Quitting food logging???

24

Replies

  • its a dismal picture and outlook if you're going to have to log everything for the rest of your life!! that's too much, If you feel you can stop logging, stop, see how it goes, if it doesn't work come back try again. Its all swings and roundabouts, whatever works for you, works for YOU and thats what's important

    I'll probably be a lifetime logger...it's easy enough to do, it works for me and I don't find the prospect of doing it forever to be a dismal picture or outlook at all! :flowerforyou:
  • WifeMomDVM
    WifeMomDVM Posts: 1,025 Member
    its a dismal picture and outlook if you're going to have to log everything for the rest of your life!! that's too much, If you feel you can stop logging, stop, see how it goes, if it doesn't work come back try again. Its all swings and roundabouts, whatever works for you, works for YOU and thats what's important

    Absolutely. My 3 week hiatus didn't work out so well for me. But to each their own! :)
  • Fairysoul
    Fairysoul Posts: 1,361 Member
    There are lots of people who do not log, if you feel ready then give it a shot!
  • Lyadeia
    Lyadeia Posts: 4,603 Member
    I am thinking of stopping logging my food and wondered who else had done this successfully. I pretty much eat similar foods most days and have a fair idea of the calories etc. I am guessing most people don't want to log forever, so am interested in how people have found it when they stopped ie did they gain weight or stay on track.

    I have been doing this for a few weeks now. My diary says that I still have "1550 calories left" LOL. Anyway, I have also found that I eat basically the same way everyday, and I even typed in a majority of my own recipes into MFP. So, as long as I eat the foods that I had previously logged, I do just fine.

    That said, I have lost 2 pounds this past month so I am still doing OK. However, I want to lose about 10 more to reach my ultimate goal. I think that I personally will go back to logging, probably starting next week, so I can keep better track of macros. I mean, when I don't log, I know that my calories are just fine, but when you are *this* close to goal, I personally believe that it is important to track macros. I can't really do that in my head very well.

    Now when I get down to my goal body fat (16% or so, give or take) then I will go back to not logging because after this past month, it is obvious to me now that I have been here long enough to know what to do do.

    I do recommend trying it out, at least to see if you are capable of keeping up with yourself and your motivation. At some points, I know that I am not...but it seems that the more I keep myself on track with my workouts, the less I need to log since I am always thinking of it in my head. If that makes sense?
  • grapenutSF
    grapenutSF Posts: 648 Member
    My intention is to do it for the long haul. Yes, the OCD thing is a real risk and drawback. I've not been able to maintain healthy weight in the past without it. Bums me out, but there it is.
  • If by successfully you mean staying on track then I've not tracked consistently for a while. If you've got the discipline then go for it!
  • You've received replies from both ends of the spectrum. Ultimately, you have to be the one to make the decision, but I know for me -- I will not quit logging this time. I too thought I had a good idea and could manage without logging everything. Not so.

    In 2012 I'm finding myself only about 20 pounds away from gaining back an entire 100 pound weight loss (from 10 years ago)! So no ma'am .... I won't quit, but I'm also looking at it differently .... not as punishment, but as a tool that will help to keep me healthy.

    I just wonder as we think about it though, why are we so resistant to keep track of what we eat? We keep track of our pennies and dollars in our checking account...or else there would be major mayhem!
  • tbresina
    tbresina Posts: 558 Member
    I will not quit since I know that when I do I tend to slack off, can't help myself I just do. It literally takes about 5 min a day to log all my meals and exercise so why would I not?
  • jamja72
    jamja72 Posts: 119 Member
    For me...I've stopped logging. I've maintained for over 1 year and never slide outside my 5 lb window. So for some it can work. However I log intp mfp daily to continue staying motivated and motivating others.
  • Silverstar46
    Silverstar46 Posts: 187 Member
    Considering I've been fat my whole life I don't know WHAT I will do if I ever get to my goal weight of 150lbs. I think I would log at maintainance for a couple months to see the difference in food amounts and then try being sensible on my own.

    HOWEVER, since I have been fat for 29 years, I can see me slipping into bad habits reallllllly easily again. I do not want to be one of those "She lost 170lbs and then put on 200lbs and a crane lifts her out of bed in the morning" people. It is one of my worst fears.

    So I may very well end up being a lifetime logger so that I can have a lifetime of success! :drinker: :love: :wink:
  • 123Kate
    123Kate Posts: 32 Member
    I stopped logging for several weeks, just kept tracking my weight. I did fine, my weight maintained. I found iw as getting obsessive about food while i was logging which to me isnt healthy. I was getting anxious when my calories eaten would reach my maintaining level - i was so trained into eating fewer calories to lose. So it was really good for me to stop logging, I got less caught up on what I was eating (in a good way).

    I have recently started weight training though, which has seen me start logging again... this is mostly to make sure im eating enough protein etc than the actual calorie count. A few weeks of this and I will probably stop logging again, as I also eat pretty predictably each day
  • emilybeatrice1
    emilybeatrice1 Posts: 163 Member
    not a good idea! i thought i was good after logging for two years. i thought i would know for sure if i was going over... ughhh six months later i had gained 15 pounds. so now i am back at it.
  • wisebadger53
    wisebadger53 Posts: 382 Member
    ...I don't know WHAT I will do if I ever get to my goal weight of 150lbs...

    I suggest you change that to ...I don't know WHAT I will do "WHEN I" get to my goal weight of 150lbs... :wink:
  • vettle
    vettle Posts: 621 Member
    Firstly, I studied psychology in university so this is where my view point comes from - behaviour.

    If you log your whole life it's not exactly healthy behaviour (similar to an eating disorder really if our lives revolve around obessing over food), but then again we are just trying to be heatlhy. However, one should be able to take the habits we have learned and developed over the last year (or however long it's taken) and apply them. If you have to rely on a logging machine then we really haven't learned anything. The whole point ultimately is to be healthy right? Change bad habits, change a lifestyle, etc. If the only goal is to lose weight, then we'll eventually gain it back.

    We KNOW the right portions we know all this stuff but if the willpower and discipline is not there then keep logging until it is. The scale should be what we measure ourselves against after this journey is over. Weigh in once a week, if we've gained a couple pounds, then lighten up the next couple of weeks, don't just ignore the number. Also, do your clothes still fit? Do they feel tight? This is what normal people do!

    But sometimes these things take time. I think eventually we should all be off of this system but maybe it takes someone a week, maybe a month or a year at maintaining the goal weight before feeling comfortable trusting themselves again. I'm still logging and I've been at my goal weight for a couple of months now. But I've taken breaks here and there and I actually didn't log for a whole month while on vacation in Australia and I LOST 5 pounds! So clearly I am not aware just yet of the amount of exercise I do (since I was careful with what I ate).

    I will soon be only logging every other week to test myself. See how that goes!
  • jadedone
    jadedone Posts: 2,446 Member
    I plan to stop once I get to goal but probably I'll probably measure.

    For me, the goal is to get the right portion/ratio on the plate, and stick with that. (Goal: 50% veggies, 25% starch, 25% protein for lunch and dinner, and breakfast: 33%/33%/33%: protein, starch, produce or 2 out of 3.
  • justfungrandma
    justfungrandma Posts: 91 Member
    L17606968.png
    Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Weight Loss Toolsogging helps keep my on track even when I eat mostly the same things all the time. I add food before I eat it, so I can make decisions based on where it puts me. I have done this on my own with a notebook and always do better when I log than when I don't
  • neaneawy
    neaneawy Posts: 146 Member
    Millions of people don't log, and don't have any weight problems.

    The ultimate goal should be to no longer need to obsess over food, and maintain health effortlessly.

    In the mean time, I'm still a fat person in a skinny body, beaten into submission.

    I agree that milions of people don't need any help tracking their food and maintaining a healthy weight; however many of us did not get to our current or previous sizes because we were like everyone else. I love food too much and I think this will always be a problem for me. If I stop logging I know I won't be as careful.
  • HonkyTonks
    HonkyTonks Posts: 1,193 Member
    I am thinking of stopping logging my food and wondered who else had done this successfully. I pretty much eat similar foods most days and have a fair idea of the calories etc. I am guessing most people don't want to log forever, so am interested in how people have found it when they stopped ie did they gain weight or stay on track.

    I tried that but it didn't work. However, I have lost weight and been slimmer than I am and didn't log. Just need to find that mental state again. Wish I knew where it went!
  • Arrrgghhh don't do it... lol! I lost my laptop around Christmas then had some illness and so didn't log for about 6 weeks, I actually still ate what I thought was quite a similar mealplan to what I was eating when I was tracking but nope, the scales are telling me differently. So I would have to recommend, keep logging! Seems to make a real difference when you acknowledge and make yourself accountable for what you stuff in your gob each day!

    :)
  • VeganPanda
    VeganPanda Posts: 582 Member
    UGGGGGG. Don't do it. Been there done that. Never again. It is amazing how many items you don't remember eating.
    please keep log gin.

    Is that similar to regular gin?

    :laugh:
  • chevy88grl
    chevy88grl Posts: 3,937 Member
    I've stopped logging food and exercise.

    I am doing just fine and happily maintaining my weight. I don't want to log food or exercise for the rest of my life. It makes me too obsessive. Plus, logging exercise and then making sure I was eating back enough calories was making me not enjoy the gym anymore because I would go and be so focused on what would burn the most, how I could get a bigger burn, etc.

    Now that I don't log? I feel calmer, happier and less obsessed. I enjoy the gym again.

    I understand that some people will have to log for the rest of their life, but I do not want to be one of those people (and so far -- I'm proving to myself that I don't need to be!).


    Good Luck!

    Edited to add: If I ever feel like my eating is out of control or that I'm slipping back into old habits, I go back to logging for a week or so. It is enough to shake loose whatever is going on in my mind. Enough to make me stop with the old, bad habits and get back on track.
  • Mummsy
    Mummsy Posts: 347 Member
    I recently quit. I was logging for a long time but am following a new program and am doing well.
    :wink:
  • kellyjamespro
    kellyjamespro Posts: 88 Member
    I would say stop logging.. Watch your NSV's , the scale etc. if you start having issues go back to logging. If you dont have any issues then your are a FREE woman!
  • sillygoose1977
    sillygoose1977 Posts: 2,151 Member
    I haven't logged in about 8 months and I have lost about 10 pounds since then. I stick to being sensible and tracking in my head. I'm sure I am over some days and under some but it seems to be working okay for me. If I started gaining I would start to log again.
  • HotKanye
    HotKanye Posts: 103 Member
    An alternative to logging would be taking photos of your food. That's supposed to work just as well and would take less time but still hold you accountable.
  • BlaireV
    BlaireV Posts: 137
    I lost most of my weight before logging and am now trying to slowly ease out of it. I refuse to log for the rest of my life and plan on stopping soon. Logging is to create awareness, using it as a life long crutch is obsessive and unhealthy in my opinion.
  • I don't log food. Before I found MFP I lost weight consistently and well by just watching how much I ate, making good food choices and exercising most days. I tried logging but find it hinders rather than helps (though I can see the value of logging for some people). I log exercise just for interest. I do log weight from time to time. As long as the scales are moving in the right direction, I'm happy and I don't need to log to see that happen. The main thing to keep in mind is that the lifestyle changes need to be sustainable. If that means having the odd bit of chocolate, burger, etc then that's ok for myself. I don't intend to never eat chocolate in my life again. Making sure that I keep it in its rightful place is what is most important to me. I do intend, once I reach my goal, to monitor my weight on an ongoing basis and maintain that. It's also about listening to my body. If I'm hungy, I should eat. It's what I eat that counts at that point.
  • LorinaLynn
    LorinaLynn Posts: 13,247 Member
    I took off almost the entire month of January from logging, and didn't really exercise much, and stayed about the same weight. I'm logging now because I'm really amping up my exercise and want to make sure I'm getting enough gas in my tank. But I don't log on weekends or holidays and haven't since June.
  • MissFit0101
    MissFit0101 Posts: 2,382
    I don't want to have to log forever but I have taken breaks from it. The first time I took a break from logging I gained 9lbs back over 3 months. After losing it again and maintaining my weight for a while, I will skip days here and there, or skip a couple weeks and get back to it . I've done pretty well not logging my food and not gaining weight, but I do still try to stay in the habit of logging sometimes because I do tend to eat a little better when I do.
  • choirgirl1130
    choirgirl1130 Posts: 80 Member
    i say try not doing it, but monitor your weight...if you start gaining, you know you need to get back on to food journaling.
    i recently hit my weight goal and am considering my next steps...increasing my cals a bit, food journaling?, etc.
    best wishes to you sis!
This discussion has been closed.