How to still lose weight whilst exercising?
caroline_g
Posts: 201 Member
For the past 5 weeks I've been doing the Kettleworx programme. So I've done a cardio, core and resistance kettleworx workout each week and on 2 or 3 of the other days, I've done a cardio workout such as turbo jam or cardio box. My losses while I've been doing this have slowed right down, which I know is likely because of the exercise. My first week I lost 0.5lbs, then 3.25lbs which made me think I'd go small, big, small big but after that I lost 0.5lbs then 0.75lbs. I'm expecting another small loss again this week at my WI later. I'm losing inches too which is great but I'd like to shift a little more in terms of lbs too if I can.
So my question for you guys is, is there anything that I can do to help my body still shift the lbs whilst I'm doing this exercise? I don't know if anything like drinking more water (I aim for 2 litres a day, though I've failed at that the past few days) or changing my diet by say lowering my carbs or anything like that might help. Any thoughts or advice? I know I might just be stuck with them as they are, which as long as I'm losing inches too is fine, but just thought I'd ask.
So my question for you guys is, is there anything that I can do to help my body still shift the lbs whilst I'm doing this exercise? I don't know if anything like drinking more water (I aim for 2 litres a day, though I've failed at that the past few days) or changing my diet by say lowering my carbs or anything like that might help. Any thoughts or advice? I know I might just be stuck with them as they are, which as long as I'm losing inches too is fine, but just thought I'd ask.
0
Replies
-
I'm in the same boat with you . Am exercising every day (otherwise sedentary) and eat a pretty healthy diet, low cholesterol, low fat, low sodium. My weight loss went to 0=ZERO the last few weeks, just since I've upped exercise. I've tried to stick to a 40-40-30 (Protein-Carbs-Fat) ratio, drink a lot of water or herbal teas....NOTHING! Yes, I've lost 1 inch during the last 2 weeks but not a single pound. I thought, maybe it's water retention because the more you exercise the more glycogen your body has to store and in order to do that it needs water. But I'm not sure. Waiting for other posters/opinions0
-
I currently do 45% carbs, 25% fat and 30% protein. I work out my percentages after each day as I won't always eat every calorie. Carbs usually range 40-45%, fat 20-30% and protein 30-35%. I know that I need a rest day before I weigh in, otherwise I see a gain or STS on the scales because of the water retention. I'm a lot further away from my goal than you so I've lost better inches but the lbs are pretty low for me considering that.0
-
I've just started the 30 day shred and now I'm worried my weight loss will stall too as I have only started and still have 65 lbs to lose. I'm alsodoing zumba class once a week and another 2-3 times a week on the Wii. Maybe its not that much exercise but its far more than I've ever done in my life.0
-
How would doing exercise make you lose less weight?My losses while I've been doing this have slowed right down, which I know is likely because of the exercise.
Your diary is not open so I cannot check, but are you eating enough?0 -
I think this is the problem with so called medical experts (here in the UK at least) constantly shoving scale weight and BMI down our throats as the key indicator for health.
You will hold on to a bit of water when you exercise as cnocnacu pointed out but that will ease off over time (its a bit of an urban myth that its muscle after just a few days/weeks in a training program, as an ex bodybuilder and powerlifter i can attest that muscle doesnt come that easy
)
If you are losing inches and feeling the benefits of exercise (the multitude of which are well documented on this forum) then to hell with the scales. There are plenty of men out there under 150lbs with a 40+ inch waist, but id much rather be at a 34 inch waist and weigh 220lbs.
Trust your mirror, your clothes fitting better and the measuring tape... to hell with the scales 0 -
As the above poster mentioned, perhaps you are not eating enough. The more you workout, the more calories you need.0
-
It does make you lose less weight. I'm obviously losing fat because I'm losing inches and my BF% is coming down, which implies that I'm losing fat and gaining muscle, which would bring my weight loss (rather than fat loss) down a bit. My diary used to be open but after I made a thread once about calorie counting with a low carb slant and had two people who decided to then look at my diary and critique it, telling me that I didn't log enough. I was extremely busy on a school placement at the time so I counted but didn't always get the chance to log and really didn't need unwanted and unneeded criticism when I asked for advice on something else.
As an idea of my daily diary...
Yesterday (no exercise): 1238 cals, 124g carbs, 17g fiber, 36g fat, 100g protein, 1270mg sodium.
Sunday - couldn't log
Saturday (burned 400 calories): 1303 cals, 125g carbs, 14g fiber, 42g fat, 103g protein, 2208mg sodium
Friday (burned 500 calories): 1406 cals, 166g carbs, 23g fiber, 30g fat, 120g protein
Thursday (was an ill day so didn't eat as much, burned 300 cals): 1219 cals, 138g carbs, 33g fat, 91g protein, 586mg sodium
Wednesday (burned 350 cals): 1301 cals, 131g carbs, 15g fiber, 41g fat, 104g protein, 459mg sodium
Thee week before that I tried eating more of my exercise calories back so that I was at 1200 NET but it made no difference, I still had a small loss.0 -
People remember that WEIGHT is a number that is totally meaningless without other statistics, if you're getting leaner and healthier but not losing weight then whats the problem?!?!? Seriously I don't understand peoples fascination with this number!
Consider it a good thing because rapid weight loss without rapid toning and muscle gain = saggy skin0 -
Its not just about the lbs. You'll be building muscle which replaces the fat and muscle ways more than fat.0
-
I also found that these cardio work outs made me lose less weight weekly than i wanted i have been doing Yoga, muscle work outs and aerobics on the WII fitness plus losing about 1lb - 2lb a week at the moment
Kez xx0 -
Its probably cause your gaining muscle as well as loosing weight and muscle weighs more than fat does....if thats the case then your doing a really good job!!!!!0
-
I know that it's not just about weight loss, didn't I say in my first post that "I might just be stuck with them as they are, which as long as I'm losing inches too is fine". As I said, losing inches is great but if I can lose some lbs too, then I want to which isn't a ridiculous thing to want, at all. I know that it'll help me look more toned and therefore better once the weight is off but that doesn't mean that I can't hope for slightly better losses. I just did my WI and I've lost 1.25lbs this week, I'm alright with that. It's not a huge number but that's fine, it's the 0.5lbs that I get annoyed/disappointed with.0
-
I know that it's not just about weight loss, didn't I say in my first post that "I might just be stuck with them as they are, which as long as I'm losing inches too is fine". As I said, losing inches is great but if I can lose some lbs too, then I want to which isn't a ridiculous thing to want, at all. I know that it'll help me look more toned and therefore better once the weight is off but that doesn't mean that I can't hope for slightly better losses. I just did my WI and I've lost 1.25lbs this week, I'm alright with that. It's not a huge number but that's fine, it's the 0.5lbs that I get annoyed/disappointed with.
I'd understand where you were coming from if you didn't inform me that you are losing inches, you know you're making progress yet you still want another number to confirm this for you? It's not a very healthy attitude to have and it's undermining your progress which from the sounds of things is going great! I know you want both but it's really meaningless0 -
It's really hard to shift from watching weight decrease to watching inches or bodyfat. I do empathise. I have recently been asking the same questions but a trip to a body fat scales yesterday showed progress of 1kg drop even though I'd stayed the same on the 'normal' scale.
so hold out hope - keep track of your inches and I'm sure that will prove you are exchanging lumpy bumpy fat for lean healthy muscle.0 -
I'd understand where you were coming from if you didn't inform me that you are losing inches, you know you're making progress yet you still want another number to confirm this for you? It's not a very healthy attitude to have and it's undermining your progress which from the sounds of things is going great! I know you want both but it's really meaningless
How is it an unhealthy attitude to have? Why is it so ridiculous and unhealthy to be wanting to see my weight come down? It's not like I'm trying to lose just 10lbs, I have a fair bit to lose. There is absolutely nothing wrong with wanting to see both numbers coming down. It's also not undermining my progess, I know that I'm doing well, I was just asking if there was anything that I could be doing to try and do a little bit better. So are we not meant to aim for better and just settle for alright? So in your job, you're never going to aim for a promotion because you want to do better? It's human nature to try and do better, there's nothing wrong or unhealthy about that. If this is the best that I can do then that's fine but I want to be doing the best that I can and that's not a bad attitude to have. As I said at the beginning, it may be a case of that's just what my losses will be and there's nothing I can do about it, if that's the case then that's fine, as I've said a number of times. But in my opinion, it's not unhealthy to be asking what I can do to further my weight loss. It's a healthy question to ask. I didn't say shall I starve myself down to 800 calories a day, I didn't say shall I work out every hour god sends and eat next to nothing, I didn't say shall I go on a soup/fruit juice diet, those things are unhealthy but my questions about water, carbs, protein etc. are nothing but healthy. So I'm sorry but you're wrong.0 -
I totally agree I roughly do
Mon - burn just under 400 cal
Tues - 800
Wed - 400
thurs - 400
fri - 600
sat - rest
sun - rest
I have been working my butt off all week and have somehow managed to gain 2 lbs ! its so frustrating,0 -
Reading properly rather than skimming it does look like you have a good understanding of whats going on with your body as you exercise, i do still think our obsession with scale weight is misguided though and stems from that blasted BMI nonsense.
Maybe try switching your activities to something with lower intensities. While i was recovering from injury i kept my cals low (for me, still around 1800 a day) and walked a lot and saw big loses. Now im almost back to 100% and ive upped the level of my cardio and brought weight training back in the scales arent budging much (like you im seeing victories elsewhere still though, clothes fit better, the compliments are starting to come in and im feeling fitter than i have in a good 10 years)
Walking, moderate effort cycling or swimming will all burn cals as equally well as higher intesity stuff (as you can do them for much longer) but wont have the same effect as stuff that causes your muscle mass to hold onto water while the little muscle pixies do their repair work (they get very thirsty )
Good lucK!0 -
For the past 5 weeks I've been doing the Kettleworx programme. So I've done a cardio, core and resistance kettleworx workout each week and on 2 or 3 of the other days, I've done a cardio workout such as turbo jam or cardio box. My losses while I've been doing this have slowed right down, which I know is likely because of the exercise. My first week I lost 0.5lbs, then 3.25lbs which made me think I'd go small, big, small big but after that I lost 0.5lbs then 0.75lbs. I'm expecting another small loss again this week at my WI later. I'm losing inches too which is great but I'd like to shift a little more in terms of lbs too if I can.
So my question for you guys is, is there anything that I can do to help my body still shift the lbs whilst I'm doing this exercise? I don't know if anything like drinking more water (I aim for 2 litres a day, though I've failed at that the past few days) or changing my diet by say lowering my carbs or anything like that might help. Any thoughts or advice? I know I might just be stuck with them as they are, which as long as I'm losing inches too is fine, but just thought I'd ask.
You won't always lose weight every week. Some weeks it will be inches and other weeks it will be body fat percentage. Keep track of your measurments, body fat percentage, weight, and BMI to see your progress the best. Keeps you motivated. Last week I didn't lose a pound but dropped a half percent in body fat.0 -
By all means I'm not criticising the way you're going about it, you're putting too much emphasizes on scale weight though! If weight loss is what you're looking for then do less intense exercise regimes for a couple of weeks of each month to slow muscle build. I'm sorry if I cause any offence as it was not intended, but I've seen too many people fail despite making great progress because the number on the scale isn't going down as fast as they'd like (myself included)0
-
I have been working my butt off all week and have somehow managed to gain 2 lbs ! its so frustrating,
Do you have your rest day before your weigh in? I would, I can gain 3lbs the next morning after exercise! So having it before WI helps me get rid of that.Reading properly rather than skimming it does look like you have a good understanding of whats going on with your body as you exercise, i do still think our obsession with scale weight is misguided though and stems from that blasted BMI nonsense.
I'm really not a BMI person, I don't think it's all that important. My goal gives me a BMI of 27, technically overweight but for me I think that's about right. Personally, I'd rather go on body fat percentage than BMI, which is how I worked out my goal weight.Maybe try switching your activities to something with lower intensities. While i was recovering from injury i kept my cals low (for me, still around 1800 a day) and walked a lot and saw big loses. Now im almost back to 100% and ive upped the level of my cardio and brought weight training back in the scales arent budging much (like you im seeing victories elsewhere still though, clothes fit better, the compliments are starting to come in and im feeling fitter than i have in a good 10 years)
To be honest, if it's a case of giving up the exercise for a lower intensity thing or keeping the losses I've got, I think I'd stick with it to be honest. I love the exercise that I'm doing and it's easy for me because I don't have access to a gym or swimming pool really. I know what you mean though, I lost better doing that kind of exercise but I definitely feel better doing this kind.Good lucK!
ThanksYou won't always lose weight every week. Some weeks it will be inches and other weeks it will be body fat percentage. Keep track of your measurments, body fat percentage, weight, and BMI to see your progress the best. Keeps you motivated. Last week I didn't lose a pound but dropped a half percent in body fat.
I've actually just this week added my body fat percentage to my measurements on here so that I can track that because I look at it but haven't logged it. It definitely helps looking at the bigger picture.By all means I'm not criticising the way you're going about it, you're putting too much emphasizes on scale weight though! If weight loss is what you're looking for then do less intense exercise regimes for a couple of weeks of each month to slow muscle build. I'm sorry if I cause any offence as it was not intended, but I've seen too many people fail despite making great progress because the number on the scale isn't going down as fast as they'd like (myself included)
I didn't take offence, I just didn't agree. I do see what you're saying and I think that maybe I've come across the wrong way. If I carry on losing like I am (small lbs, big inches) and that's the best that I can do then I'm fine with that. As i said to a previous poster, there's no way that I'd cut back my exercise just to have bigger losses because I know that the benefits of it go way beyond inches and lbs, so I'd rather just carry on as I am now. And I'm definitely not going to give up because of it but I agree, it would be easy to do. I just wanted to know whether anyone else had been in the situation and found a way to bust through it and see the scales come down more. Though, I realised that I've got my losses wrong. Last week I actually lost 1.5lbs not 0.75lbs so my losses aren't as bad as I thought and over the past 5 weeks I've averaged 1.45lbs a week, which with my inch loss, is pretty good. But still, if there's ever a way that I can do better, at anything, I do try to give it a go.0 -
Hi, just on a side note how are you finding the Kettleworx I have just got some KB's and am looking for a suitable program.0
-
Hi Caroline,
In reading through this post, it seems to me you are doing everything pretty much correctly! You are exercising, losing weight, losing inches....thats great!
Its hard to really get into the numbers w/o knowing your current height/weight - not sure if I overlooked them or not.
Here's hopefully some inspiration. Ive been doing Power 90 routinely and using MFP to count my calories. Ive been doing everything "right" but recently ran into a TWO WEEK wall in which I went back and forth by 2 pounds. It was very frustrating, but I know it was a combination of increased muscle and water retention.
As long as you are losing weight or inches, I wouldnt worry about it. Concentrate on eating a healthy diet of lean protein and tons of veggies and you'll get the results you want if you are doing regular exercise.
The only thing I could possibly suggest is moderately upping your water intake and combine that with a week of eating non-processed foods you prepare at home, again....lean protein+veggies. See if you can flush some excess sodium out and see if that is the culprit. Be careful though....you dont want to flush out too much potassium.
Hope that helps....again, it sounds like you are doing great! Dont get discouraged.0 -
I'm in a similar position - I want to lose maybe another 10-15 lbs (not a load, I know) and I don't really because I'm gaining a lot of muscle. I just figure that long term eating and exercising right I will lose the weight. Maybe it will take a year instead of a few months but since we are happy with the body changes anyway taking a little longer isn't a big deal.0
-
The OP's diary is closed, but yours is not.I'm in the same boat with you . Am exercising every day (otherwise sedentary) and eat a pretty healthy diet, low cholesterol, low fat, low sodium. My weight loss went to 0=ZERO the last few weeks, just since I've upped exercise. I've tried to stick to a 40-40-30 (Protein-Carbs-Fat) ratio, drink a lot of water or herbal teas....NOTHING! Yes, I've lost 1 inch during the last 2 weeks but not a single pound. I thought, maybe it's water retention because the more you exercise the more glycogen your body has to store and in order to do that it needs water. But I'm not sure. Waiting for other posters/opinions
You are not eating enough - deficits too high.
It looks like you're not eating your exercise calories back. That will stifle progress every time.
MFP determined our total daily calorie goal that DOES NOT include exercise to lose 1 pound [recommended].
And after we complete an exercise and log it in, our daily calorie limit increases.
This is because MFP advising us to eat back those exercise calories.
Large deficits are not recommended, because while you will lose weight, what's the quality of the weight loss?
In that healthy?
What happens is decreased lean body mass - MUSCLE - which LOWERS metabolic rate, making weight loss even harder.
The quick loss, low-calorie diets may do wonders on the front end, but once the diet is over, you have a body that burns calories more slowly -- and you gain weight.
Think long term, and be wise.
Exercise intensely, but eat back the calories.
The exercise will RAISE your metabolism and burn more fat at rest.0 -
Are you drinking enough water?? 64 ounces a day might not be enough if you are engaging in vigorous physical activity.0
-
For good, steady and healthy weight loss, metabolism is key. We need to keep it rev'd up to burn fat.
Sometimes, we seem to be doing everything right, then hit the dreaded "plateau" where the body has reached a state of equilibrium. So, how do we punch through?
You change up your whole program to keep your body guessing. That works as a proactive measure, yet in most cases people experiencing a plateau have overreached and are not eating enough.
Are you following the MFP recommendations for healthy weight loss?
This is how MFP works
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/help/faq/3-how-does-myfitnesspal-work
And Tips for Newbies
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/470367-tips-for-newbies
If you are on some other program, get off that sinking ship and get to what works. Follow the simple MFP guidelines.
Just get started by going into settings to Update diet/fitness profile.
Set your goals for 1 lb weight loss per week.
NO MORE!
And eat lean meats, low fat dairy, nuts, whole grains, fresh fruits and veggies.
Do both cardio and resistance exercise.
Log in those exercises to your MFP exercise diary.
AND EAT BACK YOUR EXERCISE CALORIES!
Remember, this is not a race, and you can reach your goals if you stick to a good plan as recommended on this site.
You have many people here ready to lend support, answer qustions and discuss any challenges.
You can do this.
All Is Possible!0 -
The man is right...I lost 2 lbs last week because i ate back almost all exercise calories for the week previous. This even with pms water gain so i have gained nothing from period weight. I lift weights and started kettlebell as well as cardio things.
The OP's diary is closed, but yours is not.I'm in the same boat with you . Am exercising every day (otherwise sedentary) and eat a pretty healthy diet, low cholesterol, low fat, low sodium. My weight loss went to 0=ZERO the last few weeks, just since I've upped exercise. I've tried to stick to a 40-40-30 (Protein-Carbs-Fat) ratio, drink a lot of water or herbal teas....NOTHING! Yes, I've lost 1 inch during the last 2 weeks but not a single pound. I thought, maybe it's water retention because the more you exercise the more glycogen your body has to store and in order to do that it needs water. But I'm not sure. Waiting for other posters/opinions
You are not eating enough - deficits too high.
It looks like you're not eating your exercise calories back. That will stifle progress every time.
MFP determined our total daily calorie goal that DOES NOT include exercise to lose 1 pound [recommended].
And after we complete an exercise and log it in, our daily calorie limit increases.
This is because MFP advising us to eat back those exercise calories.
Large deficits are not recommended, because while you will lose weight, what's the quality of the weight loss?
In that healthy?
What happens is decreased lean body mass - MUSCLE - which LOWERS metabolic rate, making weight loss even harder.
The quick loss, low-calorie diets may do wonders on the front end, but once the diet is over, you have a body that burns calories more slowly -- and you gain weight.
Think long term, and be wise.
Exercise intensely, but eat back the calories.
The exercise will RAISE your metabolism and burn more fat at rest.0 -
People remember that WEIGHT is a number that is totally meaningless without other statistics, if you're getting leaner and healthier but not losing weight then whats the problem?!?!? Seriously I don't understand peoples fascination with this number!
Consider it a good thing because rapid weight loss without rapid toning and muscle gain = saggy skin
I agree. While it's always nice (ok, great!) to see a lower number on the scale, nobody knows your weight number by looking at you, but they know if you look more toned and tight and if your clothes fit great.0 -
You need to eat more calories. 1200 is not enough for you.0
-
I know that it's not just about weight loss, didn't I say in my first post that "I might just be stuck with them as they are, which as long as I'm losing inches too is fine". As I said, losing inches is great but if I can lose some lbs too, then I want to which isn't a ridiculous thing to want, at all. I know that it'll help me look more toned and therefore better once the weight is off but that doesn't mean that I can't hope for slightly better losses. I just did my WI and I've lost 1.25lbs this week, I'm alright with that. It's not a huge number but that's fine, it's the 0.5lbs that I get annoyed/disappointed with.
I'd understand where you were coming from if you didn't inform me that you are losing inches, you know you're making progress yet you still want another number to confirm this for you? It's not a very healthy attitude to have and it's undermining your progress which from the sounds of things is going great! I know you want both but it's really meaningless
You are right nut...yet...we girls need something to cling to, even if it's only a number:bigsmile:
No, honestly, everything here on MFP has to do with THE NUMBER ON THE SCALE. We're being told the number has to be "x" to be healthy, BMI, BMR, TDEE and so on. If you're working towards a goal it is so much easier to stick to numbers. And I'm one of the girls who needs the number on the scale to confirm we're doing the right thing. We DO know, that losing inches is great, we DO know....but.......
When you have been overweight almost all of your life and now, finally you want to change your lifestyle AND lose weight than you will be looking at THE NUMBERS, that's what your parents and doctors told you all the time.
I was told today my cholesterol is down significantly. I needed this number to be reassured I'm on the right track. Just feeling healthier wasn't enough, not for me.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions