Shakeology? Huh?

paravision
paravision Posts: 148
edited October 4 in Food and Nutrition
Ok so whats with it? Cheap alternatives? Why do you like it? Is it filling? Describe and name your fave flavors and why. and preference as meal replacement or snack.Thanks I want as much info as possible. I don't know really... xox
«1

Replies

  • I know Shakeology is ridiculously expensive. But personally, it is the only one I've ever had that tastes wonderful and fills me up. I love the chocolate and it really does keep you "regular"
  • cmriverside
    cmriverside Posts: 34,422 Member
    Be prepared for numerous personal messages offering to sell you some.
  • I have quite a few friends on facebook that absolutely swear by it! You can make a ton of different flavors some i have heard of are choco peanut butter, cinnamon roll and pumpkin. I guess you really can do a lot with it. Id love to get rid of a meal and have a shake but from what I hear its like 120$ for a month supply. Ouch.
  • aneajo
    aneajo Posts: 287 Member
    I have a couple of cousins who are doing it. They have lost weight and are very fit right now. BUT they were not that over weight to start with. I have looked into, its is very costly and only comes in 2 flavors.
  • MaryStregger
    MaryStregger Posts: 73 Member
    I've tried it and found it kind of gross actually - like I was drinking chocolate pudding. There are a lot of really great shake options out there that I find filling and a lot better tasting. Visalus is pretty great and if you eat one shake a day it costs about $50 a month plus whatever you mix into it (milk or orange juice or whatever).
  • Beezil
    Beezil Posts: 1,677 Member
    I've tried it. It's good, yes, but not that great. I had the chocolate flavor. Definitely fills you up too. I'd get it if it wasn't so expensive. But I think you're probably better off planning your meals out and finding healthy ways to eat. :)
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,993 Member
    Ok so whats with it? Cheap alternatives? Why do you like it? Is it filling? Describe and name your fave flavors and why. and preference as meal replacement or snack.Thanks I want as much info as possible. I don't know really... xox
    Can't speak for the taste or flavor, but for the cost you can find cheaper alternatives and get similar results. To pay $120 a month for one shake a day is pretty expensive. You can get others for $1 or less per serving compared to the $3-$4 you spend on Shakeology.
  • BodybyPlants
    BodybyPlants Posts: 76 Member
    Body by Vi - its great and nutritious!!!
  • Too expensive and I have been doing lots of research. I find Lean Shake from GNC is just as better and fulfilling and cheaper! Try it.
  • Gigi_licious
    Gigi_licious Posts: 1,185 Member
    *waiting for the shakeology piranhas to arrive*
  • kellyscomeback
    kellyscomeback Posts: 1,369 Member
    BSN Synth-6 on Amazon (cheapest prices), any flavor is delicious! I blend it with a stick blender, put some ice cubes in to chill the mix and enjoy.
  • aneajo
    aneajo Posts: 287 Member
    Too expensive and I have been doing lots of research. I find Lean Shake from GNC is just as better and fulfilling and cheaper! Try it.

    How much does that cost?
  • Unwrapping_Candy
    Unwrapping_Candy Posts: 487 Member
    The only kind of shakeology that really is worthy of attention :P

    388760.gif
  • I personally love it! I like both flavors Chocolate and Greenberry. Tropical will be out in January is Vegan. $3-4 a serving is not expensive to me. Most of you spend that much or more on lunch or on Starbucks. There are "cheaper" shakes out there but none of them have the same nutritional value. Just my opinion.
  • Gigi_licious
    Gigi_licious Posts: 1,185 Member
    I personally love it! I like both flavors Chocolate and Greenberry. Tropical will be out in January is Vegan. $3-4 a serving is not expensive to me. Most of you spend that much or more on lunch or on Starbucks. There are "cheaper" shakes out there but none of them have the same nutritional value. Just my opinion.

    Thank you for your unbiased opinion as a BeachBody coach who sells it.
  • Pebble321
    Pebble321 Posts: 6,423 Member
    I don't understand the shake fad at all - to me there is no point in getting my protein and sugars and vitamins in a glass full of processed ... um... well I don't know what it is - processed food-like-substance I guess you could say.
    My choice is to eat a varied diet full of real food. I understand that not everyone wants to or is able to do this, hence the explosion of well-marketed diet products with big promises and big prices.

    And I defnitley would not go anywhere near a diet product that is sold by multi-level marketing. That is wrong is so many many ways!

    My best suggestion is to read the ingredient label of whatever you want to try and if you know what the ingredients are and are happy to put them in your body - then go for it!
  • Too expensive and I have been doing lots of research. I find Lean Shake from GNC is just as better and fulfilling and cheaper! Try it.

    How much does that cost?
    119.00 for 30 servings
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,993 Member
    I personally love it! I like both flavors Chocolate and Greenberry. Tropical will be out in January is Vegan. $3-4 a serving is not expensive to me. Most of you spend that much or more on lunch or on Starbucks. There are "cheaper" shakes out there but none of them have the same nutritional value. Just my opinion.
    Shakeology is manufactured by a 3rd party and not Beach Body. Like most 3rd party manufacturers they will use low grade raw material (in this case from China) that isn't regulated since it's imported. So you can't be sure that you're not getting filler.
    It's moderate in protein (18g) compared to many other shakes (24g). For more than double the price, you would think you would get more protein and also higher quality protein blends. IMO, it's more about the marketing of the product.
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,993 Member
    BTW to use the analogy that eating fast food or getting a Starbucks coffee as a comparison isn't valid. People aren't consuming that as a meal replacement or protein supplement.
  • Lyadeia
    Lyadeia Posts: 4,603 Member
    I personally like the chocolate flavor but hate the greenberry flavor. I haven't had to take vitamins since using it, either. I used to have a protein shake plus a horse pill of a multi...now just the shake...so it works out for me. I think it tastes much better than pretty much every chocolate protein powder I have ever used which all taste kinda chalky to me. I like to mix it up with almond milk, flaxseed, and peanut butter and it honestly tastes like someone melted a Reese's in my cup. It gives me my choco-PB fix so I don't go running for the Reese's either.
  • Ok, yes, I'm a Beachbody coach, so of course I'm going to promote Shakeology, right? Well, listen to my story first.....

    I changed my diet to mostly raw foods over the summer, including dairy. I even started making my own kefir with raw milk. Some of you are probably gagging right now.....sorry!

    Anyway, when I signed on as a coach (free, b/c we're active duty military, so I was like, "Hey, it's free AND I get my workouts at wholesale...score!"), I decided to check out Shakeology. We are a one income family, so even with my discount I was VERY hesitant to purchase it. First I did some research on it. If I don't put unhealthy stuff in my body, I'm not going to try some shake that may have artificial stuff or is just loaded with protein.

    I was really amazed at what I found out about Shakeology. First of all, I didn't expect it to taste good, but it did. I made mine taste just like a Mocha Frappe from Starbucks. Secondly, the ingredients blew me away. There's VEGETABLES in the shakes, people! I was kind of weirded out by the thought of barley and wheat grass in my shakes. Because even though we do a lot of "weird" stuff already, I wasn't sure how I felt about that in my chocolate shake!

    I still believe it's very pricey for a shake, but when comparing what's out there, it's a reasonable amount of money.

    NOW...there are other shakes that ARE cheaper! My new fave is the Beachbody meal replacement vanilla. It's only $40 for 30 servings. It's just as filling and actually creamier in my opinion.

    AND....if you want to really go "cheap" and healthy, make your OWN shakes! I used my raw homemade kefir mixed with the same things I put in my Beachbody shakes. The protein and other nutrients can't be beat!

    Good luck!
  • PS Regardless of what shakes you consume.....you should be able to at least pronounce the ingredients!!! Don't put artificial things in your body!!!
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,993 Member
    PS Regardless of what shakes you consume.....you should be able to at least pronounce the ingredients!!! Don't put artificial things in your body!!!
    Hate to tell you that if you think that there's nothing artificial in any shake on the market, you've been scammed. You do realize that Shakeology is made by a 3rd party and not manufactured by Beach Body right?
  • Shakeology is certified by a 3rd party, but manufactured by Beachbody in NY. It really is all natural.

    I'm very open to finding out the truth if it is not. Please let me know where I could find info on how I'm being scammed. I take my health very seriously!
  • Lyadeia
    Lyadeia Posts: 4,603 Member
    Shakeology is certified by a 3rd party, but manufactured by Beachbody in NY. It really is all natural.

    I'm very open to finding out the truth if it is not. Please let me know where I could find info on how I'm being scammed. I take my health very seriously!

    It's not a scam, some people just don't like it. :wink:

    It's like Amazing Grass...also not a bad shake...or Body by Vi....another decent one. But if you don't like, that's great! But nobody should try to persuade you from getting in your good nutrition as they do.

    It started out as a hatred for the recruiting/selling types on MFP and for some people it has unfortunately been turned into a vendetta against the products. I mean, call Shakeology a scam and then say it's OK to gulp down Diet Coke? People just need to make their own informed decisions and tune out the people that make the opposite ones as long as we are all making healthy decisions.
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,993 Member
    Shakeology is certified by a 3rd party, but manufactured by Beachbody in NY. It really is all natural.

    I'm very open to finding out the truth if it is not. Please let me know where I could find info on how I'm being scammed. I take my health very seriously!
    Well first look at the bottom of the nutrition label it states it as "DISTRIBUTED" by Beach Body. If it was made by Beach Body it would state "MANUFACTURED and DISTRIBUTED" by Beach Body...........

    "Shakeology is manufactured in a facility that is registered with the FDA, adheres to current Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) and is GMP-Certified by the NSF (National Science Foundation) and the NPA (Natural Products Association)."

    This is from Denis of the ad staff of Beach Body.
    http://www.teambeachbody.com/connect/message-boards/-/message_boards/message/82773966

    Notice it doesn't say a "Beach Body owned" facility, meaning like many other supplements it's made by a 3rd party. 3rd party manufacturers under GMP get their raw materials from other countries other than the US because it's cheaper. But then you don't have regulation which is why you really don't have any idea if the raw materials are contaminated or are just filler, etc.

    So though the ingredients may be claimed as natural, it doesn't guarantee that they may not be contaminated.

    If you read the whole response from Denis, he even states it doesn't even get a "certified organic" label because of cost. But if the whole statement that "it's natural" could be reenforced should they get the certification to prove it? That would mean that all the ingredients would HAVE to be natural and organic. Without the certification, they aren't held to that, which means there could be ingredients that DON'T have to be totally natural in them.


    I've studied and used supplements since the 80's and KNOW that most of them are mostly "advertised" as being the "best".
    It's subjective and because of DSHEA they can claim what they want as long as they don't claim it "cures" diseases, sickness, etc. That's why the disclaimer at the bottom on every label.
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,993 Member
    Reading unbiased reviews helps too.

    http://supplement-geek.com/shakeology-review/
  • Nelski
    Nelski Posts: 1,607 Member
    I do like the chocolate, but not greenberry. Another fruity one is supposed to be coming out soon. It is pretty expensive. I was afraid to try it but it there is a 30 money back guaranty so I tried it. I ended up liking it so I'm sticking with it. I think the chocolate tastes good, it reminds me of Carnation Instant Breakfast that I used to drink a lot as a kid. I like to add banana or peanut butter sometimes to switch up the flavor. I wish it wasn't so expensive, but being a Beach Body coach does help with the discount. It's a filling, healthy, fast meal to have so to me it's worth it.
  • YogaRunner
    YogaRunner Posts: 652 Member
    It's definitely not a scam. I've seen the results first hand in my own family. Weight loss, lower cholesterol, no more need for Lipitor, no more IBS, no more hypoglycemia. The fact is, Some people will just be haters, full of negativity and pessimism. When they are presented with something real and genuine, they can't see it. The fact is, the public has been scammed way too often. A healthy bit of skepticism is important, but some people try to prove everything is a scam, even when it's not. Do your own research, make your own decisions and don't be brought down by the skeptics.
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,993 Member
    It's definitely not a scam. I've seen the results first hand in my own family. Weight loss, lower cholesterol, no more need for Lipitor, no more IBS, no more hypoglycemia. The fact is, Some people will just be haters, full of negativity and pessimism. When they are presented with something real and genuine, they can't see it. The fact is, the public has been scammed way too often. A healthy bit of skepticism is important, but some people try to prove everything is a scam, even when it's not. Do your own research, make your own decisions and don't be brought down by the skeptics.
    There have been many here that have done it without Shakeology. I never said the product DIDN'T work. I've more than revealed that it's an MLM and that the product is expensive for what you are actually getting.
    And really how can you be unbiased about it when you're a Distributor of it. Dispute the facts I stated about it. Don't just say I'm a hater. I've posted information on how it's made, and the processing of it.
    If it's processed that way, then it's really no different than many other supplements on the market, but the COST is WAY higher. So where does that money go? It's shared amongst the distributor, their sponsor and their sponsor, and their sponsor, and their sponsor all the way up to Beach Body. Why should someone pay higher dollars to pay income to people who had NOTHING to do with the actual sale? That's why it's a scam. All MLM's are built that way.
This discussion has been closed.