HCG diet...

elly620
elly620 Posts: 209 Member
edited October 3 in Health and Weight Loss
Has anyone tried the HCG diet? I started it yesterday and tomorrow is the beginning of the low calorie part. I wanted to know if anyone has gotten seriously sick while doing this diet. Thanks.


EDIT!!!! Please no bashing or being insulting. That is not why I posted this. I'm only asking the people who HAVE tried it to comment. Thank you.
«1

Replies

  • Apryl546
    Apryl546 Posts: 909 Member
    Who doesnt get seriously sick from doing this diet?

    I've not known one person who has kept the weight off after stopping the diet.
    Not ONE.
  • sjcply
    sjcply Posts: 817 Member
    500 calories.....that will make anyone sick! :sick: I have heard of ppl getting very ill from it and have heard ppl that didnt! If you have ANY type of medical conditions, I wouldnt do it!
  • Unwrapping_Candy
    Unwrapping_Candy Posts: 487 Member
    The amazing thing about this "die"t you're on is that it will "work" even without you taking the human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG). Why will it "work"? Because you're eating an insanely low amount of calories per day. It's truly an amazing scam..I mean "die"t. Good luck.

    P.S. "work" is in quotation marks because it won't work. Cheers. "die" is in quotation marks because that is what you would do if you made this "die"t your lifestyle. If it can't sustain you for life why do it at all?

    cheating-20110415-1704251.png
  • Jorra
    Jorra Posts: 3,338 Member
    Whether or not you FEEL sick, you will be making your body sick by not giving it enough energy and nutrients. HCG is a starvation diet and it's not a healthy way to lose weight. I've lost 62 pounds eating more than twice what that diet requires and I didn't have to pay for any expensive supplements made from urine.
  • blondski
    blondski Posts: 36 Member
    I have done it. Lost 40 pounds......gained 40 pounds....I did use it as a jump start on this site for a couple of weeks. Then started counting calories.....I am doing good without the HCG.....Also my hair is not falling out as fast as it was.
  • meerkat70
    meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
    I'm sorry, but this is an appalling diet choice. I wish you well, but this diet will make you sick, and the 'HCG' element has, for forty years, been proven over and over in medical research to be a total scam.
  • maidentl
    maidentl Posts: 3,203 Member
    I would never do it but I saw the show Dr. Oz did on it. Yes, people have become very sick on it.
  • naturallyflyy
    naturallyflyy Posts: 14 Member
    i must agree with that! everyone i know that has done it has gained back the weight plus some! very unhealthy diet!
  • comeback0903
    comeback0903 Posts: 114 Member
    I wont criticize I think if your going to use it as a jump start to get fast resultsand get motivated go on it , but when the month or so is over get serious about counting calories and exercising I know u dont exercise withHCG because of the low calorie intake.
    My sister did it los 28lbs
    and is gaining it all back because she went back to her old ways......
  • koosdel
    koosdel Posts: 3,317 Member
    500 calories a day on this 'diet'... if I remember correctly, Auschwitz prisoners were fed 600 calories/day.

    Stay away, its incredibly dangerous.
  • meerkat70
    meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
    I have done it. Lost 40 pounds......gained 40 pounds....I did use it as a jump start on this site for a couple of weeks. Then started counting calories.....I am doing good without the HCG.....Also my hair is not falling out as fast as it was.

    You're lucky, you just lost and regained. I know someone who lost lots, then added it back on and half again, and they've messed up their pituitary gland in the process.
  • Akjenn89
    Akjenn89 Posts: 265 Member
    My sister-in-law, her parents, my mom, my sister have all done this diet. I've also seen numerous other people do this diet. It's true, sometimes, people after the diet don't keep the weight off. Most of the time its because they don't do anything AFTER and just expect the weight to stay off. My sister-in-law, her parents, and sister have all had great success. But, they are also very conscious about what they put in their bodies now and are very strict about their diet. My sister exercises 5+ times a week on top of that. And so far, hasn't had any problem with it.

    But of course, everyone is different. If you personally start to experience any problems with it, call your doctor right away.

    I have to disagree with it working regardless of the chemical being there or not though. Putting your body in starvation mode doesn't automatically cause you to lose a substantial amount of weight. In fact, your body sometimes holds onto it more so than previously. (I haven't done HCG, but I have tried eating very little as possible when I was younger and it certainly did me little benefit).
  • Jorra
    Jorra Posts: 3,338 Member
    I'd also like to mention that part of this diet is not being able to exercise. If you aren't exercising and starving your body, what are you losing? Yup, muscle, not fat.
  • elly620
    elly620 Posts: 209 Member
    the hcg drops i bought says that light to moderate exercise is fine but not vigorous exercise. So i will continue to work out.
  • Qarol
    Qarol Posts: 6,171 Member
    If it can't sustain you for life why do it at all?
    This is genius...all summed up neatly in one little sentence.
  • Akjenn89
    Akjenn89 Posts: 265 Member
    I'd also like to mention that part of this diet is not being able to exercise. If you aren't exercising and starving your body, what are you losing? Yup, muscle, not fat.

    The whole point of the reason that people do this is because you -don't- lose the muscle. It puts your body in a type of "pregnancy mode" and activates your body so that it starts burning the fat -instead- of the muscle.
  • Gigi_licious
    Gigi_licious Posts: 1,185 Member
    Mission hcg needs to be aborted stat!
  • ewiedemann360
    ewiedemann360 Posts: 5 Member
    Never did this diet...used five meals a day at 2000 calories with regular work outs - three days of strenght training, three of cardio. Disciplined dieting, and no binging. Using that method, I have lost 37 pounds in just over 3 months. The better part of doing weight loss this way is that keeping the same diet will allow you to maintain healthy weight after weight loss. Read a book called Younger Next Year (there is a men's and women's version), and they will discuss the vicissitudes of this type of diet. Best wishes on you journey!
  • Jorra
    Jorra Posts: 3,338 Member
    I'd also like to mention that part of this diet is not being able to exercise. If you aren't exercising and starving your body, what are you losing? Yup, muscle, not fat.

    The whole point of the reason that people do this is because you -don't- lose the muscle. It puts your body in a type of "pregnancy mode" and activates your body so that it starts burning the fat -instead- of the muscle.

    There's never been a scientific study that's been able to replicate this result. No study has ever found it more effective than just starving yourself on 500 calories a day either.
  • meerkat70
    meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
    I'd also like to mention that part of this diet is not being able to exercise. If you aren't exercising and starving your body, what are you losing? Yup, muscle, not fat.

    The whole point of the reason that people do this is because you -don't- lose the muscle. It puts your body in a type of "pregnancy mode" and activates your body so that it starts burning the fat -instead- of the muscle.

    No, it really really doesn't. 4 DECADES of scientific research demonstrates that HCG has NO impact.

    I can't believe people are still suckered by this bull.
  • meerkat70
    meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
    the hcg drops i bought says that light to moderate exercise is fine but not vigorous exercise. So i will continue to work out.

    Please, please for the love of god... eat a healthy intake. Exercise moderately. It sounds like you've bought the homeopathic version. Which realistically is kind of a double dose of utter nonsense. Please don't do this to yourself. Do you like your hair? Do you like having nice, fully functioning organs? Do you like being healthy? Then don't buy into this incredibly unhealthy pseudo-scientific nonsense?
  • Unwrapping_Candy
    Unwrapping_Candy Posts: 487 Member
    No, it really really doesn't. 4 DECADES of scientific research demonstrates that HCG has NO impact.

    I can't believe people are still suckered by this bull.

    Where there are desperate, uneducated people there are scam artists waiting and willing to take their money.
  • thankyou4thevenom
    thankyou4thevenom Posts: 1,581 Member
    It's true, sometimes, people after the diet don't keep the weight off. Most of the time its because they don't do anything AFTER and just expect the weight to stay off.

    The thing is that's exactly what the diet sells itself as. So it's not surprising really.
  • Akjenn89
    Akjenn89 Posts: 265 Member
    It's true, sometimes, people after the diet don't keep the weight off. Most of the time its because they don't do anything AFTER and just expect the weight to stay off.

    The thing is that's exactly what the diet sells itself as. So it's not surprising really.

    Thank you. I'm not saying this is a catch all and will solve all your problems. But for -some- people, it's an okay starting off place.
  • tigersword
    tigersword Posts: 8,059 Member
    I have to disagree with it working regardless of the chemical being there or not though. Putting your body in starvation mode doesn't automatically cause you to lose a substantial amount of weight. In fact, your body sometimes holds onto it more so than previously. (I haven't done HCG, but I have tried eating very little as possible when I was younger and it certainly did me little benefit).

    Starvation mode happens when your metabolism slows down to equal the number of calories you are eating. Until that happens, you will lose weight. So, if you limit yourself to 500 calories a day, you will continue to lose weight until your metabolism slows to the point of only burning 500 calories a day. Unfortunately in order for that to happen, you have to lose a LOT of muscle mass, and a few non-essential or less-essential organ systems will have to shut down. All the HCG hormone does is suppress your hunger, so you can eat only 500 calories and not necessarily feel starving. So yes, eating 500 calories a day without the chemical will work just fine for probably several months, but the overall damage to your metabolism and system will be catastrophic.
  • koosdel
    koosdel Posts: 3,317 Member
    I'd also like to mention that part of this diet is not being able to exercise. If you aren't exercising and starving your body, what are you losing? Yup, muscle, not fat.

    The whole point of the reason that people do this is because you -don't- lose the muscle. It puts your body in a type of "pregnancy mode" and activates your body so that it starts burning the fat -instead- of the muscle.

    No, it really really doesn't. 4 DECADES of scientific research demonstrates that HCG has NO impact.

    I can't believe people are still suckered by this bull.

    Because they want to be. Or they are just stupid.
  • Thomasm198
    Thomasm198 Posts: 3,189 Member
    I'd also like to mention that part of this diet is not being able to exercise. If you aren't exercising and starving your body, what are you losing? Yup, muscle, not fat.

    The whole point of the reason that people do this is because you -don't- lose the muscle. It puts your body in a type of "pregnancy mode" and activates your body so that it starts burning the fat -instead- of the muscle.

    No, it really really doesn't. 4 DECADES of scientific research demonstrates that HCG has NO impact.

    I can't believe people are still suckered by this bull.

    Because they want to be. Or they are just stupid.

    Exactly. Too many people just want this:
    magic-bullet-system.jpg
  • meerkat70
    meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
    Has anyone tried the HCG diet? I started it yesterday and tomorrow is the beginning of the low calorie part. I wanted to know if anyone has gotten seriously sick while doing this diet. Thanks.


    EDIT!!!! Please no bashing or being insulting. That is not why I posted this. I'm only asking the people who HAVE tried it to comment. Thank you.

    Lovely, I'm not bashing you. I have a family member who did it and who is INCREDIBLY sick as a consequence. I in contrast have lost my weight the healthy way. I have another friend who has nasty, dodgy skin and hair coming off in clumps, sticking to this diet 'cause it works!'. It doesn't. It's a training in eating disorders.

    Undoubtedly someone will be along shortly to reassure you that it's fantastic and healthy. Ask them how long they've been on it. How much they've lost. How well they've maintained.

    I've lost 24lb in 8 weeks, with a healthy diet and exercise. That seems a pretty good outcome to me. Why would you (or anyone else) want to starve yourself, ingest a placebo, and risk serious illness, for a similar, or frankly poorer, outcome?
  • Jorra
    Jorra Posts: 3,338 Member
    Has anyone tried the HCG diet? I started it yesterday and tomorrow is the beginning of the low calorie part. I wanted to know if anyone has gotten seriously sick while doing this diet. Thanks.


    EDIT!!!! Please no bashing or being insulting. That is not why I posted this. I'm only asking the people who HAVE tried it to comment. Thank you.

    Lovely, I'm not bashing you. I have a family member who did it and who is INCREDIBLY sick as a consequence. I in contrast have lost my weight the healthy way. I have another friend who has nasty, dodgy skin and hair coming off in clumps, sticking to this diet 'cause it works!'. It doesn't. It's a training in eating disorders.

    Undoubtedly someone will be along shortly to reassure you that it's fantastic and healthy. Ask them how long they've been on it. How much they've lost. How well they've maintained.

    I've lost 24lb in 8 weeks, with a healthy diet and exercise. That seems a pretty good outcome to me. Why would you (or anyone else) want to starve yourself, ingest a placebo, and risk serious illness, for a similar, or frankly poorer, outcome?

    Exactly. We post because we care. We don't want you to get sick when you could be much healthier and achieve greater results.
This discussion has been closed.