Struggling to get enough protein
Replies
-
1. MFP macro percentages are just default....you can change them to whatever you want based on what works best for you and helps you stay within your calorie goal. I'm not sure about other calculations for how much protein you need but I looked at your diary and there were plenty of days you did meet or exceed your protein goal. So on the days that you didn't meet it (remember you had 'extra' protein on some other days).
2. I also noticed in your diary that there are plenty of days that you are under your calorie goal -- like even by up to 300 calories or so. Eat another snack/meal that contains protein with those calories and you will get more protein. You're leaving calories (and thus, protein) on the table so to speak by not eating them.
But ultimately ... what MFP says you need as far as grams of protein per day might not be totally accurate...0 -
I was the one who suggested you open your diary, and I appreciate that you were responsive, but truly I don't have a lot to add to what quicker responders above have mentioned. There's a lot of calories in bread-like things, compared to your goals. You are already choosing bread with some protein, which is good.
I understand that many people like bread things, some find them filling. If that's you, then definitely keep eating some. But maybe reduce the amount, or choose alternate types? Sometimes, for example, wraps are more calorie-efficient than breads (read labels), if you find them equally tasty/satisfying.
Another thing I'm noticing is that you have butter somewhat often. It's only 10g portions, but that's 75 calories per use. How important is that to you for tastiness/satiation, or is it mostly a habit? Would some alternative work as a spread that has some protein, like neufchatel cheese (if you're not familiar, it's similar to cream cheese, just a little lower in calories). For around 70 calories, you could put a couple of tablespoons of that on your bagel (or half bagel, whatever), get at least a couple of grams of protein. Or chevre, if you like that, at around 80 calories for 28g, around 80 calories, 5g protein. Or lowfat cottage cheese, at maybe 12g protein for 80 calories. (The latter might need some spice/herb mix on top for tastiness, depending on your tastes.)
The above is the kind of thought process I was talking about, when I suggested reviewing your diary routinely, asking yourself which things have relatively many calories, but that aren't contributing well to your nutritional goals. If you need them for satiation or happiness (or whatever), that's a factor in the decision, too. It's subjective. But I think the thought process can work.
One aside: I noticed rice once. Here, one can get "chickpea rice", which is really a small orzo pasta. It's similar to rice in looks/feel (not identical) and neutral-flavored, but would have about 15g protein for 1/2C dry (more like 1.5C cooked), at 270 calories, vs. 6g protein for 268 calories of the rice. One brand here just needs to be mixed in boiling water and set aside for 10 minutes, basically, so easy.
Best wishes!
Thank you, I'm not a big butter eater and might be overestimating slightly as I haven't weighed the butter that I use. I only eat butter on toast, bagels, jacket potato, and crackers. I don't have it on sandwiches or on toast if it has something else on.
I do like bread and bread based things but currently my nutrition page on MFP shows that my carb intake is below target. Is it just that replacing it with something else is better? I thought I was going ok on that side 🤣
I'll have a look for chickpea rice.
I've got to say that one factor I have to keep in mind is what everyone else in the house is eating. It's ok if I can convince everyone else to eat things like chickpea rice but if they don't like it, it makes it harder as I'm not always the one who cooks (in normal times I get back from work 2.5 hours after my wife so she has normally sorted dinner for the kids and me).
I've tried to leave things fairly normal at the moment to see if I can spot problem areas from what I eat.
I think I've been under my calorie target each day and have lost a few pounds in the first few days, which is more than planned but I'm not complaining.
I do want to balance out the things that are reported as being low by my smart scales but do have to keep in mind how accurate they are or aren't!
I highly recommend weighing calorie dense foods like butter5 -
kshama2001 wrote: »I highly recommend weighing calorie dense foods like butter
I did start to now, my 10g estimate turned out to be an average of about 7g, so not miles off.
0 -
I'm still finding protein the hardest thing to fill in my diet. I'm also learning that with regular meals I'm normally under my calorie goal for the day which is probably why I'm always hungry - which used to result in eating some extra carbs or junk to fill that hunger.
I'm still working on changes to get me to fill the calories in the best way.
