being fat in Japan

chubiD
chubiD Posts: 260
edited October 6 in Chit-Chat
I've just found this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L1hqHo6lyUU&feature=share

Gives you something to think about, doesn't it?
«1

Replies

  • Fatlorenzo
    Fatlorenzo Posts: 101 Member
    haha, imagine that happening in the west, be great ot have one more excuse to lose weight!
  • realme56
    realme56 Posts: 1,093 Member
    Wow!! They are smaller people but still...
  • woou
    woou Posts: 668 Member
    hm, I sometimes do wonder about what pressures for being thin works. Whatever we're doing here is obviously not working, since obesity is still rising or perhaps it's because of the rampant fast food places and other factors that make unhealthy calorie dense food more appealing. What is viewed as normal weight here is viewed as fat in some other countries. At 5'3" and 138, I'm pretty sure my mom's home country would view that as obese in all honesty.
  • Saruman_w
    Saruman_w Posts: 1,531 Member
    First thing I thought of: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c98qdFQF7sw
  • I just viewed your link. Wow, I didn't think they looked overweight at all.
  • MelissaL582
    MelissaL582 Posts: 1,422 Member
    Thanks for sharing. Maybe the U.S. should look into this.
  • cheeksv
    cheeksv Posts: 521 Member
    If my company were facing millions in fines and a raise in health premiums I could defiantly get behind this. A raise to them means a raise to the employee and less money in everyone's pocket. And if the company can't afford it? Then jobs would be lost so they could. I would do it happily, and if the company is the on e facing the troubles than they should be the ones to help with the changes. I mean, take a way some fast food restaurants and that doesn't do much except send people other places to get lunch. Tell them their jobs and health care could be effected and to eat healthier AT work and that might get the message across to cross it over to other parts of their life.
  • jmxxiiii
    jmxxiiii Posts: 231 Member
    I wonder what they think of those stereotypical military wives who live in Japan LOL.
  • chubiD
    chubiD Posts: 260

    Totally cracked me up! :laugh:
  • Purpleflipflops
    Purpleflipflops Posts: 563 Member
    Amazing! I wonder what it'd be life if we gave these standards to American companies?!
  • asian bodies are smaller in general, in comparison to us americans. we're taller, and overall our measurements are naturally a few inches more. not just due to fat, but because of our bones. our ring sizes, shoe size, hat size, etc..are all generally bigger. so if that system were in place, i doubt many of us would fit in the 35 inches or less category.

    but that's pretty much where the excuses for us stop. our traditional american meal is usually full of mac and cheese, mashed potatoes, casseroles, etc. stuff our grandmas used to make definitely did not total to 600 calories a meal lol

    these days we chalk up our waistlines to our stressful jobs, marriage, having children, getting older, and not having enough time to work out, etc. god forbid you tell an american woman who had a kid, that she needs to lose weight or lose her job. you'll have everyone screaming unfair sexism. it's just become culturally acceptable to be overweight. it's rude to mention someone's weight, it's considered shallow not to date a woman because she's thick, and definitely not acceptable to not give someone a job because they're overweight. so i seriously doubt we will have someone in our company measuring waistlines anytime soon...

    but! we can definitely take some of their good ideas. i'm sure alot of people who work in an office would relish the opportunity to stand up from their work twice a day and stretch, and take some relaxing deep breaths. socially speaking, it makes for a far more productive and friendly work enviornment! i've also heard they do a morning stretch in their classrooms to help the kid's improved brain function. definitely an easy addition that could have great results if we made it a country-wide practice.
  • I thinks that would only make eating disorders worse, and might raise the suicide rate.
  • chris6515
    chris6515 Posts: 131 Member
    I can sort of see something like this happening here as national health care broadens. Companies could be charged more for premiums for having overweight employees, kind of like higher premiums for smokers is becoming the norm. I could see us having to step on the scale just like we already may have to pee in a cup.
  • Laces_0ut
    Laces_0ut Posts: 3,750 Member
    I can sort of see something like this happening here as national health care broadens. Companies could be charged more for premiums for having overweight employees, kind of like higher premiums for smokers is becoming the norm. I could see us having to step on the scale just like we already may have to pee in a cup.

    hopefully this happens. the people at risk should pay more.
  • MaraDiaz
    MaraDiaz Posts: 4,604 Member
    http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/08/04/us-food-costs-idUSTRE7734L620110804

    "Eating healthier food can add almost 10 percent to the average American's food bill -- and that is just to boost a single nutrient like potassium."

    Fix the fact that unhealthy, fattening foods cost less than healthy foods for starters. Then go from there. If regular Americans can't afford to eat healthy, no program in the world is going to change that except programs that lower the cost of healthy food.
  • woou
    woou Posts: 668 Member
    What happens when people turn to smoking, cocaine, etc... to lose the weight? A smaller body doesn't always mean it was derived in a healthy manner. If we were to impose this, I think health should also be measured in other ways, not just from measurements and the number on the scale.
  • Laces_0ut
    Laces_0ut Posts: 3,750 Member
    http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/08/04/us-food-costs-idUSTRE7734L620110804

    "Eating healthier food can add almost 10 percent to the average American's food bill -- and that is just to boost a single nutrient like potassium."

    Fix the fact that unhealthy, fattening foods cost less than healthy foods for starters. Then go from there. If regular Americans can't afford to eat healthy, no program in the world is going to change that except programs that lower the cost of healthy food.

    whats to fix? bad fatty meat is going to cost less than lean meat for example. you can't "fix" that.
  • rockerbabyy
    rockerbabyy Posts: 2,258 Member
    http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/08/04/us-food-costs-idUSTRE7734L620110804

    "Eating healthier food can add almost 10 percent to the average American's food bill -- and that is just to boost a single nutrient like potassium."

    Fix the fact that unhealthy, fattening foods cost less than healthy foods for starters. Then go from there. If regular Americans can't afford to eat healthy, no program in the world is going to change that except programs that lower the cost of healthy food.

    whats to fix? bad fatty meat is going to cost less than lean meat for example. you can't "fix" that.
    the article isnt talking about lean meat vs fatty meat.. its talking about foods that would add more potassium, vitamin d, and other nutrients to your diet. fruits and vegetables vs boxed/canned/processed stuff
  • Laces_0ut
    Laces_0ut Posts: 3,750 Member
    http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/08/04/us-food-costs-idUSTRE7734L620110804

    "Eating healthier food can add almost 10 percent to the average American's food bill -- and that is just to boost a single nutrient like potassium."

    Fix the fact that unhealthy, fattening foods cost less than healthy foods for starters. Then go from there. If regular Americans can't afford to eat healthy, no program in the world is going to change that except programs that lower the cost of healthy food.

    whats to fix? bad fatty meat is going to cost less than lean meat for example. you can't "fix" that.
    the article isnt talking about lean meat vs fatty meat.. its talking about foods that would add more potassium, vitamin d, and other nutrients to your diet. fruits and vegetables vs boxed/canned/processed stuff

    "Fix the fact that unhealthy, fattening foods cost less than healthy foods for starters." thats what i was responding to.
  • rockerbabyy
    rockerbabyy Posts: 2,258 Member

    the article isnt talking about lean meat vs fatty meat.. its talking about foods that would add more potassium, vitamin d, and other nutrients to your diet. fruits and vegetables vs boxed/canned/processed stuff

    "Fix the fact that unhealthy, fattening foods cost less than healthy foods for starters." thats what i was responding to.
    so boxed/canned/processed isnt unhealthy and fattening, compared to fresh fruits and veggies?
    not trying to argue here - just pointing out that fatty vs lean meat isnt the only change that people need to make to eat healthier. its more expensive to buy enough produce and whole foods to feed a family than it is to buy some hamburger helper and ground beef
  • Laces_0ut
    Laces_0ut Posts: 3,750 Member

    the article isnt talking about lean meat vs fatty meat.. its talking about foods that would add more potassium, vitamin d, and other nutrients to your diet. fruits and vegetables vs boxed/canned/processed stuff

    "Fix the fact that unhealthy, fattening foods cost less than healthy foods for starters." thats what i was responding to.
    so boxed/canned/processed isnt unhealthy and fattening, compared to fresh fruits and veggies?
    not trying to argue here - just pointing out that fatty vs lean meat isnt the only change that people need to make to eat healthier. its more expensive to buy enough produce and whole foods to feed a family than it is to buy some hamburger helper and ground beef

    where did i say boxed/canned/ processed isnt unhealthy and fattening compared to fruits and vegetables? fat vs lean meat was one example. i didnt say it was the only thing to be concerned about. you seem to be confused.
  • rockerbabyy
    rockerbabyy Posts: 2,258 Member


    where did i say boxed/canned/ processed isnt unhealthy and fattening compared to fruits and vegetables? fat vs lean meat was one example. i didnt say it was the only thing to be concerned about. you seem to be confused.
    im not confused at all.
    other than maybe why fatty vs lean meat was the only thing you brought up when theres obviously bigger issues.
    you asked what needed to be "fixed" - i gave a useful example.
  • Laces_0ut
    Laces_0ut Posts: 3,750 Member


    where did i say boxed/canned/ processed isnt unhealthy and fattening compared to fruits and vegetables? fat vs lean meat was one example. i didnt say it was the only thing to be concerned about. you seem to be confused.
    im not confused at all.
    other than maybe why fatty vs lean meat was the only thing you brought up when theres obviously bigger issues.
    you asked what needed to be "fixed" - i gave a useful example.

    you are clearly confused when you say "so boxed/canned/processed isnt unhealthy and fattening, compared to fresh fruits and veggies? " because nowhere did i imply that. not sure what your issue is or why you feel like you need to go on like this. lets just agree to disagree. /shrug
  • janesmith1
    janesmith1 Posts: 1,511 Member
    http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/08/04/us-food-costs-idUSTRE7734L620110804

    "Eating healthier food can add almost 10 percent to the average American's food bill -- and that is just to boost a single nutrient like potassium."

    Fix the fact that unhealthy, fattening foods cost less than healthy foods for starters. Then go from there. If regular Americans can't afford to eat healthy, no program in the world is going to change that except programs that lower the cost of healthy food.

    While I agree, I am not sure what the answer is. All sides of the coin have their pluses and minuses. WF costs big bucks, but if you try to shop their 360 brand which is less and use their bulk bins it's less too. If you're in the areas where there's a Winco Supermarket they have bulk bins that have pretty incredible prices. For instance a friend of mine lives near a Winco and her bulk bin pinto beans are .69 / lb and my bulk bin pintos are 1.99 / lb

    There's also Costco and ethnic groceries too which tend to have great prices. Again, for instance I found cilantro at a local Mexican market that was .25 a bunch and at my local store it was 1.99 / bunch.

    There's other factors too. Many of us want to make sure we eat FDA approved American groceries which tend to be more expensive than ones grown in Mexico. The problem is when you eat things from out of the USA you can't be sure of the pesticide content of the fruits and veggies that you're eating, many times it's higher. For instance I saw this video of someone in Mexico that was spraying the hell out of his agave plants that he was going to sell off eventually to the USA as "agave syrup", I was kind of appalled when I saw that.

    Of course, it's always best to try to eat locally and organically but not always possible. I think bulk bins are pretty awesome and a huge savings, and sometimes Farmer's Markets are too. I love them as well.

    In this day and age it seems we have to "shop smart" and go to different places to shop for our groceries. I can go to 4 places on my shopping day. Unfortunately, most people don't have the time to do that.
  • BroiledNotFried
    BroiledNotFried Posts: 446 Member
    The people in Japan eat much more sodium, and have an increased risk of hemorrhagic strokes. We, however, our fattter. Our blubber gives us an increased risk of diabetes heart attacks, blockages, and cancer.

    I know of an insurance company that covers a major Georgia company. It is charging workers (including any dependants) that smoke 20% more on premiums. The insurance company also requires an annual physical. If the worker and all dependants missed their physical, the bill increases by 15%. In the physical, the insurance company had the physician's offices take BMI and waist size, as well as a good blood work-up.
  • MaraDiaz
    MaraDiaz Posts: 4,604 Member
    You can fix it with price controls, as long as you're willing to ignore the howls from various sectors that profit from not having price controls.
  • janesmith1
    janesmith1 Posts: 1,511 Member
    You can fix it with price controls, as long as you're willing to ignore the howls from various sectors that profit from not having price controls.

    Well, as long as you don't live in a capitalist system (and I'm not counting China since they have a thriving capitalist system, they do social controls, not price controls at this point). Iran has price controls and 70% unemployment. Even when there was a rice shortage China & India did not do price controls and the rice went back down to normal price levels. Price controls in Cuba don't work because there's a thriving black market for goods and services.
  • SerenaFisher
    SerenaFisher Posts: 2,170 Member
    I see people blaming food... work... time. What about the fact that this country is just lazy and entitled? I bet I could eat MCDONALDS for a month (eating their "better options") and unlike the movie done on it not only lose weight but be healthier than I am now with excersize and self control. No one says you have to buy a big mac when you go, furthermore no one says you have to supersize it! Its funny how we pass the buck here.

    Oh I also have raw vegtibles, home grown meat, and other natural food... because I grow my own. Sadly. Live in a city you don't have that option. :) really
  • i_love_vinegar
    i_love_vinegar Posts: 2,092 Member
    i Iive in japan and the people are not thinner because of the food or genetics LOL...i am pretty certain anorexia is extremely common here ^^ in hong kong, for instance, women will eat tape worms to lose weight...here they have 0 calorie jelly "meals" at every grocery or convenience store. In thailand (i think it is) women get botox on their legs to make them thinner...

    i am 4'10" and when i came here i was 100 pounds -- thin in the u.s. but fat here. ^^ i am currently 95 and still considered fat.

    before i came here, i understood that japanese are thin...but it is much different in reality...basically a bmi over 18.5 is fat.

    so...the ppl getting punished by this law are...considered the morbidly obese of america (but on japanese terms).

    i could go on and on...but really there are a lot of unnaturally thin ppl here...and I'm positive its because a lot of ppl here are obsessed with diets and women compete to be the thinnest (and a lot of men here find very thin attractive) ^^ ok thats all~
  • umachanxo
    umachanxo Posts: 926 Member
    Anorexia may be common and what you're seeing and experiencing is most likely by all means accurate, but that does not mean that genetics and the different builds have nothing to do with it.
This discussion has been closed.