Has anyone upped their calories from 1200 cals?

SlinkyNewMe
SlinkyNewMe Posts: 213 Member
edited November 10 in Health and Weight Loss
Hi I have been on MFP since the beginning of January and have lost only 1lb in weight! Prior to that I had been on Weight Watchers for 3 months and lost 16lbs!!

I left WW because I wanted to know how many calories I was eating rather than following their mysterious points system.

MFP put me on 1200 cals - I am 172lbs currently and want to get down to 133lbs. I am 5feet 2inches tall, age 46, and mainly sedentary. I am a vegetarian on a strict plant based diet. I never struggled 1200 cals anda lot of the time did not use all that allowance. I have also now started going to the gym a couple of times a week and do not always eat back my exercise calories.

Anyway for the longest time, I have been on this plateau of not losing weight, which was bad enough. But now I find I have hardly any energy, I have dark circles round my eyes, and basically feel really lethargic and de-motivated. So I have upped my intake to 1500 cals starting today.

I was just wondering whether anyone else has had similar experiences on 1200 cals, what did you do and what results have you had? Did it get you off your plateau?
«13

Replies

  • cgrout78
    cgrout78 Posts: 1,628 Member
    i couldn't eat that few calories. I eat like 16-1700 and work out 5 days a week and i'm still losing. You should be at least eating back your exercise calories
  • cruisintolose
    cruisintolose Posts: 25 Member
    A week ago I was feeling the same way! Tired with no energy. I had been exercising, so I was not understanding as I usually feel great when I do that. I decided to up my calories. Changed MFP from losing 2lbs to 1lb a week. I increased my calorie intake by 300. (1200 to 1500) I feel so much better and the scale moved more. Not much, but more than before. I highly recommend it!
  • NeverGivesUp
    NeverGivesUp Posts: 960 Member
    you should at least eat your BMR and some exercise calories. I am seeing more and more threads about this. The ones that eat too little have a tendency to stagnate with weight loss. The ones that exercise and eat more, lose every week and lose faster. It may take your body a little bit of time to adjust to the new calorie intake, so be patient, but I really do think you are doing the right thing.
  • wahmx3
    wahmx3 Posts: 633 Member
    I suggest having your BMR done and eating enough calories. 1200 is not enough unless you are super small and since you are exercising, you need to eat more. I aim for about 1500 and I am 5'4" and weigh 147 but I also eat more if I have a good exercise day.
  • you are eating too few calories and making your body go into starvation mode and hence cling onto all food/fat that you put in. Eating below 1,200 calories is bad for you. I upped my calorie target to 1,220 - not much but its a buffer, I ensure that I am above 1,200 calories so its not unhealthy but don't want to exceed my daily target either.
  • tbloor
    tbloor Posts: 56 Member
    I was down to 1210 calories a day,, but since I started an intense workout program I have been feeling very fatigued. I set MFP to "lose 0.5 pounds per week" and increased my calories. I feel better, and I am still losing weight!
  • undsoc
    undsoc Posts: 3 Member
    I definitely agree with the other ladies. I was originally at 1250 calories a day and my weight loss was pretty much non-existent (even with eating back my exercise calories). So I changed my set up from losing 2 pounds a week to the 1 and upped my calories to 1470. I feel so much better now. Not so tired, sluggish, and hungry. Plus, the scale is actually starting to move! I'm not so sure 1200 calories is enough. Everything I've read has said that 1200 calories is too low for women and we should stick to 1400-1600 depending on the person. So, I say up the calories and see what happens. My guess is it will work better for you. Good luck and congrats on losing 17 lbs! :smile:
  • _Ren
    _Ren Posts: 89 Member
    I tried 1200 for a good bit of the month. I was feeling tired and my eye was twitching. I wasn't eating enough calories on top of the exercise. I switched it to only lose 1 lb a week instead of 1.5 lbs a week. I am glad I switched and have more calories, I am starting to feel better.
  • ladyraven68
    ladyraven68 Posts: 2,003 Member
    Hi Slinky - I am upping mine too, as I think my BMR is higher than 1200, and I was feeling lightheaded sometimes on 1200, so I don't think I was eating enough.

    This is why I am upping - here's my post from yesterday

    "Question for all you BMR experts.

    Today I was curious about BMR calculations, so looked at quite a few different sites.

    Most of them them threw out the same figure, give or take 10 cals, of 1510, which would put my sedentary TDEE at about 1800.

    I am 44,
    5ft 0
    and 179 lbs

    MFP has my TDEE at 1730 and has set my "llb per week" calorie goal as 1230.

    I increased it to 1400 as I thought 1200 was too low, appreciating that the loss would be slower.

    However, what is concerning me is that both the 1400, and the 1200 is below the BMR of 1510, and all the warnings on here are about making sure you never drop below your BMR.

    Should I increase my calories to 1500? !
  • I just upped mine from 1390 to 1560. I am at a healthy weight--I just want to lose a few more. And I run a lot, so I figured I could. I just changed my goal from a pound a week to a half-pound a week, and the extra calories magically appeared in my daily allotment. :) I just did it yesterday--I'll let you know how it goes.
  • megsmom2
    megsmom2 Posts: 2,362 Member
    MFP set mine at 1600, plus exercize calories. That seems like a lot to me, and I'm usually a bit under, but its nice to have that leeway. And I'm still losing just fine. I figure I'll readjust my numbers if it ever becomes necessary, but this is a level I can easily live with.
  • librarygoddess2
    librarygoddess2 Posts: 145 Member
    They use a formula to decide how many calories you should eat if you want to lose weight. some that don't have to lose as much will be at a higher calorie count per day. I'm also at 1200. 5'1 194 and want to be down at around 130. So I'm in the same boat as you! However, I've stuck to the 1200 and I've lost 22 lbs since November. I don't recommend just adding an extra 300 calories to your diet. 1500 -2000 is a maintain if you are a sedentary so you likely won't lose weight Here's what I recommend.

    1. Exercise. - If you exercise you earn more calories. If you burn 600 you get another 600 to eat.

    2. It's what you eat - it's not actually the calories that matter as much as what you eat. If you are eating a lot of proteins and carbs you will use up your quota for the day very quickly. If you try to eat lots of veggies you can almost eat them endlessly. I've been trying to eat veggies with every single meal That way you can eat more for less calories.

    3. Fiber - I can't stress this enough. The higher the fibre content the slower it digests. This means your body is getting more nutrients out of the food you eat which will give you energy. It will also keep you fuller for longer. An apple for breakfast will keep you going until your snack at coffee break. Whole Grain Toast will make you fuller longer than white bread. It actually has more calories but the fibre offsets the insulin production so you actually store less fat!

    So I would stick to the 1200 calories and try to adjust what you eat.
  • lwoods34
    lwoods34 Posts: 302 Member
    I would agree with what everyone else had said so far. It seems like you are eating too few calories and that is why your energy level is so low. I would definitely increase your caloric intake...especially if you are now working out you also want to eat back some if not most of your exercise calories. I work out 6 days per week and tend to burn alot of calories so I am eating over 2,000 calories per day and am still managing to lose weight.

    You need to fuel your body in order to fuel your workouts. Whats the point of working out if you cant get through your workout because you are too tired and have no energy and are hungry all the time?
  • StrongGwen
    StrongGwen Posts: 378 Member
    YES! didn't really start losing until I upped my calories to about 1600 per day. It's important (for me at least) to NEVER eat less than my BMR requires (Basic Metabolic Rate, the calories you burn if you lay in bed all day breathing, digesting, etc).
  • I started this a little over 2 weeks ago, and at first I was on 1200 cals. But, I didn't lose any weight and I was so discouraged! A few days ago, I readjusted my expectations to 1lb a week, and it gave me 1500 cals a day. I dropped 2.4lbs! Idk all the in's and out's of this whole thing, but I think there is such a things as eating too few calories! I'm sticking with 1500 for a while since it seems to be working a lot better for me! Good luck!
  • You probably need some protein in your diet
  • NeverGivesUp
    NeverGivesUp Posts: 960 Member
    check out the Olivia method in the search feature. It is great not only because it makes you eat at least your BMR but if you exercise over a certain amount it also makes you eat back the right amount of calories. I think it is a great method!!
  • MFP set me up for 1200 cals a day when i first joined, but obviously wasn't enough for me as was constantly feelin tired and hungry and with the excercise ontop i decided to up my cals to 1600, it has worked better, but since i'm constantly increasin workout time i am tempted to push it to 1700-1800... will see what my weigh in reveals on saturday... guess its just a case of changin things untill you find somethin that fits... good luck :)
  • dianeellen2
    dianeellen2 Posts: 259 Member
    I have been on 1200 for a few months now (i am vegetarian too) and did not really struggle to maintain 1200 calories. However as i was doing more and more exercise i noticed that i stopped losing weight and was hungry all the time.

    Last weekend i upped my calories to 1470 and it was like a new lease of life - i dont think i had noticed my energy levels slipping. Not moving off my plateau yet (early days) but still maintaining and having 270 cals more a day - so watch this space

    feel free to add me if you want xxx
  • TraToy
    TraToy Posts: 35 Member
    Hi Ladies! My range is normally between 1200-1400. I workout regulary (strength training/cardio) and by doing so, I earn extra calories so I don't feel guilty when my total calorie intake for the day is over 1200. So far it's worked pretty good...I joined 1/9/12 and I have lost 10lbs! :D
  • Pinkmaddycat
    Pinkmaddycat Posts: 175 Member
    I upped mine and lo and behold ive started to lose weight, ive also stopped exercising at the present time as my body seems to be happy with just an active life style, once ive lost a bit more then i will tone up and exercise but i genuinely believe it was hindering me.

    I hope you find something that works for you
  • Problem #1--considering MFP the gospel. If you didnt see minimal results after 2 weeks, you should have adjusted.

    I have lost over 100 lbs doing 800-1200 cals a day. I hit a wall and actually took a few days off then came back and upped my calories and lost 7 pounds in a week.

    Play with your numbers...go up 200 a day to see if that helps. Everyone has a different starvation mode set on their body, you just need to find yours.
  • Helloitsdan
    Helloitsdan Posts: 5,564 Member
    I upped my calories from 1200-1600 after 2 days.
    That was last May.

    I'm 5'5" I work out 3 days a week and eat 2k calories 4 days a week and 2800 calories 3 days a week.
    I lose 1lb of fat a week and maintain all my lean mass because I pick heavy things up and put them down for 20-45 mins a session.
  • lin7604
    lin7604 Posts: 2,951 Member
    i'm 5.2 and was put on 1200 a day with mfp too. I was loosing 2 lbs a month, i have lost 6-7 lbs so far. Some days i have a very hard time not going over 1200 as i'm hungry. on exercise days i'm good as i get extra calories to eat :) As of 2 weeks ago i upped mine to 1310, as i changed my setting from 1 lbs to 1/2 a lb b/c all i was loosing was 1/2 a lb anyway, so i thought the extra calories might help. so far no change, as i also have been stuck for 1 month at 133.2 / 133.4, can't get under it, if i do it's 132.8 and it's for a day then right back up! i always eat my exercise calories and maybe that's my problem, maybe i should go to eating only half of them back? my bmr is 1252, so as long as i get 1250 a day i'm happy and net 1200 if i exercise... we will see what happens in the next week or two, my goal deadline was march 20th for all 15 lbs but i don't think that is going to happen.... ( i have been trying to loose since Oct 22nd.)
  • juliep1974
    juliep1974 Posts: 222 Member
    I was never as low as 1200 calories because I was already too hungry on 1300 plus most of my exercise calories. As I'm so close to my goal (5-10 lbs) and weight loss was going to slow down anyway, I decided to up my calories to 1500 (plus some exercise calories if necessary). It was the best thing I did. It took my body about a week to adjust (I gained 1lb), but I've been slowly but I had been slowing losing since. I think making the switch is a great idea - give your body time to adjust even if the scale goes up a little bit at first.
  • kerriBB37
    kerriBB37 Posts: 967 Member
    A friend of mine is a biochemist.. she is a book of knowledge and I pick her brain all the time. I was on 1200 cals for a long time and lost nothing. She recommended a good rule of thumb.. eat your weight + 0 (so for me, I'm in the 160's weight wise, so I eat 160+0 = 1,600 calories a day. So if you're 170... 1,700 calories would be good, and yes, this is to LOSE weight. Also, she recommended eating 60-80% calories if you do strenous workouts like lifting weights, running, Spin class, etc... in turn, don't document every little thing you do throughout the day like cleaning the kitchen, making dinner, grocery shopping LOL (lots of people log this as exercise but it's just daily living activities).. only gym time should be factored into those calories you "eat back"

    Since I've made this switch I've lost almost 10 pounds since 1/1/12.
  • I suggest having your BMR done and eating enough calories. 1200 is not enough unless you are super small and since you are exercising, you need to eat more. I aim for about 1500 and I am 5'4" and weigh 147 but I also eat more if I have a good exercise day.

    I am eating 1200 calories and getting no where. I had not thought about at least eating your BMR calories. That makes a lot of sense! Thanks!
  • BAMFMeredith
    BAMFMeredith Posts: 2,810 Member
    I upped mine to 1300. I work out around 6 days a week, so I usually eat more than that (since I've earned extra) but on days that I don't work out, I'm good between 1200-1300 calories. My weight loss goal is set at 1lb a week, but as I lose and get closer to my goal weight, I'll probably change that to .5 lb a week just to kinda keep myself balanced. 1200 is good if you're not exercising at all and you have a considerable amount of weight to lose (like more than 50 lbs).
  • gsager
    gsager Posts: 977 Member
    If you start working out more and eating back your exercise calories you will start losing weight again I'm 5'2", 58 years old and have lost 19lbs. CW 115.....I work out 5 days a week, eat my exercise calories. I think that you have to get moving a little more. At least go for a walk if you can't make it to the gym and log all your exercise calories.
  • wedjul05
    wedjul05 Posts: 472
    I recently changed my cals from 1200 to 1540. I find this is better and I'm not starving. I generally don't eat back all my exercise cals.

    I eat most of my food in the early afternoon-late evening as I workout at say 8pm-9.30pm.

    I was hungry on 1200 a day. It is so easy to go over. SOme days still, I would only eat 1200 but at least I have the option of going to 1540 if I need it.

    When i exercise alot, a few days later I will be starving. I just eat more dense/slow release foods but would defo go up to 1540.
This discussion has been closed.