What is "skinny fat"?

shaycat
shaycat Posts: 980
edited November 12 in Fitness and Exercise
? I keep seeing this. I thought it was just when you are skinny but eat unhealthy and dont workout. If that is the case though then why would cardio lead to skinny fat?

Replies

  • Anthonydaman
    Anthonydaman Posts: 854 Member
    The correct term is "Finny" ,hahahaha. That said just like our diet should be balanced, so should our exercise. Equal cardio to strength training should be the best, theoretically...
  • NKF92879
    NKF92879 Posts: 601 Member
    It's when someone is "skinny" yet has a high body fat percentage (little muscle).
  • AggieCass09
    AggieCass09 Posts: 1,867 Member
    skinny fat is where you have poor muscle tone ... cardio can lead to this IF you don't also do strength building moves (lunges, squats, push ups, and pull ups count too)

    I was skinny fat at my lowest weight because i was losing muscle as a result of not consuming enough calories and protein. Now, I eat more and I lift...I weigh more but I'm 2 sizes smaller and 8% lower in body fat...

    9fe0cb22.jpg

    e8d60f22.jpg

    me initially (front and back) , just doing lots of cardio and being a veggie

    2012-03-20214552.jpg

    me now as a CrossFitter and on a Paleo Diet at 160 lbs (that is ONLY a 5 lb loss!!!!!!)
  • shaycat
    shaycat Posts: 980
    Ohhhhh ok.
    Well I do Insanity and dont think I am skinny fat at all. I just wanted to make sure though. :tongue:
  • capriciousmoon
    capriciousmoon Posts: 1,263 Member
    It's when someone is "skinny" yet has a high body fat percentage (little muscle).

    This. It's being skinny, with high body fat. All flab and no muscle, which is why it's more common in people that mainly do cardio and no strength training.

    My picture might be a good example of skinny fat.
  • jadedone
    jadedone Posts: 2,446 Member
    ? I keep seeing this. I thought it was just when you are skinny but eat unhealthy and dont workout. If that is the case though then why would cardio lead to skinny fat?

    There are 2 attributes of skinny fat:
    low weight unhealthy habits (crappy eating, no exercise....)
    low weight, high body fat percentage

    low weight, high body fat percentage is rectified with strength training. Doing only cardio will give you a similar body composition at a lower weight, so you won''t look very "toned"
  • skywa
    skywa Posts: 901 Member
    skinny fat implies that one is thin with low muscle mass.
  • shaycat
    shaycat Posts: 980
    Wow, you look great. Thanks for sharing.
  • lakersfan4life
    lakersfan4life Posts: 322 Member
    i was watching a movie called Day Zero. That Elija Wood or whatever his name is in the movie. ( The kid from Lord of the Rings)

    Anywho, in one part of the movie, hes checking himself out in the mirror and says, " How can i be skinny and fat at the same time!? Thats almost physically impossible!"

    Made me laugh. and think of MFP since we all know its definitely possible.
  • mgmlap
    mgmlap Posts: 1,377 Member
    I am considered skinny fat at 135 pounds and 27% BF...my reason is because I have PCOS,IR, and hypothyroidism..so it takes me FOREVER to lose body fat. I lost 40 pounds..but only 6% BF...I now have cut down on carbs..try to stick to complex carbs..and am 1/2 way through Stage 1 of NROL4W
  • Di3012
    Di3012 Posts: 2,247 Member
    It's when someone is "skinny" yet has a high body fat percentage (little muscle).

    This. It's being skinny, with high body fat. All flab and no muscle, which is why it's more common in people that mainly do cardio and no strength training.

    My picture might be a good example of skinny fat.

    People who do cardio DO use their muscles, they are not skinny fat - whatever the hell that means.

    People who do cardio will not have a high body fat, they will not have flab and WILL have muscle.

    Muscle is always there, it is quite clever actually and will adapt to whatever way is best for the person's activities. Hence a marathon runner will be sleek, a sprinter will be bulkier/more muscle. A rower will have amazonian shoulders, a skiier will be extremely fit and strong.

    All have muscles, all are different due to the various activities.

    Weight lifting is not the be all and end all, even though many people on MFP seem to think it is.

    I defy anybody to tell a marathon runner who does no weight training that they are "skinny fat" and they will laugh in your face ;)
  • ChitownFoodie
    ChitownFoodie Posts: 1,562 Member
    I am currently skinny fat. Skinny based on the scale, but I have no muscle tone so I look squishy.
  • countdowntotarget
    countdowntotarget Posts: 108 Member
    skinny fat is when you are underweight and inactive, what fat you do have in your body accumulates around your vital organs - you can be overweight and active and your fat will be under the skin rather than around your organs which is actually healthier
  • cbl40
    cbl40 Posts: 281 Member
    Hmmmmm....is Lance Armstrong skinny fat? I don't know his workout routine, but he sure does cycle a lot! ; )
  • For those of you that are interested in the Bible, I used this phrase to assemble a sermon. The outline can be viewed here: http://www.wordsoftruth.net/ahealthyexteriorbut2012byeager.htm
  • soehlerking
    soehlerking Posts: 589 Member
    ...better than being fat-fat.
  • mslindsay
    mslindsay Posts: 93 Member
    ...better than being fat-fat.

    LOL! Where you have fat around your organs and under your skin.
  • AZackery
    AZackery Posts: 2,035 Member
    Weight lifting is not the be all and end all, even though many people on MFP seem to think it is.

    I agree with you. A lot of people on here think that everyone should be lifting weights and not only lifting weights, but lifting heavy. A person doesn't have to lift weights period to get results.
  • BlaireV
    BlaireV Posts: 137
    It's when someone is "skinny" yet has a high body fat percentage (little muscle).

    This. It's being skinny, with high body fat. All flab and no muscle, which is why it's more common in people that mainly do cardio and no strength training.

    My picture might be a good example of skinny fat.

    People who do cardio DO use their muscles, they are not skinny fat - whatever the hell that means.

    People who do cardio will not have a high body fat, they will not have flab and WILL have muscle.

    Muscle is always there, it is quite clever actually and will adapt to whatever way is best for the person's activities. Hence a marathon runner will be sleek, a sprinter will be bulkier/more muscle. A rower will have amazonian shoulders, a skiier will be extremely fit and strong.

    All have muscles, all are different due to the various activities.

    Weight lifting is not the be all and end all, even though many people on MFP seem to think it is.

    I defy anybody to tell a marathon runner who does no weight training that they are "skinny fat" and they will laugh in your face ;)

    This.
  • LorinaLynn
    LorinaLynn Posts: 13,247 Member
    Skinny fat isn't just the absence of muscle. That's just plain skinny.

    Skinny fat is when someone is a normal body weight, but a high body fat percentage. I'm sure you've seen men and women who don't weight a lot, and might have little spindly arms and legs, but a mushy gut or droopy butt. That's skinny fat.

    Last time I lost weight, with a large calorie deficit, I became skinny fat. I weighed the same as I do now, but I still had a muffin top, back fat rolls, double chin, etc. I didn't retain my muscle mass as I lost weight, and it wasn't pretty.

    Photos: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/494091-i-just-don-t-care-anymore
  • Meggles63
    Meggles63 Posts: 916 Member
    Skinny fat isn't just the absence of muscle. That's just plain skinny.

    Skinny fat is when someone is a normal body weight, but a high body fat percentage. I'm sure you've seen men and women who don't weight a lot, and might have little spindly arms and legs, but a mushy gut or droopy butt. That's skinny fat.

    Last time I lost weight, with a large calorie deficit, I became skinny fat. I weighed the same as I do now, but I still had a muffin top, back fat rolls, double chin, etc. I didn't retain my muscle mass as I lost weight, and it wasn't pretty.

    Photos: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/494091-i-just-don-t-care-anymore
    ^^^This. I had the same issue. I lost a ton of fat doing Insanity and "thought" I was eating enough, but ended up "flabby fit." That's why I'm working at balancing the cardio with strength training and making sure I am fueling my muscles!
  • london_chick
    london_chick Posts: 4 Member
    just like everyone has said, it's being skinny, but with no muscle. i used to be very skinny 'fat'. i lost weight in my first year out of high school, going out a lot, drinking, but not eating properly. i did this for a couple of years and i dropped about 20-25kgs. got as low as 49. but i had no muscle, and my stomach and thighs still had those ugly ripples. the moment i started eating normally, i piled on the kgs.

    whilst your still skinny, its not the way to go. you can't sustain the weight and lead a healthy lifestyle. ideally you need to build muscle (which involves both cardio and strength training), eat substantially and healthily, and your body will to turn into a calorie burning machine. the weight also becomes much harder to put on.

    i'm not an expert by any means, and still to this day struggle with my weight, but i can talk from experience.
  • Scorpioangel
    Scorpioangel Posts: 951 Member
    From what I understand it's when someone looks skinny/thin but really has no muscle definition or tone. :)
  • mmklinemm
    mmklinemm Posts: 58 Member


    People who do cardio DO use their muscles, they are not skinny fat - whatever the hell that means.

    People who do cardio will not have a high body fat, they will not have flab and WILL have muscle.

    Muscle is always there, it is quite clever actually and will adapt to whatever way is best for the person's activities. Hence a marathon runner will be sleek, a sprinter will be bulkier/more muscle. A rower will have amazonian shoulders, a skiier will be extremely fit and strong.

    All have muscles, all are different due to the various activities.

    Weight lifting is not the be all and end all, even though many people on MFP seem to think it is.

    I defy anybody to tell a marathon runner who does no weight training that they are "skinny fat" and they will laugh in your face ;)


    Thank you!
  • siobhano_
    siobhano_ Posts: 101
    Lol I think i'm a pretty good example of it. I'm 5'9 and about 143lbs, yet my bf% is 27%.
    It's being small according to the scale and when clothed, but looking wobbly, having no muscle tone, and having a high bf%.
  • mandylooo
    mandylooo Posts: 456 Member
    It's when someone is "skinny" yet has a high body fat percentage (little muscle).

    This. It's being skinny, with high body fat. All flab and no muscle, which is why it's more common in people that mainly do cardio and no strength training.

    My picture might be a good example of skinny fat.

    People who do cardio DO use their muscles, they are not skinny fat - whatever the hell that means.

    People who do cardio will not have a high body fat, they will not have flab and WILL have muscle.

    Muscle is always there, it is quite clever actually and will adapt to whatever way is best for the person's activities. Hence a marathon runner will be sleek, a sprinter will be bulkier/more muscle. A rower will have amazonian shoulders, a skiier will be extremely fit and strong.

    All have muscles, all are different due to the various activities.

    Weight lifting is not the be all and end all, even though many people on MFP seem to think it is.

    I defy anybody to tell a marathon runner who does no weight training that they are "skinny fat" and they will laugh in your face ;)

    I agree with you about cardio not leading to being skinny fat, but just want to point out that sprinters and rowers probably spend some time in the weights room as well to get the strength they need.
  • mandylooo
    mandylooo Posts: 456 Member
    and what's with 27% being a high percentage body fat? I thought 25 - 30 % was average for women.
  • snookumss
    snookumss Posts: 1,451 Member
    It's when someone is "skinny" yet has a high body fat percentage (little muscle).

    This. It's being skinny, with high body fat. All flab and no muscle, which is why it's more common in people that mainly do cardio and no strength training.

    My picture might be a good example of skinny fat.

    People who do cardio DO use their muscles, they are not skinny fat - whatever the hell that means.

    People who do cardio will not have a high body fat, they will not have flab and WILL have muscle.

    Muscle is always there, it is quite clever actually and will adapt to whatever way is best for the person's activities. Hence a marathon runner will be sleek, a sprinter will be bulkier/more muscle. A rower will have amazonian shoulders, a skiier will be extremely fit and strong.

    All have muscles, all are different due to the various activities.

    Weight lifting is not the be all and end all, even though many people on MFP seem to think it is.

    I defy anybody to tell a marathon runner who does no weight training that they are "skinny fat" and they will laugh in your face ;)

    I'd like you to find me a legitimate marathon runner with good times that actually is "skinny fat". Nobody said its ALWAYS the result of only cardio... and most people don't do that much cardio.
  • Lolli1986
    Lolli1986 Posts: 500 Member
    just saying... I used to do only cardio (I think i did my weights circuit two or three times, lol) and I definitely did not end up skinnyfat. I had toned runners legs that looked like they could kick down buildings (I have really large lower body muscles, for some reason, lol). my bf was supposedly 16%. every time you push off the ground you're lifting your entire body weight. ;)

    i want to do weights to get strong and sculpt... not to burn cals. o_O
This discussion has been closed.