I did have one night out too which hit the calories and resulted in a 2lb weight gain but it is back heading down again.0 -
I'm still finding protein the hardest thing to fill in my diet. I'm also learning that with regular meals I'm normally under my calorie goal for the day which is probably why I'm always hungry - which used to result in eating some extra carbs or junk to fill that hunger.
I'm still working on changes to get me to fill the calories in the best way.
I did have one night out too which hit the calories and resulted in a 2lb weight gain but it is back heading down again.
This is probably water retention and not fat gain, so yes, it should drop rather easily. 2lbs of fat is about 7000 calories - so you would have needed to eat 7000 extra on top of your maintenance calories to gain that much. You probably didn't do that, even if you ate at a surplus that day.
I actually do set up my food to permit myself a small treat pretty much every day, and I think that's fine. Once I hit my minimums, I let the rest of my calories for the day come from wherever. It's true that I'm more satisfied overall if I'm eating mostly very nutritious food, but I wouldn't discount the emotional satisfaction from something that isn't like that, if you can fit it into your calories.0 -
It's tough to adjust at first because proteins are so satiating. I eat about 215g per day. I need 4 meals plus snacks.
Try a cup of egg whites everyday with an egg added in. Also, make sure that your other foods have some protein. Everything counts. Protein shakes, protein pancakes, protein ice cream are all good strategies to augment. It's an adjustment. You'll get used to it.1 -
I'm still finding protein the hardest thing to fill in my diet. I'm also learning that with regular meals I'm normally under my calorie goal for the day which is probably why I'm always hungry - which used to result in eating some extra carbs or junk to fill that hunger.
I'm still working on changes to get me to fill the calories in the best way.
I did have one night out too which hit the calories and resulted in a 2lb weight gain but it is back heading down again.
I see you haven't logged since August - you still with us?
Your dinner on Aug 30 looks delish, but I see you have tons of carbs in relationship to protein. So again my advice is to reduce carbs to make room for protein.
Or, when you are having difficulty meeting your calorie goal, just eat more protein.
Before I got my own protein sorted, my wires used to get crossed and I'd *think* I wanted carbs but what I *actually* needed was protein, and eating protein made that carb itch go away.
(Unless I was sleep deprived or had waited too long to eat, in which case only carbs would do. So I work very hard to not let that happen.)1 -
I am in the same boat, but I'm also a picky eater, so meat is my main source. I've only had a protein shake once but mixed it with "healthy" ice cream (I believe it was Nick's-highly recommended btw). Way too thick haha! I know if I'm running low on protein and don't have any meat handy or in a rush, I LOVE the Power Crunch Pro bars. They taste amazing and have 20g of protein (peanut butter creme is my favorite).
I love reading these suggestions. I'm currently dealing with some heavy mental health issues and going through medication changes (ugh), so my focus has been elsewhere and my diet has been s**t, so I need help getting back on the horse, so to speak. I'm going to try to do some precooking today like I used to, so hoping it helps.4 -
kshama2001 wrote: »I'm still finding protein the hardest thing to fill in my diet. I'm also learning that with regular meals I'm normally under my calorie goal for the day which is probably why I'm always hungry - which used to result in eating some extra carbs or junk to fill that hunger.
I'm still working on changes to get me to fill the calories in the best way.
I did have one night out too which hit the calories and resulted in a 2lb weight gain but it is back heading down again.
I see you haven't logged since August - you still with us?
Your dinner on Aug 30 looks delish, but I see you have tons of carbs in relationship to protein. So again my advice is to reduce carbs to make room for protein.
Or, when you are having difficulty meeting your calorie goal, just eat more protein.
Before I got my own protein sorted, my wires used to get crossed and I'd *think* I wanted carbs but what I *actually* needed was protein, and eating protein made that carb itch go away.
(Unless I was sleep deprived or had waited too long to eat, in which case only carbs would do. So I work very hard to not let that happen.)
Yes I'm still going with it. I haven't got the time to log everything and it is difficult to accurately measure my lunch as I am back at work now and get my lunch provided every day. I'm using what I learnt during the time I recorded to try and make subtle changes.
I initially lost 6lbs of my 10lb target but have plateaued now but I'm not putting it back on so that is good.
I'm certainly eating more protein than I did before and trying to replace some carbs with more protein where I can.1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions