Help! ... I'm not losing anything!
Peta22
Posts: 377 Member
I have been reading through other threads asking the same question but there is so many possible causes I'm lost as to what to try! So I thought maybe I may be able to get some specific advice...
I've been counting calories and working out for a couple of weeks now but my weight isn't really changing at all. I fluctuate between losing and gaining the same 500gms every couple of days. I did MFP for 5mths last year and consistently lost 500gm to a kilo a week. The only thing I'm doing differently this time is that I'm working out harder (I'm doing the 30DS and presently on my 11th day).
Other points to note maybe;
- All my exersize calories are Recorded on a Polar FT7 HRM
- I previously always ate back my exersize calories and lost weight. I have continued to do this but now not losing weight!
- my BMI is 26 which puts me in the overweight category
- I'm presently 68.5kg and my goal is 60kg
- I'm taking a low carb protein powder each day
- EVERYTHING I consume is on my diary (public) and I weigh and measure everything!
- my appetite has become insatiable in the last few days, and
- although the workouts have been getting slightly easier each day, I'm insanely tired and I feel like I'm not recovering properly - I feel weaker and more lethargic, not stronger like your apparently supposed to feel.
Hoping someone can give me some advice... Or am I just being impatient expecting results this quickly again?
I've been counting calories and working out for a couple of weeks now but my weight isn't really changing at all. I fluctuate between losing and gaining the same 500gms every couple of days. I did MFP for 5mths last year and consistently lost 500gm to a kilo a week. The only thing I'm doing differently this time is that I'm working out harder (I'm doing the 30DS and presently on my 11th day).
Other points to note maybe;
- All my exersize calories are Recorded on a Polar FT7 HRM
- I previously always ate back my exersize calories and lost weight. I have continued to do this but now not losing weight!
- my BMI is 26 which puts me in the overweight category
- I'm presently 68.5kg and my goal is 60kg
- I'm taking a low carb protein powder each day
- EVERYTHING I consume is on my diary (public) and I weigh and measure everything!
- my appetite has become insatiable in the last few days, and
- although the workouts have been getting slightly easier each day, I'm insanely tired and I feel like I'm not recovering properly - I feel weaker and more lethargic, not stronger like your apparently supposed to feel.
Hoping someone can give me some advice... Or am I just being impatient expecting results this quickly again?
0
Replies
-
One more thing - do you have it set at losing 1 pound per week?0
-
Yep... Set at 1lb a week - which I think is roughly half a kilo?0
-
What's your activity level at? Tiredness/lethargy could come from not eating enough.0
-
All I would suggest is maybe switching it to 0.5lb a week, you're right on the cusp according to these guidelines:
o Generally someone with a BMI over 32 can do a 1000 calorie a day (2 lbs a week) deficit
o With a BMI of 30 to 32 a deficit of 750 calories is generally correct (about 1.5 lbs a week)
o With a BMI of 28 to 30 a deficit of 500 calories is about right (about 1 lb a week)
o With a BMI of 26 to 28 a deficit of about 300 calories is perfect (about 1/2 lb a week)0 -
Are you drinking enough water?0
-
Do you have a rest day in your exercise regime? I just had a quick look through and you seem to do 30DS every day. Your body needs at least one day a week in order to recover.0
-
I'll second the rest day and the water. If this doesn't help, I'd check with a dietitian or a doctor if you have access.0
-
Ok
Starry eyed... My activity level was set at light activity in the MFP set up I think. However, I've been working out twice a day the last few days doing 30DS and a lighter session on the exersize bike or dancing class. I haven't had a rest day as I thought 30DS was meant to be 30 days straight...
Schmuck94... I've been trying to drink as much water as possible - probably about 2-3 ltrs a day... Not hard as its been INSANELY hot where I am over the last week (high 30,s low 40's - Celsius)
LesleeAH... I'm confused... Does that suggest I'm trying to lose weight too fast?0 -
Ok
Starry eyed... My activity level was set at light activity in the MFP set up I think. However, I've been working out twice a day the last few days doing 30DS and a lighter session on the exersize bike or dancing class. I haven't had a rest day as I thought 30DS was meant to be 30 days straight...
Schmuck94... I've been trying to drink as much water as possible - probably about 2-3 ltrs a day... Not hard as its been INSANELY hot where I am over the last week (high 30,s low 40's - Celsius)
LesleeAH... I'm confused... Does that suggest I'm trying to lose weight too fast?
I'm in Perth too and I know what you mean about the heat! Easily guzzling that water!
The idea is, when you have a lot more to lose, you can stand a higher deficit. Since you have only 8kg to lose, you should only have a smaller deficit, about 300 cals a day, or MFP's settings for 0.5lb/week. You should be eating above your BMR, which is probably around 1400 - 1500 for you.0 -
Did you take your measurements before you started 30DS? Could be you just lost a load of inches(cms lol) rather than Kgs.
Just read up on 30DS and it does say to do every day. Most exercise regimes require a 'day off' to allow the muscles to rebuild.0 -
StarryEyed500,I did take measurements before I started and I do keep meaning to check them now as I think I may have lost inches, however, I still want to lose fat! I can see it on me and I want it gone!!
As soon as I find the time to find the tape measure, I'll check my measurements!
LesleeAH, thanks for that... I was wondering whether I wasn't eating enough but it feels so counterproductive to be eating more! I'll amend my settings and give it ago. BTW, great to meet another Perth person
0 -
If you are losing inches, You ARE losing fat. It may not be reflected on the scale numbers, but believe me, you are getting smaller.
If you are doing the shred everyday, then you are toning and building muscle.0 -
yStarryEyed500,I did take measurements before I started and I do keep meaning to check them now as I think I may have lost inches, however, I still want to lose fat! I can see it on me and I want it gone!! As soon as I find the time to find the tape measure, I'll check my measurements!
LesleeAH, thanks for that... I was wondering whether I wasn't eating enough but it feels so counterproductive to be eating more! I'll amend my settings and give it ago. BTW, great to meet another Perth person
you are losing fat lov!! it will all catch up, i say you are doing great and give it time. i equate it to how a kid grows.. they gain weight, then they get taller.. just like your body, you will lose some inches, then next time around you wont but you lost on the scale!
0 -
Maybe increase your calories...i looked at a few days and it looks like you are consistently UNDER 1200 net calories. As much working out as you are doing you need fuel for your body, especially to maintain muscle mass while losing fat. Maybe you need to workout less to keep your net calories above 1200.0
-
If you set your activity level to include the workouts, you don't want to eat the exercise calories back from them because they are already included. Is that what you meant when you said you have your activity level as lightly active? Set your activity to what it would be IF you didn't do a workout.0
-
All I would suggest is maybe switching it to 0.5lb a week, you're right on the cusp according to these guidelines:
o Generally someone with a BMI over 32 can do a 1000 calorie a day (2 lbs a week) deficit
o With a BMI of 30 to 32 a deficit of 750 calories is generally correct (about 1.5 lbs a week)
o With a BMI of 28 to 30 a deficit of 500 calories is about right (about 1 lb a week)
o With a BMI of 26 to 28 a deficit of about 300 calories is perfect (about 1/2 lb a week)
This is good stuff... I find it to be accurat in my situation. Do you happen to have a referrence for where you found it or is it personal knowledge?0 -
Thanks boobee32... I know but how long will it take to shed the layer/s of fat over the top of the newly toned muscles that I KNOW are developing?
It also frustrates me that on the BMI scale I'm still over weight and, for my height, I'm supposed to be between 55 and 60kg - I'm 68kg!
Sorry - venting!
I know it's only been 2wks but even a small loss would be soooo satisfying after 2wks of counting every calorie and hours of sweating, groaning, cursing and pain in general! Lol...0 -
I feel your pain! I have been working out A LOT over the last 3 months and have not seen results on the scale (well very little) BUT I HAVE lost inches. My clothes fit better and people have been able to notice a difference. I think someone else already suggested it but if you haven't taken your measurements (i do calf, thigh, hips, waist, chest and bicep) I would recommend starting now. My trainer has me wait one month in between measurements. Whatever you do DON'T GIVE UP. Even if you aren't losing the weight think of all the good you are doing for you body with the workouts. GOOD LUCK!0
-
My1985freckle... Cool username I set my activity to lightly active because my day consists of about 70% desk work and 30% on my feet (I.e: housework, errands, gardening, cooking ect)... I'm presently working out 1-2 times a day doing 30DS and some lighter cardio for about an hour (fat burning not fitness according to my HRM). 0
-
StarryEyed500,I did take measurements before I started and I do keep meaning to check them now as I think I may have lost inches, however, I still want to lose fat! I can see it on me and I want it gone!! As soon as I find the time to find the tape measure, I'll check my measurements!
LesleeAH, thanks for that... I was wondering whether I wasn't eating enough but it feels so counterproductive to be eating more! I'll amend my settings and give it ago. BTW, great to meet another Perth person
You may also, if you are not doing this already is to eat 5 small meals a day. I just realized this week that my slow progress was due to not eating enough calories (I too thought that you never eat back your workout) and that I needed to kick my metabolism into gear and eat 5 times a day. i will see how I do in a few weeks.0 -
Drmryder... Good point. I've heard that many times before and it makes sense to eat smaller meals more often but, when I'm busy, I struggle to eat 3times a day, never mind 5!!
I do wonder whether I have metabolism problems though. I've heard it can develop from bad eating habits and massive sudden weight loss and these things have been no stranger to me in the past. Does anyone know if there is some sort of metabolism test?0 -
Even though you're technically overweight you stI'll are close to your goal. So as others said set it to whatever 0.5lb loss.
Make sure to have one rest day. I'd look into lifting heavier weights. I enjoyed 30DS but the change my body has made in five weeks from NRoLFW is great. Not huge weight loss (which is ****ting me) but I have a waist!0 -
bump curious as to the answers0
-
Gee, it sounds like you are doing things right. I have two other suggestions not mentioned yet: 1) Have your thyroid levels checked. Hypoactive thyroid can leave you sluggish and tired, but does not explain the hunger aspect. 2) You may also want to have your blood sugar levels checked at the same time. Hyperglycemia will leave you sluggish, tired, and hungry. So, I guess I am suggesting that you visit your physician and have a few tests run.0
-
Might consider having your thyroid function evaluated---TSH test.0
-
I've been considering visiting the Docs for some tests so that might be the answer. Funny that the blood sugar has come up though... A friend tested me a few years ago with his 'prick test' device and said my results we're so low he thought I should have been in a coma! I felt normal?? I don't have much of a sweet tooth though - I don't like cakes or Lollies much - and if I have something really sweet, it gives me headaches.
Lozze... What is NRoLFW?0 -
I too have been having the same problem. I need to see a physician but I am enjoying this thread. I really think it is the post menopausal state for me. Since I had a hysterectomy about 5 years ago, the weight is stubbornly hanging on, even doing the programs and regimine I had done in the past. 0
-
Seems like some sound advice here. Drop your goal to .5/wk, which will up your calories. Doing 2 weeks of the Shred could be the issue at the moment. Anytime you start a new exercise regimen, if you haven't exercised in a while, your muscles hold onto glycogen - they get little tears and hold onto it to repair them - so basically it's like water weight. I know a lot of people haven't seen a drop from doing 30DS until later in the program, and some only see a small scale drop but lose inches.
If you're going to see a doctor anyway it's always good to have things tested. What you could also try is eating at your maintenance calories for a few days to a week and then go back to a deficit. I've heard that has worked for some people to break a plateau. Good luck.0 -
Looks like you got some good answers sweetie. Think the .5lb a week sounds like a good idea from what I've been told by my dietitian. She says a big deficit is fine when you've a lot to loose, but not once you get closer to goal. Also like the idea of a maintenance calorie week followed by cutting back again, to try to break the plateau. Maybe a extra protein shake would keep you fuller? Zara X0
-
I am new to this and no expert but here is my 2 cents.... in looking at your food diary, you are not eating as many calories as suggested. You have amped up your exercise and reduced your caloric intake all at once so I'm thinking your body thinks it is starving so you and your bod are battling each other. Perhaps try eating the number of calories recommended and see if you don't see a change. Sounds ridiculous to eat more to loss weight but you have to work with your body too (perhaps outsmart it!).0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions