Eating for your Bloodtype...fact or fiction?
Replies
-
People love this diet because the "blood type" part makes it sound scientific, and because it's tailored to MY particular blood type it must therefor be special somehow. It's garbage people, garbage. Some people have had success on it because in general it suggests healthy eating practices, more so for certain blood types. You lost weight by eating healthy? NO WAY! There's not one shred of scientific evidence that backs up the claim of your blood type requiring a special diet. None.
I will now share a little known secret diet that IS backed up by science, for FREE!... It's called the... "Don't put so much food in your mouth" diet.0 -
Quick - here comes the **fad diet bus** - all hop aboard!!
I never once thought of this as a "fad diet" for there is no such thing as a diet (per se) working long term -- it's a lifestyle change, and if I have to avoid wheat, dairy etc to keep my eczema at bay, so be it. Just found it very interesting that my allergy test results and eating for one's bloodtype were identical. But then again....how many eat mechanically made food (Protein Shakes, etc) and are ones to diss such a thing as this? Is that not a "diet" type of food...and yes, I do have protein shakes once in awhile when in a rush and I need something in my stomach...but much rather have something that is recognizable AS a food, lol...Yep, just my opinion!
0 -
You are right - I shouldnt diss - I have just been hanging around the boards too long and my sceptasism has started to get the better of me. If it works for you, its awesome - especially if its helping with allergies and other intolerances.Quick - here comes the **fad diet bus** - all hop aboard!!
I never once thought of this as a "fad diet" for there is no such thing as a diet (per se) working long term -- it's a lifestyle change, and if I have to avoid wheat, dairy etc to keep my eczema at bay, so be it. Just found it very interesting that my allergy test results and eating for one's bloodtype were identical. But then again....how many eat mechanically made food (Protein Shakes, etc) and are ones to diss such a thing as this? Is that not a "diet" type of food...and yes, I do have protein shakes once in awhile when in a rush and I need something in my stomach...but much rather have something that is recognizable AS a food, lol...Yep, just my opinion!
I guess what I meant with my hop aboard the bus comment was all those that were posting 'interesting' and 'I will have to look into this'... it just seemed like a snap decision formed so quickly at the first hearing of something new...
Interesting though that you had a look at my food diary and all you were able to comment on was my protein shake? (Unless i'm just making assumptions and if so, feel free to ignore!). I only have one if Im going to do heavy weights at the gym - I've got a 10km run tomorrow morning and I really, really dont want to be sore! Im trying to increase my speed whilst adding extra hills from my Monday run :happy:0 -
You are right - I shouldnt diss - I have just been hanging around the boards too long and my sceptasism has started to get the better of me. If it works for you, its awesome - especially if its helping with allergies and other intolerances.Quick - here comes the **fad diet bus** - all hop aboard!!
I never once thought of this as a "fad diet" for there is no such thing as a diet (per se) working long term -- it's a lifestyle change, and if I have to avoid wheat, dairy etc to keep my eczema at bay, so be it. Just found it very interesting that my allergy test results and eating for one's bloodtype were identical. But then again....how many eat mechanically made food (Protein Shakes, etc) and are ones to diss such a thing as this? Is that not a "diet" type of food...and yes, I do have protein shakes once in awhile when in a rush and I need something in my stomach...but much rather have something that is recognizable AS a food, lol...Yep, just my opinion!
I guess what I meant with my hop aboard the bus comment was all those that were posting 'interesting' and 'I will have to look into this'... it just seemed like a snap decision formed so quickly at the first hearing of something new...
Interesting though that you had a look at my food diary and all you were able to comment on was my protein shake? (Unless i'm just making assumptions and if so, feel free to ignore!). I only have one if Im going to do heavy weights at the gym - I've got a 10km run tomorrow morning and I really, really dont want to be sore! Im trying to increase my speed whilst adding extra hills from my Monday run :happy:
No worries, all's good -- and no, I didn't look at your food diary. I've just noticed this a lot on MFP that many judge another on a 'diet' when in fact they consume protein shakes for most of their main meals. Hell, the weight will fly off of me if I did that, but geez, I can't live on those...blech. Oh, and the only ones I really liked were the Whey shakes...can't have whey (allergic) and the Hemp ones are gawd awful...LOL0 -
All I've gotten out of this thread is FIRE UP THE GRILL!
Thanks MaximalLife, will do.. :happy:
Swiss cheeseburger, with small red potatoes are
already entered in MFP for the night, so I'm good to
go! :drinker:0 -
My neighbour went on the diet and she is very good at sticking to it as well, and she is still on it.
I think so far she has lost 7 kgs in the past 4-5 months and that is with no exercise either.
I personally couldnt stick to it myself, but I know that it worked for her...i guess it just depends on how good you are !0 -
Have only read the title - FICTION0
-
Type is is mostly veggies and hardly any carbs...I'm type A it says eat mostly carbs. If I eat carbs I binge and gain weight. The best thing anyone can do is listen to their own bodies and do what works for them.0 -
Its nonsense and has no basis in science.
Most of the 'allergy tests' especially administered by health food stores or online are BS as well
Also a physician.0 -
SO we're all made the same according to most posters? That's just absurd. There are different body types, mesomorphic endomorphic, ectomorphic.
Some people have a majority of different muscle times, which helps them excel in certain sports. A skinny lanky guy will never be a world class power lifter. A big husky guy will never be a world class marathon runner.
This is due to muscle fiber types, and energy systems, some people just work better on a carb based diet cause of their muscle fiber types, and some work better on a high protein diet.
Can you provide any physiological evidence for these body types? All of my research has shown that the terms were developed by a psychologist and used them to justify personality types. They are named for the three types of developmental tissues, which makes no sense considering what you claim them to mean.
I understand that one can train the muscles to have a higher concentration of slow-twitch or fast-twitch, but I have never heard of it being an innate quality.
Yes fiber types can be trained to behave more like another. I am NASM CPT, and there is different body types. The terms might be the same in the psychology field as in health and fitness, but they obviously don't mean the same thing. If you think of children, some children are stronger than others, some are faster than others, this is due to what i said previously, genetics of fiber types.
I won't deny that there are different body types, but I do believe the somatotype theory originated in psychology. The system was developed by psychologist W.H. Sheldon. He has received quite a bit of criticism for the theory.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:CoCOF6VFug0J:en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somatotype_and_constitutional_psychology+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us
http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/553976/somatotype0 -
Its nonsense and has no basis in science.
Most of the 'allergy tests' especially administered by health food stores or online are BS as well
Also a physician.
Too funny, but no, didn't take an allergy test from online, nor from a health food store. And, I respect the physicians who state they are physicians, but why? Does that make them correct in everything regarding health issues? I do know that many physicians (especially here) love to administer consistant meds instead of getting to the root of the problem, which in my case is indeed certain foods. We are what we eat -- is there no truth in that statement?0 -
Lady at work believes in it. I secretly laugh at her because all she has done is created a calorie deficit and she calls it magic. LOLZ0
-
Lady at work believes in it. I secretly laugh at her because all she does is created a calorie deficit and calls it magic. LOLZ
LOL!!0 -
I read about it once, I have wheat/dairy/soy/egg intolerances, they were on my foods to eat list. I'm not buying the hype0
-
Can we all agree that whatever helps to get a person to a healthy weight and living an active lifestyle is ok for that person? A hell of a lot more is known about digestion now than 50 years ago and there are still mysteries to the science. Who knows what will be discovered in the next 50 years. There are more than one flavor ice creams, protein shakes (LOL) so can't there also be more than one way to lose weight? Do what works and feels best for yourself. To each his own!!!0
-
Its nonsense and has no basis in science.
Most of the 'allergy tests' especially administered by health food stores or online are BS as well
Also a physician.
Too funny, but no, didn't take an allergy test from online, nor from a health food store. And, I respect the physicians who state they are physicians, but why? Does that make them correct in everything regarding health issues? I do know that many physicians (especially here) love to administer consistant meds instead of getting to the root of the problem, which in my case is indeed certain foods. We are what we eat -- is there no truth in that statement?
You absolutely should not take anyone's word for anything. You should educate yourself on the subject of how the body works. Whether you want to use scientifically proven facts or anecdotal words of mouth as the source of your education is entirely up to you.0 -
Can we all agree that whatever helps to get a person to a healthy weight and living an active lifestyle is ok for that person? A hell of a lot more is known about digestion now than 50 years ago and there are still mysteries to the science. Who knows what will be discovered in the next 50 years. There are more than one flavor ice creams, protein shakes (LOL) so can't there also be more than one way to lose weight? Do what works and feels best for yourself. To each his own!!!
No. Sometimes people achieve things in spite of themselves and then purport incorrect theories as the cause for the achievement. This is the case with the blood type diet. It basically gets people to eat restrictively in most cases, which results in a calorie deficit.0 -
Can we all agree that whatever helps to get a person to a healthy weight and living an active lifestyle is ok for that person? A hell of a lot more is known about digestion now than 50 years ago and there are still mysteries to the science. Who knows what will be discovered in the next 50 years. There are more than one flavor ice creams, protein shakes (LOL) so can't there also be more than one way to lose weight? Do what works and feels best for yourself. To each his own!!!
No. Sometimes people achieve things in spite of themselves and then purport incorrect theories as the cause for the achievement. This is the case with the blood type diet. It basically gets people to eat restrictively in most cases, which results in a calorie deficit.
You are right that it doesn't make it an absolute fact. They lose weight because of the calorie deficit. Still if the ultimate goal is achieved I see no harm. Besides, they feel better eating the foods according to the OP. It seems the important goal is to achieve a lifestyle change that can be maintained comfortably and healthfully.0 -
Too funny, but no, didn't take an allergy test from online, nor from a health food store. And, I respect the physicians who state they are physicians, but why? Does that make them correct in everything regarding health issues? I do know that many physicians (especially here) love to administer consistant meds instead of getting to the root of the problem, which in my case is indeed certain foods. We are what we eat -- is there no truth in that statement?
When someone identifies themselves as a physician, or in my case, as a research scientist with a PhD, it means simply: I have a lot of education with a strong background in medical science. Please consider that when you consider my opinion.
Does that magical "Dr." in front of our names make us all-knowing gods? Hell no. Should you accept our opinions as the absolute truth? No. But... it would be nice if you at least least thought of us as 'expert witnesses' and judged accordingly.
Of course... this is the internet and every one of us could be lying about who we are. I might be some hairy dude, sitting at home in my underwear, and not actually the woman I pretend to be. Stranger things have happened.
Unfortunately, the guy that wrote the bloodtype book also has a Dr. in front of his name :grumble: and that's what makes this whole thing so frustrating for me. I personally feel he was incredibly irresponsible to publish such nonsense, but that's just me.
I do NOT deny that you probably feel better eating the way that you do. I do NOT deny that there are genetic variability between individuals that mean one person is going to flourish on one type of diet whereas the other person will find that diet unsatisfactory in so many ways.
The blood-type thing just doesn't make sense. There's just no way that the biological markers on your red blood cells have anything to do with how you respond to food. There are other, better, more likely explanations for why your diet works well for you (and not for anyone else).
More importantly, the blood type diet has NOT been tested in randomized, double-blind clinical trials. Ketogenic diets (low carb, high fat, high protein) HAVE been tested. Low fat diets HAVE been tested. Low calorie diets HAVE been tested. The effects of exercise HAVE been tested. So why hasn't the blood type diet been tested? If it's based on science, WHERE IS THE SCIENTIFIC PROOF?
So in the absence of proof... I suppose you could say I look at the blood-type thing the same way that I look at astrology. Is my horoscope sometimes right? Sure, I suppose, usually because it's written in an open and flowery fashion that's subject to various interpretations that can easily fit my circumstances. That does not, however, make astrology a science. And the blood type thing isn't (in my mind) science either- it strikes me as superstition.
Please, please don't think I'm telling you not to eat the way you're eating. If it makes you happy, if it keeps you healthy, if it's meeting all of your needs, you're golden!
You just asked what we thought, and I, as a research scientist with a solid understanding of human physiology and cell biology and a Dr. in front of my name say... Dr. what's his name is peddling superstition in the name of science. Actually, I'll be nicer than that. The good Dr. is extrapolating and drawing unsupported conclusions. He is presenting those conclusions as fact, when they are not fact and are only his guesses.0 -
i'm o- and mine is to eat lots of protein especially meat but im a vegetarian so its not going to work lol0
-
More importantly, the blood type diet has NOT been tested in randomized, double-blind clinical trials. Ketogenic diets (low carb, high fat, high protein) HAVE been tested. Low fat diets HAVE been tested. Low calorie diets HAVE been tested. The effects of exercise HAVE been tested. So why hasn't the blood type diet been tested? If it's based on science, WHERE IS THE SCIENTIFIC PROOF?
Rebekah wins.0 -
Again what works for one does not necessarily works for others. I have a friend who changed her name and her husband and kids followed suit because a numerologist told her to do so. She thought it helped. I also know many people who are hooked into finding out your sign and that it means and they swear it is dead on. Energy healing is also believed to work for some. So is Chiropractic care. Whereas physical therapy was the only thing that worked for me. The power of the mind is amazing sometimes and sometimes believing something is true makes it true.0
-
Amazing the number of people willing to believe in magic voodoo0
-
I call "Bullcrap"!0
-
Fiction.0
-
Doesn't sound kosher to me. Although I looked up the info for my bloodtype (O) out of interest and it seemed at a glance to be everything I'm doing already so..0
-
I have both books Eat Right 4 Your Type and Live Right 4 Your Type. I am living after them now for 4 months and I am completely allergy free for the first time in my life and all my blood work is better and loosing weight is actually easier too. So all the skeptics can holler and say whatever they want, I know it works. Not only for me but also for my husband. There are a lot of case studies and reading the book it makes a lot of sense.0
-
There is a book about this at Books A Million. And I am an A type also which I love veggies so that is great and it does say you can have carbs but you do have to limit them and I do and it does seem to work for me if I could always follow it. LOL0
-
I've just read that I should avoid chicken?? and eat loads of fish......Yuk! I hate fish!! Also I should avoid nuts and seeds, which I've been eating for the iron! I shouldn't eat wheat or tomatoes, there goes my salads and cheese and tomato toasties!! I won't be following this diet, that's for sure.0
-
Two years ago I had a food allergy panel done. Then 2 months ago, I got another one done (just to see if the same foods are the culprit) I've suffered from eczema off and on since I was a baby, and found out that eczema (as well as other skin conditions) can be caused by certain foods, for it's a form of an allergy.
You're right, eczema CAN be irritated/inflamed by certain foods or other environmental factors, BUT, it is also genetic.
This bloodtype diet was created based on one man's BELIEF that it was so, he then set out to try to prove it. His son has carried on his work.
For every person who claims that it works and is a miracle diet, there are a dozen that it didn't work for. I've seen countless threads on this subject.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that it won't/doesn't work for YOU. I'm just saying that it's coincidence.
I mean, what the 'creator' of this diet wants us to believe is that there are only FOUR diets in the world that exist for all people in every economic/environmental circumstance? Seriously?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions