Jennifer Hudson too thin?

they'll write anything to sell a story....she looks fine.

I think she looked great before she lost the weight and now I still think she lookes great!!!! I think the people that are saying that she is too thin is the people that have never had to struggle with their weight and now that she las lost the weight they still want to find something to say about her!!! I am proud of her!!!:happy:

She looks great, and she isn't too thin. She still has some weight on her. They put her in 4 inch heels which makes her look a lot thinner. And seriously, she's embracing healthy and moderate eating. Do they want her to be heavy so that heavy kids don't feel bad? Everyone should be following her example of trying to be healthy, and she's a better role model now.

I think she looked great before she lost the weight and now I still think she lookes great!!!! I think the people that are saying that she is too thin is the people that have never had to struggle with their weight and now that she las lost the weight they still want to find something to say about her!!! I am proud of her!!!:happy:

Exactly. And why aren't they saying anything about people like Megan Fox. If we're going to talk about too thin they should be directing it where it's deserved. Put Them two side by side and people will get the picture. She is healthy and looks great!!

People will never be satisfied. Yes, she looked great when she was a little on the heavy side. She is a great artist and she loved herself. But, she also wanted to get healthier and when they are paying you millions to lose weight, hell you gotta do it or you don't get paid. That is my honest opinion. She looks great now, too.

NOT TOO THIN YET...BUT DOES NOT NEED TO LOSE ANY MORE WEIGHT. SHE LOOKS AWESOME NOW! BUT WHEN LARGE FRAME WOMEN LOSE TO MUCH WEIGHT THEY LOOK LIKE A BOBBLE HEADS TO ME!

Too fat... too thin. Sometimes, you can never win.

If I can't win, then I'm having cake...

Maybe she was some sort of role model for young girls when she was embracing her larger figure and still succeeding in her career, but isn't getting herself in great shape and maintaining a healthy weight just as much of a good message for young girls these days? I would think in light of the childhood obesity statistics, this is a good thing!

I think this is the answer to your question.

I think younger celebrities are less susceptible to the criticism about being overweight because that is the norm in American society now. If you look at older celebrities, like Kirstie Alley, who used to be thinner and then gained a lot of weight, they take a lot of heat for it. They were thin before because they HAD to be. You couldn't get a job if you were overweight back then. Once their careers winded down and they put on some pounds, the media treated them like circus freaks with all the before-and-after photos and the "This is what she looked like 20 years ago!" headlines.

You don't have that as much today in most segments of the entertainment industries. There are a lot more overweight actors now, and especially in the music industry, being overweight is not as much of an obstacle as it used to be IF you are a great singer, like Jennifer Hudson, Adele, etc. So people will point to Jennifer Hudson and say "Oh, it's so great that she can be successful even though she's chubby ... what a great role model she is for overweight kids who are afraid to be who they are." It's such a load. Jennifer Hudson is not a better singer because she lost weight, but she is a better person and a better role model because she said to herself "I can change this," and then she went out and changed it. She set a goal, she worked hard on it, and she attained it. That's what overweight kids need to learn from.

Unfortunately, now, our society teaches kids that there's no such thing as failure, and thus, no point in trying to reach for anything better. They're all in for a rude awakening when they get to the real world and people suddenly expect them to try harder.

Jennifer Hudson is hot.

she was hot heavy

and she's hot thin.

she is just HOT.

and she has the self esteem to back it up, which only makes her more attractive.

ppl just like to talk *kitten*.

Too fat... too thin. Sometimes, you can never win.

Exactly. Women simply will never be able to get by without someone finding something to criticize.

She looks HEALTHY!

There is always someone who will criticize something (unfortunately)

Just to play Devil's Advocate, Jennifer Hudson has lost a lot of weight since she shot the WW ads. All in all, she's gone from a size 16 to a size 0.

1) If you ask me, she's "Hollywood thin" now -- she's built like Kate Hudson, Mila Kunis, Jessica Alba, etc.

2) Going from a size 16 to a size 0 is probably not a realistic goal for most normal people. My guess is that like most Hollywood hotties, she does it by micromanaging her macronutrients, spending a lot of time with a trainer, and only dropping to her show weight when she has an appearance or a gig.

3) To WW's credit, they're using the slightly heavier photos, not holding out the current Hudson as an example.

4) I agree, she's gorgeous at all weights.

Just to play Devil's Advocate, Jennifer Hudson has lost a lot of weight since she shot the WW ads. All in all, she's gone from a size 16 to a size 0.

I find this hard to believe, unless there are some secret, VERY thin photos of her that I'm not finding... I know she said that she was, but I don't know if it's true. I was never a 0, the lowest I've been is a 2... and I feel like I was much thinner than Jennifer is now. (See my pics, the one in a teal tank top was when I was a 2!)

Not to say anything negative about her... I think we all agree that she looks excellent. I just don't see her being a zero.