Diet," but that was always meant to be a brief jumpstart to my more sustainable weight loss.2
-
goal06082021 wrote: »I've also tried Couch to 5K a few times - it seemed pretty popular in the early-mid 20-teens when I was doing it, so I'm comfortable calling it a fad. And when I finished the program (the one time I got past week 4 and kept at it), I did one of those gimmicky "color run" 5k races where you get pelted with colored cornstarch the whole time. It was a fun thing to do once, and I took the most colorful and satisfying shower of my life afterward.
I wouldn't call c25k a fad. Its an excellent way for someone to slowly build up to running. It's not only still around, but recommended a lot by most runners for new runners for the above reason. Also its free.
Colour run is a fad, that I agree with15 -
Was it grade 9? Or 10?
Ayds to the rescue....
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayds
The weight loss lasted a summer...by December it was all back with friends3 -
goal06082021 wrote: »I've also tried Couch to 5K a few times - it seemed pretty popular in the early-mid 20-teens when I was doing it, so I'm comfortable calling it a fad. And when I finished the program (the one time I got past week 4 and kept at it), I did one of those gimmicky "color run" 5k races where you get pelted with colored cornstarch the whole time. It was a fun thing to do once, and I took the most colorful and satisfying shower of my life afterward.
I wouldn't call c25k a fad. Its an excellent way for someone to slowly build up to running. It's not only still around, but recommended a lot by most runners for new runners for the above reason. Also its free.
Colour run is a fad, that I agree with
Agree, I used couch 2 5k to start running as well, I think it's a really useful programme to gradually increase your running endurance.6 -
Weightwatchers
Atkins (gave me gastritis, so had to stop)
Callanetics - anyone remember that?1 -
Before I actually researched everything, I did the "no fat" product eating which of course still had loads of calories and sugar. Also did the "ab cream" thing back in the 90's because of pseudoscience that I couldn't verify was true or not until internet became much more available.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
2 -
Tried:-
BBC Diet
Weight Watchers
Cabbage Soup Diet
Atkins
Slimming World
IF
Fast 800
Think Soup & Atkins only Fad ones ?
All worked to a various degree, some more painful than others 🤣
2 -
I did the 'eating 6 meals a day thing', popularized in the book 'Body for Life'. It worked very well, I lost 40 lbs. At the time it fit my life well and the weight training program that came with the book has given me a love for the gym that I never had before.
I have since moved on from the eating program because I understand that nothing magic happens by spacing your meals out, and at this stage of my life, eating less often just seems to be more sustainable for me.4 -
I have always been wary of fad diets, since Grandma used to drink SlimFast with her meals.
I did do South Beach when I lived in Miami, but frankly my current diet is very similar to the second stage.
We did a Whole 30ish elimination diet about a year and a half ago, but we did an even slower reintroduction phase and did indeed find two food triggers for my husband's chronic pain (and snoring!).2
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 392 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 926 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions