Anyone trying to go "wheat free?"
inafit16177
Posts: 84
I just read the book "wheat belly" and I have to say that I am wondering...I figured that I could try it out...see for myself if there is some validity to it. The science makes sense...last week I thought I was on board as I was reading the book. Then realized as I finished the book that wheat is in a lot of odd things...So this is day three for me, wheat free...I have to say that it is odd...I am not having the between meal hunger that I normally experience. Yesterday was a very stressful, and emotional day, normally I would have sought out food for comfort, and I did not want to eat a pizza. It took me by surprise. I did have some wine last night, but hey it is wheat free. I am making sure that I am getting 5+ fruits and veggies a day( trying to stick to 1 or 2 fruit and the rest veggies). We are a vegetarian household so our foods always seem to be very wheat heavy, whole wheat bread, whole wheat pasta, wheat crackers...you get the picture, it was as I started reading that I realized my almost 9 year old daughter who has always been slender has what the author would call a "beer belly" Yikes. I am nervous about the nutrient aspect, and I realize that I am rambling...just looking for some feedback...
0
Replies
-
I'm gluten-free, because it makes me sick... which is basically anything with wheat flour in it. And some other weird stuff that uses gluten as a binding agent.0
-
My hubby and I are 99% gluten free.0
-
I've been reading alot about this lately and am willing to try it, but need to read a book on it to get the whole scope before I start. I have that beer belly look and I'm not really much of a beer drinker. Any suggestions on a good book. Short articles just don't seem to cover enough info.0
-
I saw an interview with the doctor that wrote "Wheat Belly" a couple of weeks ago. I am aware that genetically modified foods are already in the system, so his theory about "franken wheat" did not surprise me and made sense.
I play around with it all the time and just started gluten/wheat free again this week. I do know in the past I have done better in terms of weight loss when I don't eat any bread/pasta etc.0 -
I am probably about 2/3rds wheat free as my boyfriend is wheat intolerant, so we have wheat free pasta etc at home, and all the cooking sauces/gravy etc have to be wheat free. i do fins that when i have 'normal' pasta - usually a treat when we eat out, it does make me feel more bloated.
Its now habit for me to check the ingredients of ANYTHING i pick up at the supermarket! its quite suprising how much stuff has wheat in it!0 -
Thanks for your post. Congrats on maintaining a vegetarian household! I'm vegan, no coffee, alcohol, or sugar/corn syrup/artificial sweeteners. A wheat-free diet has always intrigued me, though. Need to do more research before making the leap and plan to check out that book. Please keep us updated on your progress!0
-
My bf is trying hard, as he is allergic (causes sinus problems and rapid fire sneezing, stuffy head every time he eats it). And I want to go that direction too, as I believe (without doctor verification) that I have a disordered insulin response. My extra weight is very belly oriented, too. I also understand that gluten and processed sugars in over abundance can lead to an overgrowth of yeast in the body that causes a whole host of issues....
Wheat really is in everything, and there are too many words that they use to hide wheat and gluten in ingredients...but I think it is worth it for folks to try. Even if they aren't sensitive or allergic. If you have stubborn weight that doesn't come off or serious skin problems, it could be wheat/gluten.0 -
Im all kinds of " free". Basically all known allergien foods, if i eat it ill breakout ugly by my jawlines, it messes with my hormones, all i can eat to be ok is fruit and veggies ... Wheat is in alot of things like soy, yuk....0
-
The book that I read is called "Wheat Belly" and it is written by William Davis M.D. It is an eye opener0
-
I've been reading alot about this lately and am willing to try it, but need to read a book on it to get the whole scope before I start. I have that beer belly look and I'm not really much of a beer drinker. Any suggestions on a good book. Short articles just don't seem to cover enough info.0
-
Was gluten free for about 7 months, went off it because I am stupid, and now I am back on the horse after my most recent doc. appointment this past Friday.
IT HELPS.
Most people just take in TOO MUCH wheat. If you aren't a celiac or have a gluten intolerance, you could always try reducing your intake to 2-3 times a week, rather than cutting it out completely.
Schar is a great gluten free brand.
Trader Joes has wonderful brown rice noodles on the cheap (most of these are really mushy and bleh, but not TJ's)
Hmm... what else? I can't quite think of anything else right now, but if you have any questions, feel free to message me.0 -
It has not been an easy road going against the norm...We are a no HFCS home as well because my almost 5 year old started having horiible bowel issues about 2 1/2 years ago...After many doctor visits and no explanations to why he was literally passing undigested foods we were told that he was HFCS sensitive. IT was an amazing difference when we eliminated it, and if it somehow sneaks by us (via grandma), he is sick for several days. People think that we are making it up when we say he can't have it that he has a sensitivity to it, they will say so he is not allergic..so he can have it, or we have had people say that they saw a commercial on t.v. that told them that our bodies can not tell the difference between sugar and HFCS...0
-
...or we have had people say that they saw a commercial on t.v. that told them that our bodies can not tell the difference between sugar and HFCS...
I remember when those commercials came out...really chapped my *kitten*!! While I agree that sugar is sugar, I'll take the refined white sugar any day over HFCS. I am amazed at the products that you find it in: it is everywhere. There are a lot of things that I don't eat anymore for that reason. Every once in awhile I will have something with it, and it's usually because I mindlessly grab something w/o checking the label. But for the most part, I steer clear.
I have noticed recently though that some products that used to have HFCS now use regular sugar. I suppose you could call that progress.0 -
I have noticed recently though that some products that used to have HFCS now use regular sugar. I suppose you could call that progress.
That's only because with the increased use of biofuel (made from CORN) the savings companies had by making a product with HFCS have greatly diminished. The cost savings is almost gone completely. They are now shifting to regular sugar because there isn't enough savings to justify all the processing costs for the HFCS.... It's all about the $$$$$, nothing to do with being healthier or not. :-\0 -
I have noticed recently though that some products that used to have HFCS now use regular sugar. I suppose you could call that progress.
That's only because with the increased use of biofuel (made from CORN) the savings companies had by making a product with HFCS have greatly diminished. The cost savings is almost gone completely. They are now shifting to regular sugar because there isn't enough savings to justify all the processing costs for the HFCS.... It's all about the $$$$$, nothing to do with being healthier or not. :-\
Great point! I know that the whole biofuel thing (which IMO is complete rubbish), has driven up the cost of corn, and subsequently food prices. But I had not made that connection in regard to switching from HFCS back to plain old sugar. Anyway, I don't eat a lot of processed foods, so it doesn't really impact my diet one way or another.0 -
I am about 95% wheat free due to allergies. I feel great. Please freind me so we can share ideas.0
-
I need all the help I can get. I am reading the book now but I cannot seem to start following any diet...especially wheat free. Any suggestions?0
-
I've though about going gluten free, no allergy/Celiac just curious about what would happen. For those of you who are gluten/wheat free, have you noticed a significant increase in food costs? I just got out of college and am BROKE and am spending all of my money applying to graduate school so I'm trying to figure out how to budget for it. It seems like all of the gluten free items I check out at the store are much more pricy. What's your experience? Was it worth it?0
-
Yes, I do about 3 months wheat free a year. I definitely do get less gassy, and I lose weight, but I can only do 3 months at a stretch as it makes me feel tired and hungry after a few months, and my running times start suffering. I always feel great for the first 6 weeks.
I think going wheat free for short periods is great and helps clear out your system, but I am not personally happy with it as an ongoing lifestyle. I have enough restrictions on my diet being vegetarian and allergic to citrus fruit. I don't think it is good for me to further restrict my diet without medical need. I am not someone who has a huge amount of wheat in my diet anyway. I don't eat cake or biscuits, and don't like pasta or white bread.
Edit, I also get much worse skin when wheat free, even though my macros stay the same. I invariably get spots, which I shouldn't be doing at 34!0 -
I have been mainly wheat free since about august/sept.
For me I found cutting a huge chunk of it out helped.. I don't bother checking all ingredients for it but for example instead of having wheat based cereal, AND bread for sandwiches for lunch AND pasta (or other carbs with dinner) i changed the biggest things.
Cereal I use Rice Krispies or Oats, lunch is salad or soup, dinner is salad or veg with fish or white meat. I do allow a mini yorkshire pudding with sunday dinner but that's the only flour item I have. I managed to find some gluten free brownies and don't have any other pies or pastry products.
I found this easy to stick to, only have small amount with sunday dinner doesn't make water weight go up by huge amount it has improved drastically from 3-5lbs daily fluctuations to 1-2lb and monthly was previously 6-10lbs and now around 4lbs for that week.
I also cut potatoes, rice, pasta (any grain based item) with main meal and replaced things like mashed potato with carrot and swede mash. I allow potato OR rice once a week for treat meal.
I don't think I'm allergic to it though I just pile on water after eating lots of it? I've lost 12" from tummy and 8 " off waist since cutting amount of carbs I eat daily.0 -
I have been mainly wheat free since about august/sept.
For me I found cutting a huge chunk of it out helped.. I don't bother checking all ingredients for it but for example instead of having wheat based cereal, AND bread for sandwiches for lunch AND pasta (or other carbs with dinner) i changed the biggest things.
Cereal I use Rice Krispies or Oats, lunch is salad or soup, dinner is salad or veg with fish or white meat. I do allow a mini yorkshire pudding with sunday dinner but that's the only flour item I have. I managed to find some gluten free brownies and don't have any other pies or pastry products.
I found this easy to stick to, only have small amount with sunday dinner doesn't make water weight go up by huge amount it has improved drastically from 3-5lbs daily fluctuations to 1-2lb and monthly was previously 6-10lbs and now around 4lbs for that week.
I also cut potatoes, rice, pasta (any grain based item) with main meal and replaced things like mashed potato with carrot and swede mash. I allow potato OR rice once a week for treat meal.
I don't think I'm allergic to it though I just pile on water after eating lots of it? I've lost 12" from tummy and 8 " off waist since cutting amount of carbs I eat daily.
My girlfriend is totally gluten free due to a serious celiac problem. One thing, is she lost serious weight. She ids tiny to begin with, 5'! but went down to 80 pounds which is horrible. She was 95 and dropped 15 in a month, without any exercise. So, IDK if it was the gluten free or the celiac. She said the food was horrible, expensive but she had no choice.0 -
I have been mainly wheat free since about august/sept.
For me I found cutting a huge chunk of it out helped.. I don't bother checking all ingredients for it but for example instead of having wheat based cereal, AND bread for sandwiches for lunch AND pasta (or other carbs with dinner) i changed the biggest things.
Cereal I use Rice Krispies or Oats, lunch is salad or soup, dinner is salad or veg with fish or white meat. I do allow a mini yorkshire pudding with sunday dinner but that's the only flour item I have. I managed to find some gluten free brownies and don't have any other pies or pastry products.
I found this easy to stick to, only have small amount with sunday dinner doesn't make water weight go up by huge amount it has improved drastically from 3-5lbs daily fluctuations to 1-2lb and monthly was previously 6-10lbs and now around 4lbs for that week.
I also cut potatoes, rice, pasta (any grain based item) with main meal and replaced things like mashed potato with carrot and swede mash. I allow potato OR rice once a week for treat meal.
I don't think I'm allergic to it though I just pile on water after eating lots of it? I've lost 12" from tummy and 8 " off waist since cutting amount of carbs I eat daily.
I havent had anything white since August. No rice, no pasta, no potatoes, no potato chips or fries. No cake, no cookies, no pudding, no soda, skim milk, no cereal. Just vegetables. I have only lost 15 and since Christmas gained 5. I swear it is metabolism.0 -
Grain free since Dec 1st and have dropped 5 lbs. Mostly dairy free and sugar free as well. I do have berries, and a tiny bit of honey in some almond flour cookies, but no sugar. Pretty much no processed foods at all. Trying to kick a plateau that had bugged me from Oct 1-Nov 30. So far it's working.
I eat meats, veggies, nuts, seeds, fruits, especially berries. Cravings are gone. Gone! I was giving this a month, but I think I'm on this for a long time now.0 -
I eat millions of pounds of gluten I'm sure. Tons of carbs in my diet for energy. I watch my calories and exercise. I've lost 85 pounds since having my first son (although I lost, then gained back 50 of it with my second son, and then lost it again)
If you medically need to for a condition, then its necessary to stick to it 100%
As for just doing it for weight loss, I don't think it will help you unless its just one way to limit your calorie intake. There are still plenty of fattening things to eat without gluten, so be careful.
as for whet belly: I carry weight in my thighs and hips. My tummy is pretty flat and always has been even when I was heavier. even with tons of wheat eating. It might just be genetic for your family.0 -
Edit: sorry this reply was originally directly under itamatgo when I started typing it.. got to learn to type faster... lol!
@Itamatgo: I noticed on your Profile you have Graves Disease ( a form of HYPERthyroidism).. I found this link online
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmedhealth/PMH0001398/
According to this weight gain is rare and weight loss much more common. I was born with mine not working so opposite to yours (HYPOthyroidism) and if my meds are too high I lose weight much easier but also get lot of bowel problems (and chest pains).
The thyroid is a very delicate organ if levels aren't 'just so' for you then it can cause loads of complications as your thyroid feeds your cells which work EVERYTHING!
If yours is/was over.. I'm assuming you've had surgery as its the only way to correct an over active thyroid? . which would mean you are now UNDER active and on thyroxine (synthroid) ? the only thing would be to get a blood test and see what your T4, T3 & TSH levels are and go from there.
If your thyroid levels are way under even going wheat free won't help!0 -
IMO it is in so many things under so many different names that it is really only worth trying to do 100% if you have a medical need to do so. Having said that - we do have way to much wheat in our diets these days so I think it is a good thing to do what one can to reduce the amount being consumed. There are several good sites on celiacs disease that list the names that gluten lurks under and there are so many amazing grains and seeds available that you can use in place of wheat that it is worth experimenting if you can afford it.
I have a severe gluten intolerance and have been relatively wheat free for some time. Where I live, the wheat flour substitutes can be hard to find and are expensive, and it can be hard to find gluten free products that aren't loaded up with other things like fat and sugar to make up for the loss of texture that gluten provides. I have been lucky in finding some places where I can mail order the flours and grains, and I have been experimenting with different recipes to find some flour mixes that produce some pretty darn good results. There are some out there that might produce nice looking results but they taste horrible so I have been taking the best of the worst, and combining a bunch of different products to find some that at least taste decent.
One of the big discussions I come across is the use of guar gum and xantham gum in gluten free recipes to add the texture and elasticity that gluten does. Some people are totally against using them for various reasons and others find they have no problems with them. I started using them and I find that they significantly improve the results and quite frankly, if that means I can stick with the gluten free eating, I will use them and just pay attention to what my body is telling me (besides the usual "feed me feed me" thing that it is doing lately :happy: )
I really enjoy learning about things, and I love to cook and bake and experiment anyway so I found this whole gluten intolerance thing to be somewhat of a positive challenge??? I am happy to offer up some of the experiences I have had if you are interested and give you the names of a book or two that have some decent recipes in them. Just let me know.0 -
bump0
-
We are also vegetarian (almost 20 years) and gluten free (3-4 years). I am recently off of all grains, even rice and corn (incl corn starch, corn syrup/glucose/fructose, etc.)
When we first went gluten-free, I gained a number of pounds, experimental baking for Christmas.
Now I do a lot less baking. Our meals are more centred on whole foods now, naturally grain free. Curries, chili, soup, salads, fruits and vegetables on their own, quinoa and buckwheat, potatoes, nuts (those I'm not allergic to) and seeds, etc. I get one loaf of bread and one pack of daiya cheese each week for hubby and DS, and they also eat corn tortillas. For myself, I make a tapioca and buckwheat based bun, and keep them in the freezer for when I want bread. I use the same recipe for homemade pizza crust and other bread based treats, but that is pretty rare. I only make cake or cookies for special events, esp. when we have to go out to a meal somewhere else and there are going to be treats.
There is still plenty that you can eat, and it is possible to gain weight instead of losing even on a restricted diet like this. I have to be really conscious of portion sizes and get lots of exercise to lose weight, and MFP has been such a lifesaver there.
Pam0 -
yes...today is day 1 of going wheat/processed foods free. my goal is 2 weeks raw, and one month wheat free, just to see if wheat is what's been bugging my stomach. also it might help the weight loss plateau. (:0
-
"Do or no not. There is no try."
Seriously, I've been wheat/grain free for going on 3 months. I can't explain how much healthier I feel. Do it.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions